News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @01:58PM (#29290801)
You’re presuming ownership universally means copyright. It doesn’t. Ownership is as much a cultural norm as a legal one. Owning the NFT, in certain circles, allows you to participate in an alternative cultural norm of ownership, decoupled from copyright ownership.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by evan_ on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:10PM (#29290905)
Would you like to participate in an alternative cultural norm of ownership of a bridge in Brooklyn?
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:59PM (#29291359)
Depends on the context. For example if it meant I was the only one able to spawn the bridge in Meta’s Horizon, maybe?

You just don’t know what’s happening.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by evan_ on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:22PM (#29291525)
For $6,500 USD I will create a GitHub repo called “A Bridge in Brooklyn” containing your name in the readme. You may consider the commit ID your non-fungible token. If you wish to sell it I will add another commit with the new owner’s name after I receive a $500 “gas fee”.

I will have my kid draw a picture of a bridge and send you a JPG of it; you can put that on Meta Horizon as many times as you want.

Naturally like all NFT wallets I fully reserve the right to delete the repo at any time for any reason with no warning.

Lmk what you think and I’ll get you my Venmo.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:09PM (#29291872)
No, that doesn’t meet my requirement above. Nothing does, because Meta doesn’t impose the constraint I am talking about: it was a hypothetical example to try to convey to you the dynamics going on regarding NFTs that you seem to think you fully understand.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by Volundr on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:24PM (#29292391)
Isn't that the point though? Every time I try to figure out the value of this thing called an "NFT" I can find plenty of hypotheticals, but I've yet to encounter anything concrete. Using your example you want to be the only one who can use this "thing" in Meta Horizon. Cool, but that's something Meta Horizon has to implement, and they don't need some weird blockchain thingy to do it.

If someone buys an NFT what good is it today, or what problem can it solve in future that can't more simply be solved by something that already exists?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:00PM (#29292579)
I used meta because I assumed you’d be aware of what I was referring to instead of cryptovoxels, sommium space, or webaverse. If you grant that the meta example would be useful if it exists, then we’d just be haggling over if eg cryptovoxels has enough analogous utility to pull it into the set of things you consider worthy.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by Volundr on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:22PM (#29292703)
I'm not familiar with any of these, but then I'm not familiar with Meta Horizon either. I'll be the first to admit I'm not up on what the "cool kids" are doing. If it helps feel free to imagine your explaining this to your culturally clueless but technically savvy grandpa.

But looking at these, I'm just not seeing the value that NFTs have provided vs already existing methods. For example I'm looking at https://somniumspace.com/parcel/3402?elv=-0.68. I assume the art on the walls here are NFTs no? And I'd have to be the owner of the NFT if I wanted to take it to my own "parcel"? But what prevents me from simply taking the source image and simply minting my own NFT and displaying it? And why would I want to use a space like this instead of something like Second Life or VR Chat where I can go the much more direct route of simply uploading a PNG?

That's the piece that I have yet to see answered clearly. I certainly get it's technically possible to build something based around NFTs, and given that they are currently trending I'm not in the least bit surprised someone has. I just can't see how it's superior either via ease of use or in technical capability to something that already exists.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @04:39PM (#29311858)
> But what prevents me from simply taking the source image and simply minting my own NFT and displaying it?

Because the NFT isn't just a pointer to an image, it's a tuple that also includes which wallet address is granting you that NFT. So, the "real" NFT for a work is the one granted by the original artist or other authority people culturally agree upon as the one that has real social and economic value. (For example, the artist may post the public key somewhere authoritatively that conveys it is the one they've sanctioned.)

It effectively acts as a fully-provable (and scarce) signature by the artist, and eventually if it isn't already, will be displayed visually on the work in these apps to confer legitimacy. Putting up an image that isn't signed by the original artist will be possible, but it won't confer the same status to a person the genuine NFT would, since observers will be able to know it is not the genuine NFT.

And of course, the reason you'd want to use this kind of environment is self-referential: you want to use it because you want the status or other benefits that come from being able to put your genuine NFTs on display. For example, it can show how wealthy you are, show that you are willing to patronize artists, cause the original artist to come visit your showroom, etc.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:26PM (#29323768)
> For example, it can show how wealthy you are, show that you are willing to patronize artists, cause the original artist to come visit your showroom, etc.

Many different kinds of publicity stunt can achieve these things. NFTs offer no unique benefits.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by verdverm on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:19PM (#29291505)
What would stop someone from spawning a slightly modified (imperceptible to human eye) Brooklyn Bridge?

The idea of artificial scarcity seems central to NFT, but it is unclear if this is really a moat or desirable. Does it really convey exclusivity over a "unique" set of bits?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:12PM (#29291886)
No, an NFT is not a pair but a tuple. The third part of the tuple is the third party who issued the NFT. In the case of the Brooklyn Bridge, the NFTs I expect that would confer social status in the metaverse regarding the bridge would be ones issued by the City of New York or perhaps the descendants of the original architects. This will probably actually happen in some form but it will be a while. If you’re talking about a specific work of art depicting the bridge, the only NFT of value is the one sanctioned by the original artist.

That NFT is scarce. Too many people do not understand what an NFT represents and what it’s short and longer term expected conferred benefits are, and are hung up on trying to create analogies to existing forms of ownership like physical property rights or copyright.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:57PM (#29292219)
It’s reasonable to assert that NFT’s are about conferring social status in the metaverse.

I.e. they are in-game currency.

People are ‘hung up’ on analogies to physical ownership, because proponents of NFT’s keep claiming they are like deeds of ownership, which is what the linked article strongly asserted before it was amended.

If NFT advocates stopped calling it ownership, I don’t think anyone would be hung up about it.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:01PM (#29292588)
I agree a lot is lost in the noise due to presumption about what the other side means when they’re using “ownership.”
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:21PM (#29292694)
This isn’t correct. People outside the ‘community’ are using a long established meaning.

People within the community are using a meaning that has essentially none of the attributes of the conventional definition while claiming that the meaning is the same.

This isn’t a question of two sides disagreeing over meanings. It’s a question of a deceptive use of a very well established pre-existing term.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @06:03PM (#29312660)
No, there are already a variety of uses of the term ownership. For example, copyright ownership, license ownership, or physical ownership. There isn’t a single definition, and the definitions of ownership have always been contextual and evolve based on things like norms and technological changes.

The ownership of NFTs is the ability to assert you control the keys of a wallet pointing to a tuple that pairs, for example, a URL to a smart contract. Both of these elements in the tuple then confer certain things by proxy: the URL a proxy to the work, and the smart contract a proxy to an authority. Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits (there are several contemporary realized and theoretical future ones.)

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Monday November 22, 2021 @07:23PM (#29313233)
> There isn’t a single definition

True but that doesn’t mean there isn’t a commonality to the meaning.

We don’t use the term ‘ownership’ to refer to preparing food, or driving a car for example.

And as I have pointed out. The lie is not that people don’t own NFTs. They do.

The lie is that NFTs confer ownership of the media that point to.

> Once that linkage is accepted by a third party, then it serves as a form of semantic ownership with contextual benefits

Only in the sense that owning a movie ticket provides benefits at a particular theater.

You can also keep the ticket stub as a memento or sell it if you like.

NFTs are no different.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:15PM (#29291477)
> You just don’t know what’s happening.

You mean NFTs as an in-game currency for Facebook’s VR?

Yes, that’s a reasonable account of what they are good for.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by malermeister on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:18PM (#29290971)
The thing about cultural norms is that they're only meaningful if they're accepted by the prevailing culture.

Based on this thread, I would say NFTs are not.

So what exactly is the point of an "alternative form of ownership" that is only considered valid by a small subculture and not society at large? Is it really ownership in any meaningful sense?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:01PM (#29291373)
NFTs are considered ownership in nascent online societies. There is no “at large” society. Even nation state recognized ownership in terms of copyright has its limits.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by malermeister on Saturday November 20, 2021 @08:07PM (#29293265)
> NFTs are considered ownership in nascent online societies.

iow: "small subcultures".

> There is no “at large” society.

Of course there is. Do you really think USD for example isn't accepted by society at large?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:11PM (#29291453)
If there is no “at large society”, why don’t you live in a nicer house?
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:24PM (#29291976)
Huh? I own my home in the eyes of most people I care about (for example, most citizens and authorities of the United States.) But even within the US there are for example socialists who reject the idea I own my home. They just don’t have the means to overturn this particular norm within the sovereignty of my country - but in some circles like that insofar as “being a homeowner” confers privileges such privileges would not exist.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:58PM (#29292232)
Sure but that’s what people mean by ‘at large society’.

The fact that there are a few socialists tho object is irrelevant.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @06:09PM (#29312722)
When it comes to physical land and real estate then I agree there is a pretty natural definition of “at large” - the sovereignties the land is located within.

For other things like copyright and other extra-physical forms of ownership that span society at large, there is no macro set of laws governing these things universally so context matters.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Monday November 22, 2021 @07:47PM (#29313390)
There are in fact laws governing copyright, and international agreements.

Using the words macro and universally allow your statement to be true in the most literal sense that there are no universal laws, but otherwise, copyright is just as universal as land ownership. I.e. most places have a version of it, but there are many local variations.

Arguably, copyright is probably more universal than land ownership since it is a newer concept and there is less local divergence.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @11:16PM (#29314541)
I’m aware that there are international copyright laws but they are far from universal if that’s taken to mean human society on Earth.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:45PM (#29323952)
They exist in nearly everywhere on the planet are in fact a great candidate for the most universal laws that exist, and are objectively far more universal than land ownership laws.

“Copyright laws are standardized somewhat through these international conventions such as the Berne Convention and Universal Copyright Convention. These multilateral treaties have been ratified by nearly all countries, and international organizations such as the European Union or World Trade Organization require their member states to comply with them.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright#International_copyri...

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by nefitty on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:06PM (#29290869)
I tried to understand what you said but it ends up indecipherable like a koan. In this case, this koan confers a monetary benefit to the self-appointed Zen Masters of crypto. For only a few dollars the followers get a little sticker that says "Enlightened".
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:04PM (#29291401)
Concretely there are a variety of metaverse projects which only allow you to spawn the item if you own the (creator sanctioned) NFT.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:12PM (#29291457)
It’s perfectly fair to say that NFTs work as an in-game currency and nothing more.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Saturday November 20, 2021 @04:25PM (#29291983)
If you presume that we will in large part be continually living in a video game of varying levels of immersion relatively soon then this becomes something fairly significant.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:50PM (#29292530)
I partially agree with this. But then why all the bullshit? Why don’t people just come out and say that it’s all about in-game items for the metaverse rather than all the talk about owning media?

Nothing suggests that existing NFTs will be relevant in that world even if the technology is.

It’s also not obvious that a distributed ledger has an advantage over a centralized one.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @06:57PM (#29313065)
I think whenever you see someone say "owning media" you should re-write it in your brain as "owning the only author-signed copy of media" - that's probably the most effective rewrite that maximizes the utility of analogy.

The value of the distributed ledger is rooted in a theory: that it will be, in the long term, the most durable and agreed upon place to look to for arbitrary third parties to decide whose artist's signature is legitimate.

The thing that suggests the NFTs of the world today will be relevant in that future world is pretty simple: take any piece of art where the artist involved has publicly sanctioned an NFT for it, and ask the question if the signature of that artist on that work will theoretically be something valued by society in the future. (Grounded by the well placed assumption that this is truly non-fungible - the artist can't even reneg on this, since history will record this was the original.) The number of times you can affirm this as a "yes" should increase the weight you put on the hypothesis today's NFTs will be valuable in the future.

It's worth noting: these two hypotheses are decoupled. The blockchain has already been written. So even if the idea of an NFT burns out so much that future artists do not make them anymore, this doesn't necessarily mean the NFTs that exist today will not be valuable or recognized. They are in the public record, and those who control the wallets they are assigned to will always be able to prove they are the owners of them, even if the chains they are on stop adding new blocks in the future.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Monday November 22, 2021 @07:57PM (#29313450)
NFTs are not signatures on works of art. The media is not signed by the NFT.

A signed artwork is more valuable than an unsigned artwork.

However NFTs do not create signed artworks. The artwork remains the same.

The NFT is just a receipt for someone paying money to someone else, who in some cases is linked to the an artist.

Is that valuable? Maybe. I concede that a bill of sale from some point along the chain of ownership of ‘the last supper’ might have value to some kind of collector.

But, an NFT is not equivalent even to the bill of sale.

If you have the bill of sale, you have a unique historical item, whereas the NFT is on the public blockchain where everyone can see it and copy of it, so even that doesn’t have any scarcity.

Both the media and the NFT are infinitely copyable.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by gfodor on Monday November 22, 2021 @09:37PM (#29314031)
You seem determined to think with analogies. If my attempt above didn’t help you understand why people are paying tons of money for these things, I’m afraid I’ve run out of ways to help.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by zepto on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:51PM (#29324569)
> The value of the distributed ledger is rooted in a theory

A theory which many people disagree with.

> You seem determined to think with analogies.

So do you.

An NFT is not a signature on a piece of art. You are trying to convince us that an NFT is analogous to a signature on a piece of art.

Whether the analogies of the crypto community hold is what is being debated here.

I assume you are aware that NFTs are not actually signatures on physical artworks.

> If my attempt above didn’t help you understand why people are paying tons of money for these things,

I’m sure you wouldn’t be claiming that people never pay money for things that later turn out not to be valuable.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by nefitty on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:34PM (#29292445)
Zuckerberg's moves make sense in this context. NFT's make sense in it as well.

I don't feel compelled to play video games, and I don't feel interested in joining an AR metaverse. That might just be personal shortcoming clouding my expectations of Web3...