News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by wirthjason on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:48AM (#29430589)
I saw a term in the comments: AFOL. I had to look it up: Adult Fan Of Legos.

I loved legos as a kid and would spend hours building stuff. Now the kits seem more like models to be assembled and put on display and not touched rather than “a paint brush of blocks” where I can use my imagination. It lost my interest. My attention is now on software where I feel I can build anything. I liken it to my lego experience as a child.

I don’t necessarily think there’s a right or wrong thing here. It’s interesting to note how our mind changes as we age and grow older. The ”do anything” mentality get displaced with something else. This would make for an interesting PhD topic. :)

I found another quote from a related article that captured this feeling.

    “It’s like a blast to the past, straight to our childhoods,” said Deason, 40, who lives in Connellsville, Pa. “It took me by surprise, but it makes sense: Life is so structured. But with Lego, you can do anything.”

    Deason has a few million Lego pieces, which she organizes by type and color. The Star Wars and Architecture sets, she says, are the most popular among adults, who almost always look for the instruction manuals.

    “The younger kids come in and it’s all about their imaginations — playing pretend, building zombie towns,” she said. “But at some point that gets lost. The adults seem to value the final finished project. That’s where they get their satisfaction.”
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dec0dedab0de on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:45AM (#29431277)
They still have the original sets that come with guides to build many things out of the same set of bricks, and a box to put them in. These are the best ones to get kids just starting out.

Plus the lego stores have pieces sorted in buckets like a candy shop, you buy a container and fill it up with whatever you want. I've never used it, but the website lets you choose from 1400 different bricks https://www.lego.com/en-us/page/static/pick-a-brick

The Sets will sometimes have a unique piece or two, but outside of the mini figs it is way rarer than you might think. And as others pointed out if it's unique now it doesn't mean they won't find a way to reuse it later.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by thesuitonym on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:03AM (#29430783)
>Now the kits seem more like models to be assembled and put on display and not touched rather than “a paint brush of blocks” where I can use my imagination.

This isn't true at all. You can still buy a box full of bricks. You can even go online and purchase single bricks if you have a specific build in mind. Even the model kits are still just a box full of bricks--Lego abhors creating unique blocks unless they can be used in other sets.

The reason a lot of adults gravitate toward the finished kits is the same reason adults stop picking up cool sticks outside: We just lose our imagination.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dave78 on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:33AM (#29431149)
> Even the model kits are still just a box full of bricks--Lego abhors creating unique blocks unless they can be used in other sets.

I've heard this again and again, and I believe it used to be true. But is it still really the case? My daughters have been gifted a number of Lego sets in the past few years that are simply full of very one-off looking pieces that are hard to use for much else, with very few standard bricks.

I don't doubt that the molds can be repurposed for some other sets potentially, but as an example look at this set that we have and see if you really think it's "just a box full of bricks".

https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/anna-elsa-s-frozen-playgr...

What bugs me about sets like that is there's very little ability to build something completely different with it, which to me is what Lego used to be about. The most fun I had as a kid (and what my kids seem to enjoy most) is just building random things from a pile of bricks (which is why I buy them the generic brick packs rather than the sets like above).

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by OskarS on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:02AM (#29431463)
I just bought and built the relatively recent Lego typewriter set [1], and I had this exact same question: how much of it was going to be purpose built, and how much would be just generic pieces. The answer is: almost all pieces are just regular Lego pieces.

A small number of components (the curved edge just above the keyboard, for instance, or the roller handle) seemed purpose-made for this model, but, like 99% of the pieces were totally generic. And this is in a set with more than 2000 pieces with lots of very intricate mechanics (there's a roller, a carriage, air pistons, and a ratchet/escapement mechanism that moves the carriage), but virtually all of it was made up of standard bricks, rods, connectors and generic components. I was super impressed. Even the keys are just Lego disks with stickers on them. The spacebar is just regular Lego with a smooth surface.

I feel like people have been making this complaint against Lego forever, and it's always "when I was kid, we just got a box of bricks and let our creativity take over!". The harsh truth is that Lego didn't change. We just grew up.

[1]: https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/typewriter-21327

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by Zachery on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:31AM (#29431835)
Lego very very rarely will design a new element for a set, let alone a Ideas/Creator set. For a new part, its in the neighborhood of 300-500k for a new injection mold for a single new piece. That's not going to happen for most one off sets. Sometimes sets do get designed with new pieces in mind, or when they really have a shortcoming. But I don't see anything obvious in the typewriter set that is purpose built.

Reviewing the bricklink entry for the typewriter, the only noticeable new items are the painted key tiles for the typwriter. Painting is a great way to give new life to old tiles. I see some new color options as well, but nothing "new"

https://www.bricklink.com/v2/catalog/catalogitem.page?S=2132...

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by bluetomcat on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:05PM (#29432277)
For good creative play, they have to limit the diversity of pieces and colours within a single theme. Different sets from the same theme need to have similar pieces in the same colour scheme so they can co-exist nicely. Take these 3 sets from the classic 1990s Pirates, for example:

6259 "Broadside's Brig" https://brickset.com/sets/6259-1/Broadside-s-Brig

6267 "Lagoon Lock-up" https://brickset.com/sets/6267-1/Lagoon-Lock-Up

6265 "Sabre Island" https://brickset.com/sets/6265-1/Sabre-Island

Combining these 3 on a big baseplate can give you something completely new and interesting that still belongs to the Pirate theme. The bulk of the parts are white and yellow-coloured bricks for walls and architectural elements.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by Zachery on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:16PM (#29432433)
Was this reply meant for me? I agree overall!
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by OskarS on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:58AM (#29432190)
You’re right, I misremembered: the keys didn’t use stickers, they were painted on. But as you say, they were standard Lego pieces, just painted.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mattashii on Saturday December 04, 2021 @07:33AM (#29440446)
> Even the keys are just Lego disks with stickers on them

My set had the letters printed on the top pieces of the keys; did you have to put stickers on them seperately? If so, then that's a major setback in quality: I really dislike Lego sets with many stickers as the stickers always loosen over time.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by OskarS on Sunday December 05, 2021 @06:08AM (#29448387)
I was mistaken, mine was printed/painted as well.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by xahrepap on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:44PM (#29433538)
I find this to be more true in "gift-priced" sets. ~$25 and less.

But once you hit the ~$30+ sets, you see more and more creativity with the generic pieces. I would assume that the cheaper sets need to look good but have fewer pieces, so they reach for bigger pieces to fill in the gaps.

$100+ sets are mind-blowing in how fun they are to assemble and to see the level of creativity the designer(s) used to create the set. I got the recently released Mario question block cube. And I can't get over how fun it was to assemble.

I think the summary is: to really get to the "reusablility" there's a tipping point in those price ranges I listed above. If you buy a bunch of little sets or one big set, you'll hit that point.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by cout on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:50AM (#29431321)
I don't see any specialty pieces in there that I would be unable to use in another build. The problem is that the ratio of specialty pieces to generic pieces is too high; you would need a lot of generic rectangular bricks to build anything substantially different from what's in the picture.

I wonder how much the ratio of specialty to generic pieces differs between the lego junior sets like the one you linked vs sets intended for older children.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by kergonath on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:39AM (#29431955)
My parents used to say exactly that circa 1990, and yet I managed (to build my own designs without instructions). Now, I definitely agree that there are more sophisticated bricks than there used to be, but my daughter manages as well. I think it’s just different.

In your example, the ice-looking things can be repurposed. The slide could be anything from an emergency exit from a secret lair to a thing for kids to play on a beach. Plenty of stories if you think a little. The snow flake could be a sign for an ice cream shop or anything decorative in a fancy home, or an exotic rock on another planet. The other bricks look fairly standard. I’m pleased that the chest hasn’t changed, I quite liked it ~30 years ago.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by pavon on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:38PM (#29433453)
The counter argument to this are the Creator 3-in-1 sets. The whole point of these sets is to take apart and rebuild something different, teaching by example the different things you can do. These didn't even exist when we were kids (first released 2003). I remember some of my old sets having supplemental build instructions, but I also recall them never being as interesting as the main build, which isn't true with these 3-in-1's. Plain buckets are also still sold. Both of these are on the shelves of Target and Walmart, and are often featured as Christmas gifts at places that just stock them seasonally, like Costco. Lego has just as many of these sort of sets as it always has, if not more.

First off I don't think the existence of large, expensive adult-targeted "display model" kits doesn't really detract from what is happening in the kids sets.

On the kids sets, Lego is doing a lot more licensed sets than in the past, and these inevitably have more custom pieces. But I think adults really over-estimate the negative impact this has on reuse and creativity. The first thing the kid in me thinks when I see that kit you listed is "How can I build a ramp at the end of that slide?" "How can I extend the slide at the top to make them go faster?". Sometimes pieces having having a purpose can prompt ideas and creativity. Sure those big ice blocks will only every be used for ice/glass, but there are lots of things you can build with ice/glass especially when playing with Frozen characters. Many of the custom pieces in licensed sets are just flourishes (like that snowflake or ice-flame) which are fun things you can add to your model, and 80-90's kits definitely had those as well. I think the biggest obstacle to reuse on that kit is just that it is a small kit - it really needs to be combined with other kits do do interesting things (and for which reason I don't think they should have included those large ice blocks in this particular kit, as that just exacerbates that problem - they would be fine in a larger kit). And again, I remember getting bored with small kits received as a kid after a few days of play (visiting grandparents), and looking forward to getting home and combining some of the cool new pieces with the Legos I already had.

In other words, the licensed kits are the equivalent of the castle and pirate kits we had as kids, with the exact same complaints. I think those complaints were overblown then and they still are now.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by tspike on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:44PM (#29433532)
That you're unable to find uses for those pieces speaks to a lack of creativity, ironically :)

Check this out: https://www.newelementary.com/2017/10/pdc-parts-festival-day...

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by thesuitonym on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:41AM (#29431983)
I only see two bricks in there that I don't recognize from when I was a child. Three if you count the bear, but there have always been animals that aren't actually part of building anything. Yeah, that particular set would be difficult to build anything else with, but not because the pieces are unique, there just aren't that many. It's a cheap set, there have always been cheap sets that you can only really build one thing with.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by ttmb on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:15PM (#29433973)
There are only a few pieces in that set that don't appear in hundreds of other sets:

The baseplate is custom and the most egregious example of what you are talking about, of course. The slope at the front with the swirl on it is also custom. There's a round tile with a snowflake on it, that appears in two other sets. The giant snowflake on top, about two dozen other winter-themed sets. The slide also appears in only a couple of dozen pieces, but this basically all pieces that include a playground or similar. The slide is functional for play so it can't be trivially made of smaller pieces without compromising that. There also an ornamental swirly translucent smoke-like piece that only appears in a handful of sets, again, all winter themed.

That's it, the rest of the pieces in the kit appear in literally hundreds of other sets.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dave78 on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:05PM (#29434613)
It's not so much about whether the pieces are used in other sets - of course Lego is going to want to build molds and use them in multiple sets, dedicating a mold for just this set would not be smart.

I think my concern is more nuanced - if you're a kid and you only get sets like this one, when you get past the "let's build what's on the box" stage and they end up as just a pile of bricks, the number of more generically-useful pieces is low compared to all the specialty pieces. I think in an ideal situation, you have lots of generic pieces and a selection of custom (like the typewriter mentioned in another post), but these sets seem to be the opposite with lots of quirky custom pieces and few generic pieces good for general building.

I'm sure as another poster pointed out that this is a result of "gift-priced" sets, and trying to have something impressive while keeping the part count low. And for my kids it doesn't matter as I've bought them plenty of "just a bunch of brick" sets to go with all these specialty parts. But if you're a kid whose parents aren't willing to drop a lot of $$$ on Lego (which have always been on the pricey side), then you're more likely to end up with a collection made only from the $10-25 kits with an over-emphasis on specialty pieces.

When I was a kid (in the 80s), I remember getting lots of Lego sets along these lines:

https://brickset.com/sets/6375-2/Exxon-Gas-Station

Notice the cars - they are very blocky and do not look much like real cars because they're almost entirely made out of generic bricks. The gas pumps and roof and such are mostly just regular pieces, possibly with stickers or screen-printing. Compare it to something like this:

https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/fire-rescue-police-chase-...

Yes, there's still generic pieces in there, but my eye sees a lot more specialty pieces like the hoods, car roofs, fenders, motorcycle, etc. IMHO, the 80s set offers more potential for rebuilding into other things, but maybe I'm wrong and it is just nostalgia or something like that.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by wirthjason on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:40PM (#29435092)
I had that gas station!

I agree with you on the blocky -ness of the cars. I wonder how the distribution of sizes changed. As the complexity of the design goes up you need different distribution of sizes, smaller for more detail and larger for bigger structures. I always had a good balance of blocks, never too many of one size and never running out of others.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by Talanes on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:42PM (#29438752)
They had those style of vehicles by my childhood in the 90's, and I don't think having a few pre-built vehicle pieces really hampered creativity. I would just spend hours working out how to work those car parts into a giant mad-max monstrosity using as many bricks as I could.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by thrower123 on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:06AM (#29431512)
This is a textbook example of the widespread "juniorization" issue Lego had for a while 15-20 years ago. You'd get a Town car set, and it would have about 17 pieces, because the entire chassis would be one piece. You have linked a set explicitly in their Junior product offerings, bridging between Duplo and real Legos.

I think things have actually swung too far in the other direction now with their main-line sets. As much as 25% of the part count typically consists of tiny 1x1 or 2x1 plates and tiles, or 1x1 cheese wedges. There are often many cases where they will use more smaller bricks rather than a more structurally-sound brick - 1x3 bricks and the corner L-shaped bricks in particular.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by shagmin on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:01AM (#29431455)
I believe it's true for some sets more than others. In my experience any sets with Disney on them or sets based on partnerships with other brands are the worst for this however.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dr_orpheus on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:06AM (#29430814)
> Lego abhors creating unique blocks unless they can be used in other sets.

Its always my favorite thing to see how some of the semi-unique pieces get re-used. I put together Anakin's Podracer recently and part of the decorative elements on the engine part were the Lego LOTR Orc Swords!

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by abbub on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:14AM (#29430920)
I think the fins on the back of a batmobile set I have are from a dragon in one of the 'castle' sets...
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dr_orpheus on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:18AM (#29430971)
Or the original blasters in the Star Wars sets that were backwards megaphones with a piece on the end.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by smarterclayton on Saturday December 04, 2021 @12:22PM (#29442363)
The Lego Star Destroyer has several “hammer of Thor” greebles (the interesting decorative surface details) in the engine section
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mcbain on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:50PM (#29438232)
When I was building the James Bond DB5 I was amused that the exhaust manifolds for the engine are actually revolvers: https://brickset.com/sets/containing-part-4211029
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mcphage on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:10PM (#29432346)
I purchased the Spring Lantern Festival earlier this year, and the decorations on the corners of the pagoda are blue bananas :-)

And the lightposts used paint rollers as part of their design.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by GLGirty on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:01AM (#29431452)
bullwhip + lightsabre hilt = ghostbuster proton wand
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by CapitalistCartr on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:06AM (#29430825)
I have discovered a way to reverse that effect of aging, but it's painfully expensive: I have a son in my fifties. It has rejuvenated my sense of play.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by kzzzznot on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:28AM (#29431086)
I have recently been enthusiastically playing with my daughter and her Duplo sets (Lego for younger children, basically just larger blocks). Now eyeing up various adult sets for myself…
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by spicybright on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:26AM (#29431068)
Everything you said is very true.

ANY Lego set you buy lets you arrange the bricks how you want. If you want different parts you can buy different sets.

Why are people saying Lego should be responsible for this? Take your model and drop it on the floor. Start building.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by Broken_Hippo on Saturday December 04, 2021 @07:00AM (#29440329)
The reason a lot of adults gravitate toward the finished kits is the same reason adults stop picking up cool sticks outside: We just lose our imagination.

This just isn't true. When you are a kid, lots of sticks seem different: When you are an adult, you've seen lots and lots of sticks and they cease to become interesting. This is the same reason we don't find a lot of joy in children's learning toys. We should be moving on.

Some folks find out they like putting things together, even if there isn't much imagination going on: Cue lego kits, puzzles, cross stitch, home improvement, and so on.

Adult imagination looks different from children's imagination, in part because adults have knowledge and experience that children lack, which is why sometimes an imaginative child won't necessarily be creative in their daydreams. Adults are more likely to put it into things like parenting or making dinner or trying to stretch money to cover everything and still get gifts.

Adults are out there making artwork. Creating new software. Creating music and movies and designing buildings and public spaces and stadiums and playing sports. All of these things require imagination and creativity.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by jerrysievert on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:50PM (#29437547)
> Lego abhors creating unique blocks unless they can be used in other sets.

true for the most part, but there was a time where that was not true, we had part of the 90's where unique pieces ran wild. thankfully, they've moved back to more generic pieces, but the bioncle years were crazy.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by robbyking on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:06PM (#29433053)
Absolutely! I wasn't into building with Lego growing up, but my 5yo is and we often go to an aftermarket Lego store to buy bricks in bulk that aren't part of a specific kit.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dr_orpheus on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:04AM (#29430792)
The AT-AT model that they are talking about here is a UCS (Ultimate Collector's Series) set. These are definitely intended for adult builders to assemble a model and put on display. They are more focused on detail and less focused on "playability" as with some other sets that have moving or reconfigurable elements.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by NoGravitas on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:31AM (#29431116)
This is literally the core conflict driving the plot of the Lego Movie.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by airstrike on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:19PM (#29433229)
I guess I know what I'm watching this weekend...

EDIT: I see someone made a reference to 'This Island Earth' elsethread, so now I've got to pick one of the two

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by rootusrootus on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:29AM (#29431811)
My wife is very much an AFOL. I buy her a couple of the expensive creator/expert sets each year.

We also have several bins of generic legos of all shapes & sizes for the kids. They occasionally get technic sets, too, as gifts.

These are not at odds with each other, Lego is successfully marketing to two demographics that are complimentary to one another. It's a good strategy. What's not a good strategy is their really lackluster pace of creating new sets, or the speed with with they take old ones out of production so they become a thousand bucks on the secondary market.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by skocznymroczny on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:58AM (#29430700)
These kind of lego sets still exist, mostly under the "Lego Classic" brand. Also, many "yes we are making legos but can't use that name" companies exist which produce more of a playset instead of a model to assemble.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by nkrisc on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:20AM (#29430988)
It’s been a while, so maybe there are better ones now, but I never found a company that produced bricks anywhere near the quality that LEGO does.

If anyone knows of LEGO alternatives that are high quality I’d love to know.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mcphage on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:16PM (#29432436)
I believe the current best is Mould King or Decool? At least for Technic sets. But check out r/lepin on Reddit and people will be talking about all of the alternative brick manufacturers, and people will say which ones are the best.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by erulabs on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:40PM (#29433483)
I mean, it's also an AT-AT... You know, from 1980? It's not just that it's not simple bricks, it's that it's still our generations fantasy, too.

If our generation will be remembered for one thing, it will be our iron-fist clenched around our childhood culture. Our children will have toys, yes, too many to count, but they will be 50 year old references to things kids only see the regurgitation of. New stories? Bleh, give them GhostBusters 19 in 2035, screw it.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by dwd on Saturday December 04, 2021 @05:24AM (#29439944)
I built my own AT-AT back in '81 using mostly red bricks as I only had the articulating flat bricks from various fire engine sets to use for the legs. You built what you could from the pieces you had.

I did buy a lot of Star Wars sets for my kids but it's not the same when you skip the design step.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by ip26 on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:50PM (#29433620)
The ”do anything” mentality get displaced with something else

I disagree, I think plenty of adults still have that mentality, but for them Legos is not the place to fulfill it. As a kid, Legos are one of the most approachable medium to manifest your imagination. But they are also very limited. As an adult, with more skills, knowledge, and money you might get into wood or metalworking or software instead, where you have significantly more freedom.

An AFOL might be looking for something more nostalgic or meditative (e.g. rock gardens, bonsai?), and so they approach it differently.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mrweasel on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:25AM (#29431047)
Some of the newer sets have the "issue" in my mind that they aren't balanced. Either they use tiny bricks and build up everything, or they're based on pretty large single pieces.

The mid-size bricks seems less used now compared to the sets I got as a kid 30 years ago. When I pick out Lego sets for my daughter it's often based on the type of bricks included, and sometimes we just get classic brick sets. Building using the 1 - 4 stud piece, especially the flat ones, get boring pretty quickly.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by saturdaysaint on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:29AM (#29431094)
I agree. It feels like most Lego sets on the market have several major/foundational pieces which are essentially useless outside of the model they're built for - some huge chunk of molded plastic. A big part of the joy of Lego sets in the past was that they showed you what was possible with these unassuming bricks. Sure, any big/intricate set would have some funny pieces, but they would mostly lend themselves to many forms of re-use that even a 10-year old could easily figure out. My 4 year-old has had a great time with Duplos, but I'm sort of leary about transitioning to Legos because to me, they've become more emblematic of consumerist collecting than creativity.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by tablespoon on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:55PM (#29433701)
> It feels like most Lego sets on the market have several major/foundational pieces which are essentially useless outside of the model they're built for - some huge chunk of molded plastic.

Do you have an example of a one of those pieces?

I haven't had a Lego set in decades, but I do recall feeling that the ratio of fiddly pieces vs "foundational" pieces getting out of whack towards the end of my time with them. When my kids get old enough I suppose I'm going to have to get them one of those "classic" sets, because I'm not sure they'll be able to get enough by just collecting regular sets.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by saturdaysaint on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:20PM (#29434842)
I feel like almost any new kit I look at is composed of big specially-molded bricks that would seem really odd and difficult to find a use for if they were deconstructed in a big box of bricks. Maybe I'm misremembering or am being too harsh on the newer kits, but I feel like the Lego sets I grew up with in the 80's and 90's were more reusable. I had the sense that every Lego kit I bought was also giving me cool new tools to build bigger/wilder spaceships and trucks, whereas these just look like a nice weekend project with no application thereafter.

https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Legendary-Mountain-Awesome-Build...

https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Creator-Adventure-Building-Creat...

https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Champions-McLaren-Building-Piece...

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by paavohtl on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:56PM (#29435326)
All I'm seeing in these sets is mostly standard pieces, possibly with custom prints or stickers. The waterfall pieces might be entirely custom, but pretty much everything else is something you find in a lot of sets. Most things are made from small & reusable pieces like before, but there are just more kinds of bricks and they are assembled more creatively (especially in more expensive sets like the Creator Expert sets).
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by tablespoon on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:12PM (#29437281)
> The waterfall pieces might be entirely custom, but pretty much everything else is something you find in a lot of sets.

And stuff like that isn't new. I remember I had a "castle" set that had these wall-with-window pieces [1], which were kind of similar. You could still use them creatively. Also that waterfall set has a lot of pieces that would be good for building stuff like spaceships or planes.

[1] https://www.bricklink.com/v2/catalog/catalogitem.page?P=4444...

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by specialist on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:21AM (#29431699)
The older pieces fell out of copyright. So Lego differentiated by making new peices, to stay ahead of the knockoffs.

At least that was my understanding in the mid-90s, when I worked in the toy industry.

I'm still conflicted about it. Though I can't deny the creativity on display at any LUG or brickcon, I greatly miss the simplicity. I own too much Lego and I've given up trying to rationally organize loose peices.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by tspike on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:49PM (#29433605)
This article is due for a refresh, but it's still relevant on this topic: http://www.realityprose.com/what-happened-with-lego/
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by shp0ngle on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:47AM (#29431297)
They still sell the unassuming legos? And they are quite cheap (compared to the branded ones) and still quite popular
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by andai on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:11AM (#29431580)
Are you referring to the Chinese clones?
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by mcphage on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:13PM (#29432393)
Not the OP, but they're probably referring to the Classic sets: https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Classic-Medium-Creative-Brick/dp... which exist in any possible size, full of bog standard bricks. There's also a large line of 3-in-1 sets, which have the instructions for 3 different models, all using the same set of bricks.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by nouveaux on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:22PM (#29432504)
As a kid, I was given a random box of legos with no guidance. I wanted to make things but I couldn't. Didn't know "how". I quickly lost interest.

As an adult, I've purchased a couple of sets and had a great time putting it together. Following the instructions, I can see more easily see how different combinations of bricks, when put together, makes a certain shape. I wish I had something similar growing up.

Some kids can be given a paint brush and develop enough interest by themselves to become an expert. Most kids need guidance. Whether its a coloring book or more formal instruction, having concrete and achievable goals is how most people stay interested in learning a skill. For people who do not have any artistic skills, it's not realistic to ask them to just pick up some paint and a canvas, and just "use your imagination". IMO, what Legos is doing is the right thing for most people.

For the people who can be motivated to learn in a vacuum, they have a valuable gift.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by tspike on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:50PM (#29433615)
I make both free builds and sets. I view sets as lessons on building techniques.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by biztos on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:43AM (#29431249)
When I was a kid in the 70's we would (more or less) build the "picture on the box" (sometimes with, sometimes without instructions) exactly once after getting a new Lego set, then liberate the bricks to never inhabit that form again.

Can't imagine what the attraction is of having the same boring thing as everybody else.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by cout on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:54AM (#29431364)
The kits I got in the 80s and early 90s often came with instructions for alternative builds. It was like they wanted you to know you could build things other than the picture on the box.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by octorian on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:28AM (#29431800)
The designs of those kits from the 80s and 90s were also very flimsy and would break easily if you started to play with them. So really, the original build falling apart and becoming spare parts was almost expected.

This really changed once they started including Technics pieces as structural parts of builds, rather than as a totally separate product line. Most things I've built in recent years are far more robust than what I built as a kid.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by biztos on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:58PM (#29432952)
Can't comment on kits from after about '80 but this reminds me, when I was a kid my older brother would labor extensively to build the most elaborate and beautiful spaceships, while I would pack my bricks tight into a minimalist indestructible vessel. When the inevitable clash arrived, my ship almost always prevailed, though I usually had to run away after.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by spiralx on Saturday December 04, 2021 @04:24PM (#29444453)
My brother and I used to build space fighters with a pilot inside who could see outside, with the goal of being able to throw them at the wall as hard as possible without them coming apart - our parents were not fans lol. It's perfectly doable if you build around the pilot using nothing but flat grey bricks, wings and horizontal boosters, and ensure almost every piece is reinforced by multiple overlapping pieces above and below.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by frosted-flakes on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:11AM (#29431577)
They still do this. I have a 341-piece LEGO kit of a Space Shuttle on a transport truck from a couple of years ago. It also includes instructions for building two additional models that use nearly all of the pieces: a jeep with a camper trailer, and a flatbed truck with a helicopter landing pad with the helicopter. I don't think the set has any specialized pieces at all.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by andruby on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:35AM (#29431902)
I loved Lego as a kid. Used to build so many things without manuals. My brother built houses and I built a lot of vehicles.

Now I've got 2 boys and I buy tons of lego's for the three of us. We're trying to get mom involved and bought her the Parisian Restaurant (10243). We still use the 20 year old ground plates from my childhood. You can rejuvenate most lego in a dishwasher (put them in a washer net)

I still think it's great fun. I do focus a little more on the manuals then when I was younger. But most builds inevitably get destroyed and the bricks re-used for our ever evolving lego land.

Pirate Roller Coaster (31084) is inexpensive if you want coaster parts for your DIY city.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by jerome-jh on Saturday December 04, 2021 @08:42AM (#29440768)
I still firmly believe Lego is "one of a kind" in the toys category. I personally still use Lego Technics to prototype stuff from time to time. The thing is, kids (and maybe adults too) do not play Lego as they did before. The less toys you have, the more you reuse, reshuffle, tinker. It may be surprising but kids have no time for this today. Build (following the instructions), play, switch.

I actually find it interesting in a positive sense that it is possible to design something that cannot be taken apart in Lego.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by lhorie on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:18PM (#29436867)
Lego sets these days seem geared more towards vapid consumerism than to promote free flow creative building. My kids found a way to fill that gap via knex.

I don't agree that only adults take enjoyment in the final product. It's just that adults and children are interested in different things and have different household decision making circumstances. As an adult, you wouldn't buy a zombie town lego set that consists of random pieces haphazardly thrown together even considering the prospect of build-anything flexibility nostalgia, and as a child, you typically don't have the means to buy architecture sets on an impulse, nor the inclination to stare at a complex lego project with few flexible components.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by CRConrad on Saturday December 04, 2021 @05:47PM (#29445014)
> Now the kits seem more like models to be assembled and put on display and not touched rather than “a paint brush of blocks” where I can use my imagination. It lost my interest.

That's how that whole "kit" malarkey has seemed to me ever since it started. What's the fricking use of a Millennium Falcon, or a motorized excavator for that matter, when it's full of bespoke pieces that only really work for that particular end product? The whole idea totally sucks, IMO.

When I was a kid, "kits" didn't exist; there were only generic pieces, and I think that's the way it still ought to be.

Yeah, yeah, get off my lawn.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by cjohnson318 on Friday December 03, 2021 @05:01PM (#29436188)
> I don’t necessarily think there’s a right or wrong thing here.

Yeah, I feel like the giant, expensive Star Wars sets are for adults that don't intend to take their creations apart, and are actually concerned about keeping them whole while moving between apartments, condos, or homes. In that regard, I think this is kind of a feature for them.

Most parents are going to buy smaller sets throughout the year for their kids, budget permitting.

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by klyrs on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:37PM (#29437453)
Having kids helps. Mine likes to build the sets, sometimes with help, but he'll irreverently tear them down for parts. I like that the official builds don't stick around. We do our own thing. Most of the weirdly shaped one-off parts do get repurposed, except, sadly, the dart launchers, because the darts fell victim to the Jaws of ADHD Oral Fixation.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by rhplus on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:11PM (#29434704)
> I had to look it up: Adult Fan Of Legos.

An AFOL would likely tell you that it's actually "Adult Fan Of Lego"

Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by JamesAdir on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:16AM (#29431631)
Lego still sells basic sets that can used to build everything.
Re:Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart by flerchin on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:05AM (#29431501)
AKA President Business.