Except that they simply haven’t.
Try taking someone’s house from them. You’ll find that it’s not just semantics that defines ownership.
Try copying the artwork pointed to by an NFT. You’ll find the NFT doesn’t stop you.
> If at this point you are trying to argue semantics when most of the community has a pretty intuitive sense of what exactly "owning an NFT" means, it seems a bit pointless.
I agree that it’s pointless to argue with people who think “owning an NFT” has any relationship to owning the artwork itself. It’s ok if people want to be part of a community who believe that together.
If you feel secure as a member of that community, don’t let the rest of us perturb you.
Have you considered that most people are not in fact part of that community, and that discussion of this point is quite relevant to anyone who hasn’t already committed themself to this belief?
Wrong.
> I think I make it pretty clear when it gets to more detail that the NFT is the thing you own.
Yes, you contradict yourself.
> Further, I make it clear exactly what rights you and others have over the media, which is basically none.
Yes, which is not what you say in the parts I quoted - let’s remind ourselves:
> Just like a deed conveys ownership of a house at some address, the token conveys ownership of that media.
This is a common pattern in writing about this subject, which is why I point this out. It’s a standard Motte and Bailey technique, which is a dishonest form of persuasive writing.
This is just a lie. The token doesn’t convey ownership of then media. There is no rough understanding by which this is true.
> I make it clear exactly what rights you and others have over the media, which is basically none.
Which you acknowledge here.
This isn’t a matter of exact details that aren’t important to a buyer.
If you tell someone that an NFT conveys ownership of the media, you are lying to them and participating in a con.
The fact that you later contradict that statement, doesn’t change the fact that you lied.
The debate around this is pretty somewhat tiresome. Yes, you have to buy into the believe that the token represents the media, but it's as good a definition as any because all ways we talk colloquially about "owning" a JPEG are simply not the same as owning a chair.
- Copyright is just a set of limited legal rights granted to someone temporarily by certain jurisdictions. It's not the same thing as owning something, which is why we were laughing at the "you wouldn't steal a car" ads in the 2000s.
- Actual ownership means having access to a copy of the bytes, which is not perceived as meaningful, and only valuable to the extend that access is otherwise arbitrarily restricted.
- You can choose to believe in the artificial scarcity of a certificate of ownership.
This is fine. There is no problem with a club of people who choose to play a game in which they agree that a token has a particular meaning.
The rest of us can point out that it doesn’t mean the same thing outside that club of believers.
https://meebits.larvalabs.com/meebits/termsandconditions
And note you don’t own the media and that what owning the NFT means can change.
Not really sure what point you are trying to make. With Meebits, you don’t own anything other than the token itself.
There is no thing that another person can do regarding a piece of art backed by an NFT that you own that will cause state employees with guns to show up to stop them.
For example, I can offer a free milkshake to anyone who parks in my parking lot in a yellow car.
Then yellow car isn’t doing anything in this situation, I am, and if I can always change my mind.
Then same is true with cryptovoxels and NFTs.
The point is if 1M people all agreed to give a free milkshake to people who parked in your parking lot, the parking lot is pretty important.
There are paving stones on which a million people walk each year. They are of no more importance than a parking lot in which a particular trade promotion takes place.
BS. That’s the marketing excuse. The real value is only in the fact that you can potentially sell it to a greater fool who will buy for more so you won’t be the one holding the bag. It’s the new tulip mania!
> Just like a deed conveys ownership of a house at some address, the token conveys ownership of that media.
Again, if you don't like specific wording, I invite you to write a better explanation for regular folks which is simultaneously perfectly accurate in every sense in every phrase and word you use.
Not really. The original document contained an outright lie which have now removed because it was exposed.
If you didn’t accept it was a lie, you wouldn’t have removed it.
This has nothing to do with imperfect accuracy. It has to do with you writing an outright falsehood.
The idea that a lie stops being a lie because of the number of words you say later is obviously absurd.
As I have pointed out this is a motte and Bailey fallacy.
Also, it’s still a completely misleading statement. The change to ‘similar to’ doesn’t make it true. It still isn’t true, only now you have some wiggle room to claim it’s not a lie.
You are still trying to misleading people into thinking that NFTs confer ownership of the media.
Similarly, this community has agreed that a contract written in a certain form, with the requisite signatures and registrations, conveys ownership of a piece of art. Subject, again, to caveats and rules and fine print.
If at this point you are trying to argue semantics when most of the community has a pretty intuitive sense of what exactly "owning an NFT" means, it seems a bit pointless.