News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by roody15 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:20AM (#28760647)
To me this is a fake story being promoted as a way to further a political narrative.

Nothing the whistleblower has revealed is shocking or previously unknown. Yes facebook tweaks an algorithm on your news feed to drive engagement and make money.

Yes facebook allows some content that some would consider not to align with mainstream US narratives.

My two cents this is an attempt to force facebook to kowtow to the US and follow googles lead in stopping “unapproved” discourse on topics dealing with covid among others.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by chmsky00 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:23AM (#28760702)
It’s not “unknown” to technologists.

How it all works is very unknown to the average parent.

This thread seems to think the government needs to function with the logic of this thread in mind.

Pretty entitled to believe you’re the only perspective worth listening to.

Any individual is just “one of seven billion.” Shut the computers off and what perspective do you have that puts you above anyone else?

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:41AM (#28760981)
> It’s not “unknown” to technologists.

I think the odd bit is that if this information isn't unknown to anyone in technology, even those not working on similar systems, then how is this "whistleblowing". It's like calling informing people about marginal tax rates "whistleblowing" because so many people don't understand how they work.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by aeturnum on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:01PM (#28761276)
It's whistleblowing, in this instance, because Frances Haugen released a bunch of internal documents showing what everyone has been saying. Generally the term is applied to someone who releases information from inside a company or organization showing that their public statements have been deceptive or are out of sync with the internal point of view.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by pp19dd on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:48PM (#28761978)
In this case it's a specific term related to SEC whistleblowing protections. The context is not about whistleblowing for some semblance of public protection, but whistleblowing for protection of investors who may have been misled.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by samstave on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28762754)
It is important to discuss because its the INTENT behind what is being done, not so much HOW they are doing it technically - we 'technologists' love to know the how, but everyone needs to know the 'WHY' -- especially non-technical users.

Just because most people are non-technical does not make them stupid... and it doesnt remove their humanity, which, as unpopular as it may seem, throughout human's entire history there was more privacy than there has been in the last 75 years.

So, as we have evolved with actual privacy (due to lack of adequate/developed survellance technologies), and its idiotic to say that humans should have no expectation of privacy.

Then why are you wearing clothes? is the intimate nature of your body not referred to as "private parts" -- so there are "private thoughts" and "private personal details" that shouldnt just be available because "government" says so...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:07PM (#28763190)
I agree it's important to discuss the WHY in things, but I don't see how that applies to my confusion around the usage of the term "whistleblower" at all.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by samstave on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:55PM (#28763926)
I think my point was that the whistleblower is telling of the WHY.

If you never have the WB telling of the why, then you cant put any personal context that affects you, and as such, have a ho-hum attitude to the situation, when one should be taking it much more seriously...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by anon9001 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:53AM (#28761159)
> It's like calling informing people about marginal tax rates "whistleblowing" because so many people don't understand how they work.

You mean like these?

* https://www.propublica.org/article/lord-of-the-roths-how-tec...

* https://www.propublica.org/article/the-secret-irs-files-trov...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:14PM (#28762348)
No, neither of those have anything meaningful to do with understanding marginal tax rates.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by InsomniacL on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:40AM (#28760956)
I found your post hard to follow overall. For example, who does this apply to and why?

> Pretty entitled to believe you’re the only perspective worth listening to.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by arbitrage on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:52AM (#28761144)
I mean it's fairly well laid out of a topic.

Which part specifically are you having trouble with?

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by InsomniacL on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:07PM (#28761346)
are you a bot? I gave a specific example in the post you're replying to.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by arbitrage on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:51PM (#28882313)
i don't think i'm a bot. what makes you say that?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by roody15 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:44PM (#28762848)
“ Pretty entitled to believe you’re the only perspective worth listening to.”

Odd statement. I just stated my opinion on the matter. I encourage others getting lots of perspectives and making up their own minds.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ladyattis on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:02PM (#28762158)
>How it all works is very unknown to the average parent.

No one complains about not knowing how proximity sensors work in their car. They're just happy that they work and there is in theory someone who keeps the manufacturers responsible.

And I think that's the real issue here. Software for years has been treated outside of some very small instances as a value added affair and thus not worthy of investigation or oversight beyond those who fund such development. So all software companies outside of specific situations have been allowed to do what they will so long as it works well enough. Now it seems the situation has gotten more complicated because of the impact of software on non-software conditions/situations. But giving it over to Congress who currently is dominated by the Silent Generation and Boomers who aren't largely as tech savvy or educated to write legislation that will likely benefit Facebook and destroy the Internet as we know it (probably returning to a version of AOL and the like) is in my opinion the worse possible option.

I'm not for laissez faire policies but I'm certainly skeptical of Congress not intentionally making claims that their laws will protect privacy all the while they open the Facebook surveillance machine to law enforcement to spy on me and my own in violation of the 4th amendment. And knowing how this SCOTUS who's been virulently anti-privacy especially among the conservative justices then this will be much worse.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by jtdev on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:39AM (#28760926)
Your perspective disregards the likelihood that this whistleblowers input will be used to censor political speech rather than actually protect children and teens online.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by scop on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:26AM (#28760739)
Let's also remember that Facebook has decimated traditional media. Traditional media seems awfully excited by this "whistleblower"!
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by gitfan86 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:48AM (#28761076)
There is certainly some of that. Cosmopolitan magazine wishes they were the ones making money off of teenage girls insecurities instead of FB. I see this as more of a consumer protection transparency issue.

Facebook is saying that they are selling a product that makes the world better, but that isn't true. They are selling a product that prioritizes engagement over happiness. Maybe the same thing is true for Cosmopolitan magazine, but at least Cosmopolitan magazine isn't pretending that it is saving the world.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by bryan_w on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#28762000)
Exactly, "Facebook is manipulating us into thinking bad things" from expert manipulators, The Guardian and NYT
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ctvo on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:40AM (#28760966)
> Nothing the whistleblower has revealed is shocking or previously unknown. Yes facebook tweaks an algorithm on your news feed to drive engagement and make money.

Can you provide a citation here? People have suspected these things externally. Facebook has always denied. The news here is that an insider has provided documentation that Facebook knew. And I'm not talking strictly about the algorithm, but the harm to teenagers, and the other bits.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by therealdrag0 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:34PM (#28763613)
My partner and I rolled our eyes at the 'harm to teenagers' bits when we heard NPR talking about it forever. How can anyone be surprised at this? Before instagram everyone bitched about teen-magazines harming teens, is this really surprising or that different? And IIRC the % was incredibly small. It's not like Instagram is leading teenagers off a cliff, it's unhealthy for teenagers who are already unhealthy. SHOCKER!
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by igornadj on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:37PM (#28780748)
The difference between engagement algorithms and magazines when it comes to potential risk is in the orders of magnitude.

It's well known that engagement algorithms create a feedback loop to trigger negative emotions as they are the easiest way to increase engagement.

This is possible with traditional media, but nowhere near the immediacy or effect of an engagement algorithm.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by tboyd47 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:33AM (#28760843)
I totally agree.

If Congress really had a problem with the lack of accountability, then they can repeal the CDA. Presto, now not just Facebook but all tech companies are accountable.

If it were really about the children then why don't they go after TikTok?

For someone who has only had a 4-year long career in technology and no experience in the public eye, Ms. Haugen seems unusually confident.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by mbesto on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:02PM (#28761287)
> Nothing the whistleblower has revealed is shocking or previously unknown. Yes facebook tweaks an algorithm on your news feed to drive engagement and make money.

Known and verified are two very distinct things. Does the public know that Facebook does this? Yes. Do they know it's harmful? Yes. Does Facebook also know this? Yes. Did they tell congress that they know this? No, in fact they told them the opposite.

The whistleblower is simply proving that unverified known - that Facebook has done research in its harm and knows they exist. Facebook would say "so what, we're doing stuff to fix it".

The most important part is the following: Facebook believes that its implementation for corrective actions of its harm is solely its responsibility. IMO, this is what is so dangerous and revealing. There is no one auditing other than taking "Facebook's word for it".

> Yes facebook allows some content that some would consider not to align with mainstream US narratives.

This is an incredibly disingenuous description of the situation. Facebook's own (non-public, now publicly leaked) research indicates that Facebook causes harm to teens mental health. The only "US narrative" here is the one backed up my the incredible amount of research supporting the growing issue of mental health in the US (and the world for that matter).

EDIT: To further my point and give you a comparison - when a similar thing happened with Tobacco the government was able to control behaviors by (1) forcing tobacco companies to put labels on their products and (2) tax tobacco such that it dissuaded customers to buy. Imagine if William Morris said "we know tobacco causes cancer so we've actively decided to sell 10 million less cartons of tobacco this year". No, they ended selling X million less cartons because of those two measures (among others).

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by camdat on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:31PM (#28761705)
>This is an incredibly disingenuous description of the situation. Facebook's own (non-public, now publicly leaked) research indicates that Facebook causes harm to teens mental health. The only "US narrative" here is the one backed up my the incredible amount of research supporting the growing issue of mental health in the US (and the world for that matter).

This is disingenuous, that same data shows the majority of the teens surveyed said FB improved their mental health.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by mbesto on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:36PM (#28761787)
This is news to me and frankly makes no sense. How does the data say that FB both improved mental health and harmed it?

Can you share your source?

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by makomk on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:54PM (#28762062)
That seems pretty straightforward to me - there are a huge number of teenagers who use Facebook, some of whom say that it improved their mental health and a smaller group who say it made it worse. The media reporting only talked about the teens who said Facebook was harming their mental health rather than the broader picture. Which, if accurate, would mean that closing down Facebook would actually hurt teens' mental health overall but anyone getting their news from the mainstream media would falsely think it'd help. This kind of deception using facts that're technically true is really common in the mainstream media, and Facebook in particular has pissed off journalists by hitting their industry hard both in the pocketbook and in terms of the amount of power they hold in society.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by mbesto on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:03PM (#28762171)
I just double checked and we don't have access to the Facebook study (only excerpts and interpretations from WSJ - i was originally referring to external studies). So let's just state the obvious, if the conclusion of the study was that Facebook has an overall net benefit to mental health then why wouldn't Facebook be forthcoming with the report? Congress has explicitly asked them for it, so why wouldn't they produce. That's what I'm confused about.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by camdat on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:41AM (#28769933)
Sorry about the delay getting back here. They have been forthcoming with this data. See here:

https://about.fb.com/news/2021/09/research-teen-well-being-a...

I will correct myself and say the majority surveyed believe Instagram has a neutral or better impact.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by LordHumungous on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:54PM (#28763922)
Also there's the problem of a lack of a control group in this data. If you asked people in an online questionnaire how the Coca-Cola corporation was affecting their mental health what sort of responses would you get?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by camdat on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:43AM (#28769954)
This is addressed in the discussion of the study they completed. This wasn't a formal survey and shouldn't have been interpreted as such. WSJ were the ones who contextualized this as a valid study.

https://about.fb.com/news/2021/09/research-teen-well-being-a...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:56AM (#28761206)
In what way could this be possibly be “a fake story?” Do you not believe that it happened? Or is she making stuff up? Or do you just mean that people don’t really actually care about the topic? Or because it’s not previously unknown, it’s too late and public interest is supposed to move on to other topics now?

The initial bombshell was around instagram’s affect on teen girls mental health, so calling it an attempt to force FB to kowtow to the US on covid seems like some deep 4D chess conspiracy idea. And calling it fake is ridiculous rhetoric.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by hammock on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:59AM (#28761250)
OP likely means it's disingenuous- the true intentions are hidden- it's part of a lobbying effort for greater control and consolidation of power.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by neither_color on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:21PM (#28761539)
All I know is there have been several Facebook whistleblowers why is this one the one being lauded on NPR & 60 minutes for their "bravery" and not the others?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:18PM (#28761500)
Whose true intentions are hidden, and who is trying to lobby? The person who posted this on HN and all of the people who upvoted it here and all the comments critical of FB here and twitter and twitter users and bloggers and redditors and, yes, traditional news?

It seems like the assertion is that this isn't newsworthy... despite the fact that huge amounts of people clearly care, but that this is only really making news for a reason totally separate from the fact that there is new leaked data and people clearly care.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by hammock on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:35PM (#28761764)
The general idea is that Facebook will assent to more censorship of undesirable content if and only if the same standard is applied to their competitors. This is achieved via legislation of new regulations. And legislation typically needs some semblance of popular support to pass, hence a ginned up/accelerated/forced narrative. The net effect of new regulations would be to shore up Facebook's market share and dominance of social media, since they are the biggest and can most efficiently execute on any new regulations.

A similar thing happened in the tobacco industry. For decades tobacco was happy to sell cigs relatively freely. But there was a turning point where they acknowledged their unhealthiness, At this point Big Tobacco actually campaigned for greater regulation, and the net result was a consolidation of the entire industry.

There are plenty of other examples as well. Monopoly power is made and preserved by regulation.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ogaitnas on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:14PM (#28761450)
Lobbying efforts by who exactly? And are these efforts trumping Facebook's lobbying?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by moksly on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:42AM (#28760993)
Well yes, but there is also a rather big difference between knowing something and having evidence and testimonies of something.

We also “knew” that a lot of the rich families in Denmark were hiding money in tax-havens. We couldn’t act on that knowledge until the Panama papers were leaked to give us evidence or what we knew.

You’re certainly right that certain parts of the political leadership are going to use these leaks to further their agenda, but that’s how politics work in a democracy. You use what you get.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by colinmhayes on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:34AM (#28760861)
This was absolutely unknown to probably at least 90% of the people who use facebook. People on HN largely don't use facebook from what I can tell because they've seen all this stuff that facebook does.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ryandrake on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:55AM (#28761188)
Yea, I like to think of my [becoming elderly] parents. They didn't know any of this stuff. I've tried to explain the harms of social media to them but it's tough to do that without deep-diving into algorithm tech-talk, and without the recently divulged evidence you sound like a raving conspiracy theorist. Now, it's being explained in plain language in front of Congress, and on "60 Minutes" which targets their generation directly, and, although I haven't talked to them since, I guarantee they get it now.

Remember how long it took to mainstream the idea that cigarettes were bad for you? "We all knew it" for a long time, but it didn't become genuine shared cultural knowledge until long after it was well known.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by nyghtly on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:18PM (#28762408)
The whistleblower part is internal Facebook research showing that the algorithm is known to be harmful (for example, politically polarizing and hate-mongering) in it's current form. In addition to that internal research, she also revealed during the 60 minutes interview that Facebook used a "weaker" version of the algorithm during the 2020 election cycle in order to prevent disinformation. The weaker version was replaced with the high-engagement strategy after the election. Notably, the Jan 6 insurrection occurred when the high-engagement algorithm was being used.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-facebook-files-11631713039

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-whistleblower-frances-...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by lostmsu on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:23PM (#28762500)
Just clarifying. Why is political polarization harmful?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by adolph on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:51PM (#28762946)
I'm not certain but in considering your question I came to: Political polarization is a network of cognitive biases which decreases mental models' connection to the reality that people agree on more things than disagree.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by lostmsu on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @08:14PM (#28767490)
> Political polarization is the extent to which opinions on an issue are opposed, and the process by which this opposition increases over time.

From wiki. Seems obvious. Where did you get, that is has anything to do with cognitive biases?

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by nyghtly on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:53PM (#28762977)
"This 2019 internal report obtained by Haugen says that the parties feel strongly that the change to the algorithm has forced them to skew negative in their communications on Facebook ... leading them into more extreme policy positions." (8:07)

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-whistleblower-frances-...

Although the above statement is from a group of European politicians, it's not hard to see the same story playing out in the United States. Take the Covid-19 pandemic, for example. The impact of partisanship on this issue is as clear as day:

"There's A Stark Red-Blue Divide When It Comes To States' Vaccination Rates"

https://www.npr.org/2021/06/09/1004430257/theres-a-stark-red...

"Ron DeSantis isn't anti-vaccine. But he has started standing shoulder-to-shoulder with those who are."

https://www.politico.com/states/florida/story/2021/09/15/des...

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by lostmsu on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @08:15PM (#28767510)
Are you sure this is due to "polarization"?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ogaitnas on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:54AM (#28761173)
What is so fake about this story?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by Leparamour on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:10PM (#28761381)
When was the last time that a 'whistleblower' was interviewed on prime time TV?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by infamouscow on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:22PM (#28761547)
Governments like corporate whistleblowers because they stand to gain legitimacy and earn trust. Government whistleblowers have the opposite effect.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ogaitnas on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:17PM (#28761482)
Snowden has been interviewed a number of times, is he not a whistleblower? Not sure why that makes it suspicious.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by sp332 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:21PM (#28761543)
60 minutes interviewed Rick Bright in May last year.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by e12e on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28762740)
It may be propaganda - but how is "a false story" if it is true?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by jayd16 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:48AM (#28761080)
Its a fake story but we've known its true for a long time? Wah?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by papito on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:38AM (#28760913)
Ooh! "Fake story", "mainstream US narratives", "discourse"!

All the greatest hits. You forgot "alternative facts".

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by sumtechguy on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:57AM (#28761209)
It has some of the earmarks of a something is up. You do not go from nobody to 60 min interviews that quick.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by aardvarkr on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:55PM (#28762070)
That "nobody" is a Harvard MBA with a degree in Computer Engineering that's worked at Google, Pinterest, and Facebook as a Data Science with high level access to key data and leaked over ten thousand internal documents who witnessed what she believes is a critical failure of one of the largest companies ever that controls a vast majority of how the world consumes information and communicates with one another. This is a bombshell of a leak and I'm glad the world is paying attention.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ogaitnas on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:05PM (#28761328)
Oh please, is it that hard to believe she was just repulsed at what she saw while working there? Pretty cynical to believe she has a hidden agenda.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by Leparamour on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:13PM (#28761423)
>Pretty cynical to believe she has a hidden agenda.

She openly calls for more censorship, at least that agenda isn't even hidden.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by sp332 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:41PM (#28761863)
It's a live program, so I missed that part. What content does she want censored?