News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by ryandvm on Thursday September 02, 2021 @10:58AM (#28392881)
Libby and the bizarre false scarcity model of e-book sharing is the kind of weird crap you end up when you try taking existing laws and paradigms and applying them to the digital landscape.

There is absolutely no reason that a kid should have to wait in a queue to borrow an e-book because the 3 "copies" they have are already in use. If it's about making sure authors are compensated appropriately, then we need to restructure licensing fees so that libraries are paying reasonable per-use licensing fees. But to pretend that there are only a few copies of this book we can borrow is asinine.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by jawns on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:19AM (#28393131)
> But to pretend that there are only a few copies of this book we can borrow is asinine.

Is it really "borrowing" under the reforms you propose? And to take your argument a step further, why should there be a due date? If your borrowing a book doesn't prevent anyone else from borrowing it, then why should you need to "return" it at an appointed time? Boiled down, your proposal is really just a license to read the book, paid for by the library.

I actually don't mind maintaining the artificial scarcity and pretending that digital assets are like physical assets, because: (1) it's no worse than the system we have in place now with physical books; (2) it doesn't require us to entirely revamp copyright law; and (3) it allows libraries to make the argument that once they buy a digital asset outright, they can "lend" it just as they do with physical books, under a set of principles commonly called Controlled Digital Lending. This is a better option than the status quo, where libraries have to pay highly marked up licensing fees for ebooks.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by troyvit on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:27PM (#28394864)
One additional thing I like about scarcity and forcing returns of ebooks is that it forces me to pick it up and read it instead of just grabbing it and forgetting about it.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by pempem on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:41PM (#28400169)
Nearly every book i'm trying to get from the library has a queue over 10 weeks long. Some are legitimately 18 weeks.

Libby already automatically returns them even if downloaded locally and thats fine.

The user experience has a lot to be desired.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:46AM (#28404905)
I would be okay with applying the existing laws to digital assets if we actually applied the whole thing. The first sale doctrine somehow disappeared with digital assets. The copyright holders gets strictly more rights with digital assets and concedes nothing to make up for it.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by canuckintime on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:23AM (#28403851)
> (2) it doesn't require us to entirely revamp copyright law;

Actually there’s no reason Congress couldn’t just make an exemption to copyright law for libraries in regards to electronic media

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by leokennis on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:29AM (#28393288)
I'd say the correct analogy is movie rentals.

* In the past, I rented a VHS tape of which there were 3 copies. Now I rent a movie from iTunes, there are infinite copies and I rent the right to watch it (as often as I'd like) within a 48 hour period.

* In the past, I lended a physical book of which there were 3 copies. In my proposal I rent a book from Libby, there are infinite copies and I rent the right to read it (as often as I'd like) within a xyz day period (or I pay per day I lend it, some books take longer to finish than others).

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by NanWilder on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:21PM (#28393979)
You don’t pay enough in taxes to fund this model — not even a significant fraction of it. If you want to switch to a user-pays-to-rent model, there are iTunes/Netflix-alike options out there — go nuts. But our societies and our literature would be worse off if we all did.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by pempem on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:41PM (#28400171)
We (I'm assuming you and I have jobs and aren't independently wealthy or multi millionaires) pay enough taxes, they just arent directed to libraries.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by ViViDboarder on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:11PM (#28398981)
It’s not a pay-to-rent mode they are proposing. They are proposing getting rid of scarcity and allowing folks to borrow for a period of time, as many times as they’d like. An option to keep it longer than the allotted time is akin to a late fee.

In what way would more access to literature make society worse off?

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by wisty on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:53PM (#28399281)
There's near-infinite access to free literature, it's called the internet. Any author who wants to make their work freely available can just put it online.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by selykg on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:04AM (#28392941)
I think there's a bigger issue here. Currently the library buy's x copies of an ebook, which they can then distribute out to members. This is the model you're saying is bad.

But the benefit here is that the expense of the book is predetermined and controllable.

If you were to switch to a model where they're pay per use, fundamentally the amount is lower initially. But what happens when a book is incredibly popular and there aren't any limits on who can read that book. Now the library could be on the hook for a large bill that never would've happened had they had more control over the book. Sure, they could set a limit per book on the per use rules, but say they hit that limit in 6 months out of the year, now the book is just unavailable for the remaining 6 months?

I feel like per use complicates things. I hate the current model, too. But I don't think all libraries are super well funded.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by blacksmith_tb on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:07PM (#28394581)
Yes, it could be that 'books' would only be available until they'd been 'borrowed' 100 times, at which point the library would have to buy/license additional 'copies' or patrons just couldn't read it any more. In some ways that seems fine, but there's a sadness to the idea of the library as a repository of knowledge going away, and being replaced by a vending machine.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by nfriedly on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:18PM (#28394737)
I think the current "3 copies out at a time" model also has a 100 borrows and then the library has to buy it again. limitation. (The number is probably higher than 100, though.)

Edit: I was wrong, it's lower than 100. From the article:

> In 2011, HarperCollins introduced a new lending model that was capped at twenty-six checkouts, after which a library would need to purchase the book again.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by selykg on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:47PM (#28395109)
Further proof that the library system is just plain being broken by publishers.

There's a lot of bad shit in this world, but oh boy do I wish some of our country's leaders would solve problems like this. We don't elevate youth or those around us by limiting access to knowledge.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by blacksmith_tb on Thursday September 02, 2021 @04:19PM (#28396853)
That passage though does provide some more details: "For a classic work, which readers were likely to check out steadily for years to come, a library might purchase a handful of expensive perpetual licenses. With a flashy best-seller, which could be expected to lose steam over time, the library might buy a large number of cheaper licenses that would expire relatively quickly." At least perpetual licenses are an option.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by pavel_lishin on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:50PM (#28394363)
I don't think anyone in their right mind would say that e-books should be "pay per use" when borrowed at the library, any more than you'd institute a "pay per use" model with regular books, DVDs, etc.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by nkurz on Thursday September 02, 2021 @06:46PM (#28398319)
I don't know if it disproves your "right mind" argument, but here's Overdrive's CEO explaining the advantages of their new "Cost per Circ" model whereby libraries pay a smaller cost for each checkout rather than purchasing items in advance: https://overdrivesteve.com/pursuing-the-holy-grail-of-librar...
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by hyperbovine on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:49PM (#28394350)
It's funny, music piracy is all but dead, whereas book piracy appears to be alive and well. I guarantee you that kid will quickly learn how Googling "<title> pdf ebook" saves them three weeks of waiting. Whereas to listen to a song, they just go on Spotify or YouTube, blissfully unaware of what we had to do back in the day to get songs digitally.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by MinorTom on Thursday September 02, 2021 @03:35PM (#28396360)
Eh, as a kid maybe, but my time is too valuable to waste it going through pages upon pages of scam google results (note: google is the search engine most publishers send takedown requests to, use any other search engine for piracy).

Now, a private tracker, on the other hand...

Disclaimer: Piracy is morally wrong, and if any LEO asks all I've been downloading is 1984.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by novok on Thursday September 02, 2021 @10:18PM (#28399740)
It's really easy nowadays for most books although, just go to libgen
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by jxidjhdhdhdhfhf on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:15AM (#28404503)
Also b-ok.org. I think that's why book piracy is so popular, it's super easy. In fact it's easier than buying and dealing with DRM.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by wintermutestwin on Thursday September 02, 2021 @03:16PM (#28396138)
Yes, interesting that book (and audiobook) publishers are further behind the music industry. And then there is movie and tv with it's inane fragmentation.

One subscription for access to ALL the content is the way to beat piracy. Anything else is anti-consumer at this point.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by webmaven on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:53PM (#28407923)
> One subscription for access to ALL the content is the way to beat piracy. Anything else is anti-consumer at this point.

So what do you do when an Amazon Prime membership is required to access most contemporary books?

Or when you have to get several different all-you-can-read memberships to access all the authors you like. Eg. first there was just Netflix, now there is Hulu, Disney+ and Paramount+ as well if you want to see The Handmaid's Tale, Stranger Things, Game of Thrones, Star Trek: whatever, The Expanse, Star Wars & Avengers movies (to name just a few of the most popular and culturally relevant shows and movie franchises).

Whether there is a monopoly or oligopoly doesn't make much difference to consumers, though it does make some difference to content creators.

To make a system like you describe palatable over the long term, you would have to add in structural separation (content owners can't also be distributors) and strictly limit the kind of exclusive licensing deals that are allowed (eg. require statutory licensing of some sort) so new publishers and distributors can't be prevented from entering the market.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by wintermutestwin on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:29PM (#28409009)
I'm guessing that you missed my point. I was saying that the music industry has the right model that is mostly consumer friendly and beats piracy. I can pay Spotify or Apple a single reasonably priced subscription and have access to "all the things." Books, audiobooks, movies and TV are all a fricking mess (as you point out) and it is anti-consumer and promotes piracy.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by webmaven on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:30AM (#28424606)
The music industry doesn't have the right idea (from their POV). They let Apple become dominant (same as publishers let Amazon). The movie and tv industry (which overlaps with music) wasn't going to let Netflix (or Apple, or Amazon) do the same, so we consumers get fragmentation that preserves their profits, and they get to demonize piracy.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by elliekelly on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:00PM (#28394499)
> whereas book piracy appears to be alive and well

Not just alive and well, but monetized by sites like Scribd.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by PalaceProject on Thursday September 02, 2021 @02:26PM (#28395553)
There are a lot of layers to licensing e-content that you have to navigate to be able to lend ebooks though libraries.

I'm working with a non-profit right now on this problem, working on open source apps to make it easier and more patron friendly for libraries to lend ebooks. The project website is here: https://thepalaceproject.org and our github is here: https://github.com/ThePalaceProject

If there are any talented mobile developers out there that would like to work on this problem, we are looking for iOS and Android developers. The team is 100% remote, and its work that you can feel good about. Drop me a line at: [email protected].

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by xhkkffbf on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:10AM (#28393006)
The simple solution is to go to a model where the author is paid per reader or maybe even per page that's read. For someone reason, though, people seem to cling to the idea of "borrowing copies". It worked reasonably well when the copies were on paper, but it doesn't make sense for digital versions.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by Thespian2 on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:08PM (#28394584)
While I agree, there still remains the practical question of who would pay. In the physical book library world, the library pays for a quantity of physical books, and lends them for free to the patrons. They are reimbursed for various fixed costs by existing grants, and taxes, and similar funding streams. The physical scarcity supports this model, by capping costs.

If we remove the scarcity, and pay authors per reader or per page (a good thing, in my opinion) we uncap the expense the library must bear if something becomes popular. One could shift the costs to the users, but then what is the point of the library? The user is just buying an ebook, and we already have markets for that.

The library gives access to books to those who can't afford them. Artificial scarcity sucks, but actually serves a purpose in this context.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by elliekelly on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:02PM (#28394519)
> The simple solution is to go to a model where the author is paid per reader or maybe even per page that's read.

I think Kindle Unlimited might work this way?

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by Finnucane on Thursday September 02, 2021 @09:56PM (#28399636)
And scams are rampant on the system.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by librelibre on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:41PM (#28395027)
I won't get into the ethics or morals of copyright, DMCA, licensing, and so forth. I've held my opinions for decades, and I tire of rehashing them. I'll just share what I've been doing recently. You'll have to Duck for the links.

Calibre is a crazy awesome e-book swiss army knife utility. A user "apprenticeharper" has a "DeDRM_tools" repo on GitHub that includes a Wiki that has a lot of this info. This includes a plugin for Calibre to strip the DRM from books like the ones you get for Amazon Kindle.

When you "check out" an e-book from your library via Amazon Kindle, Amazon will "wrap" the book encryption keys with your own individual account keys. The De_DRM plugin uses your own individual account private key to unwrap the book key that then decrypts the book contents.

The Amazon Kindle PC and Mac apps store your private key to disk. I have Kindle reader version 1.17.0 (44170) installed on Win10, and under "Tools -> General" I have "Automatically install updates when they are available without asking me" unchecked. I found that version of the reader by searching online and downloading a mystery binary. The hash of the binary checked out with hashes I found posted in forums talking about it, so I'm not really that worried about the authenticity of it. If you're really concerned you can run all this in a VM, which probably wouldn't be a bad idea.

So after you "check out" the book via the library, the book will show up in your Amazon Kindle library. You can download it in the Kindle app. At that point the book that's "wrapped" with your account keys will be in a place like "Documents\My Kindle Content" as an .azw file.

After I installed the DeDRM plugin for Calibre I went to "Preferences -> Plugins -> DeDrm (7.2.1) by Apprentice Alf, ...." and double-clicked on it. Then I selected "Kindle for Mac/PC ebooks" and made sure "default_key" was present. Note that you can also "Import Existing Keyfiles," and at one point I had success using a Kindle device key (you have to download an .azw file from Amazon Kindle's web site that's wrapped with your device key for that to work). But the Kindle app is easiest for me.

"default_key" will cause the plugin to look for your on-disk keys in the usual location that the Kindle app drops them in your local filesystem. If you want to see the magic you can restart Calibre in debug mode (under the Preferences menu, or Ctrl+Shift+R). This will drop a log file from the plugin telling you what it's trying to do and why it might have problems finding your account private key.

Once the Calibre with DeDRM plugin is working and accessing my Kindle app account key, I can click-and-drag the .azw file in the "My Kindle Content" into Calibre, and Calibre will strip the DRM and store the e-book file under your "Calibre Library" directory.

You can then use the "Convert books" context menu for the book to export to EPUB or MOBI format. I use EPUB for my Kobo reader and MOBI for my Kindle reader.

Once you have it all set up, the process is pretty quick and straightforward. It takes me just a couple of minutes.

For the occasional Adobe Digital Editions e-book (.acsm file) I simply use the Adobe Digital Editions app to download and then grab the .epub file from the "Documents\My Digital Editions" directory.

For audiobooks, those are distributed as .odm files. I use the "overdrive.sh" script from chbrown's overdrive repo on GitHub to download the audio files, which get distributed without DRM. I wrote another script to combine the audio files into one big audio file because that's more convenient for me to work with. I use the BookPlayer app on my mobile device to listen to them.

I try to do all of this the same day my e-book becomes available for checkout so that I can return the e-book ASAP to help the next person waiting in the queue to get access to it.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by easton on Thursday September 02, 2021 @02:05PM (#28395312)
Is this more legal than just pulling the book off of libgen? I knew someone in middle school who would rent movies from Redbox, rip them and then take them back, and I didn't understand why he wouldn't just torrent them to save the trip.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by no_wizard on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:44PM (#28399235)
Ultimate no trace I suspect

I wonder if anyone does this with the Netflix movies by mail

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by danans on Thursday September 02, 2021 @07:58PM (#28398880)
> the bizarre false scarcity model of e-book sharing

The scarcity is in our willingness to pay sufficient taxes to allow the library to purchase more book licenses, and in doing so possibly negotiate bulk discounts.

That is, unless you are arguing that the government should force authors/publishers to sell their e-books at a discount to public libraries. It's not clear why authors/publishers would agree to that.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by pirate787 on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:53PM (#28399277)
Strawman argument. The reality is the vast majority of books should already be free to distribute, as the copyright should have expired. Just roll back copyright to 28 years, as it was originally in the US, and let information be free.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by sparrc on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:49PM (#28395132)
> There is absolutely no reason that a kid should have to wait in a queue to borrow an e-book because the 3 "copies" they have are already in use.

There definitely is a reason, it keeps the cost fixed for the library. Libraries have a fixed budget, they can't pay per-use because they don't receive income per-use.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by esrauch on Thursday September 02, 2021 @11:04PM (#28399975)
I think op is arguing that somewhere libraries should be able to have reasonably fixed budgets and not have this constraint, though more aggressive legislation that weakens publisher's rights. I think it's possible with things like reducing copyright durations entirely to get a healthier public domain offering instead of books written by people whose grandchildren or even great-grandchildren have died of old age still covered by copyright.

I actually just checked and I think there's no infinity copy ebooks on Libby at all; even books that are long since in the public domain have a fixed number of copies to borrow that presumably the library is still paying someone for per-copy.

Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books by prepend on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:33PM (#28399164)
I use Libby quite a bit with my local library and it is frustrating. But I’m also amazed that publishers allow it at all.

It’s the closest thing we have to a library and unless we special legislation, I think we’re stuck.