Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by blacksmith_tb on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:07PM
(#28394581)
Yes, it could be that 'books' would only be available until they'd been 'borrowed' 100 times, at which point the library would have to buy/license additional 'copies' or patrons just couldn't read it any more. In some ways that seems fine, but there's a sadness to the idea of the library as a repository of knowledge going away, and being replaced by a vending machine.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by nfriedly on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:18PM
(#28394737)
I think the current "3 copies out at a time" model also has a 100 borrows and then the library has to buy it again. limitation. (The number is probably higher than 100, though.)
Edit: I was wrong, it's lower than 100. From the article:
> In 2011, HarperCollins introduced a new lending model that was capped at twenty-six checkouts, after which a library would need to purchase the book again.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by selykg on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:47PM
(#28395109)
Further proof that the library system is just plain being broken by publishers.
There's a lot of bad shit in this world, but oh boy do I wish some of our country's leaders would solve problems like this. We don't elevate youth or those around us by limiting access to knowledge.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by blacksmith_tb on Thursday September 02, 2021 @04:19PM
(#28396853)
That passage though does provide some more details:
"For a classic work, which readers were likely to check out steadily for years to come, a library might purchase a handful of expensive perpetual licenses. With a flashy best-seller, which could be expected to lose steam over time, the library might buy a large number of cheaper licenses that would expire relatively quickly."
At least perpetual licenses are an option.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by pavel_lishin on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:50PM
(#28394363)
I don't think anyone in their right mind would say that e-books should be "pay per use" when borrowed at the library, any more than you'd institute a "pay per use" model with regular books, DVDs, etc.
Re:An app called Libby and the big business of library e-books
by nkurz on Thursday September 02, 2021 @06:46PM
(#28398319)
I don't know if it disproves your "right mind" argument, but here's Overdrive's CEO explaining the advantages of their new "Cost per Circ" model whereby libraries pay a smaller cost for each checkout rather than purchasing items in advance: https://overdrivesteve.com/pursuing-the-holy-grail-of-librar...
But the benefit here is that the expense of the book is predetermined and controllable.
If you were to switch to a model where they're pay per use, fundamentally the amount is lower initially. But what happens when a book is incredibly popular and there aren't any limits on who can read that book. Now the library could be on the hook for a large bill that never would've happened had they had more control over the book. Sure, they could set a limit per book on the per use rules, but say they hit that limit in 6 months out of the year, now the book is just unavailable for the remaining 6 months?
I feel like per use complicates things. I hate the current model, too. But I don't think all libraries are super well funded.