The ownership of NFTs is the ability to assert you control the keys of a wallet pointing to a tuple that pairs, for example, a URL to a smart contract. Both of these elements in the tuple then confer certain things by proxy: the URL a proxy to the work, and the smart contract a proxy to an authority. Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits (there are several contemporary realized and theoretical future ones.)
True but that doesn’t mean there isn’t a commonality to the meaning.
We don’t use the term ‘ownership’ to refer to preparing food, or driving a car for example.
And as I have pointed out. The lie is not that people don’t own NFTs. They do.
The lie is that NFTs confer ownership of the media that point to.
> Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits
Only in the sense that owning a movie ticket provides benefits at a particular theater.
You can also keep the ticket stub as a memento or sell it if you like.
NFTs are no different.
People within the community are using a meaning that has essentially none of the attributes of the conventional definition while claiming that the meaning is the same.
This isn’t a question of two sides disagreeing over meanings. It’s a question of a deceptive use of a very well established pre-existing term.