I have no idea, but my take is that streaming services are trying to find other artists within the same genre, or using the listing patterns of other users to match you up with new music.
This makes a weird assumption that I actually like everything a band makes, which is rare, or that because I like an artists or a few songs within a given genre, then I must like all music with in that genre. Mostly I listen to music from a wide number of artists, across generes. There a musicians where I like most of their work and some where I just like the sound of one particular track.
What I want, is button, when I press that, "The Almighty Algorithm" will analyse the sound, the beats per second, the vocals, the instruments, the lyrics, anything that affect the sound and locate other songs with similar profiles. Bonus points for letting me input stuff like: higher tempo, less bagpipes, the singer has a high pitch voice which hurt my ears.
The social stuff is easy and the streaming platforms can quickly implement something similar and put you out of business. Actually analyzing the sound profiles and using that to help you create playlists and discover new artists, that not something I've seen done and I bet it's because it's will require actual work.
And sometimes I don't even know why I like a particular song. This is especially true when it comes to the concept of catchiness. There is certainly some music theory around hooks, chord loops, etc. but I honestly haven't found any of it anywhere near as explanatory or predictive as more well-established classical western music theory concepts like harmonic function or voice leading. So often it really just feels like "that song is super catchy just because it is."
Spotify has the tech to do this, they've demonstrated it with a genre explorer tool, but they clearly don't use it in their radio stations and recommendations.
As several other comments have mentioned, music companies inevitably end up being redesigned to match the desires of rightsholders, and not users. The only way around this would probably be some kind of legally mandated compulsory licensing, so that any streaming service or end user can play any content if they pay the predetermined price, removing contract negotiations from the picture.
However, that method has the property that the algorithm can’t judge any new music, it always requires existing ratings from members of the platform before it can recommend a song to other people.
Then there’s the additional issue that a person’s musical taste changes over time.
It doesn't give me any control of which attributes I care about, which frustrates me to no end, but it does fairly well at turning up things I haven't heard before and like if I can give it a decent set of seed tracks.
I also occasionally go back to Slacker/LiveXLive for it's fine tune controls, DJs and news. But it's discovery system isn't as good and it's had plenty of bugs (like playing wrong songs/titles). So I stick with Pandora for that radio experience tailored to me.
Agreed 100% on this. I find I like a certain BPM and "type" of sound to songs I often have on repeat.
This might be possible in theory but part of the issue is that the algorithms input parameters are not the same from person to person. The parameters you described are mostly technical attributes of the sound, but what about cultural/political affiliation? Do you care if the lyrics are in a different language (some people do, some people don't). Do you care if there is a political or religious message (and are you particular about which religion or political tribe)? Can Spotify take that into account somehow? Maybe, but it seems very difficult to tailor that to the user.
Speaking personally, music is more than just an aural experience for me. At times it's about connecting with my social group, or cultural traditions, or a spiritual experience. At other times it's just the music. When I listen to mainstream stuff, Spotify is ok. When I get deeper into edge-case territory, Spotify doesn't really know what I'm looking for and often makes suggestions that appear to demonstrate a shallow understanding the cultural meaning of the music I'm listening to.
Zune had the Channels concept - essentially what Spotify-owned playlists are nowadays - but they partnered with radio stations and Billboard (among others) to provide content.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UmUU3R-Y21I
(Notice how 10 years later that UI is still largely fresh and modern; I miss Zune)
I really loved my Zune, the desktop software was some of the worst ever created. It helped pushed me towards eventually just getting an iPod to flash with Rockbox so I could just use common lightweight sane software on my desktop to manage the library on my devices.
Things are so much better now that I can just load up 200GB of music on my android phone, manage it via a normal file explorer on desktop, and use the VLC app to listen and create/manage playlists.
I doubt myself in this, of course, because it's patently idiotic. Is this anything you have the slightest recollection of?
I really didn't remember it being called that, but reading this makes me vaguely remember my assistant manager making fun of the feature name because she also had a Zune.
I really get the feeling that the folks and Bandcamp are actually into music.
Everything else I've tried just seems to make it very hard to break out of the bubble they decided to put me in.
> Discovery is not a viable product
I'm parsing "viable" as "commercially viable". You may solve the problem (for some definition of "solve" and "problem"), but can you make money doing so?
I don't know, I have no experience in this field, but OP seems convinced that the answer is "no".
What discover tab are you referencing, I've never found a place in the app where you cannot directly play from and all their apps support cross device management.
I went back to check today to confirm that even if I had an existing network device selected it'd disconnect that and only play locally, but clicking on the tab just showed an error page. I force quit the app and relaunched, and now the tab is gone entirely.
Guessing I was in some A/B experiment of a pre-release feature, it'll probably have more functionality in the full release (assuming they didn't can it)
In my region(s) of France, they either suck or only play very big names. I envy people who live in range of a good local radio.
Apple Music is better about keeping out of the way, but their generated playlists often feel either boring or stale; good when I want to listen to throwbacks but I can’t recall the last time I heard a new artist I really liked from one.
In my opinion, the best source for music discovery continues to be local radio, especially college radio. The good news is that having been a part of college radio pledge drives, I can pretty confidently say that the discovery service provided by local/college radio is indeed a viable product. Just not in the algorithmic world-scale sense tech companies want to see.