Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll...
by whatshisface on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:52PM
(#29353991)
>In other words, gravity and dark matter have very different ontological status.
I get what you're saying, but you can make them the same again by transposing Dark Matter to Dark Matitation, by analogy to Gravitons->Gravitation.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll...
by Ma8ee on Friday November 26, 2021 @06:24PM
(#29355349)
No, they are still not the same. If I understand you correctly, you are saying that Dark Matter would correspond to Gravitons. But that would just prove my point, because Gravitons is just a hypothetical explanation of gravity, in the same way as Dark matter is a hypothetical explanation of, e.g., the rotation profiles of galaxies.
(And here we have so far left out that the only reason Dark matter makes sense is because we are trying to not have to modify our current understanding of gravity.)
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll...
by astrange on Saturday November 27, 2021 @05:09AM
(#29359032)
Well, one reason dark matter is winning over modified gravity theories is that there seem to be some galaxies that don't have dark matter. So MOND needs more special pleading there, unless the observations are wrong.
Re:Physicists detect signs of neutrinos at Large Hadron Coll...
by Ma8ee on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:47AM
(#29379804)
The only thing I was arguing was that Gravity has a much more solid basis than Dark Matter. I certainly don't think I made it sound like I think MOND is more likely than Dark Matter (even though I confess that I still think the issue is far from settled).
Gravity is the effect. It’s there. Whether you explain it with force carrying particles or the geometry of space time won’t change it.
Dark matter is one hypothetical explanation of an effect (or rather several). It’s possible to find another explanation for the same phenomena without changing the phenomena.
In other words, gravity and dark matter have very different ontological status.