News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by photochemsyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @01:54PM (#29219511)
The US record in Afghanistan is arguably even more ridiculous (and psychotic) than in Iraq. We went in with a pretty good justification (Taliban refusal to hand over Osama bin Laden for his central role in 9/11 terrorism) - although to be honest, the argument for doing the regime change op in Saudi Arabia was far more robust, as members of the Saudi government aided the hijackers and Saudi Royal family members were a key funding source.

Everything since then has been ridiculous. Getting in bed with heroin-shipping warlords because they were anti-Taliban? Not that the Taliban got over $100 million from the USA in 1999-2001 for opium poppy eradication efforts, which were quite successful, although TAPI pipeline talks didn't go as well in this period.

The whole 'Special Forces' fetishization is also pretty ridiculous. The best of the best of the best, la-dee-dah. Lots of nightime raids, which only pissed off the local population and made them quite willing to hand over power to the Taliban without a fight this year. Didn't 'US leaders' learn that from Vietnam? If the locals all hate you they're not going to support your remotely installed puppet government.

Oh, and the "Afghan Army Training Program" - at a cost of something like $10 billion to train and equip 350,000 Afghan Army members who'd be the nucleus of the new independent government... all that cash just went into Dubai bank accounts, didn't it? Or McMansions in Kabul. Gross blatant corruption (and the 'infrastructure projects' oh god... for a million bucks you get a chain of ten subcontractors backed up by one guy digging a ditch with a worn-out shovel... get used to it, that's coming here now).

American foreign policy in the 21st century - what an absolute disaster. Reminiscent of say, France and Britain in the Middle East from oh 1945-1954. Similar long-term results are to be expected.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by P-ala-din on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:45PM (#29219979)
> Taliban refusal to hand over Osama bin Laden for his central role in 9/11 terrorism

If we put in mind what we know post hoc about the torture and inhumane interrogation techniques used in both Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, wouldn't you agree that it's reasonable to assume that there was a high risk of torture? and isn't torture a well-accepted reason to block extradition.

In fact, let's take it even a step further in light of the fabrication of evidence seen in Iraq. The general atmosphere of hate at the time. not to mention that we now know that bin Laden not only was not tried but was thrown in a bag with the fish. How can we be so sure that he would have had received a fair trial? How would you even find an unbiased jury[1]?

Do we deem it ok to extradite someone to a place with a high risk of torture and unfair trial?

[1] - this is a rhetorical question but I'm actually curious how would one find such a jury that hasn't already made its mind?

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by midasuni on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:41PM (#29220458)
If that were the real situation then the taliban could have taken Bin Laden into custody and hand him over for trial in a neutral country (say the Netherlands alike Lockerbie trial, or somewhere like China or India)
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by boomboomsubban on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:11PM (#29220748)
The Taliban offered to cooperate in turning Bin Laden over to another country. The US refused.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by bettysdiagnose on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:08PM (#29221186)
That was after the bombing had already begun and it had to be a "country that wouldn't come under US pressure".

I don't see what's so unreasonable about handing him over to the US tbh.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by boomboomsubban on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:29PM (#29221358)
>country that wouldn't come under US pressure

Given the context of also asking for bombing to stop, that seems like they were trying to stop the US from using military pressure to force their will on Afghanistan. The deal wasn't even considered, who knows what they were actually trying to negotiate.

>I don't see what's so unreasonable about handing him over to the US tbh

History has now shown the US was willing to torture people associated with al Qaeda, and execute Bin Laden then desecrate his corpse. They were absolutely right to distrust the US there.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dd444fgdfg on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:37PM (#29222195)
Burial at sea. I'm not even convinced they killed him at the time.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by bettysdiagnose on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:35PM (#29222179)
Yeah and the Taliban were willing to protect the guy who committed one of the worst terrorist atrocities in memory. Funny how it's totally understandable according to you why the Taliban wouldn't trust America, but somehow America isn't afford the same understanding by people like you.... Utterly transparent from you I'm afraid.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by hiyer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:38PM (#29223010)
Pakistan was willing to protect him too (that's where he was found at the end) but the US didn't invade them. Why is that? Because Pakistan has nukes?
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by hunterb123 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:48PM (#29223829)
We should have imo. Possibly we didn't because of nukes, but not quite the argument though is it?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

I believe the above post wanted to drill down why it was hard for Afghanistan to give him over.

After that the Pakistan discussion can happen if energy exists.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by boomboomsubban on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:50PM (#29222287)
If Afghanistan trusted the US and the US proceeded to torture and execute Bin Laden, they would have no recourse. If the US trusted Afghanistan and Afghanistan proceeded to not cooperate then the US could then start the invasion.

Afghanistan wasn't more trustworthy, the amount of trust necessary was far lower.

I think that addresses your accusation. I barely understand what you consider "utterly transparent" in my comment.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by jay3ss on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:08PM (#29221185)
Do you have a source for this? Sounds like an interesting read
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by boomboomsubban on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:18PM (#29221252)
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by jay3ss on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:52PM (#29221931)
Thanks!
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by prepend on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:31PM (#29220376)
> and isn't torture a well-accepted reason to block extradition.

Maybe for blocking from the UK to US, but Afghanistan legally tortured/tortures so not sure why they would care about that regarding extradition.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by throwaway0a5e on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:53PM (#29222738)
>and isn't torture a well-accepted reason to block extradition.

When you rule the way Taliban did the idea that you're not extraditing someone because you're worried about them getting hooked up to a car battery or beaten with a rubber hose is laughable.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dumdumdumdum on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:13PM (#29219690)
> Taliban refusal to hand over Osama bin Laden for his central role in 9/11 terrorism

That's not entirely true. They wanted to negotiate his extradition. As any sovereign nation would.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/oct/14/afghanistan.te...

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by tuyguntn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:23PM (#29219791)
One more thing!

Person who tried to expose what is actually happening is now going to jail, right? I am talking about Julian Assange.

No one needs such "world police", who is trying to build a democracy in other countries, but failing on pillars of democracy by putting journalist to jail in home country.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by photochemsyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:35PM (#29219891)
That's one of the central reasons a regime change op in Saudi Arabia would have been more justified. I think the rational explanation is that Team Bush wanted war, but couldn't directly attack Iraq (the efforts to link Al Qaeda and the anthrax letters to Saddam were largely unsuccessful), so they went into Afghanistan instead.

The complete abandonment of 'nation-building' Afghanistan in 2002 as all efforts shifted to invading Iraq sort of supports this scenario.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by tuyguntn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:20PM (#29219759)
Exactly!

US have an excuse all the time, surprisingly, people who represent educated segment don't either want to look to other side, I remember Taliban tried to have a negotiation with US, they tried to get their voice heard in western media, but failed, because everyone was blind sided, no one wanted to hear them and US anyway launched attack, 20 years later, everything is even more fucked up over there.

Now we should be really worried if there are other extremist groups are training and planning another attack soon, this time everyone would know US don't have a justification and obviously will fail again. (I don't remember if US won any war recently? Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan all are in trouble, all of the wars are started wrongly)

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:30PM (#29219855)
Given the official statements of the Taliban (ie: that Osama Bin Laden didn't cause 9/11), what exactly is your proposal?

Taliban were protecting Bin Laden, period. Their official stance on the subject is clearly false, and they were willing to go to war to provide sanctuary to Bin Laden. The main worry was that any such delays at this point would give Bin Laden more room to get away (and Bin Laden did escape: all the way to Pakistan).

So if anything, we should have pursued Bin Laden even more vigorously back then. The Taliban were successful in buying enough time for him to hide with their false diplomacy.

We were at least successful in destroying the Al Qaeda training centers in Afghanistan (successfully located, blown up, and dismantled). Maybe these bases will return now that we've left Afghanistan, but we at least rendered them unable to train new terrorists for the last 20 years or so (and the new Taliban regime officially doesn't want to sanction any such training sites anymore. They've got an ISIS-K problem because of it too)

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by whakim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:42PM (#29221017)
> So if anything, we should have pursued Bin Laden even more vigorously back then. The Taliban were successful in buying enough time for him to hide with their false diplomacy.

The problem was, real intelligence on the whereabouts of Bin Laden and Al Qaida in general was extremely rare. It was the vigorousness with which we pursued Al Qaida that helped really poison the relationship with local Afghans. You had local elites claiming that their rivals were somehow related to Al Qaida, which usually resulted in innocent people being taken into custody, tortured and/or killed. You had some legitimate leads (but often on mid-level operatives at best) that resulted in extremely risky special forces operations in remote and treacherous terrain - often resulting in both US and civilian casualties. You do this enough and people hate you, you've got an insurgency.

> We were at least successful in destroying the Al Qaeda training centers in Afghanistan (successfully located, blown up, and dismantled).

Real "training centers" were something of a white whale for the military in Afghanistan. A lot of the supposed Al Qaida "training" was taking place in Kunar and Nuristan provinces, in particularly inhospitable terrain. We'd run military operations in these remote Nuristani valleys, US troops would die, we'd almost never capture anything of value, and local people would slowly get fed up with their husbands/children/etc. getting accidentally blown up in airstrikes.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:16PM (#29223632)
The Battle of Tora Bora, taking place in December 2001, has been subject to US Senate debate and discussion.

Bin Laden wrote his last will and testament on December 14, 2001, coinciding with the battle. The commandos who stormed Tora Bora were met with fierce resistance... not by Taliban, but by US Troops who refused to drop bigger bombs or deploy sufficient forces to attack the mountainous terrain.

--------

Donald Rumsfeld himself was worried that too many troops in Afghanistan at this time would fuel anti-American sentiment. Our problem was half-assing it in the early days of the war, when it mattered.

https://www.foreign.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/S%20Prt%20111-3...

When the Afghan forces complied with the Taliban / Al Qaeda cease fire, there was nothing for US troops to do anymore but let Bin Laden go. There wasn't sufficient strength to attack.

Perhaps intelligence on the ground was insufficient to allow a bigger military footprint at the time. But given the next 20 years of fighting and insurrection, a bit more force used in December 2001 could have prevented a lot of the force we used later.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by whakim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:46PM (#29223809)
Yes, we narrowly missed Bin Laden at Tora Bora in 2001. But "just send more troops" and "use bigger bombs" betrays a lack of familiarity with combat in the mountainous and inhospitable parts of Afghanistan. There's only so much air power can do in these places. It's incredibly hard to insert troops into places like these. You need to be able to medevac the WIA and KIA when things go wrong. There were no roads. In 2001, we were often literally using Russian maps. The history of these big mountain operations in Afghanistan is basically one of "let's send more troops/use bigger bombs/etc. etc." and it never got us anywhere. These operations pretty much always failed and we almost never got whoever we were going after.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:51AM (#29224191)
> The history of these big mountain operations in Afghanistan is basically one of "let's send more troops/use bigger bombs/etc. etc." and it never got us anywhere.

Except in the Battle of Tora Bora, where the commanders on the ground said that the 100 troops deployed to the area were insufficient to push into a heavily fortified mountainous region.

And they're right. If those 100 troops pushed in, they would have been massacred. More troops absolutely would have helped at that time.

Plenty of airplanes dropped plenty of bombs. But the use of air-deployed land mines was not authorized, which could have also helped (GATOR mines self-detonate after 15 days, to minimize risks to the local population after battle. They are further battery-operated, and are designed to run out of battery in case the self-detonation fails)

The gloves were still on. We could have easily used more force in that battle, but decided against it.

---------

Traditionally, you need to outnumber your opponent 3 to 1 if you wish to lay siege to an enemy in their home territory. At some point, just raw manpower is what you need.

As you said: we dropped plenty of bombs in that battle, but bombs aren't boots on the ground. You need people there to know if the bombs are in fact hitting their mark.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by whakim on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:20AM (#29227000)
You're getting fixated on the specifics of Tora Bora. Zoom out and look at the other big mountain operations over the following 15 years; you'll hear similar excuses "we needed this technology/we needed more men at this spot." With that context it's easy to see that Tora Bora probably wouldn't have been a success even with GATOR mines or more men.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:47AM (#29227998)
We are literally talking about a battle that scared Osama Bin Laden so much that he wrote his last will and testament during the battle.

Bin Laden thought he was going to die in that battle. We were close: just a little bit more would have done it.

Sure, we didn't know how close we were until afterwards. But when you consider what we did accomplish with just 100 boots on the ground + air support, it really makes you wonder what we could have done with 800 or 2000 men instead.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by whakim on Monday November 15, 2021 @11:09AM (#29229009)
I'm not sure this conversation is going anywhere because (again, with context you'd realize this) narrowly missing the target by a day or two was par for the course with these types of engagements.

If you're interested in learning more, I'd strongly recommend Wes Morgan's excellent book "The Hardest Place."

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by tuyguntn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:44PM (#29219968)
agree with you, maybe they tried to protect Bin Laden.

But there are multiple questions which should be answered:

1. are we 110% sure that Bin Laden ordered the attack? I am not trying to defend him, but you know there are many organizations who can do that attack, including multiple organizations funded by CIA (don't forget Bin Laden was initially funded by CIA), maybe government could prevent attack but didn't prevent, because they were also interested in natural resources of Afghanistan?

2. Are we 120% sure we can capture and execute Bin Laden without civilian fatalities? if civilian fatalities can't be avoided, did we have numbers in mind, how many people will get killed?

3. Why western media didn't give enough voice to Taliban at that time? If enough people listened to them, maybe US could make public negotiation and if negotiation fails publicly, then everyone would definitely know Taliban is to blame for this war. In reality, US just said, we are super power, we can do whatever we want.

4. Are we sure war wasn't lobbied? You know, US sells lots of weapons, they sometimes need to test, are we sure that war wasn't lobbied? where did 2T$ go? Do you think all were eaten by corrupt Afghan government? even 10% of it would be 200B which would create 100 billionaires.

I am not defending Taliban or Bin Laden, just showing how decisions made was wrong and I still doubt US can make right decision. Now Afghanistan has lots of uneducated people, who lost their families, children. Do you think they would just forgive? Who can guarantee that they won't come over to US and start killing people?

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:52PM (#29220030)
> 1. are we 110% sure that Bin Laden ordered the attack?

Bin Laden attacked the USA in the 90s (the original twin tower attacks). Then issued a Fatwa declaring a Holy War against the USA (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fataw%C4%81_of_Osama_bin_Laden).

Bin Laden's writings on 9/11 are well published, even on Western Media (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2002/nov/24/theobserver).

There's no doubt in anybody's mind that Bin Laden was involved in 9/11.

> 2. Are we 120% sure we can capture and execute Bin Laden without civilian fatalities?

Of course not. We would have preferred for the Afghan government (aka: the Taliban) to cooperate with us. But they didn't.

> 3. Why western media didn't give enough voice to Taliban at that time?

We have Bin Laden's writings published and the Taliban's writings published. What exactly is missing from their argument that you want published?

> 4. Are we sure war wasn't lobbied?

Oh, Cheney was definitely a Warmonger. But that doesn't make the Afghan War a wrong move.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by iszomer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:49PM (#29221062)
> Bin Laden attacked the USA in the 90s (the original twin tower attacks).

Thought it was the "other guy"..

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramzi_Yousef

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:53PM (#29220042)
> are we 110% sure that Bin Laden ordered the attack?

Bin Laden made a video in '04 regarding the US presidential election at the time in which he implicitly claimed responsibility.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:50PM (#29220017)
They wanted proof bin Laden was responsible for 9/11. Given that they've denied he was responsible as recently as a couple months ago despite him claiming responsibility on video in '04 or so, I don't think this was in good faith.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by missedthecue on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:22PM (#29220293)
The Taliban can not be expected to negotiate in good faith. It would be beyond naive to think they would.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by rendall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:39PM (#29220440)
Can you say more about that? Why not? Have they broken agreements before?
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:58PM (#29220632)
In this specific case, the Taliban still to this day doesn't believe bin Laden was responsible for 9/11, so their supposed offer to hand over bin Laden back then if they were given proof he was responsible probably wasn't made in good faith.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by rendall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:04PM (#29220688)
... I don't see how that follows, logically.

These can all 3 be true: The Taliban does not believe that bin Laden was responsible for 9/11. They would hand over bin Laden if they saw credible evidence. Their bar for credibility is quite high.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by missedthecue on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:11PM (#29220749)
Why isn't bin Laden saying verbatim to the public that he's responsible enough? If that's not enough, what could the coalition forces possibly say that would convince the Taliban?

There isn't high bar to cross. They've already decided what they think. That's what I mean by 'bad faith'.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:26PM (#29220883)
Killing infidels is justifiable and completely ethical to some people.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by rendall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:03PM (#29221153)
Unfortunately, true. We humans are still just scary, tribal apes who have brains big enough to feel the need to build elaborate rationalizations for brutish, reprehensible behavior
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by trasz on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:43AM (#29225156)
No different from killing terrorists to some other people.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by rendall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:36PM (#29220968)
I cannot conclude logically that evidence sufficient for me means that anyone who disagrees is per se operating in bad faith.

I'm not going to argue for the Taliban. I have no idea whether they're good faith actors or not. Regardless, they're assholes, and I'm pretty sure, as far as I can ever be, that bin Laden is responsible.

But to be fair, "he claimed responsibility" isn't by itself iron-clad proof for anything. All kinds of people claim all kinds of false things for all kinds of reasons. We know this. The Taliban knows this. I could easily come up with a plausible, reasonable explanation why bin Laden would falsely make such a claim. You could too.

When someone rejects evidence that you find convincing, don't assume bad faith. Ask them what evidence they would accept no matter how unlikely. If they have something (e.g. "If I had a private meeting with bin Laden and he assured me personally..."), it means they just have a really high bar.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by Supermancho on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:33PM (#29221381)
> Ask them what evidence they would accept no matter how unlikely.

> it means they just have a really high bar.

Nope.

Truth does not require meeting everyone's bar for evidence.

Motive, Opportunity, Means, Confession. Done. Unquestionably culpable, even if only through negligence (in controlling his own messaging).

Just as the US is for various "mistakes" made in targeted attacks.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:36PM (#29220969)
Bin Laden himself claimed responsibility on video in '04. If that isn't credible evidence, no evidence in the world could ever have been credible for them.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by icelancer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:12PM (#29220756)
bin Laden said he did it. Many times.
[dead]
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:57PM (#29221955)
There's an abundance of other evidence that bin Laden was behind 9/11, his claim of responsibility being only the most blatantly obvious one. Claiming he wasn't responsible for 9/11 genuinely requires conspiracy theorist-levels of contrived argumentation.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by kreeben on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:13PM (#29222043)
With an abundance of evidence it would be trivial to try and convict him, no?

Why, then, didn't they bring him before a court? It would have been awkward of course, logistically, but judicially, so worth it.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by mannerheim on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:32PM (#29222154)
The mission was capture or kill. If he had surrendered, he could have been tried and convicted, but realistically that wasn't going to happen, so he ended up dying as expected.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by icelancer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:01PM (#29221602)
>> If the CIA/US military was sure of his guilt, why didn't they bring him before a court?

Well, they killed him, so there's that. Hard to bring a dead man to trial.

Also... it was Obama's desire to try Osama bin Laden.

“We worked through the legal and political issues that would have been involved, and Congress and the desire to send him to Guantánamo, and to not try him, and Article III.” Obama continues: “I mean, we had worked through a whole bunch of those scenarios. But, frankly, my belief was if we had captured him, that I would be in a pretty strong position, politically, here, to argue that displaying due process and rule of law would be our best weapon against al-Qaeda, in preventing him from appearing as a martyr.”

There is no doubt that bin Laden was the mastermind behind the attacks on 9/11. It is not remotely controversial or in any way disputed.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by kodah on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:13PM (#29221225)
> The whole 'Special Forces' fetishization is also pretty ridiculous. The best of the best of the best, la-dee-dah.

This is a pretty common misunderstanding by civilians. Special forces come in tiers and usually they're designated for certain kinds of work. It doesn't mean they're "best of the best", just special training that may or may not be useful in a place like Afghanistan. Historically they're used for training foreign fighters. From what I read in this article, this looks like work that line companies should have been doing.

> Oh, and the "Afghan Army Training Program" - at a cost of something like $10 billion to train and equip 350,000 Afghan Army members who'd be the nucleus of the new independent government...

I don't think that money went any conspicuous. I served in 2012, when a lot of that ANA training and colocation was going on. You're absolutely right that it was a failure. The problem was that the President was telling the American people things were going well, when in reality troops were getting shot in the back on patrol by their counterparts, people were deserting post while high on hash, and most ANA were paid over four years the equivalent of a dowery.

> Getting in bed with heroin-shipping warlords because they were anti-Taliban?

This was surprising to me when I was in country, but I get it. Most of these dudes are the equivalent of governors and own their own armies. They just didn't want to follow the Talibans rules, so "the enemy of my enemy is my friend." Quite complicated, but I don't know how it'd be different.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by hh3k0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:01PM (#29219575)
> We went in with a pretty good justification (Taliban refusal to hand over Osama bin Laden for his central role in 9/11 terrorism)

That would _not_ be a good justification to wage a war, but I think the actual casus belli was Saddam Hussein's weapons of mass destruction – later found to be non-existent. 215 Republicans and 82 Democrats voted for this. They paved the way for a war of aggression… and I seem to remember that Americans have previously hanged foreign politicians for precisely that.

Edit: Misread above comment and thought he was talking about Iraq. Point still stands, though.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:05PM (#29219604)
> but I think the actual casus belli was Saddam Hussein's weapons of mass destruction

Afghanistan War was 2001. Iraq War was 2003. Your history is off by about 1.5 years.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by pan69 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:13PM (#29219680)
> After 9/11, the Bush administration national security team actively debated an invasion of Iraq. On the day of the attacks, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld asked his aides for: "best info fast. Judge whether good enough hit Saddam Hussein at the same time. Not only Osama bin Laden."[90] President Bush spoke with Rumsfeld on 21 November and instructed him to conduct a confidential review of OPLAN 1003, the war plan for invading Iraq.[91] Rumsfeld met with General Tommy Franks, the commander of US Central Command, on 27 November to go over the plans. A record of the meeting includes the question "How start?", listing multiple possible justifications for a US–Iraq War.[92][93] The rationale for invading Iraq as a response to 9/11 has been refuted, as there was no cooperation between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda.[94]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_War

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by bserge on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:01PM (#29221147)
The atrocious English makes me question this Wiki entry.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by tomjakubowski on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:50PM (#29221917)
Rumsfeld wrote weird.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by h2odragon on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:16PM (#29219721)
> train and equip 350,000 Afghan Army members

"Afghanistan's ghost soldiers undermined fight against Taliban" https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-59230564

IIRC there were complaints being published at least as far back as 2009 about that problem.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:25PM (#29219812)
People keep crapping on the Afghan Army, but it should be noted that the Afghan security forces suffered 65,000+ casualties officially (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Afghan_security_forces...).

And some estimate that the number may be as high as 100,000.

-----

In contrast, the US sent ~110,000 soldiers at its peak (2011 surge), and lost ~7000. The Afghan Army took the bulk of the attacks by any reasonable analysis.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by photochemsyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:38PM (#29219920)
But is that 'official death count' any more reliable than the total count of 350,000? Let's say I'm a grossly corrupt Afghan general, and I'm diverting pay and equipment money, say 50% of the total, to my private bank accounts. Now someone asks me to account for the smallish number of soldiers in my barracks.

"Oh sir, we have suffered great casualties in our fight against the terrorists, here are the records."

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by dragontamer on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:39PM (#29219925)
> But is that 'official death count' any more reliable than the total count of 350,000?

No. Because the Afghan security forces would be lying to try to improve their morale.

If anything, the official death count is almost certainly an underestimate. No army likes to admit that their death rates are in the 25%+ level, when you admit such a thing, you won't be able to find recruits.

------

Besides, we paid the Afghans on number of soldiers on payroll. Not on number of deaths. So the number they were corrupt on was #-of-soldiers.

Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by bserge on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:06PM (#29221173)
The ghost army in LOTR was cool, but that's fiction. Doesn't work that well irl, I guess.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by celloductor on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:09AM (#29223940)
you can't justify going to war with a country just because they refuse to extradite an individual. that is what a bully does.
Re:How the U.S. hid an airstrike that killed dozens of civil... by justicezyx on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:40PM (#29221435)
> made them quite willing to hand over power to the Taliban without a fight this year.

The most ridiculous I saw from your post:

A reasonable citizen, who saw from the very beginning the ridiculousness of the whole thing, in the end, seems to suggest the whole thing should not end so abruptly?