News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:32PM (#28280826)
We really seem to know extraordinarily little about how our bodies work apart from physical mechanics & electrical activity. I can't even put a % on the rest except that we have barely scratched the surface. From epigenetics to the brain, metabolism, and immune system, we have a long way to go.

On the other hand, we've probably made more progress in that understanding during the past 100 years than in all of the time before that. So, if our rate of knowledge acquisition is increasing, maybe that upward hill isn't quite so steep.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by grishka on Monday August 23, 2021 @07:51PM (#28283536)
Well, once we discover a way to prevent or reverse aging, everything else would be a matter of time, of which you would now have an effectively unlimited amount.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by pdm55 on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:45PM (#28283899)
I have never believed the argument that we can develop a way to live to 200. I am now in my mid 60s and it seems that a number of my parts are starting to "wear out". My skin is certainly thinner; my eyesight is damaged (macula degeneration) in one eye; ... And covid has taught us that our immune systems are not as effective as when we were younger. We older folks all see heart and cancer problems over the horizon. Cancer just seems a matter of time: I mean how can our cells keep replicating the 3 billion(?) base pairs in our genomes - with a mistake rate of about 1 per 100 000 (i.e. 30k mistakes per division) - without those eventually leading to cancer? And if I could only remember how to spell that alzyhmr thing, I would mention it also. And why does our government keep sending me those kits for faeces samples? Sorry to disagree with you, but I don't think aging is a reversible process: we seem to have too many parts, each with an "expiry date".
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by dwohnitmok on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @02:01AM (#28285574)
The main reason why it seems like it's not just a matter of "parts wearing out" is that different animals all age at different rates, but strikingly they all seem to age in similar ways.

For example while dogs have a much shorter lifespan than humans they seem to face all the same age-related declines humans face. This holds for animals close to or exceeding our mass as well. If different parts of the body wore out simply due to e.g. mechanical stress, you would expect e.g. dog joints to be perfectly healthy after 15 years since they are biologically very similar to human joints, when in fact dogs tend to still have arthritic and otherwise fragile joints at 15 (or earlier).

Everything declining together, just on different timetables in different animals, seems to suggest that aging is controlled by either a single mechanism or some interwoven set of mechanisms that cause everything to fail at the same time, rather than individual parts failing because "they wear out." If you could target that mechanism(s) then maybe you can make humans live as long as e.g. tortoises. But of course we haven't confirmed that such things exist, but the above is at least some motivation for why they might exist.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by honzzz on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @02:37AM (#28285756)
I would guess it is because there was no evolutionary pressure to have joints that can sustain 80 years if there are other parts of body that only sustain 18. Maybe I am missing something but I would expect that life expectancy of various parts of body of each specie converge because of that.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by dwohnitmok on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @03:14AM (#28285928)
Evolution is rarely so tidy in its convergence. Humans have vestigial organs and crazy anatomical features left over from our ancestors. In light of that it would be a rather stunning coincidence to find that when it comes to aging across species (!) that organisms seem to have all their systems age at the same rate simply by individual evolution of each of those systems or that all the systems are effectively immortal with nothing in-between.

Without a coherent theory of senescence this is all conjecture, but there's compelling evidence that there's some set of hidden variables we aren't seeing that is "pulling the strings" when it comes to aging.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by honzzz on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @09:08AM (#28288335)
What compelling evidence?
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by dwohnitmok on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @05:42PM (#28295355)
On reflection evidence is too strong a word given that we don't have a good, specific hypothesis for what's going on. Observations of the sort I laid out above.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by grishka on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @08:38AM (#28288000)
Not a biologist, but I'm following related research and at this point am fairly convinced that aging is an intentional, pre-programmed process, as opposed to the popular understanding that it's the consequence of wear and tear.

Let's just think logically about it for a bit. Your cells come with all kinds of repair machinery and redundant DNA encoding. All cells do. But there are single-celled creatures that don't age and reproduce by cell division, and they haven't lost their function despite billions of years and millions of generations. Same for humans and whoever else reproduces sexually — there's A LOT that needs to go just right for a new human to be born, including making billions of copies of parents' DNA, yet it does work just fine most of the time. This tells us that the DNA copying process must be very robust, and that with age, it's these mechanisms that keep everything in check that deliberately get weaker or stop working altogether.

Recent research proves it.

For example, there's evidence that organisms propagate their age throughout all tissues using some kind of signaling in the bloodstream: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms13363

Even more bizarre, the aging clock, as determined by DNA methylation, gets reset to zero at the beginning of embryonal development: https://hplus.club/blog/how-and-when-mother-nature-resets-th...

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ak217 on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @01:03PM (#28291696)
You're not wrong, but your models of aging events seem to be too simplistic. Aging is not one process but a complex of interacting processes.

There are definitely a number of processes involved in aging that are pre-programmed as you suggest, namely the hormonal clocks involved in puberty and maturation, and then later senescence.

It's not particularly useful to compare humans/mammals to single-celled organisms, which operate under way fewer constraints. They don't have to deal with cancer, as just one very basic example. They also don't have to figure out how to clear old junk from their tissues and individual cells. They just start over with a clean slate every time.

Signals in the bloodstream - various hormones and immune cells - are obviously involved in aging. But there are many of them, and we are just starting to understand their different interactions. There is no doubt that aging research is going to yield ways to suppress or promote the action of certain hormones, replenish/reactivate certain stem cell populations, etc. but better understanding of intercellular regulatory networks is needed for that.

To call DNA methylation the determinant of an "aging clock" is also too narrow or simplistic. DNA methylation is the mechanism of cell differentiation, but it's "metadata" that has to be copied over between cells when they divide, just like the DNA itself. Early in embryogenesis, the DNA methylation pattern is reset and overwritten using the regulatory cascade of master control genes (homeobox, etc.) - so it is expected that the methylation pattern will have lower fidelity with each division cycle before or after that point.

This is the golden age of biology - we have just gotten a hold of the tools that will let us solve these problems - but it's messy and complicated. Investing in your understanding of these processes can have a huge payoff - I recommend reading some of the Nature Reviews articles like https://www.nature.com/nrg/ - I've always found them to be incredibly helpful in summarizing the state of the art.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by nrdvana on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @03:52AM (#28286101)
Every cell in your entire body (on average) gets replaced over a 7 year span. If you figure that you stopped growing around 18, and your body has been slowly replicating itself since then, it completed the first full replication at 25, the second at 32, the third at 39, the fourth at 46, etc. Each time you accumulate some chaos. As the chaos grows, the cell groups decline in performance. The decline in performance makes it more likely that the next replication will be even worse.

While that makes it really unlikely that aging can be reversed, it certainly isn’t logically impossible. All you need to do is expell the chaos, and get one good quality regeneration (possibly taking about 7 years) and then you’d be right back to 18 years old again. That might make it worthwhile enough to be willing to have your body burned by a billion laser shots and float in a vat of liquid for 7 years. We might get to find out in our lifetimes? who knows.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by gscott on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @04:06AM (#28286179)
Good movie on the subject https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8548830/
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by finolex1 on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @01:10AM (#28285313)
Not a biologist, but certain sharks, whales and tortoises have been known to live for >150 years, so I suppose it is theoretically possible.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ejolto on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @06:38AM (#28287010)
Greenland shark reach sexual maturity at 150 years, and can live for over 400 years according to Wikipedia.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by snvzz on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @12:19PM (#28290895)
SENS[0] is engineering (not discovering) a way. And they are not that far off.

[0]: https://www.sens.org/

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by KSteffensen on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @06:20AM (#28286911)
I would not want to be born into a society where everyone else has lived for hundreds of years.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by grishka on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @08:49AM (#28288127)
In a society where there's a cure for aging, dying of old age would be regarded the same way as we would think today of a person who dies of a bacterial infection by refusing to take antibiotics. Yet bacterial infections used to be inevitably deadly for most of the human history.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by r00f on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @04:12AM (#28286215)
if we do, we will die of starvation and pollution pretty soon, unless we start making wonders really fast
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @09:53AM (#28288844)
I think that would be very difficult without a much better understanding of our bodies, so it becomes a chicken/egg problem. Aging isn't really just one thing, it is a constellation of factors that often comingle to make the process even worse. I frequently see Telomere "reset" referenced as the big thing that would win or achieved the most gains in the war on aging, but that seems like it would only be an incremental gain. Here's a good overview on the topic:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4712935/

Also consider that long life may not produce the advancements you might hope for. There's a saying: "Science progresses one funeral at a time." It's a reference to the fact that individuals typically hold fast to their ideas-- scientists included. Certainly we may react to & integrate new knowledge, but at some fundamental level we are hindered by the cognitive foundations of knowledge laid down when we're younger that are not automatically escaped on new information. That's not even accounting for pride & ego causing people to cling even more fiercely to their own ideas.

You might think that on ongoing infusion of new talent would prevent this, but massively extended age would also entrench the older generations firmly into the power structures of the scientific community, creating at least a partial gerontocracy. Heck we have a bit of that now: Plenty of PhD candidates get stuck "playing the game" and not bucking the status quo too much, only guided down paths their advisors find acceptable. If you have something that significantly contradicts the current consensus, then without a very good & open minded advisor willing to go to bat for you, you might as well shelve it, do something mundane & acceptable for your dissertation, and dust off that other idea when you're done. This situation would not improve with the further ossification of power structures.

If we got there though-- massively extended lifespans, the gerontocracy aspect of things in society in general would be also be a difficult sociological issue. With a 300 year lifespan, by the time you got to 200 you would probably consider anyone under the age of 50 as little more than children. The issue of wealth inequality would be incredible as generational wealth accumulated by anyone remotely careful with their finances would, by late-middle age, dwarf the resources of anyone starting out.

There could be some interesting & positive aspects to all of that though too. Imagine have half a century to explore intellectually or otherwise before you were expect to settle into a path in life. And if we found societal of medical methods to help people break out of psychological & intellectual inertia then a person might expect to have multiple very different careers in their lifetime.

Anyway, all of that would be a very long ways off. At my age I might still hope that leaps in medical advances could give me an extra 10 years of productive healthy life, but probably not much more. And I've also gone a long ways off the original topic, so I'll end it here.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amrcnimgrnt on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:36PM (#28284201)
You can't reverse aging, that's a violation of the second law of thermodynamics.

You might be able to restore the body's ability to regenerate itself. But that's a terrible idea. I shudder at the idea of living to 120, never mind 200. Imagine being born in 1821 and having to live today. Imagine how confusing that would be.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by anyfoo on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:25PM (#28284772)
> You can't reverse aging, that's a violation of the second law of thermodynamics.

Next time someone asks me to do the dishes, I will tell them the same. Hopefully they also forgot about the sun providing energy into the system.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amrcnimgrnt on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:58PM (#28323850)
Now start doing the math for how much power (I made it easy, I I'm only asking for the rate) that is required to keep someone alive indefinitely.

Don't cheat! Don't use the caloric needs of a fully grown adult. Their bodies stoically accept a lot of the damage done by entropy. You have expend additional energy to reverse it.

Don't cheat, remember to account for a population growth rate == the current birth rate.

If you don't like having to account for the growth rate, please give a moral explanation for why some select few get to live forever and others croak.

How much power do you need? How are you supplying this power? It's cute to say "Sun". But solar panels (let's assume 100% efficient) require surface area that would otherwise be used by plant and animals for their existence.

So live forever by

1. Radically transforming the Earth into a massive ball of polycrystalline silicon 2. Giving eternity to only a (very) select few.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by elzbardico on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:48PM (#28284289)
>You can't reverse aging, that's a violation of the second law of thermodynamics.

We are not closed Systems

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amrcnimgrnt on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:48PM (#28323800)
Reversing the flow of aging is reversing entropy locally, so you're, overall, increasing entropy more outside of your body.

The live forever types are just assuming that energy will be plentiful enough to sustain hundreds of billions of people indefinitely [1] and heat easy to dissipate

[1] The population of the earth is stable at 7 billion only because people have this nasty habit of dying. If we stopped doing that, the population would grow exponentially at the birth rate of 1.7%. Or a doubling every 42 years. In 160 years (not that far off from the current record of longevity) the world's population would hit 100 billion people.

Of course the "live forever" types never mention that eternity is a promise for the privileged, and not for the masses.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by distantaidenn on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:17PM (#28284747)
Huh? If you were an immortal, you don't just suddenly appear out of time. A person born in 1821 and still alive today would know more about the world than anyone else.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by anyfoo on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:28PM (#28284784)
Yeah. I was born and lived before the Internet (in its widespread form) existed. Life was very different back then, and I am not confused.

As long as changes happen gradually, I don't see the problem. If they don't, people of almost all ages will be confused.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amrcnimgrnt on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:53PM (#28324120)
"Yeah. I was born and lived before the Internet (in its widespread form) existed."

So you're in-between the age of 40 to 60? Let's say you're 60, born in 1961:

- Your local pop radio station often plays a rock song from your adolescence. The Queen of Pop whose posters adorned your room and so scandalized your grand-parents still sings at the Super Bowl.

- The Star Wars movie you geeked out as a teen/young adult has become a billion dollar franchise your grandkids drag you to

- The ATM you learned to use thirty years ago are still around basically unchanged.

- the quarter the tooth fairy left you as a kid that you found in the tin can of boyhood treasures is still accepted as currency

Compare that to a 60 year old person born in 1820.

They have yet to have seen a train: most people in the world at the time lived their whole lives in their villages far from any railroad. China's first railroad was built in 1875, and quickly dismantled. (China, alone, in the 19th century had between 30 to 38% of the world population)

Most likely this person lives in feudally arranged society. The emancipation of the serfs in Russia was in the mid 1800s, and that was the last of the European countries to remove feudalism.

In the anglo saxon world, women were effective properties of their spouses.

The superiority/inferiority of races was obvious to the learned classes.

Slavery was practiced throughout the world except Europe and then the US.

Homosexuality was punishable by execution most everwhere in the world

Sexual roles were well defined and strictly obeyed according to local customs (i.e. they weren't universal norms, but norms existed universally).

The only way to fly was in a hot air baloon. The only people who ever witnessed this lived in Paris or in London

Steel existed but was extremely expensive and not used for construction. Wrought iron was used instead, and it was a brittle mess that resulted in catastrophes. As a result the buildings in urban areas were typically no more than 6 stories high. Religious buildings were much taller, but projects that took centuries to build.

Communicating with someone across the Atlantic took weeks.

Now, let's say our hypothetical person living in 1880 and born in 1820 lived another 60 years.

The airplane is invented and used to devastating effect in multiple wars

The automobile is invented, and by 1940 mass produced.

Throughout the world, therefore, buses provide transport to remote area that aren't serviceable by rail

Skyscrapers pop up.

A world war has impacted most people in the world. A new one has just started.

A communist society exists and has mechanized death killing millions.

Telecommunication, first by wired-telegraph, then by wireless telegraph, and finally by radio exists and enables instant communication across the globe. The most remote villages can receive the BBC world service, often in their native language.

Our gentleman most likely wouldn't be aware of this development but classical physics has been shattered, the concept of time turned upside down. The atomic era has also begun, but most people will be blissfully unaware for another 5 years.

Penicillin is about to revolutionize life expectancy.

I think this person born in 1820 would be very uncomfortable if living today.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @03:26AM (#28285977)
Related: the movie “The Man from Earth”
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by mucle6 on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @11:12AM (#28289905)
I'd take being confused over being dead
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amrcnimgrnt on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:56PM (#28324134)
You haven't thought it through. It's terrible to be confused, whereas, it's nothing to be dead. You just rot, blissfully unaware.

Unless you're religious. Then it's not death you should fear, but the judgement.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amelius on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:43PM (#28280950)
Things can really speed up once we have robots that grow cells and perform experiments on them, and collect (big) data and automatically analyze the data.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by asdff on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:56PM (#28281123)
People already can grow up billions of cells for experiments and use supercomputers to process terabytes of sequencing data with statistical modelling. The hard part isn't the scale, but designing experiments and figuring out what evidence is needed to answer specific biological questions. That stuff you can't speed up with robotic arms and more processor cores, it takes time for people to think about these things and have conversations with others about these topics.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by EamonnMR on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:04PM (#28281220)
Not to mention the amount of time experiments take-suppose we want to know if a drug prevents an illness that takes decades to develop? Sure you can model it in a mouse, but to do that you need to know exactly what the parameters of your model are.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amelius on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:49PM (#28281734)
I'm not so sure about that. For example, with robots you can run "for GENE in GENOME do ..." For humans even thinking about what that statement does is a lot of work already!
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by mythrwy on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:00PM (#28282528)
It's not a one dimensional problem though. There is a lot of interaction between the various systems in a human body.

To keep with the programming analogy, ya, you can see the SUM statement and that is necessary to understand, but what is it for? What is it's role in the larger program? Where do it's inputs come from? Where do they go? What effect does changing it have in other places?

I do agree our knowledge of genetics etc. will be much expanded soon. But we'll probably also make some nasty errors.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amelius on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:15PM (#28282697)
> There is a lot of interaction between the various systems in a human body.

Yes, the interactions are the interesting bit. Perhaps we can figure out the biological pathways at the cellular level by taking a systematic approach of turning genes on/off and turning their expression on/off, then looking at the expression of other genes. This is exactly what could be done by robots.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ethanbond on Monday August 23, 2021 @07:19PM (#28283300)
I think you’re seriously underestimating the scale of the genome and the number of possible combinations that might be responsible for some phenotype, even assuming the genotype -> phenotype causality was straightforward (which it’s not).

This is simply not a problem we’re going to computer our way through, at least until we have large scale quantum computers and way better data than we have today.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by jcims on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:45PM (#28284260)
Naively, a small protein of ~100 amino acid residues has ~21^100 configurations. Amino acids average 110 Daltons each (110g/mol), you would need approximately 3*10^107kg of matter to build them all. There is an estimated 10^53kg of matter in the known universe.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ezconnect on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:10PM (#28281293)
The problem is how do we sense and measure them. Once we invent the methods of sensing, measuring and observing a single process we need a million more for the other process and that takes time.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by amelius on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:51PM (#28281756)
There are various techniques for that. For example with RNAseq you can measure which genes are expressed as a result of an experiment.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by jes on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:42PM (#28281654)
I was having a discussion with a friend yesterday and we got onto the topic of vaccinations.

To my knowledge, while we can develop a statistical assessment of a vaccine's safety, we can never know how the vaccine will affect a specific person that takes it. My argument here is that the human body is so fantastically complex that no two cases are ever the same, and so the only way to know how a vaccine will affect a person is to run the experiment, by having them take it.

I think this is one attribute of what are called "Wicked Problems": The only way to know if a change is going to be an improvement or not is to make the change and see how the system state evolves forward in time.

Is this roughly correct?

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:03PM (#28282560)
We have a very bare minimum of knowledge for individual treatment, but only in a very few cases. There are genetic markers known, for example, to impact metabolism of specific medications, and there are tests (Genesight) to find out your own profile. So there is some very minimal progress on that front. It's a start towards personalized treatments, but we don't always know why a specific genetic marker doesn't work the same way or why an enzyme has such a large impact on things.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by teekert on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:59PM (#28281854)
Not really, we can test a drug on a large population and determine it to be effective on 5% of all people. With no further info you know you have about a 5% chance of getting better. With more research we may determine that for people with a specific variant in their DNA the succes rate is 60%, so you can be part of two groups. We can keep making it better, maybe never 100% but very from “a gamble”.

Would you say that hopping on a plane is an experiment in testing if it will crash? When you know it very likely will not?

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Vrondi on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @12:25AM (#28285097)
Your plane analogy would only work if every passenger had a unique plane due to genetics, epigentics, etc.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by teekert on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @04:10AM (#28286201)
I’d say it’s more like we have a lot of similar genetics (the plane) and then some small differences (the seat you are in) but yeah the analogy is a stretch, “similar” is not really a quantitative term but I think you are assuming we are more different then we really are. But that also varies per parameter.

For example there is a reason we test drugs on mice, because they are pretty similar to us (mammals), of course there are also differences.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by dd36 on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:58PM (#28281848)
Evolution says hi.

I like Kevin Kelly’s technium concept. We are merely an extension of evolution and our purpose is to continue it, which we do willingly and unwillingly.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:35PM (#28284551)
Yes, you are absolutly correct.

The reason for this is that living things are evolved, rather than designed.

We have seen that even in very simple hardware, when using a genetically evolved design, we end up having circuits that functions as per the requirement [1]. But it ended up being very hard to figure out how the thing actually worked, and when components were removed that seemingly did not have any purpose, the thing stopped working.

And this, in my opinion, points to a very important aspect of evolved systems. We can only have a statistical assessment as you say. But no way to say for sure that, "This and this alone will be the only effect of an intervention".

But we can have some idea, depending on the type of intervention. For example, we can say that something that was part of the evolution, will not interfere with its working, simply because evolution has taken it into account during the process. And here comes the concept of something being "natural" to the organism. So we can say that stuff that is taken orally, is much safer than injected stuff. All through our evolution, we have been taking stuff orally. So a Vaccine is much more like throwing a spanner into our workings, than taking something taken orally. Similarly stuff that were part of our natural environment, during evolution can be considered as safer, as opposed to stuff that were not.

I think this is why mocking the concept of "natural", by saying, "Everything is natural, because it is found in nature", is embarrassingly missing the point..

[1] https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by skulk on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:05PM (#28281928)
It points to an interesting gap in discourse around vaccines.

One side (the mainstream) claims vaccines are effective and safe. The other side, claims that no, we do not in fact know that the vaccine is safe and therefore you should not get it and take your chances with the disease.

The problem is that we don't in fact know that the vaccines are truly safe for everyone, because mRNA technology (while incredible) is new, but from my personal interactions I've observed that most intelligent people see that getting the vaccine increases your expected quality of life given you've never had COVID before. However, those who don't believe this will take any claim made by the mainstream (vaccines are safe) as evidence that they are hiding something, further deepening their suspicions.

This is a feedback loop; the more people that refuse the vaccine, the more the mainstream will push for more vaccinations, causing more people to refuse the vaccine. All because the nuance of "we don't know that this is as safe as taking a walk in the sun, but we have solid evidence that it improves your E[QOL]" isn't easy to communicate.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by endgame on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:22PM (#28282148)
More precisely, "the other side" claims that we do not in fact know the vaccine is safe, and points to all the other times "the mainstream" side lied to us as reasons to be skeptical: the US Surgeon-General told us "masks don't work", lying to manage supply, now they're critical; Biden said "get vaccinated, or wear a mask until you do", now the masks are going back on; Kamala Harris said she wouldn't take a Trump vaccine, now there's a big fight over mandates and passports; Fauci kept dangling a vaccine target just beyond what the country was tracking towards (there are articles where he's quoted as saying "I can nudge this up a bit"); Cuomo was hailed as some great leader despite sending covid-positive people into old people's homes (it was his sexual misconduct that finally sunk him).

Hesitancy around covid vaccines isn't the antivax of the previous generation, and responding as if it was won't help anything. Actually having an honest conversation with the public that you're more likely better off with a vaccine is not an easy concept to communicate (as you correctly point out), but it would be a good first step in trying to rebuild that lost trust.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:41PM (#28283869)
It has definitely become partisan, but not all of it is inconsistent. For example Biden said "wear a mask until you do" before the massive rise of Delta and our knowledge that it causes breakthrough infection. Once we knew that, it made sense to start wearing masks again because we found out that vaccines will be less effective against Delta.

Cuomo was held up as a great example when it looked like he had done a good job, but then when screwups were revealed opinions rightfully began to change.

By all means let's point out the ridiculous partisan aspects of this debacle, or out & out screwups like initial mask guidance. But also recognize that in plenty of cases a change of stance is not partisan or contradictory, it's the rational response to new information.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by jcims on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:55PM (#28284325)
>it's the rational response to new information

The challenge is that guidance not regularly delivered with any caveats or margins of error. I think this is a mechanism to try to drive compliance up through a posture of confidence, but when the guidance ultimately flip-flops it just looks like either people are lying or they don't know what they are talking about.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by endgame on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:26PM (#28284126)
https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2021/01/07/22334/ Cuomo has been known-terrible for a long time.

---

https://unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/delta-variant-... discusses "The Hammer and the Dance", an article published in March 2020, that correctly flagged the risk of mutations.

https://twitter.com/WSJ/status/1368229958158610435 https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-19-variant-in-brazil-over...

WSJ, writing in March 2021: "countries such as Brazil risk becoming a breeding ground for potent versions of the virus that could render current Covid-19 vaccines less effective, public-health specialists warned." Biden's "wear a mask until you do" was in May - very irresponsible.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @02:06AM (#28285604)
>we do not in fact know that the vaccine is safe

It would go a long way in these discussion if you make it clear which vaccine you are talking about.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Vrondi on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @12:23AM (#28285086)
Yes, this is correct. For example, give most people most vaccines, and they will be fine. However, some vaccines will cause a few people in every 100,000 or so to develop ITP, which can mean a brief period of bruising and bleeding (as your immune system eats your blood platelets) that clears up with simple steroids, or it can mean longer term or even chronic illness, splenectomy, even death. We have zero way to predict this for any given person. The same is true of other "rare" reactions.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Cort3z on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:06PM (#28281945)
With this reasoning you can't know if drinking water is good for you without drinking it, so bringing vaccines into the mix has nothing to do with it.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:59PM (#28283983)
Yes, and even after 30 years you might still say, "but what about 50? What about 70? How do we know it won't contaminate our bodies after death and leach dangerous toxins into the soil hundreds of years from now when our coffins break down?"

At some point you have to decide to balance the risk in some way and make a choice. Or live your life in a perpetual state of epistemic uncertainty & indecision. In most cases people are fine doing this: very few people refuse to drive over the unlikely possibility of a fatal car accident, or live in a basement on the remote possibility that a tree or meteor will fall on their home.

Unfortunately in this case, politics entered the equation. People cling to epistemic uncertainty to justify consistency with their political allegiance rather than make a decision on the basis of balanced risk, because they they have chosen a balance point that would make them an agoraphobic recluse if applied consistently across their life.

I withhold that judgement for those who are reluctant due to the "emergency" approval (in the US) but plan to get vaccinated when fully approved (which Pfizer now has received). I might disagree, but I think a rational person could still balance their risk on that "emergency approval" point. So long as they also are consistent in their application of risk balancing to recognize that strong precautions to avoid infection were required in the meantime.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @01:50AM (#28285523)
>very few people refuse to drive over the unlikely possibility of a fatal car accident, or live in a basement on the remote possibility that a tree or meteor will fall on their home.

That is because there is no media that is fear mongering on these things by reporting 24x7 on every car accident in gruesome details, and run reports on how driving in a car is very dangerous, when there is a chance that one of the thounsand other drivers that you come across on the road might be a crazed, drunk, distracted person that could hit you, support it with "statistics", and just because you survived the last trip, does not mean that you ll survive the next.

They will also run stories about these "anti-walk" persons who took a car or bike, but died in a horrible crashes.

The point is, everything is a line between risk and benefits, and when the risk and benefits are a matter of perception, media has great potential to come in and set where that line is..

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:39PM (#28284572)
As I said in comment above, we know that drinking water cannot be bad for us, because all organism drank water all through their evolution, and if it was bad in some way, natural selection would have selected those that incurred damages caused by water drinking...

But it didn't happen even after so many years, so we know that drinking water did not make us less capable.