News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by Kuinox on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:22AM (#29672682)
in mice.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by omgitsabird on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:27AM (#29673059)
This low-effort comment is popping up more and more.

I would say just assume the title has "in mouse disease model" at the end of it.

Then we can get away from the large dismissive negativity spiral that all of these threads turn into.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by fareed79 on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:54AM (#29673211)
It appears to be on mice only in the 5th paragraph, and the sole photo is of a patient (before it is said to be on mice). Sarcasm/negativity is a normal reaction when you spot an ad for a local university with a random research with especially touches most of us. It is not so hard to be honest and support honest research and these respectable advances without such tricks.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by jtbayly on Friday December 24, 2021 @08:36AM (#29673438)
No.

The title is clickbait. It claims there is an effective treatment for ALS.

It is so bogus. In mice should be added to the title.

Thank you, GP, for the “in mice” comment. In this case it was absolutely crucial for me getting what was going on.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by xyzzy21 on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:13PM (#29675334)
The warning is 100% correct. What works in mice only works in humans about 20% of the time and it's even smaller that it works without toxicity or adverse effects in humans even then. So eagerly expecting a human treatment is irrational and pollyanna.

Typically it's 10-20 years after animal studies such as mice or monkeys before you can expect doctors to have it available. And that's assuming everything work just right.

This is the same mistake MANY people make when some new wonder-technology is announced from university labs - it's another 20 years before an economically viable product that actually is available to consumers will be appearing. It's often called the "20 year rule". New battery technology could solve green energy? But it's just a lab discovery? Nope. Not anytime soon!!

I recently did a study of this for penicillin: it was almost exactly 20 years from Fleming discovering it to when consumers could get it from their doctors or hospitals post-WW2!

Transistors didn't start to eclipse vacuum tubes in consumer electronics until 20 years after the invention of the transistor (1948 to early 1970s). Same for integrated circuits - 20 years before the Silicon Valley boom took off (1959 to mid-to-late 1970s) and consumers started to benefit with PCs.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by junon on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:46AM (#29673160)
Not really low effort if it points out a huge problem in the world of scientific journalism...
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by scoopertrooper on Friday December 24, 2021 @08:06AM (#29673254)
The article stated exactly the limitations of the experiment. It was conducted with mice and only mice with a less common form of ALS.

I'd say the problem is less with journalism in this instance, and more-so with peoples limited attention spans.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ProjectArcturis on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:48AM (#29674004)
The article didn't even name the drug. It's a terrible article.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by scoopertrooper on Friday December 24, 2021 @10:22AM (#29674283)
I had a quick look around, no article seems to mention it, but the article leaves enough clues that it's pretty easy to find. The drug is curcumin derivative GT863, I'm not sure how much that enriched either of our understandings though.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356971571_Therapeut...

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by maximus-decimus on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:02AM (#29673632)
It's a problem with the title.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by scoopertrooper on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:12AM (#29673717)
My point regarding attention span stands. The title could certain do with improvement, but people should not be consuming their news of the basis of titles.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by maximus-decimus on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:21AM (#29673786)
I do because most articles are crap. The comments are simply better quality. For example, I was able to tell in 2 seconds that this was on mice from reading the comments and so that I don't care about the article.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by scoopertrooper on Friday December 24, 2021 @10:26AM (#29674328)
Quite often comments are wrong, top-rated comments are often reflective of bombastic conclusions arrived at (and upvoted) by people who had not read the article.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by D-Coder on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:46PM (#29675703)
The first page of HN has thirty articles. I can't read all of them. I don't recognize the author's names, so I can't judge by that. The number of comments does not tell me if I will be interested in the article. The title is all I have to go on.

Admittedly, I should probably assume that anything relating to Alzheimer's or Parkinson's has an implicit "(in mice)" tag.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by omgitsabird on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:57AM (#29673220)
Isn't this more of a problem with HN guidelines for submitting articles than anything else?

If someone reads the article, they see where it says this is in a mouse model of an uncommon form of ALS.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by actually_a_dog on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:44PM (#29678485)
Yes. There are lots of problems with the HN "guidelines," not least of which that they're actually rules you get punished for breaking and not "guidelines" you can choose not to follow.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by busyant on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:12PM (#29675326)
Low effort, but high information density.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by cute_boi on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:41AM (#29673936)
"Mice lies Monkey Exaggerate"

The title is deceiving and it should contain mice. And such criticism are okay in my book.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by Aaargh20318 on Friday December 24, 2021 @08:22AM (#29673343)
Every time I read about some drug that appeared to work in animal models but not in actual humans I wonder how often the opposite is true. We are necessarily limiting ourselves to drugs that work in humans + at least one other species.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by dorkwood on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:44AM (#29672807)
How do they find mice with ALS?
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ekianjo on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:45AM (#29672816)
Mice models which have pretty much nothing to do with actual ALS.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ProjectArcturis on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:51AM (#29674037)
You're getting downvoted, but this is exactly right. We create a mutant mouse that has symptoms that are somewhat similar to the disease we're studying. Then we find a drug that cures the "disease" in the mouse. Then we try it in humans and it fails and we make the shocked Pikachu face.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by sva_ on Friday December 24, 2021 @10:33AM (#29674387)
Similar deal with Alzheimer's.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by chaps on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:59AM (#29672897)
Can you clarify? Like, I would assume that if it's still named "ALS" that there are some commonalities. If those differences are big enough (to the extent that the models are nothing alike) why is the naming shared?

Happy to accept "bad journalism"!

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by johnisgood on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:23AM (#29673034)
I dunno, but when they do research on MS (multiple sclerosis), they do it on mice with experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), which is an animal model of MS.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by moffkalast on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:13PM (#29675335)
If a medical researcher can't give a mouse cancer and cure it he ain't any good.

Somewhat better ones can do the same for ALS it seems.

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by hunterb123 on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:31AM (#29672737)
Is this trope necessary every time? It's clearly in mice in the article.

Just consider it an update if you're skeptical, now they'll be moving on to the next set of mice w/ sporadic or non-inherited ALS....

Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ekianjo on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:46AM (#29672823)
It took them 6 paragraphs to mention mice. Thats astonishing how much they oversell this kind of stuff.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by shawnz on Friday December 24, 2021 @11:58AM (#29675192)
Is it really such a big deal for them to build hype around a potentially promising medical advancement? What's the downside of this kind of reporting? Even if the drug fails, maybe it will spur more research into similar candidates
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by toast0 on Friday December 24, 2021 @01:17PM (#29676110)
This type of reporting contributes to announcement fatigue. What use is all this hype now for something that is probably 5 years out from the market, if it even works (which past results suggest is unlikely).
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by shawnz on Friday December 24, 2021 @01:28PM (#29676228)
Has that actually been demonstrated? I don't personally feel fatigued by medical advancements which ended up not panning out. In fact they make me feel hopeful about the future and glad to exist in a society where such research is even possible.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ekianjo on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:31AM (#29682385)
Maybe you are still young? When you have seen 30 years of such revolutionary tech in pharma every other week with 0.001 % actual outcomes on the market, yes, you get tired of it.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by shawnz on Saturday December 25, 2021 @12:08PM (#29684828)
I am approximately 30 if that's what you meant. I think a 0.001% success rate is pretty good for revolutionary technologies and I'm glad to have those successes. I think it is wrong to downplay the importance of the failed attempts just to increase that success rate. More absolute successes is strictly better than a higher success rate.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by ekianjo on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:29AM (#29682375)
getting clicks for overhyping stuff that in 99.99% of the case does not even make it to human trials. Shoving ads in your face at the same time.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by shawnz on Saturday December 25, 2021 @12:09PM (#29684833)
Admittedly I'm using an adblocker and didn't notice the latter problem, which sounds annoying. But I don't see why the former is a problem on its own.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by cblconfederate on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:17AM (#29673002)
If people are so bothered by mouse research, why don't we have a line of research aiming to make humans look more like mice?
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by msie on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:34AM (#29672758)
They could have tried the drug on humans but they wouldn’t have had the results they got with mice.
Re:Japanese university finds Alzheimer's drug effective in t... by TheChaplain on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:54AM (#29672864)
They probably have plenty of candidates, but if the outcome would make the situation worse for the patient... Well, they'd be in for a world of bad PR and possibly legal issues.

Imagine the headlines.. "Company X ruined the last living days of patient"