I have no idea if her concerns have merit, but I don't believe it should be shot down without consideration either.
UK’s vaccine top advisory body (that refused to recommend the vaccine for 12-15 age bracket) membership:
Professor Andrew Pollard, Chair (University of Oxford)
Professor Lim Wei Shen, Chair COVID-19 immunisation (Nottingham University Hospitals)
Professor Anthony Harnden, Deputy Chair (University of Oxford)
Dr Kevin Brown (Public Health England)
Dr Rebecca Cordery (Public Health England)
Dr Maggie Wearmouth (East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust)
Professor Matt Keeling (University of Warwick)
Alison Lawrence (lay member) Professor Robert Read (Southampton General Hospital)
Professor Anthony Scott (London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine)
Professor Adam Finn (University of Bristol)
Dr Fiona van der Klis (National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Netherlands)
Professor Maarten Postma (University of Groningen)
Professor Simon Kroll (Imperial College London)
Dr Martin Williams (University Hospitals Bristol)
Professor Jeremy Brown (University College London Hospitals)
Approved government media: https://www.bbc.com/news/health-58438669
What was the risk and is it approved for discussion if the absolute top vaccine experts declined to recommend it and a government funded news media, BBC, reported on that?
Is this too fringe to talk about?
Is BBC anti-vaxx now? Are these professors anti-vaxxers?
That's not what the BBC is
How much more government approval do you need? The Queen to notarize personally every utterance, noise and word they say/write?
It's literally as close to that as one can get, has a Royal Charter too.
Next would be the queen herself broadcasting live 24/7/365, might be hard to get that much juice out of a 90 year old. Maybe one day.
This is the youtube outlet for it
https://www.youtube.com/user/number10gov
Are you American by any chance? Is CBS a government mouthpiece because they carry actual government broadcasts like presidential addresses and have some oversight from a government agency (FCC)?
BBC is 100% government owned.
You are basically saying there is no difference between the Empire State Building and the White House.
Tell me again how the public should not get involved in the debate but this time give the right example and do it silently?
be the Chief of the Department of Bioethics approving questionable research such as sand flies eating live Beagles. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10130709/NIH-says-b... 'The NIH said that they did do leishmaniasis research on dogs in a laboratory in 2016, and in an enclosed open space in Tunisia, but not the research pictured.'
I think you have a different issue given your highly specific criticism of dog bioethics. THe NIH primarily concerns itself with human bioethics and permits some amount of very unpleasant research on model organisms.
If my goal was to cast fear, uncertainty and doubt into vaccines, I think I'd be able to weave a far more convincing web of lies that the folks worrying about a married NIH power couple.
I guess the way I look at Fauci is that he already proved his value in the HIV/AIDS crisis and it would be crazy not to trust somebody with that level of knowledge, levelheadedness, and connections.
During AIDS outbreak, Fauci pushed for FDA to approve the toxic and expensive drug known as AZT which was eventually discontinued. https://www.spin.com/2015/10/aids-and-the-azt-scandal-spin-1...
Bactrim was cheap and not approved. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/whitewashing-aids-history_b_4...
'Dr. Anthony Fauci is rewriting history. He is doing so to disguise his shameful role in delaying promotion of an AIDS treatment that would have prevented tens of thousands of deaths in the first years of the epidemic.
In my book, Body Counts, A Memoir of Politics, Sex, AIDS, and Survival, I recount how slow the federal government was in publicizing the use of Bactrim and other sulfa drugs to prevent PCP (the pneumonia that was then the leading killer of people with AIDS) in addition to its long-time and well-known use to treat PCP.'
Bactrim addresses a symptom of AIDS (specifically, a side bacterial infecftion that many people infected with HIV are prone to getting) while AZT reduces viral infections. Two completely different things. The former is for people who are infected, the latter for people to not get infected. The fog of virus is like the fog of war: easy to criticize from the distance of time.
I think you've said enough. It's clear what your opinion about Fauci is, and it's adding absolutely nothing to this discussion.
I wonder if the current quick magic cure demanded by the public may also overlook harmful side effects. The current pressure to dose those in low risk groups may be short-sighted. Ignoring risks is the subject of the thread.
There are no quick magic cures. AZT made a huge difference for a lot of people but it wasn't until later retrovirals (based on tech that didn't exist at that time) were released. It's still used in combination with other therapy.
Deep within the linked piece there is a small section entitled 'On “statistical significance”'. It says this:
Now, this result does not happen to be “statistically significant.”
People often use arguments like “but it’s not statistically significant” to try to discount results. I even hear people with PhDs or MDs say this, because somewhere in their schooling they were falsely taught that results need to be “statistically significant” to be “real.”
But even if a result is not statistically significant, absent better data, it still remains the best available estimate for the effect in question. This is just common sense. “Statistically insignificant” does not mean that there is no effect. More on statistical significance here: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-00857-9.
As a non-PhD who has (relatively) thought a lot about statistics, and who has previously linked others to that Nature article, this is the sort of balanced statement that makes me think she is not clueless. How about you?
BTW, I strongly disagree the quote you have about statistically insignificant data. It cannot be used to say there is no effect, or anything about the direction or magnitude of the effect. I'm not sure what a statement like """somewhere in their schooling they were falsely taught that results need to be “statistically significant” to be “real.”""" even means, significance is a mathematical/probabilistic formalism that has nothing to do with underlying reality, just with the event system you're working on.
BTW I set my p threshold at 1e-6 for a single test, 0.05 is just crazy. On the other hand, I've worked with systems where nobody cared about the significance, just that the weights that got pushed to production made more money than the last set of weights.
How about discussing those points with a roomful of non-PhD, non-scientists, with no particular knowledge of medicine in general?
If I drive across a bridge I should have the right to question the competency and the trust being put in the engineers. If something looks like a crack, I would ask detailed questions and I hope my fellow citizens would do the same. Can you really not find the logic, in good faith?
The end user can usefully participate in the network architecture debate if enough of their messages are vanishing. If the expert then says: "oh, but 1 in 2680 is rare" other professionals may adjust their opinion about them personally.
If they then go on a crusade to get the exchange scrubbed from the record it would make them more credible to you?
What’s yours?
Their membership:
----
Professor Andrew Pollard, Chair (University of Oxford)
Professor Lim Wei Shen, Chair COVID-19 immunisation (Nottingham University Hospitals)
Professor Anthony Harnden, Deputy Chair (University of Oxford)
Dr Kevin Brown (Public Health England)
Dr Rebecca Cordery (Public Health England)
Dr Maggie Wearmouth (East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust)
Professor Matt Keeling (University of Warwick)
Alison Lawrence (lay member)
Professor Robert Read (Southampton General Hospital)Professor Anthony Scott (London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine)
Professor Adam Finn (University of Bristol)
Dr Fiona van der Klis (National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Netherlands)
Professor Maarten Postma (University of Groningen)
Professor Simon Kroll (Imperial College London)
Dr Martin Williams (University Hospitals Bristol)
Professor Jeremy Brown (University College London Hospitals)
----
Can you spot the unwashed, uninformed, idiots-by-definition, masses here? The result might surprise you.
[0] https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/joint-committee-on-vacc...
In a few years the other political party will be elected and make decisions on your behalf. Will you be as keen on their mission to fight misinformation from this perspective of "people are sheep"?
I'm personally delighted whenever "the general public" is interested in participating in my field of expertise. I love describing how we scientifically approach the unknown with models and attempts at falsification. And how we make engineering decisions and for what reasons. You've never talked with non-technical people about browser standards and programming language design? If you can't present good counterpoints to uninformed statements then you don't understand your own field.
I've talked to non-technical people about technical subjects, to some success. But presenting good counterpoints to people who have no intention of playing the game honestly is wasting your breath.
Children also do not need to be wearing masks at school or social distancing in the cafeteria. We are harming our children by robbing them of a proper education and the experiences of childhood. And yet good luck trying to convince a covid alarmist of any of this.
They took the vaccine, so must everyone else, science be damned, seems to be their logic.
Some even post their vaccination cards, as if it’s some kind of scientific evidence. Absolutely crazy.
There also comes a point when you have explained something well enough, and then people are just deliberately “asking questions” not because they are being honest, but because there is an agenda. I see that attitude on HN all the time. It’s disguising honest enquiry.
And then there are people that will just ignore what you have done and still want to put their 2bits in.
prediction: this "article" contains 18 invalidating points in the first three paragraphs.
I didn't write this article, nor did I rigorously fact check it. But it struck me as at least, mostly reasonable questions around which to foment a discussion. Most of the points in this article I'd be comfortable asking to a room of PhD scientists with expertise on Covid and vaccines. I'd be disappointed to see this flagged.