News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:58PM (#29971627)
What's your point? That's a valid criticism of dime-store romance novels.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:25PM (#29971845)
My point is that not everything appeals equally to all people. The reason dime-store romance novels aren't centered on nerdy boys is because they are trying to entertain adult women. Frank Miller's comics are about edgy superheroes, violence, and sex from a perspective that's trying to appeal to teenage boys.

If you're trying to write a book that appeals equally to all people without offending anyone, I think you'll end up with something anodyne. Some authors have a consistent style or niche and I don't think anything is wrong with that.

Finally, it's also not true that there are no romance novels focused on nerdy boys. There are plenty. Likewise, there are plenty of comic books where women or girls are portrayed well or are the focus of the story.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:42PM (#29972008)
Polo's criticism of Miller isn't rooted in its appeal to teenaged boys. It's taking dead aim at Miller's reputation as a forerunner for "comics for adults", and as a skilled deconstructer of superhero archetypes on a level with Alan Moore. So this rebuttal doesn't really say much, does it?

Polo is criticizing Miller in a way that you could not, for instance, criticize Todd MacFarlane, who had the clearly defined audience you're thinking of. It wouldn't make sense; of course MacFarlane's work was silly and superficial; that's the point.

This is a thing people say a lot about Roger Ebert --- that part of his skill as a critic was his ability to put himself in the shoes of the intended audience for a piece, and evaluate it on those terms, so that for instance he could give 4 stars to "Iron Man", the same rating he'd give to "Tokyo Story".

Polo's criticism here is compatible with Ebert's approach.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by ALittleLight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:45AM (#29976284)
The word "adult" is used once in that post and in context it is about how a 12 year old thought the comics were meant for adults. Where do you get the idea that Miller's reputation is "comics for adults"? The author, for example, read them as a child. My impression is that mostly these comics are read by teen boys. If your impression is that they are read by adults then I suppose one of us would need to bring in some data to break the impasse. If I wanted to research it I would use the Google ad word tool to check the demographics of who searches for "Frank Miller" and his different comic books.

Miller's comics are known to be "gritty", violent, whatever. That's his style. The author liked it when she was a child and doesn't like it having grown up. That seems not too remarkable to me.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:45AM (#29980833)
Are you familiar with Miller or do you come by your understanding of him just from this piece? Because Miller is like, on the vanguard of the "comics for adults" movement. It would be like saying Salvador Dalí is known for his surrealist work; it hardly needs a cite.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by watwut on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:39PM (#29972505)
It sounds to me that you did not read the article you are commenting on.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:07PM (#29971697)
I think the point is that you can hate Frank Miller's work without hating all comics.
Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:09PM (#29971711)
The author probably didn't even write the headline, which is the only place that sentiment appears in the piece. I'm pretty confident she's aware of Love and Rockets, Bone, and Maus.

Maybe it's helpful just to mentally substitute "superhero comics" for "comics".

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:17PM (#29971778)
Fair. Though, I suspect some super hero comics are fine.

I am also ok with the thought that that earlier exposure clouds all later exposure.

I am further ok with someone not liking comics. Or super hero stories.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:39PM (#29971970)
That seems like the interesting discussion to have, right? Whether there are superhero comics that confound Miller-ism.

I can't really think of any, though maybe early-1990s X-Men, which had a palpable subtext about bigotry long before that was a super trendy idea (making the series antagonist himself an opponent of bigotry was a pretty slick move).

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:50PM (#29972082)
Sandman stands in my mind. Though, most folks don't think of those as super hero.

I think most of that is definitionally, though. If you accept that super hero comics are bad, you probably consider any good ones to not be super hero.

Edit: that said, Gaiman's Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader is undeniably a super hero comic. Complete with an amazing call out to Goodnight Moon.

Edit2: Perez's Wonder Woman set is highly regarded, I think. In many ways more feminist than current works, from my memory.

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by tptacek on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:54PM (#29972122)
It's so not a superhero comic that DC actually came up with a new imprint for it and Hellblazer. It was, very briefly, a Moore-style sendup of superhero comics ("sleep, and if you wish, you may dream of the city of focative mirrors"), but shed that almost immediately when Gaiman got his footing.

But like, I stopped reading superhero comics pretty quickly (I got to comics late, with Punisher [gag] and X-Men, and switched within like a year to the Vertigo/Cerebus/Comix stuff). So for all I know, there's a long "Aquaman" arc where he subtextually confronts misogyny or contemplates Rawlsianism.

"Wonder Woman" is a good example! Thanks!

Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them... by taeric on Monday January 17, 2022 @05:04PM (#29972201)
My only qualm is that I feel that is shifting definitions. I'm reminded of folks calling what Gaiman writes as graphic novels, not comics. Which... Seems silly. Especially since I remember buying them, as comics.