NFTs seem like blockchain graffiti. You've purchased the right to tag a passing train car, that's all.
It means that the shared ledger (also called blockchain) has a record of that specific NFT belonging to your address.
> Can you even repudiate ownership later if you so chose?
Yes, you send it to a "burn address" which is a address no one has access to.
> Can you remove the record of your ownership of the NFT?
Like remove the history? If so, no, blockchains are (usually) immutable ledgers, it's actually one of the core value propositions for blockchains. You can send the NFT to a "burn address" if you don't want it anymore.
> Can you transfer that ownership outside of the blockchain?
Well, kind of but not really. You question is a bit like if you can transfer the ownership of a .com domain to outside the internet. I guess you could, in some way, but in most practical ways, no.
> NFTs seem like blockchain graffiti. You've purchased the right to tag a passing train car, that's all.
I don't know what to make of this, how is it related to graffiti and tagging trains?
A NFT is a really simple concept if you stop thinking about pictures and other media (since that doesn't really have anything to do with NFTs): A NFT is a cryptocurrency which only has a single token of itself. Like there only was one Bitcoin that was indivisible. You can transfer it to other addresses, but there can only be one at a time. That's all there is to it.
Such a token is inherently worthless. The only value comes from rights that token can confer.
That’s why people are trying to associate them with objects of real-world value.
Do you see data as being inherently worthless as well? Because that's all there is, data. And according to the current market, it's not worthless, just like even if some people consider Bitcoin to be inherently worthless, there is a market that says it isn't.
What's that worth? Data by itself is inherently worthless. It's only worth something if it represents something we care about. This could be something fictional (e.x. a video game world), or real (a warehouse inventory), but on it's own? Worthless.
You say an NFT is a cryptocurrency with a single individual token and... what? It's a piece of data, but what can I do with it or what can I get out of it? I can send it to someone else? Cool, what can they do with it? What benefit is there? That's the big question I've at least yet to seen answered satisfactorily.
I get there's a market for this currently, but once upon a time there was a market for pet rocks (which unlike NFTs can at least be pleasing to look at). Markets can be irrational, and the fact that there is a market price for something does not inherently mean that something has value.
I said: “The only value comes from rights that token can confer.”
Did you not see that?
To be honest, I don't see much value in the current Images-as-NFTs hype either, but again, who am I to judge what people spend their money on? I also thought the same about Bitcoin initially, but after a while saw value in it myself too.
When it comes to NFTs as a concept though, I think they can be applied better than what people are currently doing. SaaS licenses that can be resold for example is one interesting use case.
I mean, ok, if we're going to engage in some form of economic nihilism then I guess we can say anything is valuable. Q-Ray Bracelets, faith healing, and star registries included. Tulip bulbs really can be "worth" a fortune. But that's not a very useful premise for discussion. What people are arguing over is whether or not there is any non-woo value to be associated with these things.
> When it comes to NFTs as a concept though, I think they can be applied better than what people are currently doing.
I'm not convinced. I keep hearing people say this but I have yet to hear even one idea that can't be done better by other, older, non-hyped technologies.
> SaaS licenses that can be resold for example is one interesting use case.
Case in point: we can do this just fine today, but we don't because there's no reason for an SaaS provider to want to do that.
What makes the iTunes MP3 marketplace valuable? What makes the Amazon Kindle text file marketplace valuable? Is there something about the virtual nature of NFTs that gets to you in a way that these intangible marketplaces don't? Why does itunes and Kindle not bother you? Because they have an army of lawyers to enforce copyrights and license agreements behind them? Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?
The law. Copyright law makes acquiring these works via other means slightly more difficult. Like NFTs they are just a failed attempt to force artificial scarcity into a post-scarcity space.
> Why does itunes and Kindle not bother you?
They do, but they don't have scammers constantly trying to sell their shit as some kind of revolutionary new future you have to get in on before you get left behind!!1!
> Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?
What disturbs me is the shift from people viewing artificial scarcity as a desperate grasping at straws from people who can't deal with information post-scarcity to people touting artificial scarcity as the glorious technological future.
Copyright law does not exclude someone from releasing on an open source blockchain as opposed to a monopoly app store.
The only reason these marketplaces exist as monopolies is because direct distribution of creative content for profit has traditionally been difficult to manage. That's all.
> They do, but they don't have scammers constantly trying to sell their shit as some kind of revolutionary new future you have to get in on before you get left behind!!1!
Only because the dust has already settled from the same thing that happened during the dot com boom and the consumer electronics boom and the mobile app store boom.
> What disturbs me is the shift from people viewing artificial scarcity as a desperate grasping at straws from people who can't deal with information post-scarcity to people touting artificial scarcity as the glorious technological future.
Copyright enforcement over monopolistic marketplaces is a form of artificial scarcity. Come on, you know this. Napster was leaps and bounds ahead of any distribution method for music back in the 90s. Cost of music redistribution has been near zero for over 20 years. It doesn't cost the band anything to have their music copy pasted on a torrent site. The entire scheme of copyright protection is an archaic method of introducing artificial scarcity for items that are cheap to reproduce (yet sometimes capital intensive to produce). NFTs are no different.
Yes, there were scams at the beginning of those booms, but at the same time, there were obvious real world applications that end users benefited from right from the start, and absolutely no sense of doubt that there was value in them.
>The entire scheme of copyright protection is an archaic method of introducing artificial scarcity for items that are cheap to reproduce (yet sometimes capital intensive to produce).
True.
> NFTs are no different.
Obviously false. NFTs don’t have the law preventing you from ignoring them.
The music is good, and it’s harder to get them elsewhere.
> What makes the Amazon Kindle text file marketplace valuable?
The books are good, and it’s harder to get them elsewhere.
> Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?
Why would anyone be disturbed by this? I see nothing wrong with people trading tokens. What is disturbing are claims that trading these tokens is equivalent to trading in the associated goods.
Nothing.
> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.
> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.
My argument is that the system works just fine as a plausibly neutral ledger of account and for establishing provenance of ownership through reputation and convention.
And in fact I very much prefer it to the legions of corporate lawyers enforcing man-made copyright laws and enriching monopolistic centrally distributed platforms such as app stores. I consider it much more sustainable, universal, accessible, and respectful of human rights and expression than the current systems in place.
Where we disagree is our value judgement of that. I just don't see that as being useful per se, imo there's enough ways to move numbers around using computers already, a novel one can't really get me all that excited, especially considering its resource cost.
I have yet to see a good argument for crypto that doesn't boil down to that.
I think it's one of those "when you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail" scenarios. Marketplace volume isn't a good in itself if the markets don't do anything useful and waste a bunch of energy, but to people bought into crypto and capitalism really deeply it seems to be enough to get excited.
False. Just like open source software, the devil is in the details (usually the LICENSE.md file). NFT projects vary dramatically in the rights they convey to holders. To the extent that these meatspace rights are enforceable, some convey commercial use, some convey personal use, some are published as creative commons, and some are ambiguous.
The NFT space is rather immature compared to open source software, however. The ambiguity is a real problem. The space would do well to standardize on licenses and stamp that on the NFT's metadata.
But in the meantime, by convention in Web3, the apps and websites that integrate NFTs respect the ownership and provide verification of ownership for integrations, such as virtual art galleries, exclusive events or areas in Decentraland, profile pic verification on ENS, wallet gallery on OpenSea, avatars in Sandbox, etc.
By convention, web3 marketplaces also respect royalties with original artists on resales.
NFTs are tokens that can be used and verified as arbitrary authentication tokens for anything, whether it be a real life event or product or access to some software or other virtual benefit.
As such, I don't see how NFT "ownership" can (currently) be construed to possess any legal rights whatsoever unless agreed upon externally to the NFT in which case... what value is the NFT adding?
Would love to get a proper legal teardown of this space.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrink_wrap_contract
[2] All this said, I could see a world where an NFT smart contract requires a cryptographically signed _legal_ contract to be hashed into the transfer as a form of legal consent. But for some reason this isn't yet reality.
But if we called NFT's 'certificates,' then less would buy into the Tulip mania.
NFT's are just a digest of certificates, public/private key pairs, and a chain of hashes.
If Lebron James put out a limited run digital model of himself, a set of hashes and schema describing the signatures, and released the certificates for purchase on Nike.com,then all the legal, authorized implementers, such as Fortnite, CS:Go, Roblox, and Halo:Infinite could all render the model, respect the ownership (or lack therof) by validating the account and object's cryptographic digest (comparing against a global ownership ledger), and allow free, unrestricted, cross-domain/platform/Intellectual property boundary transfership and use, aligning with meatspace laws...
...all without calling it an NFT.
> False.
Really? The original poster says:
> Further, I make it clear exactly what rights you and others have over the media, which is basically none.
> NFT projects vary dramatically in the rights they convey to holders. To the extent that these meatspace rights are enforceable
NFT’s don’t convey enforceable meatspace rights.
You just don’t know what’s happening.
I will have my kid draw a picture of a bridge and send you a JPG of it; you can put that on Meta Horizon as many times as you want.
Naturally like all NFT wallets I fully reserve the right to delete the repo at any time for any reason with no warning.
Lmk what you think and I’ll get you my Venmo.
If someone buys an NFT what good is it today, or what problem can it solve in future that can't more simply be solved by something that already exists?
But looking at these, I'm just not seeing the value that NFTs have provided vs already existing methods. For example I'm looking at https://somniumspace.com/parcel/3402?elv=-0.68. I assume the art on the walls here are NFTs no? And I'd have to be the owner of the NFT if I wanted to take it to my own "parcel"? But what prevents me from simply taking the source image and simply minting my own NFT and displaying it? And why would I want to use a space like this instead of something like Second Life or VR Chat where I can go the much more direct route of simply uploading a PNG?
That's the piece that I have yet to see answered clearly. I certainly get it's technically possible to build something based around NFTs, and given that they are currently trending I'm not in the least bit surprised someone has. I just can't see how it's superior either via ease of use or in technical capability to something that already exists.
Because the NFT isn't just a pointer to an image, it's a tuple that also includes which wallet address is granting you that NFT. So, the "real" NFT for a work is the one granted by the original artist or other authority people culturally agree upon as the one that has real social and economic value. (For example, the artist may post the public key somewhere authoritatively that conveys it is the one they've sanctioned.)
It effectively acts as a fully-provable (and scarce) signature by the artist, and eventually if it isn't already, will be displayed visually on the work in these apps to confer legitimacy. Putting up an image that isn't signed by the original artist will be possible, but it won't confer the same status to a person the genuine NFT would, since observers will be able to know it is not the genuine NFT.
And of course, the reason you'd want to use this kind of environment is self-referential: you want to use it because you want the status or other benefits that come from being able to put your genuine NFTs on display. For example, it can show how wealthy you are, show that you are willing to patronize artists, cause the original artist to come visit your showroom, etc.
Many different kinds of publicity stunt can achieve these things. NFTs offer no unique benefits.
The idea of artificial scarcity seems central to NFT, but it is unclear if this is really a moat or desirable. Does it really convey exclusivity over a "unique" set of bits?
That NFT is scarce. Too many people do not understand what an NFT represents and what it’s short and longer term expected conferred benefits are, and are hung up on trying to create analogies to existing forms of ownership like physical property rights or copyright.
I.e. they are in-game currency.
People are ‘hung up’ on analogies to physical ownership, because proponents of NFT’s keep claiming they are like deeds of ownership, which is what the linked article strongly asserted before it was amended.
If NFT advocates stopped calling it ownership, I don’t think anyone would be hung up about it.
People within the community are using a meaning that has essentially none of the attributes of the conventional definition while claiming that the meaning is the same.
This isn’t a question of two sides disagreeing over meanings. It’s a question of a deceptive use of a very well established pre-existing term.
The ownership of NFTs is the ability to assert you control the keys of a wallet pointing to a tuple that pairs, for example, a URL to a smart contract. Both of these elements in the tuple then confer certain things by proxy: the URL a proxy to the work, and the smart contract a proxy to an authority. Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits (there are several contemporary realized and theoretical future ones.)
True but that doesn’t mean there isn’t a commonality to the meaning.
We don’t use the term ‘ownership’ to refer to preparing food, or driving a car for example.
And as I have pointed out. The lie is not that people don’t own NFTs. They do.
The lie is that NFTs confer ownership of the media that point to.
> Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits
Only in the sense that owning a movie ticket provides benefits at a particular theater.
You can also keep the ticket stub as a memento or sell it if you like.
NFTs are no different.
You mean NFTs as an in-game currency for Facebook’s VR?
Yes, that’s a reasonable account of what they are good for.
Based on this thread, I would say NFTs are not.
So what exactly is the point of an "alternative form of ownership" that is only considered valid by a small subculture and not society at large? Is it really ownership in any meaningful sense?
iow: "small subcultures".
> There is no “at large” society.
Of course there is. Do you really think USD for example isn't accepted by society at large?
The fact that there are a few socialists tho object is irrelevant.
For other things like copyright and other extra-physical forms of ownership that span society at large, there is no macro set of laws governing these things universally so context matters.
Using the words macro and universally allow your statement to be true in the most literal sense that there are no universal laws, but otherwise, copyright is just as universal as land ownership. I.e. most places have a version of it, but there are many local variations.
Arguably, copyright is probably more universal than land ownership since it is a newer concept and there is less local divergence.
“Copyright laws are standardized somewhat through these international conventions such as the Berne Convention and Universal Copyright Convention. These multilateral treaties have been ratified by nearly all countries, and international organizations such as the European Union or World Trade Organization require their member states to comply with them.”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright#International_copyri...
Nothing suggests that existing NFTs will be relevant in that world even if the technology is.
It’s also not obvious that a distributed ledger has an advantage over a centralized one.
The value of the distributed ledger is rooted in a theory: that it will be, in the long term, the most durable and agreed upon place to look to for arbitrary third parties to decide whose artist's signature is legitimate.
The thing that suggests the NFTs of the world today will be relevant in that future world is pretty simple: take any piece of art where the artist involved has publicly sanctioned an NFT for it, and ask the question if the signature of that artist on that work will theoretically be something valued by society in the future. (Grounded by the well placed assumption that this is truly non-fungible - the artist can't even reneg on this, since history will record this was the original.) The number of times you can affirm this as a "yes" should increase the weight you put on the hypothesis today's NFTs will be valuable in the future.
It's worth noting: these two hypotheses are decoupled. The blockchain has already been written. So even if the idea of an NFT burns out so much that future artists do not make them anymore, this doesn't necessarily mean the NFTs that exist today will not be valuable or recognized. They are in the public record, and those who control the wallets they are assigned to will always be able to prove they are the owners of them, even if the chains they are on stop adding new blocks in the future.
A signed artwork is more valuable than an unsigned artwork.
However NFTs do not create signed artworks. The artwork remains the same.
The NFT is just a receipt for someone paying money to someone else, who in some cases is linked to the an artist.
Is that valuable? Maybe. I concede that a bill of sale from some point along the chain of ownership of ‘the last supper’ might have value to some kind of collector.
But, an NFT is not equivalent even to the bill of sale.
If you have the bill of sale, you have a unique historical item, whereas the NFT is on the public blockchain where everyone can see it and copy of it, so even that doesn’t have any scarcity.
Both the media and the NFT are infinitely copyable.
A theory which many people disagree with.
> You seem determined to think with analogies.
So do you.
An NFT is not a signature on a piece of art. You are trying to convince us that an NFT is analogous to a signature on a piece of art.
Whether the analogies of the crypto community hold is what is being debated here.
I assume you are aware that NFTs are not actually signatures on physical artworks.
> If my attempt above didn’t help you understand why people are paying tons of money for these things,
I’m sure you wouldn’t be claiming that people never pay money for things that later turn out not to be valuable.
I don't feel compelled to play video games, and I don't feel interested in joining an AR metaverse. That might just be personal shortcoming clouding my expectations of Web3...
Let's rephrase to 'perks'.
The owner of a house now has access to the perks of owning a house: E.g Noone can enter property without permission, can't park on your driveway, can act how you want in your own home etc
People without a house do not have this ability.
The owner of an NFT now has access to the perks of owning that NFT: Access to exlusive discord (training and information, etc), early access to new projects, job opportunities etc
An NFT can offer a lot of different utility which are only received by proving their ownership of the cryptographic token.
> An NFT can offer a lot of different utility which are only received by proving their ownership of the cryptographic token.
The NFT isn’t offering anything. The business that offers the perks is. If the business changes or goes out of business, the perks disappear.
Not so with your ownership of a house.
Edit: here is one article describing the Swiss framework: https://thelawreviews.co.uk/title/the-virtual-currency-regul...
Doesn't the same logic apply to paintings/prints? If you buy a painting from an artist, is there anything preventing the artist from making a copy/replica? As for as I know, selling a painting does not constitute a transfer/assignment of copyright. The only difference here seems to be that paintings are analog, and take more effort to duplicate than right-clicking.
Yes, the fact that fake paintings are detectable. Prints are not which is which they are cheap.
That depends on the conditions attached to the NFT. For example, the Bored Ape Yacht Club gives full commercial ownership to the owner of each ape for the particular ape they own.
That is not ownership.
The future will probably begin to expand to more than just 'images, audio and video', which those specific NFTs in those categories are absolutely useless.
Similarly, this community has agreed that a contract written in a certain form, with the requisite signatures and registrations, conveys ownership of a piece of art. Subject, again, to caveats and rules and fine print.
If at this point you are trying to argue semantics when most of the community has a pretty intuitive sense of what exactly "owning an NFT" means, it seems a bit pointless.
Except that they simply haven’t.
Try taking someone’s house from them. You’ll find that it’s not just semantics that defines ownership.
Try copying the artwork pointed to by an NFT. You’ll find the NFT doesn’t stop you.
> If at this point you are trying to argue semantics when most of the community has a pretty intuitive sense of what exactly "owning an NFT" means, it seems a bit pointless.
I agree that it’s pointless to argue with people who think “owning an NFT” has any relationship to owning the artwork itself. It’s ok if people want to be part of a community who believe that together.
If you feel secure as a member of that community, don’t let the rest of us perturb you.
Have you considered that most people are not in fact part of that community, and that discussion of this point is quite relevant to anyone who hasn’t already committed themself to this belief?
Wrong.
> I think I make it pretty clear when it gets to more detail that the NFT is the thing you own.
Yes, you contradict yourself.
> Further, I make it clear exactly what rights you and others have over the media, which is basically none.
Yes, which is not what you say in the parts I quoted - let’s remind ourselves:
> Just like a deed conveys ownership of a house at some address, the token conveys ownership of that media.
This is a common pattern in writing about this subject, which is why I point this out. It’s a standard Motte and Bailey technique, which is a dishonest form of persuasive writing.
This is just a lie. The token doesn’t convey ownership of then media. There is no rough understanding by which this is true.
> I make it clear exactly what rights you and others have over the media, which is basically none.
Which you acknowledge here.
This isn’t a matter of exact details that aren’t important to a buyer.
If you tell someone that an NFT conveys ownership of the media, you are lying to them and participating in a con.
The fact that you later contradict that statement, doesn’t change the fact that you lied.
The debate around this is pretty somewhat tiresome. Yes, you have to buy into the believe that the token represents the media, but it's as good a definition as any because all ways we talk colloquially about "owning" a JPEG are simply not the same as owning a chair.
- Copyright is just a set of limited legal rights granted to someone temporarily by certain jurisdictions. It's not the same thing as owning something, which is why we were laughing at the "you wouldn't steal a car" ads in the 2000s.
- Actual ownership means having access to a copy of the bytes, which is not perceived as meaningful, and only valuable to the extend that access is otherwise arbitrarily restricted.
- You can choose to believe in the artificial scarcity of a certificate of ownership.
This is fine. There is no problem with a club of people who choose to play a game in which they agree that a token has a particular meaning.
The rest of us can point out that it doesn’t mean the same thing outside that club of believers.
https://meebits.larvalabs.com/meebits/termsandconditions
And note you don’t own the media and that what owning the NFT means can change.
Not really sure what point you are trying to make. With Meebits, you don’t own anything other than the token itself.
There is no thing that another person can do regarding a piece of art backed by an NFT that you own that will cause state employees with guns to show up to stop them.
For example, I can offer a free milkshake to anyone who parks in my parking lot in a yellow car.
Then yellow car isn’t doing anything in this situation, I am, and if I can always change my mind.
Then same is true with cryptovoxels and NFTs.
The point is if 1M people all agreed to give a free milkshake to people who parked in your parking lot, the parking lot is pretty important.
There are paving stones on which a million people walk each year. They are of no more importance than a parking lot in which a particular trade promotion takes place.
BS. That’s the marketing excuse. The real value is only in the fact that you can potentially sell it to a greater fool who will buy for more so you won’t be the one holding the bag. It’s the new tulip mania!
> Just like a deed conveys ownership of a house at some address, the token conveys ownership of that media.
Again, if you don't like specific wording, I invite you to write a better explanation for regular folks which is simultaneously perfectly accurate in every sense in every phrase and word you use.
Not really. The original document contained an outright lie which have now removed because it was exposed.
If you didn’t accept it was a lie, you wouldn’t have removed it.
This has nothing to do with imperfect accuracy. It has to do with you writing an outright falsehood.
The idea that a lie stops being a lie because of the number of words you say later is obviously absurd.
As I have pointed out this is a motte and Bailey fallacy.
Also, it’s still a completely misleading statement. The change to ‘similar to’ doesn’t make it true. It still isn’t true, only now you have some wiggle room to claim it’s not a lie.
You are still trying to misleading people into thinking that NFTs confer ownership of the media.
This is a false statement. The NFT doesn’t make you the owner of ‘the work’. It makes you the owner of the NFT.
> The same way purchasing a painting gives you the right to resell that painting and prove to others that you are the owner, but does not necessarily convey copyright or other rights (unless worked out separately via a contract), purchasing an NFT gives you the right to resell that NFT and prove to others that you are the owner.
I.e, In the same way that if you own a paining, the painting is yours and not the copyright. If you own an NFT, only the NFT is yours and not the artwork.
> Just like a deed conveys ownership of a house at some address, the token conveys ownership of that media.
No it doesn’t.
If you own a house, there are many things you can do with the house that others are legally prohibited from doing.
If you own an NFT, you have no more rights over the media than someone who doesn’t own an NFT.
> Just like you can invite a neighbor over to visit your house, and a car driving by can take a photo of your house, anybody can view the media associated with your NFT.
This is obviously absurd.
If you own a house, it’s illegal for people to visit without being invited. If you own an NFT, an infinite number of people can I air the media without you even knowing, let alone inviting them.
Also, a person driving by your house with a car can’t legally park in your driveway or come in and sleep in your bed, whereas someone with a copy of the media can do anything the owner of the NFT can do, including invite others to look at it.