News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by martin_drapeau on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:00AM (#29253906)
Legos are truly a marvel of engineering in terms of design, robustness and longevity. Dimensions are constant across time and parts last forever. Legos 40 years ago work well with today's pieces.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by real-dino on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:04AM (#29254815)
You think Lego are incredible, check out Gundam Plastic Models. They have runner's made of multiple colours, and ready assembled hinges that are cast in a single injection mold.

The RG models in particular are insane!

Check out this video of Adam Savage making one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xfmD1yYqP6k

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by ragebol on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:07AM (#29263560)
There's a comment on YouTube explaining how the ready assembled hinges are made:

> Michael Karnesis > 1 month ago > I'm coming here way after the fact even though I missed the boat on the first wave of comments because nobody has explained the leg inner frame correctly.

> The leg inner frame is molded in sequence in ABS plastic, which is semi-crystaline and only bonds to itself. The second plastic is in Polypropylene which is fully crystalline and also only bonds to itself. This creates working joints without having to have radically different thermoset temperatures because the two plastics chosen simply don't cling to each other. No additional coating of release agent is required at all, it just uses the plastics' innate properties.

That's awesome!

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by real-dino on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:21AM (#29263949)
They have to transfer the plastic between the two molds though? Any differences at all would cause problems. It's not like they can use release pins like the coloured runners?
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by ragebol on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:24AM (#29266461)
I know nearly nothing about injection molding, but my understanding was that the part stays in the same mold but they inject a different plastic to fill a different cavity.

But I don't know enough about this process, by a large margin. I didn't even know co-molding was a thing.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by 420official on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @02:30PM (#29257756)
He notices one of the hinges at around 6 minutes
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by _carbyau_ on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @07:53PM (#29260877)
I built a $15 snap together beginner gundam model.

The build time doubled as I was marveling at the precision involved and the thought put into the design and instructions.

I can only imagine what the larger "perfect grade" stuff is like.

My kid impatiently wanted his robot already...

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by djstein on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @01:50PM (#29257207)
thanks for the video link that was really cool
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by thrower123 on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:05AM (#29253986)
Quality on vintage Lego is usually better than what you buy today. They claim they haven't made many changes to the process, but a yardsale batch of Lego usually has less color abnormalities (aside from the age yellowing) and brittleness than a box right off the store shelf.

Perhaps QA isn't as rigorous anymore.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by handrous on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:04AM (#29254821)
IIRC they switched to some kind of biodegradable plastic a few years back. I'm pretty sure they're softer, but it might be in my head.

What'd help way more with waste is if they would stop making like 75% of the part count of modern sets short 1x1s and other really tiny—often flat-topped, because the box photo mustn't display any nubs, I guess—pieces. If my kids take some legos outside, those are what get lost permanently. I get them to pick up what I can, and make a pass myself for any they missed, because as toys go they're gold, but some of those tiny pieces are for-sure buried in my yard.

That'd also make the sets more playable—repairing play-induced damage on a modern set is hell because of the fiddly little constructions they use, and there are few exposed nubs to connect things to for expanding/customizing/having-minifigs-stand-on-it, without tearing off a bunch of pieces.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by travisgriggs on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:37AM (#29255278)
I'm personally fine with the term nubs and know exactly what you mean.

In some AFOL circles, they'll jump down your throat for not using the "correct" term "stud". The canonical term for the "flat-topped" is tile.

My personal gripe is just the explosion of special purpose pieces that Lego vends today. Less is more Lego.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by tspike on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @04:24PM (#29259008)
> My personal gripe is just the explosion of special purpose pieces that Lego vends today. Less is more Lego.

I've personally been amazed at the possibilities that seemingly single-purpose parts open up in the hands of a skilled builder.

One example is the "stud shooter" -- a utensil for minifigures to shoot out 1x1 round plates. Check out what these folks did with it:

https://www.newelementary.com/2020/05/stud-shooter-15391%20-...

New Elementary is a gold mine for creative uses for "specialized" parts.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by lostlogin on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @04:37PM (#29259156)
> I've personally been amazed at the possibilities that seemingly single-purpose parts open up in the hands of a skilled builder.

And this is great, but when you have small children who just want to join things together, a lot of the modern sets have a fairly limited ability to customise.

It’s frustrating. They sell plenty of simple sets, it’s just so attractive to buy the fancy ones recreating some movie.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by greyhair on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:25AM (#29266467)
My son did exactly that with all his 'specialized' pieces. The way he repurposed those in his own designs used to crack me up, and he was doing that when he was only eight or ten years old. The imagination didn't fixate on what the part was originally used for, he only saw it as a raw shape to serve some purpose.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by icecap12 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @12:46AM (#29262337)
Wow - amazing link. Thanks!
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by handrous on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:45AM (#29255400)
Ah, cool, thanks for the corrections. Yeah, I'm not into online lego fandom enough to know the correct terms—I just played with them for probably low-thousands of hours as a kid.

I do like how many bigger modern sets come with a "brick tool". I always wanted one as a kid when, but they were a separate purchase and I never wanted one bad enough for it to make my wishlists, over more sets. Even the $80+ sets (in 80s/90s dollars!) back then didn't come with them. They are handy.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by genocidicbunny on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:42PM (#29273560)
> My personal gripe is just the explosion of special purpose pieces that Lego vends today. Less is more Lego.

Lego has significantly reduced the number of special purpose pieces it uses since the 90's. Back then, the number of specialized one-off pieces Lego was using helped nearly sink the company. That's partially responsible for the increase in the number of small parts they use now -- it allows them to recreate some of the intricacy you could have with an equivalent larger piece.

A lot of the weird/specialized pieces Lego puts out these days are minifigure-related in some way.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by dharmab on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:34AM (#29255233)
The new bioplastic is only used on flexible parts like vegetation. Most bricks are still made from ABS (although they're continuing to prototype other plastics)
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by tspike on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @04:06PM (#29258835)
It's also not biodegradable; it's chemically identical to the polyethylene used before. It's only the process and materials sourcing that changed.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by obmelvin on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:25PM (#29255938)
Hey, random question from someone who isn't a parent, do you have any read on whether home 3D printed legos are cool to kids? I guess it's hard to match the look and 3D print the majority of your pieces while buying special boxed sets that your child wants.

I walked past a lot of Legos last week and I was thinking "these are very cool, but wow my parents spent so much money on legos". I also used to paint some of the Games Workshop Warhammer figurines in my teens. If I ever had the urge to get back into something like Legos or figurines later in life, I think I'd definitely go the 3D printing route.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by jazzyjackson on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @01:07PM (#29256551)
3D printing, at least typical FDM, does not have near the tolerances required to snap onto the real bricks, but I found that the “LEGO technics” side of things (with the pegs and holes) is much more forgiving since the real lego pegs are flexible, they can snap into rigid 3D printed parts once you get the scale right.

Years ago I was teaching a robotics class where I asked the kids to customize their robots’ faces by drawing new parts like mustaches and eyebrows with markers, and then used Inkscape and Tinkercad to model the parts in 3D. If you scroll down to the last pics in my blog you can see the result: https://coltenj.com/learning-with-social-emotional-robots/

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by sokoloff on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @06:31PM (#29260272)
It doesn’t have the tolerances to create bricks that play at all like real Lego, but it’s not that hard to make parts that will snap onto real bricks or to offer studs onto which the real parts can snap.

I’ve made many a custom kids’ name tags as parts that can plug into Lego bricks. No one thinks they plug as nicely, but Lego doesn’t have the kids’ names either, so…

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by animal531 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @11:14AM (#29267097)
This is a good answer. As a kid there were always ideas that I wanted to build, but I would for example not be able to construct the shape required in the working space that I had.

For example pieces like angle switchers, mixing holes for axles with other pieces, parts that allow things to slide etc.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by handrous on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:55PM (#29256403)
1) Seconding used as an option from the other post. That's great.

2) Big Buckets of legos still exist and are pretty cheap, actually.

3) Kids may like the sets on the shelf but my kids have treated them like puzzles: they're really excited when they get them and put them together once, play with them barely if at all, then as soon as they get a little messed up, just destroy them and go back to making whatever, and never put them together again. I've seen very few modern sets (but there are a few!) that look like they'd support the play-style I had as a kid. Even the "big" sets with huge part counts are tiny compared to large 90s sets, and have rooms and such that are almost too small even for kid-hands to play in, plus the aforementioned problems with so many of the pieces being tiny, so much of the construction being really fiddly (relying on all those tiny pieces) rather than straightforward so it's hard to fix if part of it gets broken, or you deliberately disassemble part of it for some reason. Few exposed studs plus the fiddly-construction thing makes expansion/customization and "kit-bashing" tougher, which was a big part of what I did. I suppose the modern ones appeal really well to kids who like to assemble lego sets, then display them, rather than playing with them. I knew a few kids like when I was a kid.

I don't know whether 3d printed lego replacements are any good.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by dharmab on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:36PM (#29256098)
Look into bulk used LEGOs from online stores, it's probably cheaper than printing your own and helps reuse existing plastic parts.

3D printing is awesome for figurines! Although they're banned at official Games Workshop events, it's one of the best ways to casually play 40K IMO.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by obmelvin on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:57PM (#29270432)
Fair point about reusing the existing legos!

Great to hear that about 40k - I'm fine avoiding the official events, I mostly enjoyed the painting and exploring the universe with my friend. Would love to have a full army in the future without having to pay a few grand! [I know you can buy used armies online, but then you don't get to put it together!]

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by svachalek on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:46PM (#29256268)
3D printing is great for a lot of little plastic toys but it also teaches you about the mechanical perfection that is Lego. Even the cheap offbrand bricks probably fit more consistently than what you can print.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by choonway on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:16PM (#29261921)
not exactly, i have been printing FFF parts with a tolerance of 50 microns with a .25mm nozzle. it all has to do with part design and quality filament.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by jkestner on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:10PM (#29261596)
When my 6yo saw the custom jetpack for figurines I made on an SLA printer, his eyes got wide. I think it was half because it was a piece he had only imagined, and half because he thought now he could have all the Lego he wanted for free. Ultimately his imagination does a lot of the work so custom parts aren’t that important. But the SLA printer ($200 AnyCubic) can make snappable bricks.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by vanviegen on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:44AM (#29254559)
Based on my old Lego from the mid eighties, I have a different experience. The old bricks now fit together rather loosely, compared to my children's brand new Lego. Most of the colors are also not what they used to be, besides having been stored in an UV-free environment most of the time.

No telling what the new bricks will be like in 35 years of course.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by brianpaul on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:01AM (#29254774)
I concur. My childhood LEGO from 1980-ish (now my son's) have noticeable color and fit variation. Still usable, but definitely not as nice as the new stuff.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by thrower123 on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:45AM (#29255397)
A thing I see a lot in the new bricks is that the color isn't true all the way through a brick. It's almost like a gradient, where the dye wasn't mixed into the base white ABS plastic very well
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by animal531 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @11:16AM (#29267117)
I'd imagine that after 10 years of plugging and unplugging, washing in random liquids, biting on them to get them loose etc., folding characters legs in and out until they become floppy any set would be a bit run down.

But I'm sure tolerances today are higher than ever before.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by incanus77 on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:26AM (#29255134)
Same here, some going back to the late 70s.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by bookofjoe on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:31AM (#29255197)
They will be holograms. We will be too.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by dolmen on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:08AM (#29254026)
Or just that QA didn't scale with multiple factories around the world?
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by philk10 on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:29AM (#29254357)
or QA notices but is told it's not a problem to be fixed
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by creaturemachine on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:54PM (#29256375)
Modern mini-figures from the past 10 yrs or so develop cracks in the arms where the hand fits, making them fall apart very easily. None of my old ones from the 80/90's develop them. Large blocks have been modified to use less material, so thinner walls and different structures to gain back the rigidity. They may not have change the process, but it feels like materials certainly have.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by modeless on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:39AM (#29254491)
On the other hand, vintage Legos contain cadmium.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by JeanSebTr on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @01:49PM (#29257187)
Quite an alarming claim!

Looks like regarding to Cadmium, "vintage" means up to mid-to-late 1980s [0]

> Apparently The [Lego] has been aware of this concern for at least three decades (hence the switch to Cadmium free plastic colorants sometime in the mid-to-late 1980s)

[0] https://tamararubin.com/2019/05/vintage-1970s-legos-test-pos...

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by tejohnso on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @10:57PM (#29261828)
Maybe a good time to ask...what do you actually do with lego bricks once you've built whatever is on the box? I have a terrible imagination, and I find the replayability factor abysmal with these kits. I'm sure there are people who can take a box of 500+ random pieces and have fun, and I wish I could as well. These things just never clicked for me.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by greyhair on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:20AM (#29266407)
When my son was really interested in Lego, he built each kit exactly once, admired it for a couple days, then immediately took it back apart, and put all the pieces into one giant bin.

After that, he was always building stuff from his own imagination, using combinations from various kits. He and his older sister used to film short stop animations with the things he built. It was crazy.

The people that bought him kits as gifts wanted to see the finished kits when they visited, and he could never quite understand why, when it was so much more fun to just play with the pieces.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by animal531 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @11:12AM (#29267062)
When I was a kid I would built the kit when I got it. After playing with it (e.g. as a car, house, helicopter or whatever) then I'd take it apart and build my own things (houses, towns, spaceships etc).

Sometimes they'd be static, or other times I'd try to use the pieces in a way they weren't intended, for example to create a sliding gate that a motorcycle could drive through (based on a tv show at the time) etc.

Then once a year during our big December holiday I would sort all my Lego and then rebuild all the original kits and play with them again.

I only ever lost 1 piece of Lego, a flat red 4x1 which I accidentally swallowed (which was funny because I really struggle with taking medications). Forever after my fire truck had a missing side piece.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by prawn on Sunday November 21, 2021 @11:49PM (#29302874)
I've found the 3-in-1 Creator kits can provide more play opportunities for kids.

My 9yo son will regularly dismantle and rebuild sets, but also make random things. Sometimes if we're playing together, we start with a 4x4 plate and make micro worlds with various themes - a snow scene, lair with lavafall, space tower, forest setting. Or we pick a colour scheme and each make little robots or mechs. Or make an alien in each colour.

A fun game we tried recently was to isolate all the pieces from a set. Then I was blindfolded and my son faced away from me with the instructions and had to describe the instructions/pieces well enough for me to make the set. Good team building game. Yet to try reversing the roles.

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by jedimastert on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @11:09PM (#29261888)
There's two directions you can go: 1) you could just glue the pieces together and keep it as a model. This can also apply to models you find online.

2) you can sort and sell or give them to someone who will enjoy them. Sourcing sorted pieces is actually a big function of the used market.

It's perfectly acceptable to not enjoy a kind of toy. To each there own. I also tend to struggle with open-world games if there isn't some sort of goals set up

Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by aksss on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:52AM (#29263126)
We had thousands of pooled pieces between my set of friends when young and had whole worlds we constructed. Vehicles, ships, spacecraft, cities, fortresses, whole dramas. Can’t do that anymore, but I think programming satisfies similar imaginative creativity. I’ve recently started to integrate the physical work back in to this world via electronics and having a blast with it.
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by Daneel_ on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:09AM (#29262865)
I build a lot of technic models that have functions. I like to both improve and motorise them, or use them as a base to make a model closer to something I want. I like truck cranes and 4WD/trial trucks the most
Re:Scan of the Month: Lego Minifigures by wingerlang on Thursday November 18, 2021 @12:41AM (#29262313)
I have one random lego knock off item on my shelf, it's a monkey. I don't particularly like legos, or monkeys for that matter, but I keep it because it was pretty fun to build it and it reminds me of that.

Seems like you could amplify this by about a million with a set that is both intricate and of a subject you are really into.

Or disassemble it and make new stuff. As a kid we never had sets, it was all in a big pile.