News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by yock on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:00AM (#2821496)
The real issue here is not the hardware and not Android, but what device manufacturers and network providers cram down the throats of their customers. Custom UI enhancements/replacements, useless bundled apps that can't be removed, and the removal of standard, OS-delivered features. None of this should have been new or a surprise to the writer's mom, who was coming to Android from a feature phone. Feature phones have been plagued with the same crap for years, except they don't have a marketplace full of replacement apps that range from the serviceable to the remarkable.

I'm glad the author's mom found a smartphone she likes, but this isn't an Android problem. It may very well be a Google problem, since Apple was indeed successful in keeping the kruft off the iPhone, but Android devices come to market in a completely different way than iPhones, and as long as we sign over our rights in exchange for a $400 device discount we're going to have to deal with some of it.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by sili on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:45AM (#2822395)
This is the same problem that has plagued Windows on PC for years before this. Buying a PC from Dell or any other large retailers with Windows pre-installed meant a day worth of removing their crap-ware, support software, and back-up suits. Or you could reformat straight out of the box.

Only this time the problem is more perwasive. With PC an average user did not get botherd by all this trash, the machine was good enough for surfing and email, which is what they used it for. Only advanced users and techies would get frustrated. However, with smartphones it seems to be a real problem even for an everyday user.

What I don't understand though, is all this fat that providers pile on the phones and PC really worth it for them. They spend time and money to develop all these custom themes and apps, than users remove them. Even if users don't remove them and find them good enough to use, where is the profit to the provider? Branding and recognition?

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by neutronicus on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:49AM (#2822425)
I think laptop OEMs got kickbacks for bundling crapware, especially antivirus software. I imagine the same is true of those mobile phones that bundle, say, Amazon.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jdietrich on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:44PM (#2823463)
At one point Sony offered a no-crapware option on some Vaio laptops. Until a PR shitstorm broke out, they were charging $50 extra. One can only imagine how much they're earning per-unit on kickbacks.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by amorphid on Saturday July 30, 2011 @11:36AM (#2825962)
Best Buy's "optimizes" computers prior to purchase. They charge something like $40 to remove the bloatware.

http://m.gizmodo.com/5439590/best-buys-optimization-is-offic...

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by guptaneil on Saturday July 30, 2011 @01:05AM (#2824954)
PC makers made extra money on each PC sold by bundling other people's apps for them. Until recently, this was a reasonable business strategy, since users didn't have much choice and had to put up with the poor experience, so why not make extra money at the minor cost of frustrating your customers?

For wireless companies, the custom branding is how they hope to be considered more than just a dumb pipe by providing additional "value" to users. This is why Verizon bundles their Vcast music store, and AT&T includes their custom Navigation and Yellow Pages apps. They desperately want to be seen as content companies. This is not a reasonable business strategy though, because the more they frustrate their customers with this nonsense, the more those users will flock to the pristine shores of iOS, where carriers have even less control, thereby cementing their position as a simple utility.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by henrikschroder on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:29PM (#2823409)
I find that the bundling on PCs have gotten much better in recent years. I bought a Packard Bell laptop for my dad, turned it on, chose the windows language and basic setup, waited half an hour for it to do its thing, and then it was good to go. An almost clean Windows 7 Home Premium, the only extra stuff on it was a 30-day Microsoft something trial, a 30-day Norton trial, and... that's it. And it's not even hard to remove those things if you don't want them.

So the PC experience has gotten a lot better in recent years. I don't know why though, perhaps the industry learned? Perhaps it's not worth it to pre-load it with crap anymore?

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by sgk284 on Friday July 29, 2011 @06:53PM (#2824166)
Microsoft actively restricts and controls what can be installed by OEMs now. That's why it's gotten so much better with Win7.

The crappy first use experience was ruining Microsoft's image, because people associated the cruft with them.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by drcube on Friday July 29, 2011 @04:29PM (#2823666)
Norton is not hard to remove??? Have things changed so much since I switched to Linux? I used to tell people they had to reinstall the OS to get rid of Norton.

I agree that unremoveable and unkillable apps are a huge problem with Android. This is why I switched to Linux in the first place and Google needs to fix it, ASAP.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by leon_ on Saturday July 30, 2011 @05:31AM (#2825371)
Yeah, my last PC around 2004 came with Norton. Though I consider myself pretty computer savvy (C programmer) I couldn't remove that thing without reinstalling windows.

Maybe it's different now?

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by mlvl-spb-rus on Saturday July 30, 2011 @11:58AM (#2826007)
Removed two Norton apps on a Packard Bell laptop my grandpa chose (and bought) for himself just yesterday. Hope they will not come back. We spend some time teaching him to do basic internet access and (me) assuring that it's no rocket science (by the way, he's an old-school soviet rocket (and not only) engineer, so ;).. )
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by ianthiel on Saturday July 30, 2011 @10:15AM (#2825802)
Seeing as that was 7 years ago, yes things are a bit different now =P
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by pmr_ on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:58PM (#2823528)
I really can not relate to that. I hat to "configure" a few PCs/laptops (mostly Acer and HP) during the last year. The amount of crapware was shocking and I'm not even talking about the horrible custom OSDs that some manufactures defile computers with.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by markokocic on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:23AM (#2821573)
But this what you explained is exactly the problem with Android. With iPhone, carriers, phone manufacturers and such are not allowed to install their crapware/bloatware on the phone. With Android, they can do whatever they want, and the only sane option for an end user is to root the phone.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by speckledjim on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:50AM (#2821699)
It's still a problem with US carriers. (Other countries have far better carriers and ecosystems than the US)

It still absolutely amazes me that you guys usually pay for incoming SMS messages.

I mean come on. W T F? If the carriers started charging each time you charge your battery the US public would just bend over and take it.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by nuclear_eclipse on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:50AM (#2822430)
Even worse, Cincinnati Bell charges 25c for incoming texts (if your plan doesn't include them), but then charges you $3 a month to block incoming text messages altogether! I've long since switched back to T-Mobile, and regretted ever moving away from T-Mobile in the first place, but my parents have decided to put up with the stupid 25c charges for spam texts because it's still cheaper than paying a monthly fee for what used to be a free "service" of flipping a switch in their database.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by Sthorpe on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:28PM (#2822597)
Paying for SMS is awful. Just out of curiosity how would you suggest we don't, "just bend over and take it?"
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by speleding on Friday July 29, 2011 @07:01PM (#2824186)
Just look at what other countries are doing right and copy that. More concrete: Vote for a politician who will force the FCC to create a real market, not a oligopoly of a few large behemoths.

Contrary to most the promises politicians make, this one costs no money and simply involves signing the right bills into law. It will even be good for the economy. Of course, they would have to withstand the rich and powerful lobby of said behemoths, which is of course why such a politician will be very hard to find.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by nollidge on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:05AM (#2821775)
Only if they have a plan that doesn't include texting, which is vanishingly rare now.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by dman on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:29AM (#2821930)
Both t-mobile and verizon offer this. And I havent checked the others. Ive never paid for text and have incoming SMS's blocked too.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by nollidge on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:16AM (#2822220)
Oh yeah, my guess is that all carriers offer no-texting plans, I just mean it's getting rarer that people choose them.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by joshmanders on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:02AM (#2821761)
> It still absolutely amazes me that you guys usually pay for incoming SMS messages.

What? I've never seen a carrier charge for incoming SMS.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by cryptoz on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:09AM (#2821809)
Last time I checked (a few months ago), every large carrier in Canada charges 15 cents for each incoming SMS. That's Bell, Rogers, Telus...maybe some others.

Many people have a plan addon that includes receiving some SMS for free, but the basic stock plans do not.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by thequux on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:28AM (#2821921)
Canadian cell companies are a special kind of terrible. AFAICT, they exist purely to make the american companies look good by comparison. When I was there for 5 days, the cheapest way for me to get phone/internet on my Nexus S was to stick my Vodafone Germany SIM in and use roaming. (I was just using texts, twitter, and light maps; a total of 10MB for the weekend.)
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by Shenglong on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:50AM (#2822071)
Only Telus. Bell and Rogers are free incoming texts - or at least were, when I bought my phone (I have unlimited texting, but I like to make sure). However, that's not to say they don't try to jip you at every possibility.

For the last few years, texting to the US had always been at the same rate as Canada (and covered by texting plans). Rogers decided to switch that on me when I wasn't paying attention... although I'm pretty sure I asked, and the Sales guy lied.

In either case. One complaint to the FCC in the USA, or CCTS in Canada will get things your way. Both countries, from my experience, has pretty terrible customer service. I can barely understand half of Verizon's CS team, and one guy at Roger's CS actually told me I should just do nothing, even though I felt cheated, because "if you sue, our company has more money than you, and you'll lose for sure". Sigh.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by reidmain on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:18PM (#2823372)
Actually all three telecoms charge for incoming text messages. Telus pioneered it, Bell followed suit and then Rogers jumped on the bandwagon in 2009.

I called Bell to have them block all incoming text messages and they said that they could not do it because it was somehow tied to their emergency 911 location determination service. After much prodding they said they could turn off incoming texts (but I should hope that I never have to call 911 with my mobile) but came back with a $3/month plan for like 500 text messages so I just took that instead.

I switched to Rogers and am now on an iPhone plan which has text messaging but I would love to be able to block incoming texts again if iOS 5 and Google+ gets serious traction.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by kbd on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:10AM (#2821815)
Really?

Verizon: "20¢ per text sent (per recipient) or received (including Canada, Mexico, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands)"

AT&T: "All AT&T customers with Text Messaging-capable phones are pre-activated to send and receive messages at $0.20 per message with no monthly charge."

Straight from their websites.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by joshmanders on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:23AM (#2821891)
I guess it depends on location, because around my area, all I see are 'GET UNLIMITED TEXT AND DATA FOR ONLY YOUR LEFT LEG!!" ads all over the place.

Also it could quite possibly be that I am indeed living under a rock as I am very satisfied with my carrier so I don't actively look at plans of others.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by dpark on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:11AM (#2822189)
It doesn't depend on the area. Most if not all American carriers charge for incoming text messages. When you select the "unlimited data and text" plan, you're paying for those incoming text messages.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by getsat on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:10AM (#2821820)
Have you been in a coma for the last decade? Americans get bent over the barrel on SMS pricing.

https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=incoming+text+message+...

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by nikcub on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:25AM (#2821899)
manufacturers must pass the Android Compatability Test Suite[1] in order to be granted rights to the android trademark and the permission to refer to their device as android[2].

the problem is CTS tests API consistency with the goal of preventing platform fragmentation for app developers. there is also a separate set of tests that specify minimum hardware requirements for each version of android, and specs such as battery life, etc.

compatibility and android brand licensing also requires a certain set of minimum apps, such as the phone dialer, calendar, contacts, music player, etc. but (and quote[3]):

> The Android upstream project defines a number of core applications, such as a phone dialer, calendar, contacts book, music player, and so on. Device implementers MAY replace these applications with alternative versions.

and further -- the gmail, chat etc. apps are proprietary Google apps, and there are various licensing reasons why they can not be enforced as part of 'compatibility'.

API compatibility is good, but UI and app compatibility is very flexible - and given such flexibility, carriers will almost always go the crawpware route.

[1] http://source.android.com/compatibility/android-cts-manual-r...

[2] http://source.android.com/compatibility/index.html

[3] http://source.android.com/compatibility/2.3/android-2.3.3-cd...

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by shaggyfrog on Friday July 29, 2011 @02:08PM (#2823036)
If this "Android Compatability Test Suite" is anything like how the video game manufacturers test and approve video games, let's just say a lot of things can get graded on a curve, with the right motivation.

Clearly this phone is one example, if the battery is discharging itself so quickly (and generating so much heat) in an hour.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by samstokes on Friday July 29, 2011 @04:48PM (#2823731)
The only sane option is to root the phone

How about the only sane option is to not buy a phone with crapware on it? This is what markets are for - so that crappy products can die. If Verizon sells phones with crapware and T-Mobile sells phones without, choose T-Mobile.

Even better, if the US market finally wakes up to buying unlocked phones from electronics vendors rather than locked phones from carriers, you can actually choose between handset brands like consumer electronics is meant to work.

If I buy a digital camera, I have to do a bit of research to find out which one is good. If I'm not that demanding, then the extent of the research can be asking my friend who just bought a camera which one she bought. It would be an easier choice if only two companies made decent cameras and I just had to choose one or the other, but that's not how it is, and I suspect the camera market would also stagnate in that situation.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by glassx on Friday July 29, 2011 @06:18PM (#2824055)
A local (Brazilian) phone operator made 'we only have unlocked phones' as their selling-point. Also they don't have contracts, and (at least for me) no crapware apps.

Sorta gives me a bit of hope on capitalism. I stay with them on principle.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by mikegreenberg on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:08AM (#2822174)
The only sane option?!

Give me a break. Just get a phone "with Google" and use the pure Google experience and it's a breeze. All of this spinning and complaining about what OEMs are doing to an open source OS is like complaining about the DIY boxcar racer you bought and put together turned out like shit. (and you want your money back.)

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by evilduck on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:07PM (#2822507)
This is not the case. I have a Samsung Moment "with Google". The stock Android it ships with comes with unremovable apps (and unremovable game demos), a half-baked navigation app, a terrible voice search replacement, unkillable background services that count how many times you open the keyboard. It's also got a totally broken radio driver that violated FCC 911 regulations for over a year (google it if you care), and has been abandoned at 2.1 officially 10 months from release since it's no longer in Samsung's profit interests to maintain a terrible device that Sprint pulled from their product line. The only way the phone is remotely enjoyable is with custom ROMs. I bought it with 1.5 and accepted a sub-par experience because of Samsung's publicly stated promise that it would get 2.1 quickly, it took several months before an official 2.1 update was released and nearly another year before their radio issues were resolved.

The "with Google" branding meaning nothing in terms of actual phone experience, and Samsung isn't the only vendor at fault here. After my experience, and dozens of similar accounts like this blog post, I don't recommend anyone buy an Android phone that isn't a "by Google", like the Nexus line, and even then, only if they have some strong objection to getting the iPhone, which I would recommend over any current Android device.

I really, really, really wanted to like Android, but you can damn-near put an 18 month countdown on the majority of the Android phones before the manufacturer abandons it and you're stuck using XDA developers or the like for updates, patches and improvements, or just to fix the stock crap they ship. On a 24 month contract cycle, that's just unacceptable.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jerrya on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:28PM (#2822598)
"I really, really, really wanted to like Android, but you can damn-near put an 18 month countdown on the majority of the Android phones before the manufacturer abandons it and you're stuck using XDA developers or the like for updates, patches and improvements, or just to fix the stock crap they ship. On a 24 month contract cycle, that's just unacceptable."

Somewhat broad generalization ahead...

About once a year, Apple comes out with ONE new phone, an iPhone. If the phone is bad, Apple goes out of business. Apple bets the company every year on that new iPhone, and to make that a reasonable bet, they spend tons and tons of marketing on design, engineering, quality, and customer support. Apples knows a bad iPhone makes WSJ / New York Times front pages. Apple knows that to make a bad iPhone loses them iPad, iPod, Macbook,... customers.

And so ... by and large, Apple does not make bad iPhones.

In contrast

Four times a year, each, HTC, Samsung, Motorola, LG, Kyocera, Huawei, Sony, and others, come out with a new Android phone. This phone is one of many many products made by each of these companies. The success or failure of any of these phones means almost nothing to the company. And so, the product development and rollout of any of these phones is not a bet-the-company gamble. Accordingly, very little effort is made on design, engineering, and customer support. None of these companies have terribly loyal customers, most seem to buy a given phone based on carrier affiliation, or based on costs. Losing a customer here is bad, but does not carry the long term cost as losing a customer at Apple does.

And so there is very little incentive to make anything but competitive (in all the wrong meanings) phones here. There is a race to the bottom mentality going on.

"We think the phone we make is good, at least as good as the phone they make. Let's get some more marketing dollars from our partners for it and we will all be happy"

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by danudey on Friday July 29, 2011 @02:11PM (#2823044)
Many years ago, I took a look at the Apple iPod website, and looked at the models. The breakdown was simple. iPod shuffle, iPod Mini, iPod. You could see one page with all prices for all sizes (two sizes for each model), and then you just had to pick a colour and you were good.

I then went to look at Creative's website, and looked through their list of products. They had 16 separate models, many of which were very subtle variations (e.g. the 316 vs. the 316z). There was no breakdown page that would show you the differences or help you decide. Some of them had LCD screens, some of them played WMA, some of them had more space, some came in multiple colours, but you didn't know which had what or what it cost until you clicked on the page. Making a completely informed decision would take hours of clicking links, making notes, hitting the back button, and then clicking the next link.

I marvelled that not only was Creative competing against Apple, they were competing against themselves. They produced 16 different models, which requires 16 different manufacturing processes, 16 different packagings, 16 different manuals (each in a variety of languages), 16 different QA processes.

The same thing is happening here. Manufacturers are largely unwilling to challenge Apple in the high-end of the market (where the Galaxy S, Nexus S, iPhone 4, etc. all live), so they work in the smaller end. The lower prices mean lower margins and lesser quality parts. This also leads to less testing and QA, meaning a lower quality finished product.

As a result of these lower margins, they need to sell more phones, which means producing more models of phones and shortening the lifetimes of the phones in order to encourage people to turn them over faster. It's becoming a race to the bottom.

People compare Android and iOS to Windows and Mac, but it feels like the better comparison is Mac vs. PC hardware, not software. Apple makes very few models of computer (Macbook Air, Macbook Pro, iMac, Mac Pro), which they refresh lately. There are lots of variations, but you have four base models which are simple to understand. In comparison, if you go to Dell's website, there are a dozen models you can buy, each with subtle variations, and even with different prices depending on which business unit you buy from. Other PC manufacturers all do the same thing, and because they don't control the software they ship (other than crapware), they can only really differentiate on price.

It's become a race to the bottom, trying to slash costs and increase volumes at the same time, and PC manufacturers have realized that they're fighting over a huge chunk of the market and leaving Apple to actually make the profits. Android certainly has the potential to surpass Apple in market share, but they're going to be fighting over a much smaller chunk of profits, fragmenting their efforts over multiple products and competing against other manufacturers' multiple products.

It just doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by dman on Friday July 29, 2011 @06:14PM (#2824040)
Apple is one of the few companies in the world that does both software and hardware in a competent and timely fashion. If Sony / HTC / Samsung had as much software roots as Apple I believe we would see Android handsets that actually offered credible alternatives rather than being showcases for their hardware and physical design departments. Then again I guess shipping Android phones amounts to admitting that you cant do the whole stack. I really commend HP for trying to be the other company that does the whole stack.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stretchwithme on Friday July 29, 2011 @05:53PM (#2823957)
You hit the nail on the head. Apple curates the array of products it offers, while its impossible to tell which Android best suits you.

Google needs to create a new platform that curates as well as Apple does. Or sit and watch while Amazon builds one on top of Android.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by rsynnott on Friday July 29, 2011 @02:41PM (#2823185)
"The success or failure of any of these phones means almost nothing to the company. And so, the product development and rollout of any of these phones is not a bet-the-company gamble. Accordingly, very little effort is made on design, engineering, and customer support. None of these companies have terribly loyal customers, most seem to buy a given phone based on carrier affiliation, or based on costs."

In the long run, Google needs to do something about this, or face it doing severe damage to the image of their platform.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by amorphid on Saturday July 30, 2011 @11:44AM (#2825978)
Apple is great at understanding a customer's user experience. They are making the most profit per handset, too. Making a couple of bucks via bloatware might be driving unprofitability.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by mikegreenberg on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:43PM (#2822665)
Certainly the experience is inconsistent and something I'm willing to accept. Considering the amount of experimentation on implementation and the rapidly changing OS, I will tolerate bad eggs to spoil the bunches. The problem is not with the software but with how Google has handled it's branding of Android and the "preferred" experience it associates with it. "with Google" was suppose to solve this problem, but as you point out there are still issues and loopholes.

I bought the MyTouch3G (2nd Android phone ever), the G2, the Nexus S and recently the Galaxy Tab. Overall, I'm very happy with the experience of each of these phones. There are other phones out there that have great experiences as well. As a consumer, I will research these purchases which matter and will pay with my time to get exactly what I want. If you want to, instead, pay for one company to handle quality end-to-end for you, then you will pay for that, too.

For me, the pluses in Android outweigh the (few) minuses (that remain).

For anyone else, it's great that they have the choice to make. :)

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by evilduck on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:26PM (#2823398)
I glossed over it a bit, but one of my points was that I thought I had done due diligence in researching the product before buying. I had compared specifications, Samsung hadn't fumbled any phones this badly before, it was a "with Google" product, they were pretty consistently communicating to their customers about coming updates, Sprint was pushing it pretty equally to the HTC Hero (and Sprint's contract came in slightly cheaper than AT&Ts), the only complaints that had surfaced on forums were mostly DOA devices, etc. All information available pointed to it being a pretty good decision at the time.

If years of market research prowess fails me and I consistently see similar stories crop up every month or two where other technically inclined people regret purchasing some other Android device, it says to me that I didn't simply get a lemon or make a huge mistake in my decision making but the market itself has a problem, whatever issues and loopholes allowed it before have remained unfixed. Since the price difference between iPhones and top end Android phones are basically the same ($100 variance or so on a >$2k total cost...big deal), and that I can mindlessly buy whatever the next iPhone release will be and have pretty good assurance Apple has my back, I'm completely unwilling to waste time researching Android devices and still possibly get bit in the ass for my efforts.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by NoahHendrix on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:39AM (#2822366)
LOL, that is a terrible analogy. If I bought and built a boxcar and I did it wrong then yes my fault, I'm not building the phone, the manufacturer is, so as a consumer I can expect a certain level of quality.

Most consumers don't know the difference between Google-made Android phones and the others. You're missing the core point which is that the Android platform is fragmented and regular people are being given a phone full of advertising and apps built for up selling.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by mikegreenberg on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:28PM (#2822599)
I know the analogy was horrible... -_-

Regardless, the intention of my point was that manufacturers were given "blueprints" and "tools" and they built a shitty product. Even though Android is Google's product, the end result is not and to point fingers at Android is wrong. Is it the fault of Google if people are using the tools improperly? If anything, Google should've better managed the Android trademark so as to not associate their toolbox/blueprints with sub-par implementations.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by Nerdfest on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:00AM (#2821753)
In the case of the iPhone, Users are not allowed to install certain applications either.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stcredzero on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:59AM (#2821751)
I'm glad the author's mom found a smartphone she likes, but this isn't an Android problem.

I'll be downvoted, but here goes: This shows the Linux heritage. All of Linux's problems on the desktop aren't really problems with Linux. It turns out that Android's problems aren't Android's either.

Solved!

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by bad_user on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:05AM (#2821774)

     All of Linux's problems on the desktop aren't really 
     problems with Linux.
Errr, what?
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by awj on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:48PM (#2822686)
He's referring to the finger pointing / blame shifting that seems to happen whenever someone starts criticizing desktop Linux. Any time this comes up people pop out of the woodwork to give the solutions, sometimes of staggering complexity, to the specific user experience problems cited.

The reality is that Linux-the-umbrella will be judged by any specific distro's user experience. People more familiar with the situation will know that in many cases bad experiences are caused by choices specific to distros or even the packages they bundle, but the true average user's perception is not that nuanced.

The same argument largely works for Android. In some ways worse because there is a certification process that allows you to use the Android name, but does very little to ensure someone didn't wreck the user experience with their customizations.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stcredzero on Saturday July 30, 2011 @11:11AM (#2825921)
In some ways worse because there is a certification process that allows you to use the Android name, but does very little to ensure someone didn't wreck the user experience with their customizations.

In other words, "Hey, let's make it somewhat exclusive to use our brand, but do nothing to ensure quality from the end-user's perspective!" All the disadvantages of exclusivity, with none of the advantages.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by zdw on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:12AM (#2821830)
What he's saying is that all of Linux's problems are with the kernel and surrounding low level code (which is quite stable, performs well, etc.), but with the integration, support and design of the distributions laid on top of them.

For example Ubuntu has made great strides in this regard, but some would say the continual, sometimes drastic changes in the shipped apps and modifications of the interface make it hard for users.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by allbutlost on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:38AM (#2821976)
I actually think he is being facetious. It may be true to say "it's not android", but as far as they end-user is concerned it _is_ android. It's got the logos, came with an android sticker on the box. For that user, when it comes to purchase or recommend another phone, will they make the same distinction or will their previous android experience influence their choice?
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stcredzero on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:55AM (#2822450)
It's more of a statement about the culture and expectations growing up around Android, than about Android the technical artifact.

The technophiles are right about the point they make about the latter, but it's the former that will make or break it in the marketplace.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by mc32 on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:13PM (#2822534)
I think he's saying that people can redefine a problem so that it's no longer their problem. Defining the problem out, rather than actually addressing it.

In this case, instead of addressing (usability?) issues, the perceived problem, rather than being addressed head on, is redefined as being at the feet of the user, thus transferring responsibility and absolving oneself. (I.e "It works for me"!)

I think that's what they were saying.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by tomjen3 on Saturday July 30, 2011 @02:34AM (#2825084)
If those problems had been problems with Linux, we could have solved them.

But the fact that some hardware producer doesn't want to give up the specs so that we can support it? Not Linux problem.

They may be a problem for you, if you want to run Linux but it isn't Linux problem.

This case is the same. I would prefer it was some problem with Android, since we could then solve it but crap-ware on carriers isn't a software issue.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stcredzero on Saturday July 30, 2011 @10:27AM (#2825834)
Put it another way: Just because it's not a Linux problem, doesn't mean it isn't a problem for Linux. Just because it's not an Android problem, doesn't mean it's not a problem for Android.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by micampe on Friday July 29, 2011 @08:38PM (#2824442)
I think this has been one of the major innovations of the iPhone: not allowing carriers to tamper with it.

MS understood this and they are doing the same with WP7. Google knows it is a problem so they release the Google Experience phones, but they can’t disallow it completely.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by kooshball on Saturday July 30, 2011 @02:04AM (#2825035)
I think it's quite interesting to see google go the same route as MS did with Windows and Windows Mobile which is allow the OEM to customize to make money, while letting user satisfaction drop. At the same time, WP7 is a total different strategy to tightly control the hardware and give a much greater user experience while the OEMs have less and less control.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by cmurdock on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:55AM (#2822096)
This is a similar problem to what goes on with PC vendors. They install crap-ware and borderline ad-ware on machines they sell to users who then complain that their brand new computer is already going slow after a few months. Even re-installing the OS using their provided "recovery" discs will re-install all this junk after installing the OS. Luckily you can circumvent this problem pretty easily with a PC. Not so easy with a locked-down phone from Verizon. Too bad there's not many wireless providers that don't pull this kind of stuff.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by nhebb on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:41AM (#2821653)
The battery life and "scorching hot" temperature sound like hardware issues, but I doubt they're representative of all Android phones - just this model.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jm4 on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:14AM (#2821845)
I owned 3 different Android phones over the past 3 years. My wife owned 2 models different from mine over the same span. My experience is based on using 5 different Android models from different manufacturers. Although I'm focusing now on the things I did not like, the fact that I stayed with Android for so long should suggest that there was plenty I did like.

Battery life was terrible on every Android phone I used. I could not get through an 8-9 hour work day with moderate use (an hour or two of streaming, maybe a few web pages, some texting and a brief call or two). I can absolutely confirm the weird battery issues this user experienced. On multiple phones. At times, the phone would get warm (not scorching hot in my case) and the battery would go from close to a full charge to nearly dead in the span of an hour or so. I kept spare chargers everywhere. Five freakin' phones.

I finally gave in and switched to an iPhone. Now I'm kicking myself for not doing it sooner. Maybe this is a little dramatic, but after using iOS for several weeks I have come to the realization that Android is flat out trash in comparison. I like having an "end call" button that is actually responsive and, you know... ends a call. On Android I would press it several times before the call would end. Just about every time. On too many occasions I had to pull the battery off.

The unresponsive button thing isn't isolated either. Push a button. Wait. Wait. Push it a couple more times. The whole thing is agonizingly slow. Try to unlock the screen. Crap. I have to push the button 3 or 4 times. Arrgghhh!

Don't even get me started on typing. The keyboard would lag on a regular basis, to the point where it was just not practical to use it for texting. I would start to type, the keyboard froze up and then a bunch of special accented characters would show up. Turning off basically every feature of the keyboard like haptic feedback and auto-correction would help, but the typing experience was still the worst of any phone I have used since T9 predictive text has been available.

Apps crashed left and right. I'm not even talking about random stuff from the Android market. I'm talking about the built in ones. I had a task killer installed. It was my most frequently used app. Let that sink in. My task killer was my most frequently used app. I was constantly killing things that were slowing down the phone or eating up battery for no good reason. Search the Android market for task killers. There are tons of them. Some of them run in the background and automatically kill stuff in an attempt to improve performance.

I could go on, but I'd rather not. I'm just glad I don't have to use those Android phones anymore. It will be a very long time before I would consider buying one again.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by angus77 on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:28AM (#2821923)
Wow... I'm replying to this from my HTC Desire, which I've had for over a year. I have had exactly ZERO of those problems. The biggest complaint I have is that I still don't have an update for Android 2.3 yet.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jm4 on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:47AM (#2822034)
I'm glad yours is working out. I know people that absolutely love their Android phones. I know some others that don't like them so much. After 5 phones, 3 manufacturers and 2 carriers I have seen enough to believe it's not an isolated thing, but I also realize my experience is not necessarily representative of the majority of Android phones. Still, it's enough for me to avoid them. It seems to me like a pretty hit or miss proposition. In any case, my wife and I are happy iPhone users now.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by hn_decay on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:27PM (#2822594)
Froyo is the OS version that made Android competitive. Gingerbread is the gravy that made is excellent.

I've had 4 Android devices, all the ways back to cupcake on the G1. In the early years I absolutely saw the issues that the GP observed, tolerating the platform for secondary reasons while hoping it would get better. I, too, had to pull my battery to end a call more than once. Until Froyo I never recommended Android to non-tech friends or peers. With a modern Gingerbread device I would recommend it in a heartbeat.

But...wow...reading their post is like a blast from the past. jm4 seems to have a really bad sense of timing "buy high sell low!" because Android today is a slick, smooth, reliable platform.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by starwed on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:59AM (#2822467)
> My task killer was my most frequently used app.

Oh. You probably weren't aware of this, but task killers can cause every problem you list -- app crashing, UI lag, etc.

As soon as I got rid of mine, my phone was much more responsive and had about twice the battery life!

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by MatthewPhillips on Friday July 29, 2011 @10:40AM (#2821991)
Task killers don't do anything, the issue that created a need for them was patched in 2.2. Now they're just a placebo.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by hn_decay on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:17PM (#2822560)
I can't discount your experiences. There is no doubt that Android in its earlier years was kind of an ugly baby. The OS suffered fundamental faults, lag on user interactivity being a primary one.

Is that true with current devices? Absolutely not. Gingerbread suffers from zero of the complaints that you mentioned.

"I had a task killer installed. It was my most frequently used app."

You should probably remove this from your post because it betrays that you are an ignorant user. All else follows from that.

While you have edited your post here to temper the zeal, comments like "Android just replaces feature phones" are, well, "fanboy" type comments. Tell my Galaxy S II that.

You're angry about something and are taking it out on Android. No one should draw much from your dated observations.

This story is about a bad device, possibly even a defective handset. Call the press, someone got a lemon!

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by hn_decay on Friday July 29, 2011 @04:28PM (#2823664)
And thus has the editability of HN posts been exploited.

The GP post originally contained a claim that Android is "garbage", would persist on "feature phones", among other nonse belonging in Engadget comments.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jm4 on Friday July 29, 2011 @08:40PM (#2824444)
FYI, I edited my comment once to remove an errant comma. The content never changed. I definitely did not have anything in there about feature phones. I was somewhat confused by your reference to that and previous comments I made. Are you sure you were looking at the right comment?
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by jsz0 on Friday July 29, 2011 @05:41PM (#2823926)
Mysterious battery drain seems like a really common problem on Android phones. Sometimes my Droid X lasts till 6PM -- sometimes it's dead by 1PM. More or less the same usage patterns. When it dies early in the day the phone is definitely warmer than usual.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by Dylan16807 on Friday July 29, 2011 @11:34AM (#2822328)
In my experience doing anything with constant data flow when you have bad reception can turn battery into heat amazingly quickly. Otherwise it works just fine.

I do wish having an idle skype didn't send packets constantly, though.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by stretchwithme on Friday July 29, 2011 @05:47PM (#2823941)
That's 55 cents a day over a 2 year contract. And if you make $25 an hour after taxes (hopefully you make more), you're be working 92 seconds of every day just to pay the iPhone premium.

Me thinks the better experience saves me at least 93 seconds of pain per day, possible even 2 whole minutes worth.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by dhughes on Friday July 29, 2011 @05:01PM (#2823778)
Agreed.

The touch on my Nexus One (HTC Passion) is horrible the slightest smudge and that's it no touch. I bought my mother an iPod touch a couple of years ago and the touch is fantastic. Actually anyone I know with HTC seems to have problems but not those I know with Android but not HTC hardware.

I played around with a Samsung Galaxy II on display in a store and even after hundreds of people were poking at it and smudged it the touch was flawless.

I've had a few crash on Android OS (v2.3.4 GRJ22) but I prefer it over iOS I find the iPod Touch's GUI suffocating after using Android.

Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by pmr_ on Friday July 29, 2011 @04:01PM (#2823542)
Ironically this is shaking the trust of users in a sound platform and not in their network provider is not able to _not_ break something when modifying it.
[deleted]
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by yock on Friday July 29, 2011 @09:31AM (#2821613)
The author specifically stated that his mom was.
Re:Why my Mom Bought an Android, Returned It, and Got an iPhone by rayiner on Friday July 29, 2011 @06:15PM (#2824048)
> I'm glad the author's mom found a smartphone she likes, but this isn't an Android problem. It may very well be a Google problem

It's definitely Google's problem. Experiences like this tremendously hurt the Android brand. What if you bought a "BMW" but it turned out to be a piece of crap because BMW had licensed their engines and logo but exercised no quality-control over the final products? You'd never buy another BMW, regardless of whose fault it really was.