News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by kordlessagain on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:06AM (#29349909)
It’s always bugged me that science claims there are trillions of neutrinos going through me, yet can hardly detect them with a nearly trillion dollar machine and a doctorate. Then there’s dark energy, which just seems like a lame excuse for saying “we don’t know”.

Nobody says what goes through my body but me!

(I’m being funny, y’all! Happy holidays!)

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by cshimmin on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:28AM (#29350022)
The trillions of neutrinos going through you are low energy neutrinos from the sun. We've been able to detect those for decades, and with only moderately pricey technology.

The neutrinos in the article are high energy ones produced from proton collisions at the LHC. Although we have ways of producing neutrino beams from accelerators, the LHC is not set up for that, and these neutrinos are sparsely produced, incidentally to the high energy hadron collisions being produced there.

In any case, the LHC cost at least an order of magnitude less than a trillion dollars. And the FASER experiment in particular which runs parasitically on existing LHC infrastructure runs on a shoestring budget, largely privately funded.

[dead]
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by cshimmin on Friday November 26, 2021 @09:15AM (#29350339)
Hmmm... in good faith I'm not able to parse your question. I don't know what hu liquid is, or what you mean by "their stuff". Maybe you could try again.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by magicalhippo on Friday November 26, 2021 @09:25AM (#29350418)
I had similar issues parsing the question.

I've noticed a marked uptick in almost-but-not-quite comprehensible questions in the last few months in various internet venues, like Discord and Slack.

Having run my own MegaHAL[1] on IRC back in the days, it made me think about if someone is having fun with a new generation AI chat bots...

Not saying that is the case here though.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MegaHAL

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by aardvark179 on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:34AM (#29350063)
It’s interesting that you class dark energy (the thing accelerating universal expansion) as, “We don’t know,” but don’t put gravity into that same category. They are both aspects of general relativity that we have failed to integrate with our other most successful fundamental theories, but if you asked an average person on the street I’m sure they’d put them in very different categories of understanding, as you did.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by Ma8ee on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:49AM (#29350159)
The thing with gravity is that it is kind of easy to detect, even for a layperson, while dark energy and dark matter haven't been detected at all, by anyone, but only used as mathematical devices to make indirect measurements of large scale structures align with our models.

So, it isn't only the "average man on the street" that thinks there are good reasons to put them in very different categories of understanding.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by whatshisface on Friday November 26, 2021 @01:11PM (#29352526)
Curiously... In the way dark matter has never been detected (no particle has been found), gravity has never been detected, and in the way gravity has been detected (through its influence on the trajectories of detectable matter), dark matter has been as well.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by Ma8ee on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:41PM (#29353883)
It’s a rather novel and very strange to say that something hasn’t been detected because you haven’t found a particle responsible for it, even though our whole existence and all our everyday experiences are grounded in it.

Gravity is the effect. It’s there. Whether you explain it with force carrying particles or the geometry of space time won’t change it.

Dark matter is one hypothetical explanation of an effect (or rather several). It’s possible to find another explanation for the same phenomena without changing the phenomena.

In other words, gravity and dark matter have very different ontological status.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by whatshisface on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:52PM (#29353991)
>In other words, gravity and dark matter have very different ontological status.

I get what you're saying, but you can make them the same again by transposing Dark Matter to Dark Matitation, by analogy to Gravitons->Gravitation.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by Ma8ee on Friday November 26, 2021 @06:24PM (#29355349)
No, they are still not the same. If I understand you correctly, you are saying that Dark Matter would correspond to Gravitons. But that would just prove my point, because Gravitons is just a hypothetical explanation of gravity, in the same way as Dark matter is a hypothetical explanation of, e.g., the rotation profiles of galaxies.

(And here we have so far left out that the only reason Dark matter makes sense is because we are trying to not have to modify our current understanding of gravity.)

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by astrange on Saturday November 27, 2021 @05:09AM (#29359032)
Well, one reason dark matter is winning over modified gravity theories is that there seem to be some galaxies that don't have dark matter. So MOND needs more special pleading there, unless the observations are wrong.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by Ma8ee on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:47AM (#29379804)
The only thing I was arguing was that Gravity has a much more solid basis than Dark Matter. I certainly don't think I made it sound like I think MOND is more likely than Dark Matter (even though I confess that I still think the issue is far from settled).
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by vkazanov on Friday November 26, 2021 @02:54PM (#29353488)
Well, scientists would argue that general relativity (I.e. gravity the way we understand it now) does predict a lot of things really well.

Now, the problem is that its predictions fall apart at quantum scale and cosmological scale. Dark thingies are just a way to make the equations work at cosmological scale.

There's always modified gravity, which takes an alternative approach by changing the equations.

That's how they taught me 15 years ago, so give or take:-)

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by mnw21cam on Friday November 26, 2021 @10:21AM (#29350985)
Relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1489/

The mouseover-text is the important bit: "Of these four forces, there's one we don't really understand." "Is it the weak force or the strong--" "It's gravity."

That's even though it's the one with the simplest equations.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by tsimionescu on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:37PM (#29352214)
> That's even though [gravity]'s the one with the simplest equations.

Aren't the equations for gravity non-linear, while the other 3 are linear?

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by whatshisface on Friday November 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#29353446)
They're linear to the first-order, but everything is linear to first order by the definition of first order.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by Ma8ee on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:32PM (#29352158)
Is that an attempt to appeal to authority?
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by kergonath on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:09PM (#29355707)
Worse than that: an appeal to the reader’s sense of humour.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by lookatme on Friday November 26, 2021 @10:00AM (#29350770)
In all seriousness, I found myself wondering about those numbers before; but consider that there's on the order of 10^27 atoms in your body. So, if we assume a trillion neutrinos in your body, that indicates that for each neutrino in your body, there are 10^15 atoms - that's one part per quadrillion! A machine capable of detecting neutrinos in your body would need to be _unimaginably_ sensitive, before even considering the intrinsic difficulty in detecting them due to low mass and neutral charge.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by jiggawatts on Friday November 26, 2021 @10:59AM (#29351320)
Look at it this way: Solar neutrinos carry away approximately 1% of the total fusion power output of the Sun. This works out to about 14 Watts per square meter at the distance of the Earth. The area of a human adult body front-on is about a square meter.

It's pretty easy to detect 14 W of typical forms of radiation at those scales! If it were light, it would be equivalent to the light put out by something like a laptop screen, spread out just a bit. You can see something like that with your eyes from a kilometer away!

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by JProthero on Friday November 26, 2021 @11:45AM (#29351769)
This is a great analogy, I'd never seen it translated into tangible terms like that before.

I remember reading that, at close enough range, the neutrino emissions from a supernova would be intense enough to be dangerous to structures made of ordinary matter, despite the weakness of their interactions, and that they would reach an observer earlier than other forms of radiation due to their ability to escape the collapsing star relatively unimpeded. Neutrinos would be the least of your problems if you were the observer of course.

As I was trying to find a source for this, I discovered there is a unit [1] for the amount of energy released by a supernova called the Foe, which seems apt (it's an acronym derived from 'ten to the power of Fifty-One-Ergs').

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foe_(unit)

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by gus_massa on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:18PM (#29352056)
Perhaps "Lethal Neutrinos" https://what-if.xkcd.com/73/
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by JProthero on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:32PM (#29372701)
I think my source was a book, but the XKCD is a better link! I think the book reference I had mind may have stated the effect in terms of force.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by canjobear on Friday November 26, 2021 @09:54AM (#29350718)
> seems like a lame excuse for saying “we don’t know”.

Dark matter/energy aren’t excuses, they’re labels for things that behave like matter and energy but whose nature is unknown.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by macintux on Friday November 26, 2021 @10:37AM (#29351124)
Well, dark matter at least to this layperson’s eye a label for observations that are most easily explained by matter, which is not quite the same as a “thing that behaves like matter”.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by hluska on Friday November 26, 2021 @11:54AM (#29351850)
Just for the record, I’m not trying to be a jerk - I’m a layperson too. However, in science, it’s important to understand that some of the “I don’t know”s are so incredibly precise they’re not intended for the layperson. Rather, many are precise models used to help experts communicate.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by aardvark179 on Friday November 26, 2021 @04:38PM (#29354401)
Not exactly. Dark matter might reasonably considered a label for observations that are most easily explained by matter that only interacts with anything gravitationally. That’s really a quite strange property compared to all the other matter we see, but it does seem to explain a lot of things rather well.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by pvg on Friday November 26, 2021 @10:21AM (#29350980)
John Updike wrote a poem about the crassness of neutrinos:

http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~crawford/PSG/PSG21/204_97_L21....

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by JProthero on Friday November 26, 2021 @11:11AM (#29351426)
Excellent. I give this 10^14 / 10^14.

The pedant in me wants to point out that they are now known to have some mass and do interact a bit, but this was written in 1960.

Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by spodek on Friday November 26, 2021 @09:16AM (#29350344)
If you think science has you stomach untenable ideas, it's got nothing on what a lack of science will stick you with.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll... by sleepysysadmin on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:55AM (#29350201)
>Nobody says what goes through my body but me!

That's selfish! Mandatory trip to Chernobyl!