This is true of so many things. Improvement is proportional to the amount of deliberate, conscious practice, which is more uncomfortable than “game time”.
When I used to play chess, I always found short time controls the most fun, but the least useful for long term improvement.
Now that I'm finally playing again, I feel like I'm back to my previous levels, or even better, after just 3 months of playing 1x week.
Having said that, there's also the 10,000 hours thing.
only... Deep sigh!
The closest we've done is just "more game time". The closest we've found is when learning a new tech doing a small project. But that is learning a tech and distinctly different from "practicing" the craft of programming.
I was wise enough at the early age of 12 or so to realize that whatever that "commitment" gene was, I didn't have it, so I kept piano a personal passion rather than try to go to school for it like my parents wanted.
But it still surprises me about the amount of effort to master the instrument.
Commenting as I have heard of fellow musicians sometimes performing almost ritualistic steps or 'cargo cult' emulations of 'famous' musicians to try and replicate their success.
My interpretation is even though I love those practices, I would still make myself tired from playing and concentrating for too long - after that my standard is downgrading. If I continue, I get used to those lower standards more than I could gain expertise.
Of course like with sports the fun thing is playing a game, not practicing for it, so that's what ends up happening.
The thing is with most computer games (I suppose games in general) is that you not only have to learn the rules of the game to get better, you must also study and practice the current best strategies to even stand a chance.
This is something I wish I knew 20 years ago.
> You can code all you like, but reading text books on the subject and studying other people's code will quickly improve your skill.
Companies need to prioritize this is the point. It's not about low pay, high pay jobs. Or obtaining a role once you have the skills, it's that companies don't prioritize learning/development as part of the role, they focus on output - and they would get more value from their employees of they did.
You will study other people's code on the job and code reviews provide coaching.
Chess is much harder for me because I don't have the discipline to study like that.
With coding, I can read a quick blog post or follow a tutorial, then immediately start incorporating ideas into my work.
In chess, if I study something, I might not encounter a situation where I can use that knowledge in game for a while. I don't get that immediate reinforcement so I forget things much easier.
If it's mid game it's going to be strategy, you're not going to ever repeat it, so you can apply the strategy in general terms.
If it's endgame then surely you can setup scenarios and play against engines.
Maybe, if it doesn't exist, there's a need for a game engine that will try to do a particular opening to give you practice, will try, say, to fianchetto or castle early (I imagine such settings exist) to allow practicing against those moves?
But, unless you're seriously good can't you get the repetitive practice easily with engines?
That's a problem everyone has :)
Fun fact: Botvinik became world champion without being a `professional` chess player. He had a full-time job as an electrical engineer.
Just by playing, you gain too little data - you'd have to re-invent the world's expertise on your own.
One must study the vast amounts of data generated by other players, now embodied as knowledge.
Not unlike many other fields. Reading and coaching count a lot.
Would it be proper to replace this "himself/herself" with simple self? And what do we call gender neutral person if not?
No.
> And what do we call gender neutral person if not?
they/them/their has been extremely common for gender-neutral abstract use for centuries. It spent a while with strong bias against it in formal contexts but that's weakening recently.
One/one/one’s is less controversial in formal settings, but requires a somewhat different writing style.
“Botvinnik famously recommended that a professional chess player should only play 80 tournament games a year and leave himself/herself time to think about chess.”
might become:
“Botvinnik famously recommended that, as a professional chess player, one should only play 80 tournament games a year and leave oneself time to think about chess.”
or, another option, is do it without any pronouns at all:
“Botvinnik famously recommended a professional chess player only playing 80 tournament games a year and leaving time to think about chess.”
Everybody is different. Playing lots of games gives you the ability to experience playing different types of positions against different players, which can feed into your training in terms of figuring out which areas to focus on.
If you want to get better at chess you will have to study, but I don’t think playing is in itself negative. Only if you never study and only play.
There are also practical things like managing the clock and managing your attitude that you can only practice in games.
Botvinnik's quote refers to tournament games, that is, long, over the board, classical time control games that take hours to play. It says nothing about playing practice/friendly games, or playing other time controls.
Incidentally, I'm familiar with the recommendation (actually I thought it was a maximum of 50 games in a year) but I can't find any source for it online. Does anyone have a source?
That is not grammatical. One rendition in such a style might be:
> Botvinnik famously recommended that a professional chess player only play 80 tournament games a year and leave time to think about chess.
Though I would prefer to substitute for 'year and leave time to think' one of: 'year, to leave time to think', 'year, leaving time to think', or even 'year, to live time for thinking'.
There is also an ambiguity in the original: 'a professional chess player' may be taken as definite; that is, it may seem as though the advice was directed at a specific chess player. To avoid the possibility of such an interpretation, I might prefer the rendition using 'one', or something like this:
> Botvinnik famously recommended that professional chess players only play 80 tournament games a year, to leave time for thinking about chess.
The one problem is that many people have difficulties with distinguishing usages. This is especially a problem for foreign learners, but even native speakers are not immune to naive generalizations.
A: They are after you!
B: Who, a single they or multiple theys?
Atributed to Dave Chappelle.
Improvement in chess is not directly proportional to the number of games played - that is one factor. Amateur park players and hustlers rack up many hundreds of games per week, and thousands per year, but are usually beaten by masters who have played fewer games for shorter periods of time. Botvinnik famously recommended that a professional chess player should only play 80 tournament games a year and leave himself/herself time to think about chess.
Improvement is a function of directed study of chess : analysing one's games with the aim of eliminating weaknesses in one's play, becoming familiar with common patterns (and anti-patterns) of strategy and tactics, learning the fundamentals (and advanced aspects) of openings, middle games and endings, and conquering psychological barriers.
I say this because we need to take this into account as we study perfomance else we get skewed results.