News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by jes on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:42PM (#28281654)
I was having a discussion with a friend yesterday and we got onto the topic of vaccinations.

To my knowledge, while we can develop a statistical assessment of a vaccine's safety, we can never know how the vaccine will affect a specific person that takes it. My argument here is that the human body is so fantastically complex that no two cases are ever the same, and so the only way to know how a vaccine will affect a person is to run the experiment, by having them take it.

I think this is one attribute of what are called "Wicked Problems": The only way to know if a change is going to be an improvement or not is to make the change and see how the system state evolves forward in time.

Is this roughly correct?

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:03PM (#28282560)
We have a very bare minimum of knowledge for individual treatment, but only in a very few cases. There are genetic markers known, for example, to impact metabolism of specific medications, and there are tests (Genesight) to find out your own profile. So there is some very minimal progress on that front. It's a start towards personalized treatments, but we don't always know why a specific genetic marker doesn't work the same way or why an enzyme has such a large impact on things.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by teekert on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:59PM (#28281854)
Not really, we can test a drug on a large population and determine it to be effective on 5% of all people. With no further info you know you have about a 5% chance of getting better. With more research we may determine that for people with a specific variant in their DNA the succes rate is 60%, so you can be part of two groups. We can keep making it better, maybe never 100% but very from “a gamble”.

Would you say that hopping on a plane is an experiment in testing if it will crash? When you know it very likely will not?

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Vrondi on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @12:25AM (#28285097)
Your plane analogy would only work if every passenger had a unique plane due to genetics, epigentics, etc.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by teekert on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @04:10AM (#28286201)
I’d say it’s more like we have a lot of similar genetics (the plane) and then some small differences (the seat you are in) but yeah the analogy is a stretch, “similar” is not really a quantitative term but I think you are assuming we are more different then we really are. But that also varies per parameter.

For example there is a reason we test drugs on mice, because they are pretty similar to us (mammals), of course there are also differences.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by dd36 on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:58PM (#28281848)
Evolution says hi.

I like Kevin Kelly’s technium concept. We are merely an extension of evolution and our purpose is to continue it, which we do willingly and unwillingly.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:35PM (#28284551)
Yes, you are absolutly correct.

The reason for this is that living things are evolved, rather than designed.

We have seen that even in very simple hardware, when using a genetically evolved design, we end up having circuits that functions as per the requirement [1]. But it ended up being very hard to figure out how the thing actually worked, and when components were removed that seemingly did not have any purpose, the thing stopped working.

And this, in my opinion, points to a very important aspect of evolved systems. We can only have a statistical assessment as you say. But no way to say for sure that, "This and this alone will be the only effect of an intervention".

But we can have some idea, depending on the type of intervention. For example, we can say that something that was part of the evolution, will not interfere with its working, simply because evolution has taken it into account during the process. And here comes the concept of something being "natural" to the organism. So we can say that stuff that is taken orally, is much safer than injected stuff. All through our evolution, we have been taking stuff orally. So a Vaccine is much more like throwing a spanner into our workings, than taking something taken orally. Similarly stuff that were part of our natural environment, during evolution can be considered as safer, as opposed to stuff that were not.

I think this is why mocking the concept of "natural", by saying, "Everything is natural, because it is found in nature", is embarrassingly missing the point..

[1] https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by skulk on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:05PM (#28281928)
It points to an interesting gap in discourse around vaccines.

One side (the mainstream) claims vaccines are effective and safe. The other side, claims that no, we do not in fact know that the vaccine is safe and therefore you should not get it and take your chances with the disease.

The problem is that we don't in fact know that the vaccines are truly safe for everyone, because mRNA technology (while incredible) is new, but from my personal interactions I've observed that most intelligent people see that getting the vaccine increases your expected quality of life given you've never had COVID before. However, those who don't believe this will take any claim made by the mainstream (vaccines are safe) as evidence that they are hiding something, further deepening their suspicions.

This is a feedback loop; the more people that refuse the vaccine, the more the mainstream will push for more vaccinations, causing more people to refuse the vaccine. All because the nuance of "we don't know that this is as safe as taking a walk in the sun, but we have solid evidence that it improves your E[QOL]" isn't easy to communicate.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by endgame on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:22PM (#28282148)
More precisely, "the other side" claims that we do not in fact know the vaccine is safe, and points to all the other times "the mainstream" side lied to us as reasons to be skeptical: the US Surgeon-General told us "masks don't work", lying to manage supply, now they're critical; Biden said "get vaccinated, or wear a mask until you do", now the masks are going back on; Kamala Harris said she wouldn't take a Trump vaccine, now there's a big fight over mandates and passports; Fauci kept dangling a vaccine target just beyond what the country was tracking towards (there are articles where he's quoted as saying "I can nudge this up a bit"); Cuomo was hailed as some great leader despite sending covid-positive people into old people's homes (it was his sexual misconduct that finally sunk him).

Hesitancy around covid vaccines isn't the antivax of the previous generation, and responding as if it was won't help anything. Actually having an honest conversation with the public that you're more likely better off with a vaccine is not an easy concept to communicate (as you correctly point out), but it would be a good first step in trying to rebuild that lost trust.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:41PM (#28283869)
It has definitely become partisan, but not all of it is inconsistent. For example Biden said "wear a mask until you do" before the massive rise of Delta and our knowledge that it causes breakthrough infection. Once we knew that, it made sense to start wearing masks again because we found out that vaccines will be less effective against Delta.

Cuomo was held up as a great example when it looked like he had done a good job, but then when screwups were revealed opinions rightfully began to change.

By all means let's point out the ridiculous partisan aspects of this debacle, or out & out screwups like initial mask guidance. But also recognize that in plenty of cases a change of stance is not partisan or contradictory, it's the rational response to new information.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by jcims on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:55PM (#28284325)
>it's the rational response to new information

The challenge is that guidance not regularly delivered with any caveats or margins of error. I think this is a mechanism to try to drive compliance up through a posture of confidence, but when the guidance ultimately flip-flops it just looks like either people are lying or they don't know what they are talking about.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by endgame on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:26PM (#28284126)
https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2021/01/07/22334/ Cuomo has been known-terrible for a long time.

---

https://unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/delta-variant-... discusses "The Hammer and the Dance", an article published in March 2020, that correctly flagged the risk of mutations.

https://twitter.com/WSJ/status/1368229958158610435 https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-19-variant-in-brazil-over...

WSJ, writing in March 2021: "countries such as Brazil risk becoming a breeding ground for potent versions of the virus that could render current Covid-19 vaccines less effective, public-health specialists warned." Biden's "wear a mask until you do" was in May - very irresponsible.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @02:06AM (#28285604)
>we do not in fact know that the vaccine is safe

It would go a long way in these discussion if you make it clear which vaccine you are talking about.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Vrondi on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @12:23AM (#28285086)
Yes, this is correct. For example, give most people most vaccines, and they will be fine. However, some vaccines will cause a few people in every 100,000 or so to develop ITP, which can mean a brief period of bruising and bleeding (as your immune system eats your blood platelets) that clears up with simple steroids, or it can mean longer term or even chronic illness, splenectomy, even death. We have zero way to predict this for any given person. The same is true of other "rare" reactions.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by Cort3z on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:06PM (#28281945)
With this reasoning you can't know if drinking water is good for you without drinking it, so bringing vaccines into the mix has nothing to do with it.
Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by ineedasername on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:59PM (#28283983)
Yes, and even after 30 years you might still say, "but what about 50? What about 70? How do we know it won't contaminate our bodies after death and leach dangerous toxins into the soil hundreds of years from now when our coffins break down?"

At some point you have to decide to balance the risk in some way and make a choice. Or live your life in a perpetual state of epistemic uncertainty & indecision. In most cases people are fine doing this: very few people refuse to drive over the unlikely possibility of a fatal car accident, or live in a basement on the remote possibility that a tree or meteor will fall on their home.

Unfortunately in this case, politics entered the equation. People cling to epistemic uncertainty to justify consistency with their political allegiance rather than make a decision on the basis of balanced risk, because they they have chosen a balance point that would make them an agoraphobic recluse if applied consistently across their life.

I withhold that judgement for those who are reluctant due to the "emergency" approval (in the US) but plan to get vaccinated when fully approved (which Pfizer now has received). I might disagree, but I think a rational person could still balance their risk on that "emergency approval" point. So long as they also are consistent in their application of risk balancing to recognize that strong precautions to avoid infection were required in the meantime.

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @01:50AM (#28285523)
>very few people refuse to drive over the unlikely possibility of a fatal car accident, or live in a basement on the remote possibility that a tree or meteor will fall on their home.

That is because there is no media that is fear mongering on these things by reporting 24x7 on every car accident in gruesome details, and run reports on how driving in a car is very dangerous, when there is a chance that one of the thounsand other drivers that you come across on the road might be a crazed, drunk, distracted person that could hit you, support it with "statistics", and just because you survived the last trip, does not mean that you ll survive the next.

They will also run stories about these "anti-walk" persons who took a car or bike, but died in a horrible crashes.

The point is, everything is a line between risk and benefits, and when the risk and benefits are a matter of perception, media has great potential to come in and set where that line is..

Re:Mosquito saliva alone has profound effects on the human i... by higherup on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:39PM (#28284572)
As I said in comment above, we know that drinking water cannot be bad for us, because all organism drank water all through their evolution, and if it was bad in some way, natural selection would have selected those that incurred damages caused by water drinking...

But it didn't happen even after so many years, so we know that drinking water did not make us less capable.