The fee is for: - access to install base and customer relationship - funds development of the platform, SDK, and tools - funds development of the store - funds operation of the store - profit for the company - last and least: payment processing
Could those things be funded differently? Yes... but it would require a radical restructuring of the way mobile platforms work that would not be favorable to startups or independents. It would also lead to massive fracturing of the customer relationship, lower trust, and ultimately shrink the total dollars spent on software (though the big players would make more money). People trust Apple or Google with their credit card. They know the platform requires all subscriptions show up in one place and they don't need to call and argue with a sales rep to cancel. Be prepared for all of that to disappear when it becomes a free-for-all. Stop pretending this kind of "freedom" is completely free of consequences even for those who don't take advantage of that "freedom".
<<Google Play Had a Profit of $8.5 Billion in 2019 With Margins of 62 Percent. According to court filings unsealed>>
https://www.thurrott.com/mobile/android/254978/google-play-h...
So, no, with indecent margins like that, you can't justify them using their monopoly to racket app developers with fees that are unrelated to the usage of the service.
Imagine if everyone was doing the same in real life, that would look absurd:
- your power utility provider requiring that you pay to them 10% of your business income because you use electricity somehow and they have costs and need to do profit
- the postal service requiring you to pay 15% of the bills you send by email through their online service or 10% of the bills you send by any other provider just because you benefit from receiving standard letters in your home mailbox. Just because they have costs and they need to do fat profits.
- Ikea forcing you to give them 11% on your business incomes because you use a desk and a chair that you bought there in your office. For the same reasons...
You know that high margins are someone else's opportunity? Surely someone else will build an alternative that undercuts Android.
Ah, you say there's a huge moat? Worth billions if not trillions of dollars? Huge market recognition? Agreements with huge companies? Regulations and government approvals all over the world? Years and years of development by thousands of developers?
On top of that there's an oligopoly in place by companies already convicted of such agreements for other issues (see the anti-poaching agreement from a decade back)? What? Like a cartel that probably fixes prices?
They very well can make these stipulations and expect you to pay them. They have every right to go "uh we need 100% of your business profit if you want to buy IKEA furniture". You have every right not to do that due to the unreasonable payment terms. You'll need to ask your lawmakers to fix this if you think it's unjust and you're being forced against your will to oblige.
This is the rent seeking that everybody is objecting to.
> funds development of the platform, SDK, and tools
The platform is open source. So if you want to use someone else's tools then you shouldn't have to pay this part, right?
> funds development of the store - funds operation of the store
The cost of providing this is negligible. Many alternative stores and repositories do it for free. It accounts for zero percent of the cost of anything.
> profit for the company
Profit isn't a separate thing. The cost of payment processing already includes the profit of the payment processor etc.
> last and least: payment processing
Which is the only thing left, so if you're using someone else as payment processor...
It's the "access to install base and customer relationship" that they're really sticking it to you for, and that's the illegitimate one.
> The platform is open source. So if you want to use someone else's tools then you shouldn't have to pay this part, right?
The platform here includes "android", so yes if you aren't using Android you probably don't need to pay to support Android development. It's not clear here, but do you think "open source" somehow means "doesn't require funding to develop"?
> The cost of providing this is negligible. Many alternative stores and repositories do it for free.
Few/none of those provide app review and various anti-malware stuff. You can argue that these have negative value, but they absolutely have non-negligible costs.
Also I don't think any alternative stores support canarying/progressive rollouts of new versions, which is useful for developers and a nontrivial to support for other stores.
You have a career in comedy if you think that the Play Store's definition of canary rollouts is good. Hell, the entire Play Console is probably one of the most hated piece of software by android devs because of how terrible it is, with constant changes, horrible performance, stupid requirements and non-working options.
Yes, it is true, that there are other stores - like Samsung has it's own store on Android, so technically there is a choice of stores. Apparently Google would not fight store wars with the producers of hardware... but there is nothing that prevents them to disable any other stores by any other means - by simply sabotaging their app.
The issue here with Google Play is that it assumes, that Google Play has monopoly of money transactions for that publisher outside of Play store, even if the app has a choice to receive money through oher means - crypto, Paypal or cards. Same issue is with Apple store - they did not wanted to allow to transact money in Epic store(and wanted their cut on those), where you could make transactions in the Epic website from your card.
Android is Open Source, Google Play & Google Play Services are not. Developers are free to build Android apps that don't use anything related to Google Play.
Google could charge accordingly without any "radical restructuring".
When you are buying a phone, you also pay price that includes price for OS of the phone, that includes development costs of SDK and development tools. Some of the phones nowadays has a choice to BUY and install different OS, that comes with different stores.
Unlike your assumption, payment processing is completelly different ecosystem and Apple is simply using monopoly on iPhones and not letting other stores on their hardware and software. Alphabet does not produce phones... so IMO it is acting worse, that it makes up these stupid tales. This is one of the reasons why I am switching my phone from Android, because that is MY phone, that I paid for! Besides, Android still snoops your data without your consent and I'm not even paid for that data!
Besides, the only concern about payment processing that YOU should have is not development costs(they can't be that HUGE...), but if your payment processing is safe and protected!!! That is the only costs, that stores should have - to ensure protection of those many many transactions, where maintenance and development costs are miniscule and to be even considered is laughable topic.
With the race to the bottom on cheap Android phones, it's obvious that "profit from the device only" is insanely low.
> Some of the phones nowadays has a choice to BUY and install different OS, that comes with different stores.
Just pointing out that this seemingly directly contradicts your line before it. If some phones can install a different OS and come with a different store, why should the phone profit margin go towards developing the SDK and development tools?
""" Android & the Google Play Store: The free Android operating system enables hardware manufacturers to build a wide range of devices at different price points that gives users unprecedented choice. And the Google Play Store delivers the world's largest selection of apps and games, available in over 190 countries with personalized recommendations and easy discovery of high-quality apps.
New Android platforms: We build platforms for new form factors such as Auto and TV to help developers increase their reach in new ways.
Security: Consumers trust Android and Google Play because of its security, the reviews of apps to ensure they comply with policies around safety and privacy, and with automated security of Google Play Protect that scans over 100 billion apps per day.
App distribution: Developers can instantly reach over three billion Android users with the ability to optimize delivery by device and functionality and provide ongoing updates.
Developer tools: Developers can run experiments, beta test, optimize store listings, analyze performance, and more. """
The penalty for noncompliance is so low because the money is so huge, and nobody will go to jail, that they are going to pull every stunt in the book until someone has the guts to start shutting these companies down. By claiming they are complying technically, while obviously not, they force the government to follow up the legislation with a regulatory action, which then they can tie up in the courts for years.
If they complied with the law properly now, other countries would quickly follow suit. But if they can tie up the attempt for a number of years, they can all pad out their retirement funds before all the litigation is over and duck out before the stocks crash.
It's not like we don't know how to do this stuff, we just don't invest enough in it.
Another USA company tried to do that as well. They called their OS "Windows Phone" and it withered and died because a fractured support for software people care about doesn't make a useful device.
A Chinese company tried to do that as well. They now again ship Google Services next to their own Huawei services in Europe because without software support, their smart devices weren't useful to users either.
There are also plenty of other mobile phone OS, that are not compatible with every phone and that is the main issue why they are not widespread. Phone that I own is supported not only by Android(and Android forks), but also couple of other mobile phone OS. The trend is that in future there will be more choices for OS, that might satisfy those users, that are currently not happy about Android, but have no other choices at the moment.
There are at least 10 other mobile OS choices - most of them are based on Linux, but current share of those is ~0,1% out of ~6 billion of phones. In total numbers that is only 6 million devices. 6 million device market is a significant number for any company, not to mention, that this number is only playground compared to 1000x larger world market of mobile phones.
Therefore, logically, Apple should be the one paying app developers 30% of their revenue. Witout them iPhone would be an overpriced paperweight.
South Korea is a small market. The US company is famous for mismanaging its mobile operating systems for more than 2 decades.
The Chinese company didn't "try" to do that, it was forced to. But guess what, in China, where most external apps are banned, there's an entire, completely separate ecosystem.
You do need a combination of skill and critical mass. I don't expect South Korea to achieve this, but for example if there's a bigger alliance of say, South Korea, the EU, etc., where they put resources into encouraging an OS based on open standards, that starts to look feasible.
App developers will need support, but they can port their apps. Especially since this OS doesn't need to start from scratch, it can be based on AOSP.
That's probably the biggest thing Google/Apple are afraid of this point, that a fully open/interoperable mobile OS is somehow enforced. They either have to open up their OSes to be in key markets or they're forced to let someone else create that OS.
All these governments don't have an issue with the code, they have issues with project governance.
The EU has already fined Google, South Korea is adding these new rules, I think even the US is thinking about some regulation, let's see what happens in a few years.
iPhone has branded itself as status symbol that people are rich and can pay and maintain lifestyle that includes ipHone - Androids, well - it is replacable and will be eventually.
So you are saying Google / Apple are above the law, capitalism is more important than democracy?
Where does this end? They might as well start acting as mafia, resort to raketeering and break you legs if you don't show up for work.
Is there any other reason i missed?
they do? then why does my phone have a uninstallable 'galaxy store' app that Samsung decide to fill my limited storage with.
What other manufacturers can't do is fragment the ecosystem and prevent people from also using Play Store.
Time to split app distribution from OS. Making it mandatory to allow other stores, with first class user experience, and not set their as default one.
Yup, ecosystem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braeburn_Capital
For those that don't understand what that is, Apple's products, especially the App Store, have insane profit margins. Apple's profits are so high that they don't know what to do with the money so they started their own investment fund.
> In October 2012, CNET reported that Braeburn had US$117.2 billion under management, making it "the world's biggest hedge fund."
That was in 2012. Since then they've almost tripled the amount of Apple money that they manage.
So we should expect companies to only profit to a point of net-zero? Or can you call out a percentage of revenue that is acceptable?
Just as people who are too rich distort democracy.
On the more practical side, it's kinda hard to make yours work. You probably don't want to charge a popular free app like Wikipedia the same as an app like Netflix.
First of all it is now possible to make tax declarations yourself without going through a customs agent. Previously if you bought something like a dashcam from AliExpress you'd need to pay VAT and a "processing fee" to the agent (i.e. the post office) which in total would come to around the same price as you paid the seller. It's still somewhat complicated to do yourself, but the post office here introduced their own electronic declaration system. If you choose to use their system it's €3, but if you choose to do it yourself you need to pay a "parcel handling fee" of €3.
Additionally the regulations require sellers sending goods to the EU to charge VAT at the time of purchase. So everything you buy from AliExpress now is sold with VAT (but prices are still shown without). The post office also introduced a €1 handling fee for these parcels - that they don't need to do anything with other than deliver them.
https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/merchant-fees#statemen...
In the US, PayPal is a 4.99% + fixed (US: $0.09).
> We recognize, however, that developers will incur costs to support their billing system, so when a user selects alternative billing, we will reduce the developer’s service fee by 4%. For example, for the vast majority of developers who pay 15% for transactions through Google Play's billing system, their service fee for transactions through the alternate billing system would be 11%.
You have to pay a 11% fee for using someone else's billing system when buying an in-app purchase, if that app was downloaded from the Play store?