I didn't write this article, nor did I rigorously fact check it. But it struck me as at least, mostly reasonable questions around which to foment a discussion. Most of the points in this article I'd be comfortable asking to a room of PhD scientists with expertise on Covid and vaccines. I'd be disappointed to see this flagged.
I have no idea if her concerns have merit, but I don't believe it should be shot down without consideration either.
UK’s vaccine top advisory body (that refused to recommend the vaccine for 12-15 age bracket) membership:
Professor Andrew Pollard, Chair (University of Oxford)
Professor Lim Wei Shen, Chair COVID-19 immunisation (Nottingham University Hospitals)
Professor Anthony Harnden, Deputy Chair (University of Oxford)
Dr Kevin Brown (Public Health England)
Dr Rebecca Cordery (Public Health England)
Dr Maggie Wearmouth (East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust)
Professor Matt Keeling (University of Warwick)
Alison Lawrence (lay member) Professor Robert Read (Southampton General Hospital)
Professor Anthony Scott (London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine)
Professor Adam Finn (University of Bristol)
Dr Fiona van der Klis (National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Netherlands)
Professor Maarten Postma (University of Groningen)
Professor Simon Kroll (Imperial College London)
Dr Martin Williams (University Hospitals Bristol)
Professor Jeremy Brown (University College London Hospitals)
Approved government media: https://www.bbc.com/news/health-58438669
What was the risk and is it approved for discussion if the absolute top vaccine experts declined to recommend it and a government funded news media, BBC, reported on that?
Is this too fringe to talk about?
Is BBC anti-vaxx now? Are these professors anti-vaxxers?
That's not what the BBC is
How much more government approval do you need? The Queen to notarize personally every utterance, noise and word they say/write?
It's literally as close to that as one can get, has a Royal Charter too.
Next would be the queen herself broadcasting live 24/7/365, might be hard to get that much juice out of a 90 year old. Maybe one day.
This is the youtube outlet for it
https://www.youtube.com/user/number10gov
Are you American by any chance? Is CBS a government mouthpiece because they carry actual government broadcasts like presidential addresses and have some oversight from a government agency (FCC)?
BBC is 100% government owned.
You are basically saying there is no difference between the Empire State Building and the White House.
Tell me again how the public should not get involved in the debate but this time give the right example and do it silently?
be the Chief of the Department of Bioethics approving questionable research such as sand flies eating live Beagles. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10130709/NIH-says-b... 'The NIH said that they did do leishmaniasis research on dogs in a laboratory in 2016, and in an enclosed open space in Tunisia, but not the research pictured.'
I think you have a different issue given your highly specific criticism of dog bioethics. THe NIH primarily concerns itself with human bioethics and permits some amount of very unpleasant research on model organisms.
If my goal was to cast fear, uncertainty and doubt into vaccines, I think I'd be able to weave a far more convincing web of lies that the folks worrying about a married NIH power couple.
I guess the way I look at Fauci is that he already proved his value in the HIV/AIDS crisis and it would be crazy not to trust somebody with that level of knowledge, levelheadedness, and connections.
During AIDS outbreak, Fauci pushed for FDA to approve the toxic and expensive drug known as AZT which was eventually discontinued. https://www.spin.com/2015/10/aids-and-the-azt-scandal-spin-1...
Bactrim was cheap and not approved. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/whitewashing-aids-history_b_4...
'Dr. Anthony Fauci is rewriting history. He is doing so to disguise his shameful role in delaying promotion of an AIDS treatment that would have prevented tens of thousands of deaths in the first years of the epidemic.
In my book, Body Counts, A Memoir of Politics, Sex, AIDS, and Survival, I recount how slow the federal government was in publicizing the use of Bactrim and other sulfa drugs to prevent PCP (the pneumonia that was then the leading killer of people with AIDS) in addition to its long-time and well-known use to treat PCP.'
Bactrim addresses a symptom of AIDS (specifically, a side bacterial infecftion that many people infected with HIV are prone to getting) while AZT reduces viral infections. Two completely different things. The former is for people who are infected, the latter for people to not get infected. The fog of virus is like the fog of war: easy to criticize from the distance of time.
I think you've said enough. It's clear what your opinion about Fauci is, and it's adding absolutely nothing to this discussion.
I wonder if the current quick magic cure demanded by the public may also overlook harmful side effects. The current pressure to dose those in low risk groups may be short-sighted. Ignoring risks is the subject of the thread.
There are no quick magic cures. AZT made a huge difference for a lot of people but it wasn't until later retrovirals (based on tech that didn't exist at that time) were released. It's still used in combination with other therapy.
Deep within the linked piece there is a small section entitled 'On “statistical significance”'. It says this:
Now, this result does not happen to be “statistically significant.”
People often use arguments like “but it’s not statistically significant” to try to discount results. I even hear people with PhDs or MDs say this, because somewhere in their schooling they were falsely taught that results need to be “statistically significant” to be “real.”
But even if a result is not statistically significant, absent better data, it still remains the best available estimate for the effect in question. This is just common sense. “Statistically insignificant” does not mean that there is no effect. More on statistical significance here: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-00857-9.
As a non-PhD who has (relatively) thought a lot about statistics, and who has previously linked others to that Nature article, this is the sort of balanced statement that makes me think she is not clueless. How about you?
BTW, I strongly disagree the quote you have about statistically insignificant data. It cannot be used to say there is no effect, or anything about the direction or magnitude of the effect. I'm not sure what a statement like """somewhere in their schooling they were falsely taught that results need to be “statistically significant” to be “real.”""" even means, significance is a mathematical/probabilistic formalism that has nothing to do with underlying reality, just with the event system you're working on.
BTW I set my p threshold at 1e-6 for a single test, 0.05 is just crazy. On the other hand, I've worked with systems where nobody cared about the significance, just that the weights that got pushed to production made more money than the last set of weights.
How about discussing those points with a roomful of non-PhD, non-scientists, with no particular knowledge of medicine in general?
If I drive across a bridge I should have the right to question the competency and the trust being put in the engineers. If something looks like a crack, I would ask detailed questions and I hope my fellow citizens would do the same. Can you really not find the logic, in good faith?
The end user can usefully participate in the network architecture debate if enough of their messages are vanishing. If the expert then says: "oh, but 1 in 2680 is rare" other professionals may adjust their opinion about them personally.
If they then go on a crusade to get the exchange scrubbed from the record it would make them more credible to you?
What’s yours?
Their membership:
----
Professor Andrew Pollard, Chair (University of Oxford)
Professor Lim Wei Shen, Chair COVID-19 immunisation (Nottingham University Hospitals)
Professor Anthony Harnden, Deputy Chair (University of Oxford)
Dr Kevin Brown (Public Health England)
Dr Rebecca Cordery (Public Health England)
Dr Maggie Wearmouth (East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust)
Professor Matt Keeling (University of Warwick)
Alison Lawrence (lay member)
Professor Robert Read (Southampton General Hospital)Professor Anthony Scott (London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine)
Professor Adam Finn (University of Bristol)
Dr Fiona van der Klis (National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Netherlands)
Professor Maarten Postma (University of Groningen)
Professor Simon Kroll (Imperial College London)
Dr Martin Williams (University Hospitals Bristol)
Professor Jeremy Brown (University College London Hospitals)
----
Can you spot the unwashed, uninformed, idiots-by-definition, masses here? The result might surprise you.
[0] https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/joint-committee-on-vacc...
In a few years the other political party will be elected and make decisions on your behalf. Will you be as keen on their mission to fight misinformation from this perspective of "people are sheep"?
I'm personally delighted whenever "the general public" is interested in participating in my field of expertise. I love describing how we scientifically approach the unknown with models and attempts at falsification. And how we make engineering decisions and for what reasons. You've never talked with non-technical people about browser standards and programming language design? If you can't present good counterpoints to uninformed statements then you don't understand your own field.
I've talked to non-technical people about technical subjects, to some success. But presenting good counterpoints to people who have no intention of playing the game honestly is wasting your breath.
Children also do not need to be wearing masks at school or social distancing in the cafeteria. We are harming our children by robbing them of a proper education and the experiences of childhood. And yet good luck trying to convince a covid alarmist of any of this.
They took the vaccine, so must everyone else, science be damned, seems to be their logic.
Some even post their vaccination cards, as if it’s some kind of scientific evidence. Absolutely crazy.
There also comes a point when you have explained something well enough, and then people are just deliberately “asking questions” not because they are being honest, but because there is an agenda. I see that attitude on HN all the time. It’s disguising honest enquiry.
And then there are people that will just ignore what you have done and still want to put their 2bits in.
prediction: this "article" contains 18 invalidating points in the first three paragraphs.
I glanced over it and it’s clear the author has no idea about statistics or rates. Oh at a time when a few hundred million vaccines were administered there was an uptick in absolute numbers of reported vaccine side effects? Wow! And that happened in the context of a large portion of the population being deathly afraid of the vaccine and anxious about it?
If one wants to present an unpopular and not viewed as credible point of view, it’s pretty important not to look completely ignore simple alternative explanations that are unquestionably causing part of the effects one is talking about
This is beyond useless as any kind of supporting evidence for the point the author is trying to make. Mixed in with Twitter anecdotes and random YouTube videos, it's just noise making it that much harder to critically evaluate the argument.
The term "Gish gallop" comes to mind.
Another part is how individual doctors mention individual patients who develop problems after the vaccine. Statistically, that is guaranteed to happen. There is a guarantee that someone will have their first heart attack today. The overlap between vaccine doses and heart problems is statistically guaranteed but does not imply causation.
Are those real numbers?
At least according to table S26. Death summary in Blinded Phase (https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa2113017/suppl_f...) it should be “of the 15184 people with the vaccine 16 died, vs the 15162 people with placebo, 16 died”. Unless I'm mistaken.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa2113017/suppl_f...
Group A and Group B had the same amount of deaths.
Group B also had more adverse reactions, some serious and some minor.
Given these details in isolation, I would want to be in Group A. But then you look at what that Group A is, and it's actually the control group.
There were 30,000 participants, and in both test and placebo, there were 16 deaths. The test arm had 3 covid deaths, and the control arm had 1, but it was an HIV patient who was not fully vaccinated so they are arguing it’s 0 deaths for the fully vaccinated cohort. So, the numbers we’re looking at here are pretty small.
So what can we learn from this? Basically, if you remove all the covid deaths, it’s 13 deaths in test and 15 in placebo. These are statistically equivalent. In both test and control you’re equally likely to die of something other than covid in that window.
Now onto the covid deaths. There were 3 in placebo and 0 in control. These are horribly small numbers. More data would be useful.
However.. you can do the stats anyway. The placebo group suggests that the death rate is .02%, with some error. Having 0.00% death rate in the test group is unlikely, but within that error.
So this data is too weak to draw much of a conclusion.
That's the trick, focus on the evidence that paints a particular picture instead of actually evaluating the available evidence.
Secondly, the article is broken down into sections with proper titles, and many links to evidence. It's not a "wall of text" and it's not "rambling", it's well structured.
Thirdly, the doctors and nurses in question are saying explicitly that they found the sudden prevalence of these events surprising and concerning. They are front line workers, they aren't sitting in an office reading Excel for Dummies, they're saying they noticed a qualitative change in the situation.
Finally, I only got about half way down but I actually found statements that were underplaying the extent of the problem, like this one:
"the English data, though difficult to interpret, contains some worrying signals that all-cause mortality could be higher in the vaccinated, especially in those under 60 years of age"
It doesn't contain "worrying signals" that all cause mortality "could" be higher. It shows outright that the all-cause death rate in the vaccinated has been much higher than in the unvaccinated in 2021. You can find a graph of it here:
https://bartram.substack.com/p/the-impact-of-time-on-non-cov...
And that article links to the original ONS report, if you want to read that.
210 million America are vaccine as of today. Are you trying to say the number I mentioned in my comment was wrong because I said “few hundred million” instead of “a couple hundred million plus change” when even if it were just “one” hundred million my point would be valid? Quibbling over whether it should be a couple or few when either of them support the point is 100th level nitpicking on the unimportant. Of course the point I made has been ignored because it was valid.
> show up in a trial population of 'only' ~60-70,000 participants
Why are you looking at the number of participants? It’s not relevant to your point there. The number that had covid is needed to answer the question you’re posing.
No. You claimed "of the 1000 people with the vaccine 2 died, vs the 1000 people with placebo, 187 died" which is just factually wrong. The trials didn't show anything even close to this disparity.
"Why are you looking at the number of participants? It’s not relevant to your point there. The number that had covid is needed to answer the question you’re posing."
Trial size determines ability to detect small but real effects, which is why the larger number of deaths in the vaccine vs placebo arm was ignored.
So you agree with my points about the few hundred million getting vaccinated in a highly anxious climate with tons of misinformation about side effects is essentially guaranteed to have high levels of reported side effects simply due to psychology. That alone means nearly all of the articles points fall apart so quibbling with sub comments in an effort to salvage the article is pointless.
Also the article is a long mass of poor quality text. Having section dividers doesn’t make bad references and argumentative fallacies good logic.
For the question you posed about Covid and the excuse giving, yes the number of Covid patients matters.
Not saying it is correct or not, but you did not respond to the criticism.
Nicely wrapped packages of turds is super common for vaccine posts, if the box smelled like poop and has fudge like material smeared on it, it would be odd to open the box and send it to a lab for a 12 page assessment of the exact species and last meal.
So Forgive me for just pointing out this box smelled bad and has smears on the outside. Now that I pointed it out, you’re welcome to send it off to a lab yourself if you want to know whether it’s cow or horse.
"Anaphylaxis is a well known side effect and doctors are required to report it (see FDA Fact Sheet at the top of page 10) because it is considered a “severe adverse reaction.” It occurs right after the shot. You can’t miss it. It should always be reported. A study at Mass General Brigham (MGM) that assessed anaphylaxis in a clinical setting after the administration of COVID-19 vaccines published in JAMA on March 8, 2021, found “severe reactions consistent with anaphylaxis occurred at a rate of 2.47 per 10,000 vaccinations.” This rate is based on reactions occurring within 2 hours of vaccination, the mean time was 17 minutes after vaccination. This study used “active” surveillance and tried not to miss any cases."
251,000,000 people have received 1 or more doses of COVID vaccines (https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#vaccinations_vacc-... taking that 0.000247 rate at face value results in about 62,000 cases of anaphylaxis-related symptoms. VAERS reports 282, meaning 220x under-reporting, much worse than Kirsch's "As noted in the letter, this implies that VAERS is under-reporting anaphylaxis by 50X to 123X."
Unfortunately, anaphylaxis is not as bad as death and should be more common than death, right? But Kirsch also claims, right at the top of the paper, "The vaccines have killed over 150,000 Americans so far." So that's more than two times as many instances of a result that should be less common, by his own argument.
Somebody here isn't understanding statistics.
Oh, and about that 2.45/10,000 vaccinations? That paper is https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2777417.
"In this prospective cohort of health care employees, 98% did not have any symptoms of an allergic reaction after receiving an mRNA COVID-19 vaccine. The remaining 2% reported some allergic symptoms; however, severe reactions consistent with anaphylaxis occurred at a rate of 2.47 per 10 000 vaccinations. All individuals with anaphylaxis recovered without shock or endotracheal intubation. The incidence rate of confirmed anaphylaxis in this study is larger than that reported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention based on passive spontaneous reporting methods (0.025-0.11 per 10 000 vaccinations).1 However, the overall risk of anaphylaxis to an mRNA COVID-19 vaccine remains extremely low and largely comparable to other common health care exposures.4 Although cases were clinically compatible with anaphylaxis, the mechanism of these reactions is unknown."
There's nothing wrong with seeking to make "heretical" arguments, but these should call for more caution and striving for accuracy, not less. This article does not usefully contribute to the debate.
Like, if you see a creationist proof against evolution that follows the scientific form superficially, do you post it to HN because it deserves to be discussed? I sure as hell hope not.
What happened with the AZ vaccine in the Nordic countries is pretty good at showing how tiny effects would be detected by the public health authorities once the vaccines were rolled out to prod, and how the authorities would react to it (hint: not by covering it up to boost foreign big pharma profits, or whatever the conspiracy theory of this week is). The safety of these vaccines, as well as the relative benefits, has been intensly studied by the people who have to make the actual calls. Those are the people we should be listening to, not engaging in a dialogue with malicious crackpots.
No, they're full of shit. They use small to moderate descripencies to argue that everything is wrong. The two that I saw before closing it:
(1). The vaccine is less effective than advertised but that doesn't mean it's ineffective. Two doses still provides good protection while two doses plus boosters provides excellent.
(2). It's still primarily an epidemic of the unvaccinated. The ~15% of unvaccinated turn into 70-80% of hospitalizations. If the hold outs got vaccinated (and everyone got boosted) we could cut hospitalizations 75-95%
The group who are in good health, who had the Delta variant and can prove it via antigen test results and Dr. letter of recovery, may not be afraid of the jabs. Instead, maybe they think their sterilizing immunity is the logical progression for those in good health and better than non-sterilizing jabs.
I had also heard pre print suggestion that those who had only acquired omicron without prior vaccination or delta may not have good neutralization of delta.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.01.13.22269243v...
This wouldn't seem to bear on what you have said because you were very specific about antigen testing and a doctors letter that you had recovered from covid but people are fantastically bad at making such fine distinctions about things they poorly understand and many who are unvaccinated seemed sure they had had covid even when the illness they proposed was prior to the advent of covid in country. Their logic is in general so bad that they literally changed the date of covid impacting their nation to account for this disparity instead of concluding that their illness back in 2019 was unlikely to be covid.
By January 2022 everyone who hasn't vaccinated has "had covid" whether they have actually had it or not and any differential in public policy towards unvaccinated people who have recovered is likely to result in disadvantage for society at large.
'By early October, persons who survived a previous infection had lower case rates than persons who were vaccinated alone.'
Yes - 'you were very specific about antigen testing and a doctors letter that you had recovered from covid'.
To say that given 2 different priors one is superior to the other and ergo one should behave such is wrong because it doesn't consider the cost of the prior. Considering the full cost you aren't better off getting covid and in most cases all of society is better off and ergo you yourself on net as well if you avoid it as long as possible so as to spread it out and get it when resources are available to treat you and because quality of treatment goes up over time as more treatments become available and as importantly more broadly available.
When the lockdowns started in USA I took some days to consider the possibilities while still out "in the field" in the work truck. Since the virus passes between humans and animals such as deer and cats where it mutates, it was apparent I would be exposed at some time. I chose a course of action to make peace with my family, my God, and to remain vigilant about diet and health. A year later I got it and recovered at home.
It is generally not going to be a choice to avoid this virus. Hopefully it continues to mutate to be highly transmissible and less harmful like the seasonal flu.
Now if you instead had read the entire thing and believe his points are substantially correct I couldn't fault you for vouching for it even if I personally don't agree. I do not suggest you can't have your own opinion. Instead i suggest you form it and THEN vouch for what is actually worth reading. Things are mostly flagged for a reason.
I felt I'd read enough of the piece to trust the author's intentions. I liked her "consilience" example, and liked the overview she gave of where she was going. I've finished reading it now, and continue to feel confident that it is a solid piece worthy of discussion.
> Discussion isn't inherently virtuous.
I may disagree with this, but it depends on how literally we interpret "inherently". I certainly agree that not all discussions are productive, and some can cause more harm than good. But I also believe that understanding is between parties who disagree is practically impossible without discussion. I think the inherent virtue of discussion is that when it stops things often get worse.
I'm fairly strongly on the "mistake theory" side of conflict. I think that most people share common meta-goals, but have different strategies for how to get there. I think with more information sharing, conflict can be avoided. The alternative is "conflict theory", where the goals themselves are simply incompatible. I'm hoping this is not the case in the US, as I think that leads to literal civil war.
> Things are mostly flagged for a reason.
I agree. I think "Some small subset of flagged stories are worthy of discussion" is compatible with "Most flagged stories deserve to be flagged".
I commonly flag about 5-10 new stories a day, mostly outright spam. I probably vouch for about 1-2 stories per day that I feel have been wrongly (or unnecessarily) flagged. Of these, some drop off quietly for lack of attention, some are reflagged and disappear, some turn into flamewars, and some generate interesting discussion. I'm sure this story is not "spam", and I'm doing my best to put/keep this one in the category of "interesting discussion". I think this one is (barely) in the last category, and there are some scattered small productive discussions going on.
I feel like most people think this story is making a claim that it is not. As I see it, the main claim is that adverse reactions to the vaccine are likely to be underreported. I think this is true. The author believes that as a healthy young woman, the risk of the vaccine to her is greater than the benefit. I'm not sure if she's right here, but I do believe there certainly could be a cutoff age where this could be true.
Some people think that publicly acknowledging this possibility needs to be avoided, because it lends credence to "anti-vaxxers". Possibly true, but I think they are already set in their ways. I'm more concerned that the government bodies (and "Science" as a whole) may be unnecessarily burning their credibility for future events by trying to bend the truth to better fit their desired outcome of having everyone take the vaccine. I think they are well intentioned, but don't think the "noble lie" is a good long term strategy. I'd hoped for more discussion on that level, but at least there is some.
A data scientist who is an ex-biologist who is quoting line doctors and cobbling bits of social media isn't some powerful truth-finder. They're just muddying the waters and making it harder for the public health establishment reduce mistrust.
I also don't think there is any interesting rational discussion that's going to come from posts like this since they don't rise to the level of scientific discussion.
That is literally, exactly what heretics were punished for: reducing confidence in things that were believed to be in the public interest.
So if you didn't flag this for being wrong, or at least for being written in bad faith (neither of which you have alleged), then yes you did flag it for being heretical.
I find your view dangerous. You believe the chances, that his person is "right" are vanishingly small? That's of course a good reason to flag (delete) that article. Why allow an discussion or other to read the piece and have their own opinion. I cannot believe people are saying things like that with a good conscience.
Note that there is an entire scientific literature where experts in this field argue these things and that is where the "heretics" need to go make their arguments. This work is propaganda designed to make people doubt the public health establishment, not a good-faith argument.
Let's assume you are correct.
Your claim seems to presuppose that the author believes the opposite of what the piece suggests ("not a good faith argument"). Why did the author go to such lengths to design this propaganda? Why do they want to make people doubt the public health establishment? How do they profit from that?
I could see claiming that they are wrong (though I'm not qualified to evaluate that), I just don't at all understand the claim of bad faith.
This is usually how I feel about claims of bad faith in general (and the internet is lousy with them of late). Maybe I am just naive. I tend to think it's more likely that people believe what they say and are potentially incorrect than that they are incorrect and know it, yet still make the claims anyway.
It sounds like you're saying they are incompetent, not dishonest.
I ask because I see this all over the place, and almost every time I see "bad faith" or "disingenuous" (which I think are synonymous) I wonder if the person writing it just saw someone else use it incorrectly and never learned what it actually means, or if I just don't understand what it means myself.
For the sheer quantity of usages like yours, I should probably assume I'm wrong, but I'm having trouble reconciling that with the definition.
You say upthread that they believe the thing they are trying to convince us of. You also say that they are competently using tricks to fool us into believing the thing that they believe is true. Why would they be fooling us into believing something that they believe to be true? And if they were, would that even be deceptive?
This doesn't seem coherent to me. What am I missing?
We were also taught how to identify this and counteract it. In high school we spent a lot of time analyzing William F Buckley's article https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/00/07/16/s... which uses rhetoric to make a utilitarian argument.
> ... the author is right, and should, above all, have the goal of convincing the reader ...
It still seems logically inconsistent to me to call that bad faith.
Let me try from a different angle. In my mental model, bad faith requires that the author try to convince you of something that they know is untrue (or at least may likely be untrue). Is my model wrong? If so, how?
you can't just call everyone who disagrees with your worldview L. Ron Hubbard and be done with it.
You will simply continue chanting how right you were ad-infinitum regardless of actual evidence for or indeed against it.
Given the ppl I've spoken with, this is slightly off target assumption. It's not the jab they fear per se. It's the sources (gov + pharma) and the context (heavyhanded hyperbolic data / stats manipulation), and as of late the authoritarian efforts to force the jabs on anyone (above 5 yo) with a pulse.
If these people have a fear, it's that given the facts too few others have no fear at all.
This article even includes using Facebook responses of people claiming to be part of the "consilience" of vaccine data being incorrect as one of the most egregious examples of proof of "consilience".
Some people are saying: "this person is a biologist we should trust them". Please check out their Linkedin, Linkedin posts/resposts, and Twitter and understand this persons background and where this information is coming from.
I'm doubly vaccinated and boosted, as is my wife, as are my parents. Despite having somewhat adverse reactions to the shots, I'm pretty sure my wife and I are safer this way, and even more sure my parents are. But I think discussion is a good thing though. Maybe I'm wrong, maybe there's evidence I haven't seen, maybe others are unconvinced and the rebuttals here will be what convinces them.
I mention this to suggest that before flagging this as heretical, please consider what message you are sending by doing so, and what the impacts will be. Do you think those who are currently afraid to be vaccinated will change their mind if only we can prevent them from reading more things that might encourage them? Are you absolutely certain everything you currently believe is true, and the end of the story? Or might something useful come from discussing---and possibly rebutting---this post?