News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:12PM (#29970492)
I'm 15. I read romance novels constantly. I begin to notice that the male love interests are all muscular billionaire vampire pirate bad boys with a dark side yearning to be tamed. No romance novelist ever writes a love interest who is an awkward teen boy who likes to read all day and play Magic the Gathering and video games all night. Why can't romance novelists represent me?
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by throwawaygh on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:33PM (#29970774)
(Because it apparently wasn't obvious, OP is not actually a 15 year old purveyor of young adult romance fiction. His post is mimicking the writing style of the article ("I'm 20 and a creative writing major...").)

BTW, there's a GoodReads list entitled "Nerdy Guys Are Hot" containing 114 books. And that list is obviously incomplete. For example, Harry Potter -- the most popular youth fiction series ever -- has a nerdy main character and plenty of romance subplots.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by slickdork on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:58PM (#29971053)
Are you saying Harry Potter himself was nerdy? Because he definitely never did homework or studied and lucked into every solution he ran into by dumb luck.

Hermione was nerdy, but was usually made fun of for being nerdy, and was a love interest despite her nerdy ways.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by throwawaygh on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:03PM (#29971109)
> Are you saying Harry Potter himself was nerdy?

Yes, in a certain sense, although a slightly more accurate characterization might be that Harry Potter is a nerd's idea of a hero. Although I have to admit my knowledge of the series is rather superficial, so perhaps I'm wrong.

> he definitely never did homework or studied and lucked into every solution he ran into by dumb luck.

Nerdy doesn't necessarily imply industrious or studious. I wouldn't say the average MtG or DnD player was a particularly good student at my high school.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by cgriswald on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:15PM (#29971212)
Harry didn't play DnD or MtG though. He lived in a magical world, and while some of those magical things occasionally caught his attention, he wasn't really deeply interested in any of it. His main concerns were social: casting unsubstantiated aspersions on Snape and Malfoy and occasionally being correct. He didn't care about any of his classes. His only real love was Quidditch, which he was naturally talented at, making him, if anything, a jock.

Rethinking through the series, which I have re-read within the past year, the only truly nerdy moments he has all involve girls; and then only really at the beginning of his involvement with girls. Very quickly, he begins to have quite mature thoughts regarding his relationships, even if he doesn't always make the right choices.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by willis936 on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:50PM (#29971568)
Harry Potter addressed this when Harry learned that his dad was Snape's childhood bully and cuckold.

Tina Fey also did a good exploration of this idea in 30 Rock S3E5 "Reunion" when Liz Lemon has to face the reality that she wasn't the nerdy victim but the bully. It's a recurring theme in media because no one ever thinks they're the bad guy. It's especially hard to tell when you're young and haven't learned how to be a human yet.

All that said, I don't think Harry was a bully. Malfoy was pretty unambiguously antagonistic. Snape was more antihero, but did make a point to antagonize Harry when he could. Harry mistook the antagonization as evidence that Snape was up to bad dealings because "I'm the good guy and my enemies are bad", but even this gets flipped on its head throughout the series. Malfoy doesn't become humanized until they show his family life in detail and even then he only redeems himself in the home stretch.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by watwut on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:34PM (#29972450)
DnD does not make you social outcast and hadn't for years already. It is just not know or popular.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by quacked on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:44PM (#29972031)
"Nerds idea of a hero" is a perfect way to represent it. Heroes thought up for nerds are non-threatening and approachable, unlike ancient heroes, who are threatening, great leaders of men, and often openly flaunt their "noble" lineage (Beowulf, Odysseus,etc.) Ancient heroes also often book real challenges to their hero status from their close allies.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by JackFr on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:44PM (#29972025)
Harry was literally the star athlete of his house. Definitely not a nerd.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by mlindner on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:41PM (#29971479)
On a side note, Japanese light pop fiction actually primarily does cater to the nerdy people/kids, to the point of excess. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_novel

Much of it is "sappy guy gets the girl(s)" type stories or other power fantasies/wish fulfillment of various kinds. (Or bookish girl gets found by prince charming or multiple prince charmings.) It's very popular over there. It's been a persistent thought in my mind why this type of stuff isn't written in the US (or if it is, I can't find it).

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by Sohakes on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:56PM (#29971602)
I watched two episodes of Komi Can't Communicate on Netflix and felt that. I thought it was good though, maybe it would have helped my socially anxious younger self.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by mbg721 on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:37PM (#29970813)
Wayne Brady: "How come there's no one who looks like me on Friends??" (audience: "awww")

Colin Mochrie: "How come there's no one who looks like me on Friends??" (audience goes wild with laughter)

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:48PM (#29970923)
I don't get this joke. I get Wayne Brady's - there are no black characters on Friends, but I don't get Colin's part. I tried watching the clip but I still don't understand it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djX7aDuqi48

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by mbg721 on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:51PM (#29970968)
Because he's bald and older (and very much eccentric), and Friends was fundamentally about young people in New York with no realistic means of support. The sequence is poking fun at the idea that race is the sole obstacle to paradise.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by function_seven on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:54PM (#29970998)
The joke is Colin is a bald guy who wouldn't be considered attractive. (I suppose Gunther is an example of that, but leeway for main cast vs. occasional supporting role)
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by di4na on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:21PM (#29970596)
There are romance novelists that do that ! i am not a romance specialist, but i know they exist. I advise to search a bit, maybe ask your local library. Romance is a really wide genre, the biggest, with a lot of different niche. It exist. I promise you.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:40PM (#29970848)
I'm not actually a romance novel enthusiast, I'm just parodying the article. From my point of view the article is a complaint about how Frank Miller, an author who specializes in writing edgy grimdark superhero comics for teenage boys, doesn't write the kind of character that might appeal to a 20-30 something feminist.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by majormajor on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:23PM (#29971830)
The article's complaint about Miller's stories goes quite a bit further than that.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @07:14PM (#29973234)
Please elaborate.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @07:20PM (#29973293)
There's a whole thread of elaboration on this point.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by dkarl on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:03PM (#29971107)
For me, as a fan of other kinds of escapist entertainment, the feeling of "ugh why am I not just doing this" is really easy to trigger, and it ruins the immersion and the fun. I need the fantasy to be not just attractive, but also unattainable, so that I don't start wondering, "If I'm so excited about this, why don't I take the relatively straightforward steps to experience it for myself?"

For example, imagine watching a Top Gear episode about the latest Ford Fiesta. Most of the fun of the show is the presenters, how they talk about the cars, and how much fun they seem to be having. I'm sure watching them I could get pretty excited about the Ford Fiesta. It could be a great episode! Except the fact that I could rent one for a day for $35 would force me to think about why I don't actually want to do that, why I would rather watch a TV show about driving it rather than driving it for myself, and the difference between fantasy and reality, and then the excitement evaporates pretty fast.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:58PM (#29971627)
What's your point? That's a valid criticism of dime-store romance novels.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:25PM (#29971845)
My point is that not everything appeals equally to all people. The reason dime-store romance novels aren't centered on nerdy boys is because they are trying to entertain adult women. Frank Miller's comics are about edgy superheroes, violence, and sex from a perspective that's trying to appeal to teenage boys.

If you're trying to write a book that appeals equally to all people without offending anyone, I think you'll end up with something anodyne. Some authors have a consistent style or niche and I don't think anything is wrong with that.

Finally, it's also not true that there are no romance novels focused on nerdy boys. There are plenty. Likewise, there are plenty of comic books where women or girls are portrayed well or are the focus of the story.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:42PM (#29972008)
Polo's criticism of Miller isn't rooted in its appeal to teenaged boys. It's taking dead aim at Miller's reputation as a forerunner for "comics for adults", and as a skilled deconstructer of superhero archetypes on a level with Alan Moore. So this rebuttal doesn't really say much, does it?

Polo is criticizing Miller in a way that you could not, for instance, criticize Todd MacFarlane, who had the clearly defined audience you're thinking of. It wouldn't make sense; of course MacFarlane's work was silly and superficial; that's the point.

This is a thing people say a lot about Roger Ebert --- that part of his skill as a critic was his ability to put himself in the shoes of the intended audience for a piece, and evaluate it on those terms, so that for instance he could give 4 stars to "Iron Man", the same rating he'd give to "Tokyo Story".

Polo's criticism here is compatible with Ebert's approach.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:45AM (#29976284)
The word "adult" is used once in that post and in context it is about how a 12 year old thought the comics were meant for adults. Where do you get the idea that Miller's reputation is "comics for adults"? The author, for example, read them as a child. My impression is that mostly these comics are read by teen boys. If your impression is that they are read by adults then I suppose one of us would need to bring in some data to break the impasse. If I wanted to research it I would use the Google ad word tool to check the demographics of who searches for "Frank Miller" and his different comic books.

Miller's comics are known to be "gritty", violent, whatever. That's his style. The author liked it when she was a child and doesn't like it having grown up. That seems not too remarkable to me.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:45AM (#29980833)
Are you familiar with Miller or do you come by your understanding of him just from this piece? Because Miller is like, on the vanguard of the "comics for adults" movement. It would be like saying Salvador Dalí is known for his surrealist work; it hardly needs a cite.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by watwut on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:39PM (#29972505)
It sounds to me that you did not read the article you are commenting on.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:07PM (#29971697)
I think the point is that you can hate Frank Miller's work without hating all comics.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:09PM (#29971711)
The author probably didn't even write the headline, which is the only place that sentiment appears in the piece. I'm pretty confident she's aware of Love and Rockets, Bone, and Maus.

Maybe it's helpful just to mentally substitute "superhero comics" for "comics".

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:17PM (#29971778)
Fair. Though, I suspect some super hero comics are fine.

I am also ok with the thought that that earlier exposure clouds all later exposure.

I am further ok with someone not liking comics. Or super hero stories.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:39PM (#29971970)
That seems like the interesting discussion to have, right? Whether there are superhero comics that confound Miller-ism.

I can't really think of any, though maybe early-1990s X-Men, which had a palpable subtext about bigotry long before that was a super trendy idea (making the series antagonist himself an opponent of bigotry was a pretty slick move).

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:50PM (#29972082)
Sandman stands in my mind. Though, most folks don't think of those as super hero.

I think most of that is definitionally, though. If you accept that super hero comics are bad, you probably consider any good ones to not be super hero.

Edit: that said, Gaiman's Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader is undeniably a super hero comic. Complete with an amazing call out to Goodnight Moon.

Edit2: Perez's Wonder Woman set is highly regarded, I think. In many ways more feminist than current works, from my memory.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:54PM (#29972122)
It's so not a superhero comic that DC actually came up with a new imprint for it and Hellblazer. It was, very briefly, a Moore-style sendup of superhero comics ("sleep, and if you wish, you may dream of the city of focative mirrors"), but shed that almost immediately when Gaiman got his footing.

But like, I stopped reading superhero comics pretty quickly (I got to comics late, with Punisher [gag] and X-Men, and switched within like a year to the Vertigo/Cerebus/Comix stuff). So for all I know, there's a long "Aquaman" arc where he subtextually confronts misogyny or contemplates Rawlsianism.

"Wonder Woman" is a good example! Thanks!

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:04PM (#29972201)
My only qualm is that I feel that is shifting definitions. I'm reminded of folks calling what Gaiman writes as graphic novels, not comics. Which... Seems silly. Especially since I remember buying them, as comics.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by jason-phillips on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:23PM (#29970621)
"It's a fool that looks for logic in the chambers of the human heart."

--Ulysses Everett McGill

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:22PM (#29970615)
If you continue your campaign with vision, intelligence, humor and wit, there's a chance that the books you're looking for might emerge. Good luck!
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by oweiler on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:32PM (#29970752)
Not exactly romance but I guess IT comes close enough

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8697402-scott-pilgrim-th...

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by JKCalhoun on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:52PM (#29970972)
So super hero comics are for (pre) adolescent, straight white boys?

That's too bad because I have been told that that was a stereotype and was no longer true.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by savingsPossible on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:08PM (#29971156)
Super hero comics are not. These super hero comics might be?
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by JKCalhoun on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:18PM (#29971244)
Fair.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by watwut on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:36PM (#29972470)
This sort of point would be much stronger if it was not too apparent you don't know what is in romance books nor surrounding culture nor types of conflicts going on in there.