News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by marcodiego on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:56AM (#29188452)
From https://frame.work/blog/linux-on-the-framework-laptop :

“ There has been immense interest in this configuration, with it outselling pre-configured systems with Windows 10 by a wide margin.”

There is a market. And it is currently under-served.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by warner25 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:40PM (#29190698)
I believe that the Framework DIY Edition is bringing more new users to the Linux desktop than anything in recent memory. People all over the Framework forum are talking about trying Linux for the first time on their new DIY Edition machines.

When buyers need to opt-in to Windows for $139, it seems to stop the inertia. This is true even in my own case, even though I've used Linux on and off at home and at work for the past 15 years. My previous laptop came with Windows 10, and I just used it like that (with Linux VMs in VirtualBox as needed) for four years. Now I'm getting caught up and keeping up with Linux desktop distro news, excited about it all, and trying Manjaro as my daily OS.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by jdhn on Friday November 12, 2021 @10:19AM (#29200060)
>I believe that the Framework DIY Edition is bringing more new users to the Linux desktop than anything in recent memory.

Framework DIY orderer here. I plan on putting Linux on it because I wanted to try something other than Windows. I'm excited, but admit that I'm a bit scared as this is my first time diving into Linux.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by hnaccount141 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:28AM (#29188880)
It'd be interesting to see how much of the interest in the no-OS option is due to Linux vs people choosing to buy a Windows key cheaper elsewhere.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by spinningslate on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:57AM (#29189340)
I'd like to see that data too. I'd be very surprised if that windows scenario is anything other than noise level.

Though, for completeness, I'd replace Linux with *nix - I'd guess there'll be some BSD users in there too.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by GekkePrutser on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:04PM (#29195924)
Yes FreeBSD user here. Would love to have a laptop with verified-to-work hardware. Preinstallaton is not needed nor really wanted :)
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by maltalex on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:26AM (#29188847)
Machines ordered without Windows won't necessarily end up running Linux. Many of them could end up running pirated Windows.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by prophesi on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:09AM (#29189515)
Microsoft actually offers Windows 10 for free, with some cosmetic restrictions until you pay for the license.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by neogodless on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:32PM (#29190612)
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by bitwize on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#29191202)
Yeah, these days Windows is like Fortnite: free with cosmetic IAP.

This is also why "Windows is a service" according to those Windows Update nag screens, but if Windows is a service and it's free, are you the customer... or the product?

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by vasili111 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:04PM (#29190274)
Could you please provide information we're I can get that free of Windows?
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by mbilker on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:27PM (#29190552)
The "cosmetic restrictions" are the "Activate Windows" watermark and the inability to change any setting under Personalization in Settings.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by officeplant on Thursday November 11, 2021 @05:10PM (#29193863)
The best part being if you don't allow it to get online during the initial setup you can go change all the personalization settings. It will only lock you out once you get online and it verifies its not activated. I can deal with just having that watermark when I only boot into win10 for a few specific programs.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by yellowapple on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:25AM (#29198198)
It's also pretty straightforward to emulate a KMS server and activate Windows that way. Technically against the EULA, I'm sure, but Microsoft doesn't seem very motivated to do anything about it (certainly not for individual users).
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by unethical_ban on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:24PM (#29190520)
I swapped motherboards recently. Despite /specifically/ getting a Microsoft account, thinking that it would link my account to my licenses and allow for seamless transfer, it seems I need to call into microsoft for them to re-activate my install. So first off, fuck you Microsoft.

To the question: I have a watermark in the corner of my screen saying I need to activate, and I am unable to change my desktop background and some other things. Besides that, the OS is functioning normally.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by julianlam on Friday November 12, 2021 @05:12PM (#29205155)
I haven't used Windows in over a decade now, and this behaviour boggles my mind... Imagine losing access to parts of your OS because you switched hardware around.

It's odd because a decade ago I would've probably been fine with it, too.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by pkulak on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:25PM (#29190526)
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by ravar on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:40PM (#29191375)
I don't know whats up exactly but I actually tried installing this last week and it didn't let me. Said I could only install without a product key on a system that already has a windows install.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by beanjuiceII on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:25PM (#29190534)
you can download it for free from microsoft, install it and use it no problem. like he said it has limitations until you pay, but you can use it forever without paying
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by skinkestek on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#29189886)
You can get a fully working Windows key for well under $50.

I know, I had to get one for my kids.

So maybe some are just buying a legal copy at a price that Framework aren't allowed tonsell at.

That said, if one isn't stuck in a very Microsoft-centric organization or isn't playing certain Windows-only games, which developer honestly want Windows now that even power management (suspend/resume) seems to work better under Linux?

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by anotherhue on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:35PM (#29190646)
Many laptops come with two. One on either side of the space key.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by skinkestek on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:51PM (#29190822)
My wife is out and kids upstairs so I'm reading HN alone in the living room and actually laughed out loud (after first thinking you had replied to the wrong comment).
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by stratosgear on Thursday November 11, 2021 @06:50PM (#29194776)
Sorry, I still don't get the joke! Can you enlighten me, please?
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by post_from_work on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:52PM (#29195150)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_key

easily confused with the conversation's "Windows key" aka "software license".

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by OJFord on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:56PM (#29195172)
'Windows key'

'Key' being alternately the licence key, or found on the keyboard.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:25AM (#29189744)
There is no need to pirate windows anymore, there are tons of entirely legit windows 10 pro licenses for sale at <3€.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by TheRealDunkirk on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:44PM (#29190756)
That reminds of the days that I was incorporated, and really wanted to be completely legit. I bought Office 95 Pro for half price, with CD's in a jewel case, complete with holograms on the labels, and considered myself a careful shopper. Then the company I worked for entered into a Select Agreement, and we had a meeting with an official Microsoft representative. I asked him why licenses on the Select schedule were so much more expensive than my copy of Office, and he told me that my copy was bogus. I told him about the holograms and everything! Nope. I paid $200 for very, very good, completely fraudulent and illegal fakes.

After that, I went to Linux on the desktop, and never gave Microsoft another dime, until my wife demanded Word on her Mac a couple years ago, and I now begrudgingly have an Office365 account.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by GekkePrutser on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:10PM (#29195954)
I bought office 2000 as a student for a tenner :) No holograms but it was official.

I've never paid for it since. Office apps aren't really important in my personal life at all, the open ones do just fine if I ever need them for something. And if I need the real office I just use my work laptop :P

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by maltalex on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:36AM (#29189905)
Those are the exact pirated copies I was referring to. Or do you really believe that a copy that costs 3 euro can be legit?
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by xrd on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:13PM (#29190384)
I've been researching this and the sellers of this assert they are selling licenses that are left over and entirely legitimate. It's a secondary market, not unlike used cars or anything else that is more tangible. I think there might be precedent for this to be legal even if Microsoft wouldn't like it be so.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by bitwize on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:27PM (#29191233)
It's illegal. Software is licensed, not sold; and software licenses are usually nontransferable. This was a point of contention in Vernor v. Autodesk wherein the 9th Circuit found for Autodesk.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:20PM (#29191958)
In the United States, you are right. In the EU, that is wrong. See for example: [0]

The reason you can get entirely legal windows licenses for so cheap is that there are many institutional buyers who get the licenses they actually use separately but still purchase a lot of computers that have OEM licenses bundled [1], and now they all unload those licenses at whatever price the market will bear. Last year, that was ~6€, this year it's down to ~3€.

The fact that the prices is now so low is probably a part of why it keeps going down. A lot of people in this thread express suprise that a legit key could be so cheap so they obviously must be illegal, which drives away sales.

[0] https://www.computerworld.com/article/2505356/eu-court-rules...

[1] And do note that tying the OEM license to hardware is also entirely illegal inside the EU.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by howinteresting on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:37PM (#29191333)
If Microsoft really cares about this it is welcome to price Windows Pro competitively.

(Microsoft only really cares about licensing for business customers, enforced through audits anyway.)

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by benhurmarcel on Saturday November 13, 2021 @06:22PM (#29214036)
They send you a license key that you can use with a legit Windows installer, that you get on Microsoft’s website. You can even link all that to your Microsoft’s account.

If that’s pirated software, Microsoft doesn’t try to detect it very much.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by skinkestek on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:59PM (#29190906)
I bought Pro at around $45 and activated through Microsofts own activation service so while $3 sounds unreasonably low, unless Microsoft has started activating unlicensed keys it is possible to get actual legal keys at a fraction of the list price.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by breakingcups on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:39PM (#29193529)
These are likely licenses given to Microsoft Partners which are only to be used for developing/testing software. They activate identically to regular keys and there is no indication once activated that that's the only licensed purpose of that key.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by aunty_helen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:57AM (#29190183)
It’s ‘possible’ maybe unlikely at 3€

However there is a license recycling market that buy up unused or reassignable licenses from say software shops that have gone under and still have 100 visual studio licenses etc

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by NikolaeVarius on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:10PM (#29190338)
Yes, i want to go legit by paying pirates for, checks notes, buying grey market license keys that could be disabled at any moment
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by novok on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:35PM (#29190650)
Microsoft never bothers, and at 3 euro the risk you have that "activate windows" might have a low chance of popping up again is well worth it. Just make sure its not a volume license key and your pretty much good to go.

Is it really pirating when all you get is a key and a legal inactivated copy of windows from MSFT's servers says it's legit?

I bought an OEM pro key for $15-20, and it works great.

Research it a bit more and if you call MSFT support, they go into a loop about how if you typed it in and windows says it's good, it's a legit key from their perspective.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by aunty_helen on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:23AM (#29200963)
These aren't pirates, they buy the licenses from defunct business in the same way you would buy an office chair.

Checks notes to be arogant And it says here they're entitled to do so.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by ksec on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:17AM (#29189624)
That is a very good point. Especially when the cost of Windows is priced out explicitly starting at $139.

I think the one thing we have ( or should have ) learned. Is the paradox of computing. Bill Gate said all hardware will be free. Because the cost is driven down so quickly. And it will be software that rules the world. That was late 90s and early 00s. And it make sense. Because software development is getting more expensive.

It turns out no consumer is willing to paid for software. The vast majority of consumer market wants software to be free. And they are only paying for the product ( both software and hardware ). Most developers were surprised at their iOS copies sold compared to their macOS software. Where iOS had 10x the market size, but only sold less than half of what they did on macOS. That is a 20x difference.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by judge2020 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:27AM (#29188871)
Hackintoshing is also getting easier (save for amazing battery life) with OpenCore, perhaps a small subset end up doing that.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by thereddaikon on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:49AM (#29189208)
It will get easier right up until x86 MacOS is no longer updated and then will immediately become a thing of the past.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by judge2020 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:54AM (#29189290)
Monterey supports the 2013 Mac Pro and 2014 Mac Mini, so if we can expect only 8 years of actual OS support, we'll probably see 8 more years of OS updates for stuff like the 2020 Intel iMac and Intel Macbook Air & Pro. That's a long while before this becomes a possibility.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212551

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by jagger27 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:53PM (#29191568)
As a particularly relevant counter example, the last PowerPC Macs were sold until August 2006. Mac OS X Leopard came out a year later in October 2007 and received its last patch (10.5.8) in August 2009. That's a lot less than 8 years.

This is why when the first M1 Macs were announced I immediately sold my 16" i9 MacBook Pro and bought an M1 Air for much less than I sold the Intel machine for.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by GekkePrutser on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:16PM (#29195994)
Yeah while Leopard remained supported with some security updates, you could forget about all the OS update goodness which was still significant back then.

I had a PowerBook and it was disappointing how quickly it aged because of this.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Mikeb85 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:46AM (#29190035)
Doubt it. First of all, computers with Windows aren't any more expensive than the same model with no OS or Linux.

The Framework is niche hardware and honestly, it's doubtful non-developers would ever hear about it. Odds are it's something Linux users are seeking out.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by dagw on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:53AM (#29190140)
First of all, computers with Windows aren't any more expensive than the same model with no OS or Linux.

That's not true in this case. Framework charge you the full $140 for Windows Home and $200 if you want Windows Pro.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by duped on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:24PM (#29190524)
One of the (maybe the?) largest tech reviewer on YouTube quite publicly bought one on the spot after reviewing and then invested in the company.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by officeplant on Thursday November 11, 2021 @05:18PM (#29193957)
Recently I could still save money on Lenovo, Dell, and even some HP business machines by ordering the No OS (freedos) or Linux options. I haven't checked in two years because I haven't needed a new machine. You just don't see it as often in the consumer space when microsoft is subsidizing the cost of windows to remain the ever present option.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by beanjuiceII on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:23PM (#29190503)
i bought a system76 and removed linux and put windows 10 on it so i don't think it impossible to think people do this stuff
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Rebelgecko on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:56AM (#29190168)
>First of all, computers with Windows aren't any more expensive than the same model with no OS or Linux.

That's not what Framework's website is telling me. It looks like getting it with Windows costs up to $199 more

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Mikeb85 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:58AM (#29190201)
Strange considering other OEMs bundle it for the same cost as Linux.

Framework's loss or they just don't consider it important?

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by pydry on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:58PM (#29190898)
Or Microsoft puts subtle, legally deniable pressure on the OEMs.

I've never managed to buy the laptop i want without a windows license. Often it's been a PITA to take it off, too, to add insult to extra cost.

In the 90s they threw their hands up and said it was nothing to do with them that this kept on happening and it was all a hare brained conspiracy. Until that memo came out and proved otherwise, of course.

I can't imagine framework getting the decent OEM bulk windows license deals being as avowedly pro linux as they are.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by lwkl on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:31AM (#29197106)
I think if you buy in high enough volume you can buy devices from OEMs without a Windows license. I bought my ThinkPad that way and it cost about $100 less than the version with a Windows license.

I only got this deal over a project that procures hardware for universities and students. They offer a limited amount of models with a price that is about 20 - 30 % lower than retail. I guess big companies that order in the same volume get similar deals.

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by Mikeb85 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:37PM (#29191335)
That's fair. I'm no MS fan for the record. Just assumed Framework would have access to some OEM deal on Windows OSes.

My next laptop is definitely going to be something without Windows (Linux user for the last ~15 or so years).

Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by unethical_ban on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:22PM (#29190491)
Or OEMs rip you off by including the Windows price in the no-OS cost.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by pentium166 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:29PM (#29190578)
I would guess it's a combination of Framework not having the same deal the big OEMs are getting, OEM grift, and based on the price, Framework appears to be selling retail Windows licenses rather than OEM licenses.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by tomnipotent on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:17PM (#29193300)
It reads mostly like a marketing decision.
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by reginold on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:31AM (#29188935)
Would love to see this market set the bar higher than "Linux-friendly"!
Re:The Framework Laptop Is Great for a Linux-Friendly, Upgra... by holri on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:37PM (#29192143)
Would be nice if it would mention which proprietary software is necessary.