News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by JohnJamesRambo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @01:55PM (#28318221)
https://freetibet.org/about/legal-status-tibet

Imagine being called a minority in a place you are the majority and have lived for centuries before occupation.

https://www.britannica.com/place/Tibet/People

"The population of the region is almost entirely Tibetan, with Han (Chinese), Hui (Chinese Muslims), Monba, Lhoba, and other minority nationalities. Thus, the majority of the people of Tibet have the same ethnic origin, have traditionally practiced the same religion, and speak the same language."

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by hosh on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:10PM (#28318437)
It gets even more complex when you look at the history.

The Yuan dynasty were ruled by the Mongolians. The Mongolians were devout Buddhists and revered the Tibetan Buddhists. The search for reincarnated Tulkas by the Tibetan Buddhists would extend into the Mongolian regions. The imperial family gave a lot of autonomy to Tibet.

The last Imperial dynasty, Qing, was ruled by Manchurians. The Manchurians were a foreign, non-Han ethnic minority, and the imperial family were also devout Buddhists. The Qin emperors gave the Tibetan region autonomy, though they asserted state power by changing the selection process of the lamas back in the late 1800s.

My point is that, even if I disagree with how the CCP is wiping out the Tibetan heritage, this is a outgrowth of centuries of interactions, religion, and politics in that region.

I could also talk about the many ethnic groups in Napal and Himalayan regions, from which the Tibetan Buddhists assimilated many of the shamanic traditions of the region. From those Himalayan shamans perspective, the "lamaists" ganked their traditions and practiced them for the betterment of themselves rather than the betterment of the community. (From the Tibetan Buddhist perspective, those practices were reified within the View of Mahayana, for the betterment of all sentient beings).

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by actuator on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:22PM (#28318591)
> I could also talk about the many ethnic groups in Napal and Himalayan regions, from which the Tibetan Buddhists assimilated many of the shamanic traditions of the region. From those Himalayan shamans perspective, the "lamaists" ganked their traditions and practiced them for the betterment of themselves rather than the betterment of the community.

Even if this is true, it doesn't make what CCP is doing there right. Change can happen from within without a need of a foreign invading force forcing their own philosophy on these people.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by kuraudo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:55PM (#28319006)
Ultimately, it will be less about what is 'right' and more about 'well it happened so long ago in the past and there is nothing we can do about it now'

See the current plight of the Native Americans for what I fear will be the template for decades to come with other minorities.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by justicezyx on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:02PM (#28319104)
> the imperial family were also devout Buddhists.

That is mostly a political gesture to rule Tibet under the qing empire.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by drocer88 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:12PM (#28319220)
"the imperial family were also devout Buddhists."

Do you have a link for this?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by hosh on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:09PM (#28319980)
This was the era I was referring to: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Urn

I was wrong about the dates. It was late 1700s not late 1800s.

This paper is the one I read. It is a book review: https://academia.edu/resource/work/40611694

The book being reviewed is titled, Forging the Golden Urn: the Qing Empire and the Politics of Reincarnation in Tibet. Max Oidtmann

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by MomoXenosaga on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:11PM (#28319204)
Just imagine if woke people invented a time machine. How would they figure out who's the oppressed that deserves to be saved?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by pavlov on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:28PM (#28319445)
If HN had a mute words feature, "woke" would be a good candidate because this word is exclusively used as a boring strawman.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by aww_dang on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:15PM (#28319275)
If I had to guess, it would depend on how those historical figures relate to contemporary partisan politics.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by usaar333 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:39PM (#28318806)
> Imagine being called a minority in a place you are the majority and have lived for centuries before occupation.

There's lots of criticism I'd have for Chinese policy, but this terminology isn't one of them. It's very common to use the term "minority" to refer to a group that is a minority at the national level, but could still be a majority in some local level.

This is true in the American context as well (Native Americans, Native Hawaiians, Mexicans, etc.)

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by smt88 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:00PM (#28319073)
Tibet was a sovereign country foe hundreds of years until it was invaded. It is currently occupied against its will.

If someone believes Tibet to still be an occupied country rather than a part of China, it wouldn't be accurate to call Tibetans a minority.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by kccqzy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:39PM (#28319581)
Someone else in the thread has already made the comparison to native Americans but I'll paraphrase your comment in light of that:

The Native Americans were sovereign countries for hundreds of years until they were invaded. Their land is currently occupied against their will. If someone believes Native American land to still be an occupied country rather than a part of United States it wouldn't be accurate to call native Americans a minority.

The timing matches too: the Chinese ended Tibetan independence in around 1720, around the same time European settlers conquered Native Americans.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by thereare5lights on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:29PM (#28319465)
> Tibet was a sovereign country foe hundreds of years until it was invaded. It is currently occupied against its will.

So's Hawaii, but you don't see anyone giving a damn about that.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by da_chicken on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:17PM (#28319297)
Being a minority is a description of political power as much as sheer demographic statistics. There are cases where minorities are the majority, too. Women make up 51% of the US population, but in virtually every other sense they are a minority. In South Africa during apartheid, the black population could be described as a minority in spite of their actual demographic proportions (over 75%).
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by usaar333 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:55PM (#28320598)
True, but that's a very different definition. Also, IMO, a bit of a confused one that leads to confusion.

e.g. apartheid is often referred to as "white minority rule" - that is the minority oppressing the majority.

Similarly, this gets a little subjective. It's not clear to me in modern liberal democracies that women are a minority politically, because they do in fact have the ability to set policy equally to men (even if they happen to be less present in the political ranks)

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by lostlogin on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:25PM (#28319406)
> There's lots of criticism I'd have for Chinese policy, but this terminology isn't one of them. It's very common to use the term "minority" to refer to a group that is a minority at the national level, but could still be a majority in some local level.

No. If a country annexes a smaller nation, they don’t get to call the invaded population ‘a minority’ just because a stroke of their totalitarian pen made the countries one.

It is true in the American contexts you cite, but you are there you are talking about the same land - not additional grabs.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by ChemSpider on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:00PM (#28319075)
Yeah, but they call them a "minority" within their very own country (Tibet, occupied since 1950).
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by queuebert on Thursday August 26, 2021 @01:59PM (#28318279)
I believe the CCP is encouraging Han to move there until the Tibetans are no longer the majority. They may have already accomplished this, as an accurate census is hard to find.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:10PM (#28318427)
It is difficult, only 8.17% were Han in Tibet according to the 2010 census (probably higher now, but far from 50%), not including military stationed there. Even with the subsidies they are providing, life is fairly hard in Tibet due to the high altitude. Even the high altitude areas of adjacent provinces (which were formerly part of Tibet) don't have many Han in them.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by blahblahblogger on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:44PM (#28318861)
And that's crazy to me.

I would have figured that with the CCP having ~1.5 billion people to choose from, that they could move a few million Han into Tibet (current pop. according to google: 3,648,100).

Even just 1-2 mil could potentially accomplish the CCP's goals?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by chrchang523 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:02PM (#28319091)
This is made more difficult by the fact that Tibetans tend to have biological adaptations to life at that altitude which Han Chinese lack.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:07PM (#28319164)
China isn't that socialist, there is no strong social safety net waiting to bail you out if you move to Tibet. If they can't make a life for themselves in Tibet, they would simply be left to die, so why take the chance?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by MomoXenosaga on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:19PM (#28319341)
Yes in contrast to Xinjiang you can't economically develop Tibet.

Even the CCP can't move mountains. Tibet is only good for tourism.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:25PM (#28320191)
Xinjiang, especially north, has a lot of farm land, a lot of natural resources that are easily accessible, as well a lot of urbanization and industry already. There is a reason it has 25 million people while Tibet only has 2 million. It is already 42% Han, which makes the ethnic tensions with the Uighurs a lot more explosive.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by jahnu on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:57PM (#28319038)
As an anecdote, I visited three Tibetan cities in 2007, including Lhasa and in all three it felt like there was a Tibetan quarter in a predominantly Han city.

In the countryside I'm sure it's not like this but it was quite sad.

You can't even blame Han Chinese who move there. They are fed propaganda by the central government and are given financial incentives to move there.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by 1024core on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:03PM (#28319113)
Anecdata: my buddy's sister (Han) got a job in Tibet, dressing up as a Tibetan for tourists. He jokes, the Westerners can't tell one from the other, so they walk around in "traditional" Tibetan garb, smiling, looking happy. That's their job.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by lostlogin on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:27PM (#28319440)
This is so dark. Now ‘the Peaceful Liberation of Tibet’ is complete.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annexation_of_Tibet_by_the_P...

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by narrator on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:47PM (#28323014)
The way that China exercises its imperialism is unlike the West. The West has shrinking populations and cannot colonize with settlers. They set up resource extraction puppet governments. The Chinese have a growing population and can easily move large numbers of politically loyal Han into areas they wish to control. Expect more of this in the future in Africa and elsewhere.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by vimy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:18PM (#28319314)
I remember articles from 10 years ago alledging China forcefully sterilized Tibetans.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by hosh on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:15PM (#28318496)
Yup. That is a page from the cultural assimilation playbook. This is also why much effort went into building a rail line from the heartlands of China into Tibet, including crazy engineering feats necessary to stabilize soil within the weather extremes of those region.

Another page from the playbook: standardize the official script in which you write the spoken language. That has happened multiple times in Chinese history. And American history too.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by spoonjim on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:12PM (#28318453)
Tibet is a brutal place to live, short of forcing people there I doubt they will get a lot of takers.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by jupp0r on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:23PM (#28318613)
So is Phoenix, for example.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by queuebert on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:53PM (#28321422)
Or Vegas, back in the day.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @01:56PM (#28318235)
So, native Americans?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by swiley on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:08PM (#28318399)
I have yet to meet someone IRL who thinks what was done to native Americans was just and also condemns the CCP for their treatment of minorities.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by VictorPath on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:26PM (#28318653)
> yet to meet someone IRL who thinks what was done to native Americans was just

By was, I presume you mean five years ago, as the US broke the Treaty of Fort Laramie, pepper spraying and sicing guard dogs on natives in Standing Rock in order to build an oil pipeline. The natives testified at the UN human rights council as to what was happening.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_prote...

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by Aunche on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:22PM (#28318598)
How many Americans who condemn the CCP would be in favor of other nations punishing the US for all their atrocities?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by actuator on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:26PM (#28318655)
Is it happening right now as we speak? If we go enough back in time every nation has blood on their hands.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by Aunche on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:33PM (#28318749)
I hope that the Taliban's 1 week takeover of the Afghanistan opens people's eyes as to how little Westerners understand what residents of developing countries perceive to be good or evil.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by actuator on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:39PM (#28318803)
Oh, their presence there was definitely ill thought; so was destabilising it during cold war through the same means that bit them back. For this, tough action for them and their allies did make sense just like it does for CCP at this point.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by Aunche on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:59PM (#28319062)
> For this, tough action for them and their allies did make sense just like it does for CCP at this point.

But why? Would you still support this if the punishment cost you your job? Meanwhile, does this disincentivize the CIA from stirring conflict in another region? I think that biggest weakness with American foreign policy is that it's incapable of distinguishing between geopolitical interests and humanitarian interests. As a result, we aren't particularly good at advancing either.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by thereare5lights on Friday August 27, 2021 @05:01PM (#28332927)
Yep

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_prote...

We're literally still violating treaties with them.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by optimalsolver on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:46PM (#28318891)
>Is it happening right now as we speak?

The Black Lives Matter protests of the past year say yes.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by actuator on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:47PM (#28318908)
and they did vote in a president who at least seems like supports what those protests stood for.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by afandian on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:20PM (#28318557)
Does anyone think what was done to Native Americans was just?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by rayiner on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#28318802)
Not “just” but I suspect most people in the world are indifferent to a more technologically advanced civilization displacing a less technologically advanced one. It’s how most of the world got to be the way it is and most people don’t really think about it too much. In Bangladesh we have the hill people, which we have treated similarly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chittagong_Hill_Tracts_conflic.... People are pretty blase about it when it comes up.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by selimthegrim on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:37PM (#28319561)
I'm assuming it didn't help that Raja Tridiv Roy supported Pakistan in 1971.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by VictorPath on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:27PM (#28318661)
was?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by lucasmullens on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:44PM (#28318867)
It's okay to talk about the past even if things still exist in the present.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by bseidensticker on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:13PM (#28319247)
Sure but using the past tense implies that the thing does not happen anymore.

That's why the Mitch Hedberg bit is funny (I used to do drugs... I still do but I used to, too) is humorous. It subverts your expectation that the thing you "used to do" is a thing you no longer do.

The US used to do horrible things to Natives... it still does but it used to, too.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by vkou on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:18PM (#28318534)
You'll immediately find a lot of those people if you re-frame the question in terms of reparations.

In the same way, there's no shortage of people in America condemning police treatment of HK protestors (Repressed people fighting for freedom), who also support police treatment of BLM protestors (Rioters and lowlifes with no real grievances who just want to ruin everything).

That's because most people don't hold political ideology derived from first principles, they just check what their political tribe likes/hates, and follow suit.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by bpodgursky on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:25PM (#28318639)
Not everyone views reparations are an appropriate response for past injustices. Your framing the situation is a litmus-test aimed at excluding people.

Every human being in history is at the tail of a long line of injustices and atrocities. The current way to fix things today is to look at the situation people are in, today, and remediate as necessary. I'm the 4th generation from eastern european serfs, who were treated as livestock or part of the land. It doesn't affect me today in the slightest. I don't deserve reparations.

This isn't an argument against a social safety net or social welfare. It's an argument against crude race-based cash transfers that ignore who is and isn't hindered today by past injustices.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by vkou on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:27PM (#28318663)
My framing is the only meaningful litmus test. I don't give a shit about feelings, are you going to do anything about past and current injustice, where you can?

The answer, in the United States, is predominantly "No" from both sides of the political spectrum to the first question, and "Mostly No/No" to the second.

I'd also like to point out that even the Soviet Union/the Russian Federation flirted with reparations for victims of Stalin's repression.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by bpodgursky on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:36PM (#28318776)
I apologize if I do not use the Soviet Union as a template for my social justice policies.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by bpodgursky on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#28318333)
Do you think the 17th-century treatment of Native Americans is a good template for the treatment of minority-majority populations?

I'd like to think we've gotten better.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by 8note on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:14PM (#28318485)
From a colonial perspective, colonists got everything they wanted

it's a good template for anyone looking to take sovereignty over somebody else's land.

If you're trying to do that, youre already dropping ethics

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by bpodgursky on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:17PM (#28318533)
Right.. both are bad things. If we could go back in time, we should be telling the US not to abuse and displace the native americans.

I'm confused why there's any disagreement here.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by thereare5lights on Friday August 27, 2021 @05:04PM (#28332948)
Back in time?

Who needs to go back in time? We're literally still abusing them today.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_prote...

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by allemagne on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:17PM (#28318528)
Yes, what was done to native Americans was wrong and should not be done to Tibetans, Uyghurs, Mongolians, or any other ethnicity in China.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by ssijak on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:15PM (#28319276)
What was done to Vietnamese, Syrians, Libyans, Afghans, Iraqis, Somalis, Serbians, etc is also wrong.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by vkazanov on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:16PM (#28318508)
Recent discoveries of cultural genocide of natives in Canada also tells quite a story: children taken from families, school graveyards...

We, Europeans, are a cynical crowd.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by sillyquiet on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:13PM (#28318469)
Not sure of the point of this comment, other than textbook whataboutism.

Yes, the situation with the Native Americans wrt the expansion of European settlement in the Americas is similar.

At the same time, chattel slavery was widespread and common amongst most nations in the world. Should we tolerate a nation today having slavery because it was a thing for us previously?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by sangnoir on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:40PM (#28318821)
The United States governement is not honoring its treaties with the native peoples to this day. This is not just an artifact of the past, but an ongoing injustice. https://www.history.com/news/native-american-broken-treaties
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by sillyquiet on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:19PM (#28319337)
Sure, ok that sucks. Still not sure why this is the topic of conversation in an article about the CCP treatment of a conquered nation.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by sangnoir on Friday August 27, 2021 @09:37AM (#28327635)
You don't see any links with successive US governments treatment of conquered (first) nations? To borrow a Canadian phrase. I think there is value in deep consideration of patterns across time and political ideology, and perhaps draw informed generalizations on certain societal failure modes.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by aww_dang on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:51PM (#28318953)
Judging the past by the standards of the present is problematic at best and regressive in the worst case.

The best examples of the human condition represent a desire to improve on our mistakes. Because we are imperfect, those with the will to do so must always be striving for improvement.

If we appeal to this erroneous view of history, what will future generations be able say of us under the same logic?

If we subscribe to this flawed logic, which past atrocities are not justified to be repeated today?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by tablespoon on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:04PM (#28319123)
> Not sure of the point of this comment, other than textbook whataboutism.

And mission accomplished. Almost all the comments in the top 50% of the page right now aren't talking about the topic of the OP, but rather the distraction from it.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by Quillbert182 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:08PM (#28318396)
Native Americans are not unified by language and religion. They have a wide variety of both of these things.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by yorwba on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:47PM (#28318911)
Tibetans are not unified by language or religion. There are more than a dozen Tibetic languages, and speakers of more distantly related language families like rGyalrongic are also classified as Tibetans by the government. The official policy of one standard language per recognized ethnicity does mean that many of them will have been educated in Lhasa Tibetan at school.

On the religion front, next to the various schools of Tibetan Buddhism, there's also the older Bön and other, less popular religions like Islam.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by mesh on Thursday August 26, 2021 @01:58PM (#28318259)
Native Americans represent 1.7% of the US population: https://minorityhealth.hhs.gov/omh/browse.aspx?lvl=3&lvlid=6...
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by majormajor on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:09PM (#28318405)
What percentage of the population of the land that is now the US did they represent when Europeans first started colonies there?

From the CCP's perspective, would a similar decline in percentage be desirable?

From our historical view of the US, are the actions that got us here praiseworthy?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by jimbob45 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:15PM (#28318501)
To be fair, a majority of the native population died due to the Europeans inadvertently introducing Smallpox. While I agree with your argument as a whole, I would advise against trying to use numerical arguments for Europe's treatment of the natives.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by jfk13 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:46PM (#28318887)
> inadvertently introducing

Not always inadvertently, perhaps:

https://www.history.com/news/colonists-native-americans-smal...

Although that article says that "there’s only one clearly documented instance of a colonial attempt to spread smallpox", the fact that there is any "clearly documented instance" of such an attempt is pretty horrific.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by Cerium on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:33PM (#28318750)
I interpreted their argument to mean that the Native Americans were 100% of the American population before Europeans arrived.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by ceejayoz on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:22PM (#28318594)
In 1491, that number was probably a little different.

Give things 500+ years and Tibetans may be down to 1.7% too.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by utunbu on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:02PM (#28318313)
Tibetan people represent 0.4% of the Chinese population: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_people
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by RHSeeger on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:14PM (#28318495)
But the statement being replied to was

> Imagine being called a minority in a place you are the majority

which implies that only the area of Tibet is being discussed. And

> Tibetan people represent 0.4% of the Chinese population

implies that all of China is being discussed.

So there's a disconnect there. The comment about Native Americans was presumably being read in the context of "Native Americans in the Unites States", which is a context where they are, indeed, a minority.

I expect the original comment about Native Americans was made in the sense of "like how the US treated Native Americans", not "the facts presented (majority, living there for a long time) also apply to the Native Americans". Whereas the reply to that comment was, I assume, made based on the second interpretation.

So not dense or intentional, just a different understanding of what was being said, because of ambiguity.

And, because people like to feel superior and assume everyone interprets everything the same way they do even when ambiguous, the poor responder got a bunch of down votes lumped on them.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by echelon on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:05PM (#28318363)
Tibet isn't China. They got Crimea'd in the "Peaceful Liberation of Tibet"
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by kunagi7 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:39PM (#28318809)
You can't compare pears to apples. Tibet and Crimea annexations were quite different.

Crimea used to be part of Russian Empire and then part of the Russian SSR until it was gifted to Ucranian SSR as a region in 1954. A 65% of the residents are Russians, 16% Ucranians and 12% Crimean Tatars. And most of their population speaks Russian (85%). There were tensions between Russia, Ukraine and Crimea thanks to that transfer (and they haven't disappeared). The annexation was a bad thing economically wise but it was done quite fast and clean.

The Tibet was already under Chinese control since the Qing Dynasty (1720). At that time, Korea was also a vassal state of the Qing Dynasty. The Tibet independence (1911-1950) sadly didn't have any strength (obsolete military, bad and few foreign relations) and they were absorbed by the CCP military. Also, they speak different languages, have different cultures and the Han are still a small minority in the region.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by utunbu on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:13PM (#28318474)
In replying to

> Native Americans represent 1.7% of the US population

I think the analogy between (Tibetan people, China) and (native American people, US) makes sense.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by antonzabirko on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:10PM (#28318426)
Exactly. Similar situation, though. Both countries are being unrightfully claimed.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by cronix on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:18PM (#28318543)
Yes, only 1.7% after 500 years of....being left alone?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by nohr on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:00PM (#28318284)
Are you this dense, or is this on purpose?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by RHSeeger on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:00PM (#28318290)
Native Americans are not the majority in the Americas, outside of reservations. So if you meant "Native Americans on a Native American reservation", then I guess so... but I don't think they're considered a minority in that context, are there?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by stuaxo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:09PM (#28318407)
They clearly were in at one point, which is why the situation is comparable.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:13PM (#28318477)
Also Tibetans aren't the majority in Shanghai, just Tibet - Like native Americans on current reservations, which continued to shrink in size for a long time.
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by 8note on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:16PM (#28318517)
Yeah, the chinese government is looking for a way to get rid of the Tibetans. The Americans have done well in ensuring the native population has lost power and are shrinking. The end goal of china is to be rid of their Tibetan scourge, just like the Americans would like it if the natives stopped existing
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by emkoemko on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:07PM (#28319163)
"just like the Americans would like it if the natives stopped existing" really? why?
Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by thereare5lights on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:28PM (#28319449)
> Imagine being called a minority in a place you are the majority and have lived for centuries before occupation.

Native Hawaiians: Am I a joke to you?

Native Americans: First time?

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by gunfighthacksaw on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:57PM (#28319028)
I don’t think it’s any different from the West considering non-Europeans minorities, or the completely bizarre turn of phrase “majority-minority”.

The hegemon gets to choose the semantics I suppose.

Re:CCP publication calls Tibet policy a template for other e... by superflit on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:16PM (#28319284)
"Imagine being called a minority in a place you are the majority and have lived for centuries before occupation. "

Errrrr like White people in near future US?

And there goes my karma..

[1] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2021/08/12/census-da...