A mechanic sits down next to a doctor at the bar. They get to talking. Before long, the mechanic says, "hey, you and I aren't so different. We both open things up and fix 'em. How come you get so much more credit than I do?"
The doctor says, "You get to turn the cars off before working on them."
[0] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/05/03/architect-vines/
I've heard this claim before, but this seems like a communication problem more than anything else. Keeping insane work schedules as a means to address it seems really suspect to me.
In a secondary analysis that was adjusted for the number of patients per resident physician as a potential confounder, intervention schedules were no longer associated with an increase in errors.
The culture of medical education in the west places doctors in a bubble where 48 hours exhaustion marathons are glorified and considered a rite of passage. Other fields have found ways to do handovers with minimal to no impact on the continuity of operations.
Over the decades hospital administration has grown (because health insurance is complex). Seems obvious that money would be better spent on people that provide healthcare to ease the pain of those currently providing it.
Try being in EMS.
24... 36... 48. The private ambulance company I used to work for allowed you to work 60 hours straight, and then required an 8-12 hour break, if you wanted to work up to another 60.
Funny tradition that refuses to die.
Great show called “the Knick” where I learned about this.
Absolutely not and it’s insane to even think that could be true.
For example my brother-in-law is a firefighter. He spends 3/4 days straight in the firehouse and then comes home for 3/4 days and works something like 12 hours straight when he is on call and gets rest periods when not actually doing firefighter work. This is possible because the firehouse basically has a small dorm in it. When I ask him when he is going to work he says he has a three day shift coming up. Because he doesn't come home, my sister definitely considers it "non-stop".
I can easily imagine health care workers being on-site for a few days at some sites, like a firefighter. Especially in areas where commutes could be prohibitive.
The typical maximum scheduled is 48 on, 96 off.
Around here (west coast) it's typically called a Detroit schedule (so not just west coast, I guess!)... 24 on, 48 off, but even more closely around here we use a Modified Detroit, which is a nine day rotation, where you work a 24 hour shift on days 1, 3 and 5 of the rotation, and have days 2, 4, 6-9 off.
I'll be the first to admit I don't understand precisely what is going on or the challenges involved. Still, my understanding is that this scheduling is just for drivers. Overworking drivers is somewhat scary but necessary because their district has a severe shortage of them. It seems they're hard to hire because they need special certifications, training, and additional experience, and local firefighters have struggled to pass the necessary tests. Therefore, the city "asked" the existing drivers to do extra shifts while hiring new drivers.
At least that is what they said about two years ago...
Looking at the numbers a bit more closely. 48on 96off is 1:3 uptime per firefighter. 72on 72off is 1:2, increasing the uptime but also giving at least some amount continuous away time. Probably the odd 4 day shift is because of extract coverage days, like the fourth of July, or something. Or if a driver needs a vacation. Which is one nice thing they did. They did increase the amount of paid vacation the drivers get as a kind of compensation. Not enough to make up the difference of course, as that would defeat the whole point of the long shifts, but something.
I believe it’s 10 hours for the first two days (you’re off in your own home in the evening). The next two nights are 14 hours, and the fire fighters are in bed if there is no calls. I think day shift is 7 am to 5 pm, and night shift is 5 pm to 7 am.
It’s amazing what type of hours Americans are doing.
Around here the absolute maximum I've heard about is 12.5h and that includes at least two mandatory breaks.
C'mon, that's 3 straight days, i.e. skipping 2 nights. How can that be 'the norm' anywhere? Extraordinary claims requires extraordinary evidence - or in this case, just any evidence.
I can reliably say that they’re still very overworked. 12+ hour shifts is the norm, and sometimes even 24 hours.
This vague allusion doesn't do much to convince me of the 72-hour claim. While we're doing anecdotes of extreme sleep deprivation, check out this personal account and AMA of someone who claims to have stayed up for 81 hours straight. What makes me doubt your "multiple people" is that after missing only two full nights of sleep (so ~48 hours), people start hearing and seeing hallucinations, and can't reliably hold conversation, much less deliver healthcare: https://old.reddit.com/r/AMA/comments/6sab7t/i_stayed_awake_...
In college I heard insane stories from the nursing majors. Apparently going on shifts working 72+ hours non-stop is the norm. Imagine spending 72 hours in that hell: delivering this guy's meds, then checking this guy's blood pressure while he berates you, then typing in some paperwork, then giving this baby lab work while he's screaming, then doing more paperwork, etc. for 72 hours straight. I can't imagine it, I can barely imagine spending more than 3 hours.
Anecdotally, the few times I've been to doctors' offices and hospitals, I always notice the stress on doctors. Doctors and nurses are rushing everywhere, and they try to act nice but are simultaneously drained of emotion from disrespectful patients and general fatigue. Ironically sometimes they don't look that healthy, with all due respect, probably because of the immense stress and that it's hard to fit in exercise when you work 12-hour overnight shifts.
Also, I live in Massachusetts where hospitals haven't been near capacity for some time now. Everything I described is just regular operation, pre-Covid.