News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by ferdowsi on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:10PM (#28834147)
The ability for people to give away their Legos is one of the most important ways I guage an organization's health. If I'm in an established organization and I see a VP or director prescribing technical solutions to engineering problems, it's usually an indicator that:

- the leader cannot emotionally bear to give up engineering work and focus on leadership work. This signals a lack of maturity.

- there is some other serious organizational problem preventing delegation from happening (weak engineering IC hires, lack of clear processes and ownership patterns, etc)

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by hakfoo on Monday October 11, 2021 @11:04PM (#28835628)
I don't think "engineering work" and "leadership work" should be a dichotomy, especially if you're trying to follow a promote-from-within mentality.

Sure, after N years, you might be career-tracked from development into management, but you probably also know where all the bodies are buried. If you're not doing code reviews, trying to mentor new developers, or just butting in and saying "We tried that in 2006 and it has huge non-obvious compliance/performance/maintainability costs!", it lets all that knowledge go to waste.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by watwut on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:38PM (#28842596)
Code review by someone who did not cared for years except doing reviews strikes me as a bad idea. Same with that person teaching juniors.

If is supremely annoying when code review is done by superior who does not produce code, but has opinions based on vague recollections.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by jimmaswell on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:11PM (#28834554)
Was Henry Ford a bad CEO? I have more faith in a CEO that's involved to a degree and understands the engineering side as opposed to some out of touch MBA.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by selectodude on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:59PM (#28834790)
Henry Ford was a good CEO in that he handed the reigns over to his son pretty early on. Henry did his best to hamstring the company until his death.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by _hyn3 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:30AM (#28840138)
This is not historically accurate.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by billyhoffman on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:02PM (#28834809)
I think people like Ford, Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, are the exception that proves the rule. It is astronomically rare for a CEO to be that involved at a micro-level and be successful.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by XorNot on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:18PM (#28835361)
Steve Jobs definitely wasn't proposing technical solutions in any version of events I've read.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by microtherion on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:11PM (#28846245)
Having been a bit closer to the action (through secondhand reports from colleagues), it was not at all uncommon for Steve to propose detailed technical solutions, but (1) many of them were no good (2) his teams got pretty good at working around him on such matters and (3) I think over time he developed the good sense to trust his lieutenants on matters like this instead of being overly insistent on seeing his bad ideas implemented.

In contrast, in UX/Design, Steve generally had very astute insights, knew so, and it was much harder to get him to change his mind.

For a publicly documented example of a bad technical decision by young Steve that the team simply worked around for a while until he changed his mind, see: https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&stor...

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:26AM (#28836998)
he was however heavily involved in UX and design.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by colordrops on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:10PM (#28834546)
You've got musk prescribing technical solutions at the CEO level, so clearly it's not true in every case.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by PragmaticPulp on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:48PM (#28834730)
I worked at a multi-billion dollar company (not Tesla) where the CEO considered himself chief engineer and tried to prescribe low-level technical solutions from the CEO level.

It was terrible. CEOs don’t have the time to keep up with technologies and understand the low-level requirements that drive good decision making. A person doing a CEO job can’t possibly keep up with someone doing full-time engineering work in any fast-moving field.

The only way we could make progress was by subtlety seeding our ideas to the CEO and waiting for him to claim them as his own directives after he realized they were good ideas. It was an exhaustive way to get things done.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by bobsomers on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:37PM (#28834664)
I've talked to some folks from Tesla whose stories absolutely reinforced the parent's point. Some of the silly things Musk has dictated turned into massive wastes of resources for the engineering team.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by edoceo on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:41PM (#28834685)
But not to Musk, who writes the check. Not always about engineering team resources.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by bombcar on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:37PM (#28834665)
There’s a line somewhere between understanding technical issues (and being able to make decisions on it) and being too interested in the details.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by crabmusket on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:10AM (#28835949)
And another line after that when mandating the details from on high.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by hef19898 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:20AM (#28836353)
And I'd say Tesla is successful despite and not because of that. Examples include: Tesla's shot at an in-house ERP and the drive to fully automate production. Both cost them a lot.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by afarrell on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:55AM (#28839061)
Also https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/05/tesla-must-pay-137-million-t...

The ability to say "this is no longer my job" is crucial if a leader is to focus on what is their job.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by seattle_spring on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:58PM (#28834778)
Like the absolutely asinine "steering yoke"?
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by stavros on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:05PM (#28834824)
Everyone's first words at the reveal were "is this a yoke?".
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by mLuby on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:04PM (#28834818)
I'm sick of "but Elon Musk does X." Yes, the guy's exceptional. That literally means not representative, outside the normal rule or distribution. So like a black swan, you can point to him and say "proof X is possible" but you can't point to him and say "proof X is normal"—you've got to wait for "half of Fortune 500 CEOs do X."

(Nothing personal colordrops, I've just seen this take a lot lately.)

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by Jetrel on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:40PM (#28835097)
I mean, it's a fair take to argue that CEO-ship ought to be meritocratic, in the sense of only hiring extremely exceptional individuals. If you're just an average jobsworth doing a merely 'decent' job, you shouldn't be the ceo of any company.

It's kind of similar to airline pilots or surgeons, where we have to demand "excellence" as a lowest-common-denominator. At that level, they need to be graded on a reverse curve, where unlike regular grades, where a mere 65% score is a passing grade — for those folks, nothing less than a 95% should be a passing grade.

It's easy to make the argument for airline pilots and surgeons, because the human tragedy that results from their potential incompetence is immediate and obvious. I feel like the tragedy that comes out of incompetent CEOs is a lot more insidious, and sneaky. Poorly run companies, and depressing "waste of life" has ruined a lot of people's lives.

In fact, one could dare to surmise that it's actually, statistically speaking, directly killed a lot of people (an easy low-hanging fruit here would be safety stuff that OSHA doesn't cover), but there's a lot of mental health stuff we don't track as well. This whole line of thinking reminds me a lot of Florence Nightengale — her primary contribution to medical statistics was to take something that people brushed off as irrelevant or not-causal, and prove that it was a primary malefactor. She convinced the british top brass that the bulk of their deaths during war had nothing to do with enemy action, or even hospital deaths from injury, but literally was just caused by petty diseases, due to poor barracks sanitation amongst uninjured men.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by Talanes on Monday October 11, 2021 @11:16PM (#28835691)
Competence at being a CEO, competence in the core business (whether engineering or otherwise,) and competence at splitting focus between completely different levels of the business are all different competences. Being skilled at all three is the exception, but that doesn't make the non-exceptions incompetent.

If you always aim for the exception, what you actually end up doing is selecting for the third competence; someone who can code-switch. And if that person isn't exceptional, then you just have a CEO who is getting involved things outside their depth.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by mirekrusin on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:59PM (#28835600)
Shouldn't it also make you sick to read about prescription for exceptional hypergrowth from 500 to 5500 employees? It's not like everybody here will experience this kind of rapid growth. We also don't know how much of it is survivorship bias. What if there are cases where this approach contributed to failure, ie. because people were shifted from where their expertise actually was?
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by mekkkkkk on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:53AM (#28837195)
> "proof X is possible"

Isn't that exactly what the parent comment said?

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by mLuby on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:30AM (#28839416)
In context it reads as parent disagreeing with grandparent's statement that a "leader [who] cannot emotionally bear to give up engineering work and focus on leadership work… signals a lack of maturity" by saying "[Musk shows] it's not true in every case."

So my quibble is simply that "proof leaders do X" doesn't disprove "doing X is bad leadership," despite parent's implication to the contrary.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by paulryanrogers on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:40PM (#28834323)
> If I'm in an established organization and I see a VP or director prescribing technical solutions to engineering problems

That 'established' part is key because early stage companies require wearing so many hats. And knowing when and to whom to let something go it's crucial IME.

Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by fieldcny on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:41PM (#28835108)
There are some bounds on this, I’ve seen plenty of situations where VPs may not be prescribing technical solutions because they are so far out of touch they can’t even understand the solution options in play.
Re:‘Give away your Legos’ and other commandments for scaling... by otabdeveloper4 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:13AM (#28836937)
Not so simple. You write like "weak engineering hires" is just a problem of laziness or ignorance.

But the reality today is that most companies simply cannot afford to hire strong engineers across the board for economic supply-and-demand reasons.

You have to work within the bounds of possibility, and yes, that sometimes means that people have to wear multiple hats.