News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by nojs on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:57PM (#29054083)
> Improvement is a function of directed study of chess

This is true of so many things. Improvement is proportional to the amount of deliberate, conscious practice, which is more uncomfortable than “game time”.

When I used to play chess, I always found short time controls the most fun, but the least useful for long term improvement.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by holri on Sunday October 31, 2021 @12:40AM (#29054545)
This seems to also be true for piano playing. Basically Friedrich Gulda said he only practices 3-4 hours a day sitting at the piano. The rest of the day he is sitting in the café thinking about music and piano playing.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by stef25 on Sunday October 31, 2021 @04:36AM (#29055479)
Regarding "thinking" about music ... I recently took up playing drums again after a 20 year hiatus. During those 20 years I was never able to stop tapping rhythms on things (to my own and everyone around me's great frustration). Every song I listened to I couldn't not imagine playing that drum track. That must have kept those neural pathways alive.

Now that I'm finally playing again, I feel like I'm back to my previous levels, or even better, after just 3 months of playing 1x week.

Having said that, there's also the 10,000 hours thing.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by ternaryoperator on Sunday October 31, 2021 @01:33AM (#29054720)
> he only practices 3-4 hours a day

only... Deep sigh!

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by injidup on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:01AM (#29055065)
I spend 6 to 8 hours sitting at the computer thinking about C++. 3-4 hours then sitting in a cafe seems like a sweet deal.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by nicoburns on Sunday October 31, 2021 @04:51AM (#29055539)
I’ve found sitting in a cafe (or going for a walk) often allows me to think more productively about code: sometimes the screen is just a distraction.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by adrianN on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:54AM (#29055819)
For me, most of the time the hard part is not writing the code, but understanding all the code around it so that I figure out where to get my inputs from and not break anything. I can't do that without sitting at the computer and reading the code.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by wirrbel on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:39AM (#29055224)
If I found time at work for 3-4h of concentrated, uninterrupted programming I would be happy.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by lawn on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:14AM (#29056171)
Even if I have time for more, around 4h of focus is my limit, and after that quality is lost very quickly.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by Zababa on Sunday October 31, 2021 @10:00AM (#29057016)
Assuming you're talking about your job, I'm not sure this is the same as "practicing" C++ for 3-4 hours the way you would practice piano. For us programmers there's usually no difference between practice and "the real stuff" unless you consider side projects as practice but that's "outside" our job.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by BoiledCabbage on Sunday October 31, 2021 @10:23AM (#29057172)
Unfortunately, for us as a profession we still haven't yet figured out what "practice" looks like.

The closest we've done is just "more game time". The closest we've found is when learning a new tech doing a small project. But that is learning a tech and distinctly different from "practicing" the craft of programming.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by Zababa on Sunday October 31, 2021 @11:07AM (#29057503)
I feel like a good start would be to reflect on what we do on our job, time ourselves, see where we struggled, practice these parts. But that's still far from deliberate practice. Griding leetcode is one, but it's practice for leetcode problems.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by darkerside on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:20PM (#29071642)
Every line of code that you write and later delete is practice. We practice a lot.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by Zababa on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @06:01AM (#29079088)
It is practice, but usually not "deliberate practice" in the way musician or people that talk about 10 000 hours think about practice. I'm not sure how big the difference is between practice and deliberate practice.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by Gene_Parmesan on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:08AM (#29055623)
Many professional classical musicians of all sorts of instruments will practice 6-8 hours per day or more. Whether that's necessary or not is up for debate. Either way, many of them have an almost obsessive relationship with music and their instrument -- at least at the highest levels -- which means they probably want to be playing that much.

I was wise enough at the early age of 12 or so to realize that whatever that "commitment" gene was, I didn't have it, so I kept piano a personal passion rather than try to go to school for it like my parents wanted.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by arvinsim on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:10AM (#29055096)
I immediately had the same reaction. Granted I am beginner and more on the pop side of things than classical.

But it still surprises me about the amount of effort to master the instrument.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by holri on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:01AM (#29055590)
That is very low for professional pianists.
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by mb_72 on Sunday October 31, 2021 @01:03AM (#29054626)
Ah ... I think you are onto something with this statement. What's the name of the cafe? /s

Commenting as I have heard of fellow musicians sometimes performing almost ritualistic steps or 'cargo cult' emulations of 'famous' musicians to try and replicate their success.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by krigath on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:21AM (#29055674)
This comment reminds me of the book "Daily Rituals: How Artists Work"
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by namelosw on Sunday October 31, 2021 @02:30AM (#29054912)
It seems to be very true for humans to learn things that require practice. Playing video games, playing piano, sport, etc.

My interpretation is even though I love those practices, I would still make myself tired from playing and concentrating for too long - after that my standard is downgrading. If I continue, I get used to those lower standards more than I could gain expertise.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by f_allwein on Sunday October 31, 2021 @04:20AM (#29055389)
Related book: Talent is overrated https://geoffcolvin.com/books/talent-is-overrated/
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by borroka on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:29PM (#29059621)
[I read the book years ago] Anyone who has been able to do anything measurable at a high level knows that talent is underrated. But "Talent is Underrated" would sell very few copies: who wants to have their hopes buried under a ton of reality?
Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by lordnacho on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:46AM (#29055243)
This is very true. I've never played RTS games seriously, so every time I play I just feel naked. I can figure out eventually how to build a base and crawl the tech tree, but I've always felt what I would really need is to just sit there and study what all the units are, common tactics, and videos of other people playing.

Of course like with sports the fun thing is playing a game, not practicing for it, so that's what ends up happening.

Re:How long does it take ordinary people to get good at chess? by tinco on Sunday October 31, 2021 @04:12AM (#29055348)
In expert level RTS play, if you take even a tenth of a second to think about any decision anytime during the first 15 minutes you will most likely lose the game. After that it gets more interesting but many games don't last that long.

The thing is with most computer games (I suppose games in general) is that you not only have to learn the rules of the game to get better, you must also study and practice the current best strategies to even stand a chance.