It sounds like you're saying they are incompetent, not dishonest.
I ask because I see this all over the place, and almost every time I see "bad faith" or "disingenuous" (which I think are synonymous) I wonder if the person writing it just saw someone else use it incorrectly and never learned what it actually means, or if I just don't understand what it means myself.
For the sheer quantity of usages like yours, I should probably assume I'm wrong, but I'm having trouble reconciling that with the definition.
You say upthread that they believe the thing they are trying to convince us of. You also say that they are competently using tricks to fool us into believing the thing that they believe is true. Why would they be fooling us into believing something that they believe to be true? And if they were, would that even be deceptive?
This doesn't seem coherent to me. What am I missing?
We were also taught how to identify this and counteract it. In high school we spent a lot of time analyzing William F Buckley's article https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/00/07/16/s... which uses rhetoric to make a utilitarian argument.
> ... the author is right, and should, above all, have the goal of convincing the reader ...
It still seems logically inconsistent to me to call that bad faith.
Let me try from a different angle. In my mental model, bad faith requires that the author try to convince you of something that they know is untrue (or at least may likely be untrue). Is my model wrong? If so, how?
you can't just call everyone who disagrees with your worldview L. Ron Hubbard and be done with it.