When you have someone deliberately setting fires and blocking the escape routes with a knife, you have bigger problems than just one stairwell.
The software world is well versed in the concept of a single point of failure, and the importance of eliminating it and mitigating any chance.
And yet here we are downplaying a critical design problem because it was a single point of failure?
A "crazy trap-setting knifeman attack" is not the only scenario that results in a blocked exit trapping people inside the building in a life-threatening situation. Think about it for a second. Imagine, for instance, that a fire breaks out for any reason. Is this unthinkable? And how do you factor in emergency response personnel trying to go up the same stairs that are the only way out of people trapped in the building?
We should not forget past lessons for no reason.
Yes, past lessons should be remembered but it looks like there is no data that would support building double staircases in reality - it's just too rare of a problem. Same reason why almost nowhere in the world requires outside fire exits like many buildings in NYC do - they are great in idea and I'm sure there are examples of them saving lives, but it's not worth making them a requirement for every building ever made.
Keep in mind that the bread and butter of engineering is "extremely rare circumstances".
In civil engineering, infrastructure is designed with 100 year floods and 50 year seismic events in mind.
Blocking the only exit does not come even close to be a rare event.
Part of modern US stairwell regulation also learned from 9/11, where they found out it wasn't a great idea to have all the required stairwells very close to each other either.
That’s a whole lot better than 1 stairwell!
Anyway. Most of the world does not go up in flames regularly, despite having not having this regulation.
Some folks would get stuck and not get out, but it generally requires dedicated eyes on a crowd if you want to keep them inside something for any length of time. Hence prison guards, locks being a dedicated profession, etc.
Let's say a lot of them are garbage and you only hear about the rare occasions it works. Let's say 10% of the time the fire is good enough to kill.
Two stair wells means only 1% of the time you get a kill.
Lighting two fires is also harder, you need more planning and stuff. So that probably equals out a bit for the better fire lighters.
If it's Mossad doing it then sure it's possibly similar.
Don't really need to be an expert in starting fires.
Certainly not impossible, but it requires more craftiness and more prep the more complicated we get.
Which hopefully there aren’t that many folks who are likely to do so. And if someone does, we can catch them fast.
Basic redundancy is a good idea (n=2) in general, for many many reasons. Maintenance doesn’t take out the only way out for instance, or a single fight or accident doesn’t leave someone stuck.
N=5 is probably overkill for anything for a huge convention center.
How many house fires are there? How many of them are in tall buildings? How many of them would block just one stair, and not two?
Yes, there is a probability that an extra stair will save your life; however, this is a very tiny probability, against a certainty of extra living space, for everyone, every day.
I hate the space argument because its a money argument, not a real quality of life issue - make the building 1 floor taller, or don't cram your residents just because you wanted to milk 4 apts instead of 3 on a floor.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_building_or_structure_...
We can also see if mass casualty fires in buildings stopped happening after the regulation change.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooklyn_Theatre_fire
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fi...
https://www.nytimes.com/1860/02/03/archives/calamitous-fire-...
You realize that this would mean the three residents would have to pay more for their unit, right? It isn’t just developers “milking” condo buyers or tenants. It has to do with efficiency.
We would have many new cars for 4-digit prices if not for the large number of safety systems required on cars.
And buildings in North America are often framed out of the same material that they burn in their fireplaces.
Both present inherent dangers. Both have widespread safety regulations for this reason.
Vehicle accidents are the 2nd leading cause of accidental death in the US and fires are 6th. And this is the result of many decades of both being highly regulated.
People still die in scary numbers there no matter the regulations.
Cars can't be made safer anymore. 60Mphs frontal collisions have single digit percentage survivability chance because physics.
Homes can be made much safer by building them differently.
A lot of those people live in seismically active areas. While modern masonry construction is certainly safer than traditional masonry, in general wood is far less dangerous than stone or brick in an earthquake.
Note: not apartments. Houses.
Steel and concrete are ugly and cold. Wood is warm. Even brick and stone are more humane.
Cars can absolutely be made safer. They certainly haven’t stopped getting safer yet.
2. 60mph is a speed not a force imparted on a vehicle. The way with which a vehicle’s momentum at 60mph is dissipated makes a critical difference to the crash energy imparted on the occupants. Road design has greatly improved this in recent decades.
3. Active crash prevention/mitigation systems can prevent 60mph accidents from happening or improve their outcomes.
Yes, but that doesn't count as surviving the crash
> 60mph is a speed not a force imparted on a vehicle.
The force imparted on you in a 60mph crash by the seatbelt will be lethal no matter how much deceleration space you have. You got at 27 meters per second, and you only have at a maximum 1 meter to decelerate. And if you crash into a heavier, faster vehicle, it's even worse.
It counts as making cars safer which was the above claim I am supporting.
> you only have at a maximum 1 meter to decelerate. And if you crash into a heavier, faster vehicle, it's even worse.
Most vehicle crashes are not head-on incidents.
Improvements in road design have affected the proportion of crashes that are head-on. Recent improvements in active safety features may decrease this further: eg. lane departure mitigation.
In many real-world accidents, vehicles have dozens or hundreds of meters to decelerate.
It's not the speed that kills you, it's the impact. Multifloor buildings are designed to help you live and work at a height that can kill you, and to prevent air entering and escaping which can kill you.
If you can assume that the risk of fire or collapse isn't worth mitigating against, why not assume that a car will never hit anything?
For example, if I can cram 14 windowless apartments into the same floor, is it really unfair that that 4 tenants would have to pay more than the 14?
A circular shape with one exit it's much harder to be stuck into by a single ignition point.
No one should be surprised that fire safety laws are going to the extreme for safety at a large cost to floor space.
On a totally different note, I can't find any cheap or affordable new cars. Am looking for basic wheels without finicky gadgets like backup cameras and tire pressure monitors and lane departure warnings. Something simple and without high insurance costs to cover all those gadgets I don't need.
I wonder why things (house, car) seem unaffordable and contain gadgets which are difficult to fix and which increase insurance costs. What happened America?
And the still working quite far back vehicles are pretty valuable because they have stood the test of time and don’t have all the buzzword crap, so folks don’t want to part with them.
The old cheap ones also got fed into a grinder (essentially) for cash for clunkers.
If fire advocates really cared they would figure out the rules to follow and that would make it much cheaper for everyone.
Why wouldn't you be able to compare statistics from the US to any other country that doesn't have that rule?
I'm also guessing that fire reporting doesn't include the level of detail you would need. For example, a fire in which firefighters were able to tackle from two sides would be quickly extinguished, where as the same fire with 1-sided access might have become a disaster. But thats a what-if, only learned the hard way.
You need to go back and read the article more closely. It's a HUGE quality of life issue; mainly US building codes restrict apartments to one side of the building which has all kinds of implications - cross airflow, alignment of rooms with the sun - and the ability to have more variety of sizes of units to better meet needs that currently go unmet, especially with families.
I mean if you look at the article the majority of it is all about quality of life - not only for the apartments, but greater/more effective use of the stairwells and common areas.
That's the weirdest euphemism for murder I've ever seen.
I don't believe he killed his son, and I believe the wording in the articles is intended to indicate that he tried to force his son to kill himself and ended up stabbing him in the head.
Good point. But to be fair, you should consider the injuries and deaths caused by elderly falling off stairs - 1M injuries, 12,000 deaths in the US alone. [0]
Compared that with 3,700 deaths and 16,600 injuries for ALL fires, not just fires in buildings [1].
My view would be that stairs KILL, and that new buildings should avoid stairs (at least, within a single unit) at all costs. We should also rethink how we design stairs and stair safety, and adjust building codes accordingly. Of course, this will most likely never happen.
[0]: https://www.attorneywdkickham.com/stairway-staircase-acciden....
As to fire, that is but one of many other safety concerns, I personally will never live in a place that only has 1 escape vector, even if fire concerns were mitigated
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Osaka_building_fire
> The victims gasped for air and had difficulties escaping, as there was only one escape route, with the emergency stairs and elevators being located outside the clinic.
> Experts were surprised by the fire's high death toll. The authorities are investigating how victims became trapped and the floor filled up with smoke so quickly.
> Minister for Internal Affairs and Communications Yasushi Kaneko ordered the inspection of some 30,000 buildings in Japan that have three or more floors, but only a single stairwell.