News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by kccqzy on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:18PM (#27955199)
Just want to remind everyone how far California has gone in energy efficiency:

> In 2018, California's energy consumption was second-highest among the states, but its per capita energy consumption was the fourth-lowest due in part to its mild climate and its energy efficiency programs.

Source: https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=CA#tabs-4

This is an achievement to be proud of.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:40PM (#27955355)
> This is an achievement to be proud of.

I mean I'm all for reducing power consumption, but is having a mild climate an achievement to be proud of? I'd guess that California's main population centers have fewer degree days away from 72 F than any other state in the country. By default, you'd expect their power consumption to be the very lowest.

(The other states close to CA in consumption per capita have much worse climates, but their people live in denser urban centers and have smaller, likely more efficient dwellings.)

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by floatingatoll on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:53AM (#27955823)
It’s not looking like a mild climate anymore, if that offers any comfort.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by mlindner on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:27AM (#27980813)
As someone who lives here, no, it's quite mild.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by paulddraper on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:00AM (#27956174)
Talking to Californians is otherworldly.

I had one tell me that everywhere should put street signs on the roadway itself. Had no concept of what snow was apparently.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ajtjp on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:52AM (#27956797)
We put street signs on highways in Ohio. Quite handy for knowing whether you're in the correct lane, as it doesn't have the ambiguity that overhead signs can have.

Of course, we do also have overhead signs as a backup and for longer-range visibility. But it's more likely that the overhead signs are useless due to a setting sun than that the on-road ones are due to snow. The streets with on-road signs are very high priorities to plow, so the on-road signs are going to be visible unless it's a very bad storm where you probably shouldn't be on the road, and if you are you're probably going home and already know which lanes to be in.

I'm not saying this should be done for every road; it works best for roads known by a number (I-71; US-23; OH-315, etc.) where you don't have to read a long name. But it's not an daft as idea as it might sound.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by floatingatoll on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:43PM (#27965869)
I believe California does some of this in the really complex interchanges in the Bay Area, but I don't remember for certain and it's been years since I've been there.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ineedasername on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:53PM (#27955447)
High energy prices have probably done a lot to incentivize lower consumption & efficiency. But mild climate does still give it an unfair advantage if trying to compare it apples to apples with other states. South eastern states are always going to eat a huge chunk of Watt Hours in air conditioning, and in some states many people have little choice but to use electric heat or furnaces.

I'd be very interested in state-to-state comparisons that exclude internal climate control usage.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by throwaway984393 on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:03AM (#27955521)
It might not be that California has an unfair advantage, but that southern states have an unfair disadvantage.

If southern states spike their watt hours due to aircon, we could say the cause is poor construction/architecture. The poorer the insulation (southern homes' insulation is crap compared to northern) the more you need to pump the aircon. And when homes are not designed for optimal environmental efficiency or passive temp regulation, you can't cool the home well except with more aircon.

(All this also assumes that aircon is some sort of human right. We could learn how to deal with heat without power, the way we had to for the past 300,000 years)

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by josephcsible on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:40AM (#27955736)
We dealt with disease without modern knowledge of medicine or hygiene for the past 300,000 years too. The fact that lacking something didn't make the human race go extinct doesn't mean it's something we should just give up.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by blooalien on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:18PM (#27963090)
Ummm… Humans "dealt with disease" before "modern medicine" frequently by dying.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ineedasername on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:21PM (#27966205)
frequently by dying

In the long term, humans deal with everything by dying. It's rather inefficient and denotes a tendency to run away from any problem that can't be solved within the ~55 years of an educated human period of productivity. Maybe with a little more grit and resolve to avoid such cowardly tactics as death we would undertake longer term projects.

But as long as humans insist on dying, that is going to be a nearly impossible challenge. It is hard to get a person motivated to take on a high-stakes challenge when they plan on dying before the consequences of inaction impact them.

I propose that all humans make the sensible choice to not die, at least for a century or so longer than their current predilections in this area, to demonstrate their commitment to truly advancing the cause of human kind.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by josephcsible on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:42PM (#27964390)
Yes, that's my point. Technology can save a lot of lives, even though living without it didn't kill enough humans to drive us to extinction.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ineedasername on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:26PM (#27966244)
Yes, the argument from "But this is how natural humans used to live!" Has spawned any number of misaprehemsions, not to mention a few fad diets.

By all means, embrace food as eaten by out ancestors, if that's what someone really wants, but they should understand that such diets resulted in malnutrition and stunted growth, and we're "embraced" by our ancestors living on the brink of starvation & lack of choice.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by throwaway984393 on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:45PM (#27966413)
And it doesn't mean we have to keep it, either. It helps to research the particular scenario and find out whether there's a better path than the one we default into.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by jfrunyon on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:57AM (#27957209)
> The poorer the insulation (southern homes' insulation is crap compared to northern) the more you need to pump the aircon.

Insulation can only do so much when the outdoor temperature doesn't drop below 80F for weeks at a time.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by throwaway984393 on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:29PM (#27966265)
It doesn't matter how hot it is or for how long, it does its job regardless.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by tdeck on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:05AM (#27955900)
Heating is much more energy intensive than cooling (unless you have a heat pump, aren't particularly common in the U.S). Air conditioning consumes a lot of electrical power in comparison to heating, but if we're counting overall energy efficiency it seems like darker, colder northern climates should have a disadvantage.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by BenjiWiebe on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:04PM (#27962844)
In some areas, heating is cheaper with propane or wood then with electricity. Air conditioning, however, needs electricity.

We heat with wood and propane but air condition with electricity. Our electricity bill is much higher in the summer.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by Sylamore on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:11AM (#27959554)
heat pumps aren't common in the US?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by tdeck on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:17PM (#27962113)
Not for heating, most people heat their homes by burning natural gas or oil. Obviously an AC unit is heat pump but most aren't bidirectional.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @03:32PM (#27976554)
I think it varies a lot regionally
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ineedasername on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:08AM (#27955554)
I completely, fully, and totally agree. Although that's also why, in terms of energy efficiency progress, I'd like to see those factors take out and compare where they stand on consumption that is less tied to climate and construction quality.

That's not so say they should be discounted, only that each segment of energy consumption should be compared like to like.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:58AM (#27955858)
> (All this also assumes that aircon is some sort of human right. We could learn how to deal with heat without power, the way we had to for the past 300,000 years)

Well, sure, except that the way we dealt with the climate of the American South before air conditioning was by not living there. That is a major reason the South, and not the North, had so many slaves.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by chrisco255 on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:19AM (#27955623)
Our ancestors didn't really need air conditioning in the ice age.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by Dma54rhs on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:38AM (#27956723)
It's not an disadvantage, if you care about climate change you shouldn't flock to places where burnings tons of kwh's is the bare minimum to survive. Of course it's easier to deflect the subject to plastic straws and other pseudo topics.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ineedasername on Monday July 26, 2021 @08:47AM (#27958710)
I meant that you can't get an apple-to-apples comparison on different states' commitment to energy efficiency if you don't break energy consumption up into different categories of usage. It's also important to consider sources of energy: All else being equal, I would rather a state shut down coal power plants in favor of building or importing renewable electricity, instead of keeping the coal while reducing consumption. (They can do both, but in terms of priorities I'd go with switching to renewables first) These are the important details of consumption patterns that we have to focus on to keep moving forward. Are they pseudo topics?

I also don't think the world's temperate zones are large enough to facilitate everyone living in climates that have minimal requirements for heating & cooling. Also many areas that require a lot of energy for heating also require very little for cooling, and vice versa: another reason why consumption details are important when evaluating these things.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by npunt on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:29PM (#27955279)
Yep. According to Natural Resources Defense Council via NYT, "about a quarter of all residential energy consumption is used on devices in idle power mode" in Northern California [1]. Huge opportunity for efficiency improvement through regulatory action, given idle power consumption is otherwise an afterthought for both manufacturers and consumers.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/08/science/just-how-much-pow...

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by teruakohatu on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:43PM (#27955378)
> about a quarter of all residential energy consumption is used on devices in idle power

That cannot possibly be true. I would love to know how they calculated that.

In New Zealand only about 20% of home electricity is used on electronics. And in the USA it appears to be even lower.

https://www.nzcompare.com/n/power/average-household-electric...

https://www.visualcapitalist.com/what-uses-the-most-energy-h...

Dryers, fridges, heating and lighting are the vast majority of power and they don't use much idle power.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by throwaway09223 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:59PM (#27955499)
It's not true, at least not in the sense that's implied. If you read the study you'll see they defined "idle load" not as electronics but as all devices which operate passively.

They did ten case studies, and in one they found the highest idle load device was a water recirculation pump and the second was a halogen light being left on 24/7 because no one cared.

If they studied my home they would consider my fish tanks as "idle load," because they are designed to run continuously.

This is not a study of devices in sleep mode. This is a study primarily measuring devices left on, or devices designed to always be on.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by boulos on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:49PM (#27955420)
I suspect it’s not quite right either, but two of those appliances (dryer, heating) are often powered by natural gas in the US (and on the East Coast, heating is done with “heating oil”).
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:59PM (#27955496)
Heating oil is generally used more in older installations. Where natural gas is available, we're using that instead now.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by npunt on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:49PM (#27955425)
The link to the NRDC pdf with methodology is right there in the NYT article. Here it is, page 8. I edited my comment to show the study/quote was specifically about northern california https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/home-idle-load-IP.p...
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by soheil on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:06AM (#27955538)
This is the source NYT cited [0]. From page 11:

> Per research and analysis conducted by the Stanford Sustainable Systems Labs, idle load was 218 watts on average across the 70,000 homes in PG&E’s service territory. We estimated the always-on share of this idle load to be 164 watts.

Then they go on to say:

> ALWAYS-ON, 23% Continuous loads

> ACTIVE, 77% Variable loads, including heating and cooling, lighting, and actively used appliances

So their definition of idle load includes things like heating/cooling, wtf? Then they guesstimate that 23% of that is always-on load (continuous load) where do they get than number from?

[0] https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/home-idle-load-IP.p...

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by WalterBright on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:15AM (#27955597)
It's annoying that devices don't have physical power switches anymore. I usually use a bus strip with a switch on it.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by Ardren on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:41PM (#27955360)
Yep. This is literally why these PCs cannot be shipped. Their idle/sleep consumes too much power.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by mcswell on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:31AM (#27955696)
Maybe if they didn't snore so much?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by porphyra on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:28PM (#27955271)
How much of that is due to the mild climate and how much is due to the energy efficiency programs?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by BearOso on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:33PM (#27955308)
A few months of wildfires with brownouts where only half the population can have power at a given time will save a bucketload, too.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by kadoban on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:38PM (#27955341)
You think California spent months with 1/2 the population without power at a time?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by BearOso on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:42PM (#27955369)
Not continuously, just intermittently for a few months of the year.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by sologoub on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:58PM (#27955486)
Not really, I sat through the outages in Bay Area in the coastal area that basically got turned off by PG&E at the slightest hint of winds (yeah the coast is windy, that’s not new) and eventually broke down and bought a gasoline powered portable generator… not having hot water to shower with gets old very quickly, as does refilling ice chest with actual ice to have food.

Even then, it was at most a few weeks total. Annoying as hell, but probably not enough to really move the needle. Wish we could have had autonomous solar (but while renting, that wasn’t an option). Best I could do was a portable panel to recharge phones/power banks for the evening.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by borski on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:56PM (#27955474)
As sad as the fires were, it was nowhere near half the population without power, “for months.” Even intermittently/cumulatively.

Turns out, a LOT of people live in CA.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by bostonsre on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:22PM (#27955235)
What was the energy consumption per capita before 2018? Curious how much that mild climate is responsible for the energy consumption.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by dredmorbius on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:18AM (#27955613)
I'd really like to see that trended over time.

California's energy mix tends to be low due to a lack of both a heavy heating (northern climates) and cooling (southern / south-eastern) load. Housing stock has been notoriously inefficient in insulation, though newer construction gains on that.

Major usage has been in transportation. Sprawl'll do that to ya.

LLNL has historical energy usage charts, and began breaking that out by state sometime since the 1990s (possibly only in the 2000s / 2010s). History since 2010 is readily available here there's also an archive though you've got to hunt for it:

https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/commodities/energy

US EIA have 2019 data, but no trend-over-time. The map clearly shows that high per-capita energy usage is concentrated in states with either weather extremes, a large rural population, or both:

https://www.eia.gov/state/rankings/#/series/12

Intersting, New York is directly after California in per-capita usage. Rhode Island just edges out both.

A 2013 NRDC report shows that CA's per-capita usage has been flat since roughly 1980, whilst the rest of the US has increased. I suspect much of that growth is due to population increases in the South, with growing cooling load.

https://web.archive.org/web/20130714131300/http://www.nrdc.o...

Charts here: https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/California-Is-P...

There may well be a case to be made that California's accomplished significant progress in energy efficiency. But I've a strong suspicion that what we're looking at instead is credit-claiming where not particularly due, based on dominant other factors. That's unfortunately rather common in this space, in both senses of the word.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by tzs on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:59AM (#27960203)
The big difference between the high use per capita states and the low use per capita states seems to be industrial and transportation use.

Percent industrial and transportation use in the low states:

Rhode Island is 42.7%

California: 62.5%

New York: 41.4%

Florida: 50.9%

And the high states:

Wyoming: 79.4%

Louisiana: 86.5%

North Dakota: 73.7%

Alaska: 82.9%

Iowa: 72.5%

Texas: 76.1%

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by dredmorbius on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:45PM (#27963508)
Huh.

You're basing that on this https://www.eia.gov/state/seds/data.php?incfile=/state/seds/...

Also, much of the industrial use seems likely to be energy-industry related. I'm presuming: Wyoming (coal), Louisiana (oil), North Dakota (fracked natural gas), Alaska (oil), Texas (oil and gas).

Or it may be electric power. These states' energy use is dominated by coal, and see Table 26 which bundles "industrial" and "power generation": https://www.eia.gov/coal/annual/pdf/table26.pdf

Texas is the only high-population state listed.

Note that small states have lower per-capita efficiencies across the board, though yes, those specific states have high industrial/transport usage. Note that per-capita variance in smaller states tends to be higher than large ones regardless (more of them, smaller populations, more opportunity for outliers).

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by greesil on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:38PM (#27955343)
And yet I pay $.55/kWH at peak times to PG&E. Ugh.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:45PM (#27955394)
This fact isn't in opposition to California's low energy consumption. It is one of the causes of California's low energy consumption. It is expensive to use power in Cali. This is a good thing, for the long term future of the environment. It would be better if using power stung a little everywhere, so people would make more considered choices about what to consume.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by WillPostForFood on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:14AM (#27955588)
>just want to remind everyone how far California has gone in energy efficiency

How can we know how far California has come when the citation only has a single point in time referenced? What was the per capita consumption before 2018?

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by refurb on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:46PM (#27955397)
Proud of having a mild climate that doesn't require much heating or cooling?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by WalterBright on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:14AM (#27955586)
> mild climate

When I visited Hawaii long ago, typical homes were not even sealed. There'd be a large gap between the top of the walls and the roof. The idea was to let the breeze blow through. The air temperature never varied enough to make it worth installing an HVAC system.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by spfzero on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:54PM (#27955456)
Mild climate is something to be proud of? Sure glad we all pulled together on that one and changed the climate!
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ww520 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:25PM (#27955252)
Why do the electric bills keep increasing?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by ghouse on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:44PM (#27955383)
In part, because the fixed infrastructure is built to serve peak demand, not average consumption. Bring down the peak (flatten the curve) and the rates will come down too.

Or, put differently, rates are high exactly because California per-capita usage is low -- fewer kWh across which to amortize costs.

Importantly, while California rates are relatively high, customer's bills are not -- because the customers use less electricity.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by dragonwriter on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:48PM (#27955412)
> In part, because the fixed infrastructure is built to serve peak demand, not average consumption.

Also, net metering and widespread consumer generation (largely solar) means that the fixed infrastructure costs are actually amortized not across the low total energy usage, but across a fraction of the total, already low, usage.

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by tomc1985 on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:54AM (#27981003)
> Importantly, while California rates are relatively high, customer's bills are not

Clearly you have never dealt with SDG&E, home of the highest residential electricity rates in the country. And yes that translates to astronomical electricity bills for households

Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by nostromo on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:17AM (#27955606)
You put such a positive spin on spending more for less. You’re welcome, Californians, we’re doing you a favor!
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by yumraj on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:26PM (#27955257)
PG&E
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by breadzeppelin__ on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:28PM (#27955275)
gotta pay for all that wildfire liability somehow!
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by alasdair_ on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:38PM (#27955345)
To be fair, they also have to pay for blowing people up in natural gas explosions too.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by labster on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:15AM (#27956243)
To be more fair, they also have to pay for fixing some of the infrastructure they let deteriorate with falsified maintenance reports over the last 15 plus years.
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by rodeph on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:48PM (#27955411)
Why?
Re:PC can't be shipped to CA, CO, HI, OR, VT or WA due to po... by throwawayboise on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:27PM (#27955270)
Easy with so many people living in tents and cardboard shantys.