They could just invest in well-established projects with proven technology instead of obvious scams in hopes of a "moon shot". This has very little to do with Bitcoin and other legitimate projects, which are a far cry from useless fly-by-night ERC-20 tokens with stupid animal names
If you want to push for those technologies, you have to explain how to give consumers a minimum level of protection.
I am working with people in the banking industry to add a layer of protection without compromising core values of crypto (permissionless, trustless), but funnily enough they do not want to do anything against the regulators. Retail banks have become very cautious after 2008 and won't do anything unless they are told to do it by the regulators. And the regulators are a bit clueless, tbh.
The Winklevosses came up with an elaborate system to store and secure their own private keys. They cut up printouts of their private keys into pieces and then distributed them in envelopes to safe deposit boxes around the country, so if one envelope were stolen the thief would not have the entire key.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/19/technology/bitcoin-winkle...
So these dudes both "saw" FB and cryptocurrencies.
Hate as much as you want on FB and cryptocurrencies, it's still quite a feat to have foreseen both.
Regarding storing parts of the secret here and there: it's basically and "m out of n" scheme AFAICT. There are many variations of this but the overall idea is that you can afford to lose (n - m) parts and yet you'll be able to recover the secret. And if a thief were to steal parts, he'd need m parts to be able to recover the secret.
The difference between a Shamir scheme and a true multi-signature scheme is that the former requires combining the m-of-n pieces to reveal the single private key to sign a transaction, which is a huge vulnerability and single point of failure.
Bitcoin script allows the m-of-n signatures to remain geographically dispersed, each signing the transaction with only their own key, so no single party ever needs to possess the full private key.
In a exaggerated 100-out-of-1000 scheme, even if you steal 99 out of the 100 required shares, you still have zero information. You are better off trying to brute force the value from scratch than trying to use the 99 shares you have.
It's also very simple to implement, making it my favorite algorithm.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information-theoretic_security
Some will say that you can still prosecute the crimes even if you can't initially reverse the transaction, but you can see how well that is working with hackers from adversary nations. Basically no prosecution and risk free ability to move on to the next victim.
"Friction is a feature with money transfer"
My experience is that moving money between countries where there is a high likelihood of collaborative justice against scams and thefts, ends up being pretty simple. It gets harder to transfer money to places where it is easier for thefts and scammers to get away with it.
I think we want it this way. How many people get taken in by the romance scams[1] where they wire their money to a country with 0 chance of recovery. The money transfer system has been specifically making it more difficult to send money to countries where this is commonplace as that is the only effective way to stop the crime. There is no viable criminal process only friction to make it less profitable and more difficult for the scammers.
[1] https://www.fbi.gov/scams-and-safety/common-scams-and-crimes...
from my perspective, you are comparing a user experience that has nothing to do with the technology.
a bank is a third party service providing custody to bearer instruments.
a future financial institution will be a third party service providing custody or other protections to your crypto bearer instruments.
> If trillion dollar market caps and god-knows-how-many billions of investment couldn't figure out how to protect consumers after 13 years...
there are DeFi insurance protocols, many people get paid back after being scammed, rug pulled, exploited. Look at the source, it is convenient for this to not be mentioned as all chainanalysis does is sell fear to governments to land contracts.
That's true some times, but then it works like an insurance policy to me. I like insurance, especially when it's about my life savings.
> a future financial institution will be a third party service providing custody or other protections to your crypto bearer instruments.
As you mentioned, that's a bank. There's no reason to believe that crypto-based banks will be any better than traditional ones, especially if you compare to newer fintechs.
> many people get paid back after being scammed, rug pulled, exploited
I was not aware of that, thank you. But it's still too few compare to the whole.
Many people think it will be Fintech in the front, DeFi in the back version of crypto that services mass adoption. The big difference is there is global, permissionless infrastructure for anyone to build tools/apps/services on. No more walled financial system, some kid in India can make a new banking app and it can be as useful as hsbc. They can use the same lending protocols, currency conversion, insurance protocols, and then choose what services they want on top. Maybe someone wants their banking app to be hentai death metal themed and all their moeny to be in picutres of dogs(rather than pictures of the queen or a president). Those who want self ownership and to code their own things, or arent liked by the banks (e.g. sex workers, immigrants, travellers) have just as much access to the system. To me it will be kinda like how lots of people are happy with Windows, but a smaller group like the freedom of Linux.
That wasn't the supposition. Who cares? Wait I know people that do care, you thought I was one of those? I view blockchains as a platform to launch projects, and crypto as the necessary fuel to use those platforms, I like the censorship resistance but I don't care about the ideologies, I would like to seamlessly move unlimited sums in and out of them and thats that. I care about fulfilling market needs and niches, I don't care about the accuracy of those needs.
Regarding Defi insurance protocols, there is a lot of education necessary and some ease of use improvements necessary.
The whole at least somewhat civilized world has moved to a more advanced versions of money, but cryptocoins are a step backwards and it is entirely intentional.
I'd never mail cash for that purpose.
There are <0.0001% of the population who understand transaction risk.
If I pay $Cash for Goods, In a trustless network, both side of the exchange have to be instantaneous. I can never pay cryptocurrency for any item that are not verifiable by the network itself, unless there is another trusted 3rd party (cough cough, Credit Card Processors/Banks).
For example, today the 5-member Advisory Board has unilateral power to change the contract as they see fit[1], and only the smart contracts have been audited, not the organization itself[2].
The only information about this all-powerful Advisory Board is on the home page, and I'm forced to take that at face value. What happens if I put my money there, the board runs away with it, and I try to sue them only to find out that these five people don't exist, or are not related to the project? This is far from the basic security level of any traditional financial institution.
Again, I have major respect for this team. The service is useful, and the documentation is honest and comprehensive. But a blockchain plus this insurance does not make a safe consumer space.
[1] https://nexusmutual.gitbook.io/docs/users/understanding-nexu... [2] https://nexusmutual.gitbook.io/docs/welcome/audits-and-secur...
Traditional banking is not perfect by any means, but if 6-figure frauds are making the news, it means they are uncommon. Meanwhile, cryptocurrencies regularly have scams and hacks in the hundred-million dollar range.
I believe in the USA there was already some legislation passed some time ago that would allow banks to be custodians of crypto-currencies?
---
[0]: https://bitcoinethereumnews.com/crypto/two-german-banks-comm...
It's similar to stocks and bonds - you could own them yourself, but for not-huge private investment it's often simpler to have a financial institution hold them on your behalf.
The "rug pulls" you see are from contracts written maliciously. DeFi is a ponzi scheme written into a Smart Contract, but some of them have an extra function that allows the creator to instantly steal all the money out of it.
For a very narrow definition. You still need a way to get Bob's wallet address, and to secure your own wallet. Just look around and you'll see plenty of experts failing to do that correctly.
> The "rug pulls" you see are from contracts written maliciously.
And the contracts, being from DeFi land, are immune from chargebacks or legal prosecution. Regular old fraud, made exponentially more damaging because of cryptocurrencies.
Fair enough. A transaction is secure, but the wallets might not be. If you rely on a 3rd party to host your wallet (ie, Coinbase), then you risk your money being stolen when they get hacked. If you host it yourself, then you risk losing the keys unless you make a backup, and the backup could get lost, or if you store it in cloud storage, it could get stolen there.
Credit cards are harder to secure than wallets IMO, but at least with CCs, you have recourse in the case of fraud.
Mind you, it's worth noting that MPS had four centuries of independence before listing itself on the stockmarket and losing its independence comparatively shortly afterwards in the 2008 crisis.
- The scams are online, so I cannot knock on the scammer's door with an angry mob and ask for our money back.
- Pseudonymous identities means scammers have strong protections against being sued or prosecuted.
- Digital wallets, as opposed to cash in bank vaults, means that you can lose all your savings in one mistake.
- Complete lack of trusted third parties means there's no one to appeal to, or to raise alarms in suspicious cases.
The old protections were already pretty bad (scams and thievery very much did exist), and cryptocurrencies are lacking even those basic protections.
>- Pseudonymous identities means scammers have strong protections against being sued or prosecuted.
>- Complete lack of trusted third parties means there's no one to appeal to, or to raise alarms in suspicious cases.
I think that all these things are not fundamental aspects of crypto, but rather how the user chooses to use crypto. If I wanted to I could use crypto only for buying eggs from the local market, or paying a plumber to do some work for me, etc. Scams have existed for decades that involve essentially mailing cash to people that fit the criteria you listed - it's not an issue with cash, but an issue with how people are transacting (with remote unidentified people).
>- Digital wallets, as opposed to cash in bank vaults, means that you can lose all your savings in one mistake.
This is no longer strictly true, at least for loss of wallet keys. There are all sorts of solutions out there (Argent, for example) that allow you to have 'fallback' key methods for if your main key is lost. Yes, if you mistakenly send all your money to the wrong address in crypto you lose it, but that was true of cash as well. Once you spend it it's gone.
People routinely fell victim to fraud. Why else would the government have introduced bans for ponzi schemes or regulatory requirements to go public with stocks, if not to reduce the amount of fraud?
Just because an entity uses "crypto" instead of "US dollars" it should not be absolved from the requirements of established players, they were instantiated for damn good reasons.
So...by staying out of cryptocurrencies entirely, then?
Sounds good to me.
And when even the professionals fail to see scams, how is the general public supposed to do so?
And sadly a lot of charities.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_investors_in_Bernard_L...
It's also worth examining the current system. How happy are you with your bank's 0.01% interest rate? Which is actually negative when you factor in inflation that's eroding the value of our dollars faster than ever, and increasingly transferring wealth to the top 1%? How happy are you about bank CEO compensation and bailouts? No one in crypto is asking for a bailout, even when it crashes 80%. And what about the fact that bank's charge poor people the most or flat out deny service? Or the fact that it's all closed source and behind closed doors.
No bank in the world will care if someone steals your wallet.
This doesn't protect against your credentials being compromised, and it's not useful advice unless you can explain your criteria for declaring an exchange trustworthy and how that would have excluded all of the exchanges which have lost their customers' money.
> No bank in the world will care if someone steals your wallet.
Yes, this is why most people use regulated banks which have the fraud handling and reversal processes which cryptocurrencies lack. It's not just that you don't have to carry it with you, it's that there are things like verification and reversal processes which mean that individual people are both less likely to lose money in the first place and more likely to get it back. If you've ever bought a house, the process of verifying a large amount of money being transferred is very different from writing a small check whereas all you need is a typo to lose cryptocurrencies without recourse.
The huge popularity of crypto is really eroding the tx capacity advantage.
And even in the backwards US, ACH can now settle later same day and it's free. That makes BTC a lot less attractive.
Transferring funds uses an extremely small amount of gas. You clearly have never used the chain so stop making things up.
Here I sent 11K USD to another wallet for a fee of $10. It was confirmed within 5 minutes. There is no other service outside of crypto that is that fast and that cheap. https://etherscan.io/tx/0x3edc74a15742f65d166dfc9ddb567afabf...
But wouldn't confirmations take, as you said, five minutes on a good day? I see people saying 5-20 minutes typical for Ethereum to reach 30 confirmations. And sure you can accept fewer but 30 seems a pretty widely accepted convention. That's still slower than wire transfers which are functionally instantaneous (in practice of course it takes a minute or so). And right when I looked now the base TX fee is $19.10, which is a few dollars lower than I thought, but I see that it fluctuates by a few dollars pretty quickly so it would depend on the moment. I don't know the Ethereum situation with regards to EIP-1559 in very much depth so if I misunderstand how fees currently work please correct me.
This seems to put Ethereum basically right on par with what my credit union charges for wire transfers. Now $20 is on the lower end for wire transfers on a consumer account (I think $25 is common), but you can also get lower on commercial accounts. It just seems like they're fairly on par with each other from a fee perspective, and Ethereum is at least a few minutes slower.
Right now international cryptocurrency transfers are a legally gray area, and have the aforementioned lack of protections. So the expensive and slow, but legal and safe, international transfers are a service that cryptocurrencies don't offer at all. No reason to think it'll be faster and cheaper when it's offered.
Ok i'm exaggerating of course, it just seems like some people are not willing to admit that cryptocurrency does not address certain things that people want out of a money/payments system.
If you didn't notice the total crypto market cap is 2 trillion dollars. People are happy with the way crypto works, most don't want it to be like a bank, but for those that do there is ways to make it so.
I'm happy with my bank's fraud protection. How can crypto users protect themselves without recreating traditional banking?
Bitcoin was released ~13 years ago, and wallet/transaction security has been one of the most important requirements since then (along with scalability, but let's not go there). If trillion dollar market caps and god-knows-how-many billions of investment couldn't figure out how to protect consumers after 13 years...