News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by malermeister on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:14PM (#29290935)
And neither does the Blockchain have provenance of... anything really.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by capableweb on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:23PM (#29291022)
The blockchains have provenance of themselves and the space within them, which is exactly what the NFT represents. Nothing more, nothing less.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:35PM (#29291145)
Right, and the entry in any particular star register's registry is the same thing. They have provenance over their registry, nothing more, nothing less.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by capableweb on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:26PM (#29291997)
Yes, but you cannot act within their registry as a independent actor, transferring and receiving items in the registry on your and others will. They own that registry, and they chose to give you access. That's the difference between a centralized registry like that star registry, and a blockchain where every actor has equal access to the "registry". No one can stop you from transferring your NFT to someone else, while in a centralized registry, they could.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:50PM (#29292529)
Sure, but why would anyone want that? Why would I want to buy and sell access to some entry in a registry that ultimately means nothing?
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by capableweb on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:20PM (#29292689)
That's besides the point. Why anything? I'm not gonna pretend to understand high-art, because I don't, but apparently some people see value in it, so who am I to question what they value?

To be honest, I don't see much value in the current Images-as-NFTs hype either, but again, who am I to judge what people spend their money on? I also thought the same about Bitcoin initially, but after a while saw value in it myself too.

When it comes to NFTs as a concept though, I think they can be applied better than what people are currently doing. SaaS licenses that can be resold for example is one interesting use case.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:32PM (#29292761)
> That's besides the point. Why anything?

I mean, ok, if we're going to engage in some form of economic nihilism then I guess we can say anything is valuable. Q-Ray Bracelets, faith healing, and star registries included. Tulip bulbs really can be "worth" a fortune. But that's not a very useful premise for discussion. What people are arguing over is whether or not there is any non-woo value to be associated with these things.

> When it comes to NFTs as a concept though, I think they can be applied better than what people are currently doing.

I'm not convinced. I keep hearing people say this but I have yet to hear even one idea that can't be done better by other, older, non-hyped technologies.

> SaaS licenses that can be resold for example is one interesting use case.

Case in point: we can do this just fine today, but we don't because there's no reason for an SaaS provider to want to do that.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by chrisco255 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:43PM (#29291673)
Clearly not. If an artist with an on-chain reputation such as Beeple creates a digital artwork and mints it on-chain and continues to do so over time and that artist's work becomes sought after, the reputation and history and story of that work being created and minted and transferred is as good as any other form of provenance.

What makes the iTunes MP3 marketplace valuable? What makes the Amazon Kindle text file marketplace valuable? Is there something about the virtual nature of NFTs that gets to you in a way that these intangible marketplaces don't? Why does itunes and Kindle not bother you? Because they have an army of lawyers to enforce copyrights and license agreements behind them? Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:54PM (#29292551)
> What makes the iTunes MP3 marketplace valuable? What makes the Amazon Kindle text file marketplace valuable?

The law. Copyright law makes acquiring these works via other means slightly more difficult. Like NFTs they are just a failed attempt to force artificial scarcity into a post-scarcity space.

> Why does itunes and Kindle not bother you?

They do, but they don't have scammers constantly trying to sell their shit as some kind of revolutionary new future you have to get in on before you get left behind!!1!

> Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?

What disturbs me is the shift from people viewing artificial scarcity as a desperate grasping at straws from people who can't deal with information post-scarcity to people touting artificial scarcity as the glorious technological future.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by chrisco255 on Sunday November 21, 2021 @01:51PM (#29298664)
> The law. Copyright law makes acquiring these works via other means slightly more difficult. Like NFTs they are just a failed attempt to force artificial scarcity into a post-scarcity space.

Copyright law does not exclude someone from releasing on an open source blockchain as opposed to a monopoly app store.

The only reason these marketplaces exist as monopolies is because direct distribution of creative content for profit has traditionally been difficult to manage. That's all.

> They do, but they don't have scammers constantly trying to sell their shit as some kind of revolutionary new future you have to get in on before you get left behind!!1!

Only because the dust has already settled from the same thing that happened during the dot com boom and the consumer electronics boom and the mobile app store boom.

> What disturbs me is the shift from people viewing artificial scarcity as a desperate grasping at straws from people who can't deal with information post-scarcity to people touting artificial scarcity as the glorious technological future.

Copyright enforcement over monopolistic marketplaces is a form of artificial scarcity. Come on, you know this. Napster was leaps and bounds ahead of any distribution method for music back in the 90s. Cost of music redistribution has been near zero for over 20 years. It doesn't cost the band anything to have their music copy pasted on a torrent site. The entire scheme of copyright protection is an archaic method of introducing artificial scarcity for items that are cheap to reproduce (yet sometimes capital intensive to produce). NFTs are no different.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Sunday November 21, 2021 @03:40PM (#29299491)
> Only because the dust has already settled from the same thing that happened during the dot com boom and the consumer electronics boom and the mobile app store boom.

Yes, there were scams at the beginning of those booms, but at the same time, there were obvious real world applications that end users benefited from right from the start, and absolutely no sense of doubt that there was value in them.

>The entire scheme of copyright protection is an archaic method of introducing artificial scarcity for items that are cheap to reproduce (yet sometimes capital intensive to produce).

True.

> NFTs are no different.

Obviously false. NFTs don’t have the law preventing you from ignoring them.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:08PM (#29291861)
> What makes the iTunes MP3 marketplace valuable?

The music is good, and it’s harder to get them elsewhere.

> What makes the Amazon Kindle text file marketplace valuable?

The books are good, and it’s harder to get them elsewhere.

> Does the convention and reputation-based open source nature of Web3 disturb you?

Why would anyone be disturbed by this? I see nothing wrong with people trading tokens. What is disturbing are claims that trading these tokens is equivalent to trading in the associated goods.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by Y_Y on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:43PM (#29291672)
> Nothing more, nothing less.

Nothing.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by capableweb on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:44PM (#29291683)
As a reminder:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by Y_Y on Sunday November 21, 2021 @03:25AM (#29294947)
> Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gruez on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:19PM (#29290976)
But at least some of the NFTs are endorsed by the artists themselves?
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by chrisco255 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:23PM (#29291016)
Of course it does. Go try and right click save a Bitcoin and sell it on Coinbase or Gemini.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by malermeister on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:53PM (#29291300)
Not sure how that's related to art though. Of course a self-referential system is good for internal consistency. The issue comes with trying to use it for anything outside the system, such as monkey jpegs.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by chrisco255 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:11PM (#29291449)
Not at all. It clearly works just fine as the marketplace volume suggests. Go right click save a CryptoPunk and try and sell it. Go make a BAYC clone and try and sell it. Try it out on chain, deploy your own copy of the smart contract. Or go and create a website and set up a Paypal account and try to sell some JPEGs. Let me know how that works out. Even if you succeed in making money, like selling a fake Gucci purse, you'd only succeed in increasing the clout of the original.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by mdoms on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:44PM (#29291680)
Most rational people argue that NFTs are a bubble/mania. Your argument that it's not because people are throwing wild amounts of money at them does nothing to convince us otherwise.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by chrisco255 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:03PM (#29291823)
That's a loaded opinion. A lot of people said the same about Bitcoin, the internet, social media, electric cars, and mobile apps.

My argument is that the system works just fine as a plausibly neutral ledger of account and for establishing provenance of ownership through reputation and convention.

And in fact I very much prefer it to the legions of corporate lawyers enforcing man-made copyright laws and enriching monopolistic centrally distributed platforms such as app stores. I consider it much more sustainable, universal, accessible, and respectful of human rights and expression than the current systems in place.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by malermeister on Sunday November 21, 2021 @01:04PM (#29298256)
I think we're talking past one another. I'm sure there's plenty of ways to make money by flipping various crypto assets.

Where we disagree is our value judgement of that. I just don't see that as being useful per se, imo there's enough ways to move numbers around using computers already, a novel one can't really get me all that excited, especially considering its resource cost.

I have yet to see a good argument for crypto that doesn't boil down to that.

I think it's one of those "when you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail" scenarios. Marketplace volume isn't a good in itself if the markets don't do anything useful and waste a bunch of energy, but to people bought into crypto and capitalism really deeply it seems to be enough to get excited.