News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by sudosysgen on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:55PM (#27955057)
Sorry, no. Cars are the problem. The reason why other transit modes are a solution isn't because they in particular are the best option, generally it's because they aren't cars.

Cars aren't individual choices. They are a societal choice that costs a trillion dollars a year to make work. The issue is cars. No matter which way you slice it, we need to remove cars, and that will necessarily mean making driving a car worse.

I don't think that hiding your goals or intentions is politically a good option. Don't argue something you don't believe in. If you (correctly) identify that cars and car-supporting infrastructure is one of the biggest problems in North America, you have to call it like it is.

We don't actually want other options. We want better other options. The only way to get that is to de-incentivize cars. That's the reason why cars suck to begin with, the proliferation of cars makes every other mode of transport worse, except for inter-city rail, if only by sheer mass effect.

Now I agree that we shouldn't other people by putting them in categories and identifying them with the car. That doesn't mean that we stop opposing the real policies that make cars a good personal option and counter them with policies that make alternatives better, generally at their expense in some way or another. I agree that inter-personally the matter can be approached better, but that does not carry to changing your policy positions or goals, and that should never justify lying about what those are.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by sfvisser on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:38AM (#27956051)
Not all car usage is a problem.

I’m from the Netherlands which is incredibly bicycle friendly. Small country, highly urban, great cycling infra, great public transport, nearly everyone walks or cycles whenever it makes sense.

Still, cars are everywhere. There are just tons of trips where the alternative doesn’t really make sense.

Municipalities try everything to make the life of car owners miserable to force them into using alternatives. The only outcome is miserable drivers. They are in the car for a reason and won’t just switch.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by yuri91 on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:57AM (#27957570)
But your public transport is not great, really. It is pretty expensive, to the point that renting a car is cheaper than taking the train if you are 2 people. And trains are painfully slow too. Public transport inside cities is better (but still expensive), but less needed because biking infrastructure is really really good.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by lucideer on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:14AM (#27956951)
> Still, cars are everywhere.

I don't think cars will ever disappear, they're useful in many ways. But saying "cars are everywhere" in NL seems a bit of an overstatement, no? Cars are so much less dominant in NL than in other European countries (even Denmark).

> try everything to make the life of car owners miserable

Are they miserable because of inherent challenges of car ownership that other countries try to mitigate or is it really municipalities actively causing their misery?

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by aequitas on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:01AM (#27957236)
> But saying "cars are everywhere" in NL seems a bit of an overstatement, no?

Except for cities with pedestrian only centers, cars are everywhere here. In some bigger cities there are certainly some people that go around without cars as they have everything they need close by and good public transport. But most of they (especially just outside of the city center) have at least one car in their household.

Car ownership is even growing faster than population: https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/nieuws/2020/10/autopark-groeit-ster...

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by baud147258 on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:59AM (#27957220)
> Are they miserable because of inherent challenges of car ownership that other countries try to mitigate or is it really municipalities actively causing their misery?

Can't really talk for the NL, but for Paris, it really seems like the municipality is trying to make drivers miserable, while not improving the situation for everyone else

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by lucideer on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:45AM (#27957889)
Can you expand on this? What are the municipality doing exactly that is causing misery?

If it's just removing an amenity that was previously taken for granted, then I really don't think that necessarily applies.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by sudosysgen on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:01AM (#27958826)
I agree that we will still have cars. At some point, yes, we will have to accept the level of car use we get to, and at that level making drivers miserable won't really help, I agree.

We're just very far from that level. Also, the Netherlands while amazing is not perfect, we can still do better, though it is great.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bartvk on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:02AM (#27956865)
> Still, cars are everywhere. There are just tons of trips where the alternative doesn’t really make sense.

The obvious alternative is a car sharing platform. I've got a couple in my neighborhood and they work for the kind of trip you're describing.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Toutouxc on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:12AM (#27957676)
There's one thing that car sharing proponents still seem to miss, even on HN, which is interesting, HN being a community where everyone apparently runs Arch with i3, vim and custom dotfiles on a Thinkpad.

My car is MY car. There is no more dust or dirt in it than in my living room. The cabin filter has been recently replaced and there is no mold in the condenser. I know the single other person who drives it an exactly how she drives it. The brake pads are okay. The steering is okay. The wishbone bushings are okay and the car won't pull anywhere even under heavy braking. I've driven this car for thousands of kilometers and hundreds of hours, fast and slow, in rain and snow. If I ever need to evade an obstacle doing 130 kph on a highway in a split second, just by muscle memory, without flipping the car over and hurting myself or my girlfriend, I want it to be in this car.

People die driving cars. Cars are heavy machinery (!) operated by mostly incompetent, distracted, sometimes aggressive clothed monkeys and as long as this is true, I simply refuse to drive a vehicle I know nothing about and can't rely on.

I'm not even going to mention covid, thank god for my own car.

(Btw I do use shared cars for short trips around the city and the cars, despite being almost brand new, are mostly dirty poor banged up things driven like fucking go karts by other people.)

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bartvk on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:33AM (#27958173)
I haven't had that experience. Maybe it's due to the fact that my platform of choice does not allow casual driving. It's a pretty high monthly fee. The cars have remained clean and in very good shape, lasting about four years.

I totally agree with you. If I had your experience, then I definitely would've outright owned a car. No way I'll put my kid in an unsafe car.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by varjag on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:33AM (#27957414)
That's an alternative only if you don't need a car regularly. You still have to book a vehicle (availability can vary), get to the collection lot, get back home if you need to pick up someone for the trip, take the trip, deliver the passengers, clean up and fuel/charge the vehicle, deliver it back to the parking lot and get back home.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bartvk on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:30AM (#27958151)
Yes, that's correct. I'd have to hedge my previous statement and say it's only viable for regular car usage if there are multiple shared cars within walking distance.

For instance in my street, there's one. And another two in the next street. I've got an 8 year old and it works fine and I book up to three trips per week.

But if they weren't within walking range (for a kid) then indeed, it wouldn't be an alternative to owning a car.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by dalbasal on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:39AM (#27957446)
At least in the Netherlands, you guys have other options.

I live in Ireland. We also make life miserable for drivers, and basically unaffordable for young, or poor people. But here, about 50% of the population doesn't have access to any alternatives.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thereisnospork on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:56AM (#27956155)
>Cars aren't individual choices. They are a societal choice that costs a trillion dollars a year to make work. The issue is cars. No matter which way you slice it, we need to remove cars, and that will necessarily mean making driving a car worse.

Where is the better option? Most of what I ever hear proposed or implemented are fair weather or inflexible solutions that don't replace my need for a car[0], and thereby only serve to make my transit experience worse.

[0]And this is having lived in a variety of minor to major urban centers in the States.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thayne on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:30AM (#27956337)
I can see replacing cars in major urban cities with high population density. And I'd love to see more options for long distance travel in the US (like fast trains).

However, arguments for getting rid of cars seem to ignore the fact that public transit just isn't economical in areas with low population density. And even in urban areas, there are situations where having a car is very beneficial, such as grocery shopping. If you're a single individual it's probably manageable without a car, but for a family of four, you probably can't carry enough food for more than two or three days. If there were no cars in the city, I have no idea how you would purchase larger items like furniture.

Every anti-car argument I've seen has assumed a particular lifestyle. If you really want to get rid of cars, you'll need replacements that can solve the problems of almost everyone.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:34AM (#27956704)
Grocery and furniture delivery is a thing.

>Every anti-car argument I've seen has assumed a particular lifestyle.

Yes, a no car lifestyle.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thayne on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:00AM (#27960225)
> Grocery and furniture delivery is a thing.

But doesn't the delivery driver use a car?

Also, grocery delivery/pickup might work for some people, but my experience has not been good. For one thing, the store employee won't pick produce the same way I would. And if something is out of stock, I may want to change other items as well, rather than substitute it or omit it. Store employees often substitute differently than I would, which is especially problematic with a food allergy.

> Yes, a no car lifestyle.

I mean an urban lifestyle without kids.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:14PM (#27961259)
>But doesn't the delivery driver use a car?

They use a van and drop off at a hundred other customers homes in your vicinity.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thayne on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#27961804)
1. So you still need the infrastructure for cars 2. Again, that's only efficient in areas with high population density.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by paulddraper on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:11AM (#27956223)
> Cars aren't individual choices.

But they are.

There are number of individualized transport options.

And yet, year after year people really, really like cars.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by masklinn on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:44AM (#27956416)
> There are number of individualized transport options.

That is not actually true. In almost all of the US, as well as in most of europe (outside of large urban centers with good public transport) there is no viable alternative to cars.

The netherlands is one of the few places where avoiding cars is an actual option, elsewhere it requires heavy compromission, and imposes significant restrictions on various life choices. If giving up cars means giving up living or having to seriously compromise on your ability to achieve things, it’s as much a choice as “cake or death”.

I’ve lived without owning a car for 20-odd years (with the odd rental / borrowing), it’s only an option because I’m a very non-social person and don’t have children (so my need to move around day-to-day are extremely limited), and I’ve selected my living locations largely around the ability to not have a car, which would leave about 90% of the area unlivable if everybody made the same choices, because there simply is not enough car-free infrastructure for that to be anywhere near a universal option.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by guerrilla on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:25AM (#27957032)
> outside of large urban centers with good public transport

Maybe in Eastern Europe or something but most of Western Europe has no such problem, especially in the North.

> The netherlands is one of the few places where avoiding cars is an actual option, elsewhere it requires heavy compromission, and imposes significant restrictions on various life choices.

Not even close to true in Scandinavia, Belgium, Germany or even poor ass Portugal.

I'm not sure how you got to these conclusions. Maybe you're underestimating just how bad the US as a European is or maybe you've never lived in Europe.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by masklinn on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:56AM (#27957565)
> Not even close to true in Scandinavia, Belgium, Germany or even poor ass Portugal.

It’s absolutely true in Belgium (and france), of which I have first-hand experience.

Despite the overall populations density, the public transport network outside of cities is patchy at best and tends towards low frequency: outside of school transport hours buses might only run every 2 or 3 hours, or not at all. Some lines don’t even run outside of school days.

The general assumption is that adults have a car and don’t rely — let alone depend — on public transports.

> I'm not sure how you got to these conclusions.

By having lived them? They’re not conclusions, they’re observations or having lived for years without a car (by choice).

> Maybe you're underestimating just how bad the US as a European is or maybe you've never lived in Europe.

Or maybe you’re way over-estimating how good Europe is? Just because the US is bottom barrel garbage-tier does not mean rural europe is any good.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by guerrilla on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#27961810)
> Or maybe you’re way over-estimating how good Europe is? Just because the US is bottom barrel garbage-tier does not mean rural europe is any good.

Definitely not. No, I think what we have here in these comments is, on the one hand, a bunch of spoiled people complaining about great service (which I find very typical in Europe) and differing definitions of what's efficient and expected. In 20 years, I've never had a problem, but I also don't expect to be able to get to every single cow-milking farm by foot. If you live in way out in the woods, then you need need a car, but not if you live in most villages. For rarer buses, plan ahead. It's all possible and comfortable. In the US, it's literally not possible under any circumstances for most places.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by varjag on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:37AM (#27957438)
> Maybe in Eastern Europe or something but most of Western Europe has no such problem, especially in the North.

I'm in Norway. It's absolutely a car society, and unless you live in a dense population center living carless is unfeasible.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by skinkestek on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:50AM (#27957517)
Agree. I also live in Norway and have done for years.

I can get

- to work (bike or bus + train + 1km walk),

- to the shop (walk or bike),

- to many of my friends (walk or bike),

- to the town center (bus or bike)

quite comfortably alone, and I think at least except winter most (by number) of my trips is car free.

But good look getting 5 kids somewhere where there isn't a bus line (soccer, ice hockey, activities, church, in-laws house, frinds across town, fishing).

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by varjag on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:03AM (#27957609)
I live in 2nd largest city, and 11 km drive from work. If I want to take public transport, I first have to take a bus going once per hour, switch to another bus going into opposite direction, and then take a third bus to work. Bus can be a bit late so am not making the connection, or sometimes a connecting bus not showing up. Then you stand another 20 minutes in the rain (it usually rains here) on the shoulder of a motorway.

I could also cycle in theory; however my home is 88 meters over sea level and my work in 100+ on another hill. Did I also mention it rains a lot? Some people like the challenge and do it anyway (but virtually none does that every day). I can't be arsed to sweat out on my way to the office though.

And yes that's before you get to having kids. Or living outside a city: then you have a bus on one route going maybe 2-4 times a day.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by masklinn on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:59AM (#27958361)
> I could also cycle in theory; however my home is 88 meters over sea level and my work in 100+ on another hill. Did I also mention it rains a lot? Some people like the challenge and do it anyway (but virtually none does that every day). I can't be arsed to sweat out on my way to the office though.

TBF electric bicycles help a lot with the latter, and the usual “there’s no bad weather only bad clothing” norwegian saying definitely applies.

But that’s assuming the infrastructure matches, cycling in the rain when well-equipped is one thing, cycling in the rain dodging cars and getting sprayed is quite an other.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by varjag on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:15AM (#27959598)
The infrastructure is decent, only the last mile stretch (uphill of course) is shared with car traffic. Still it's not a relaxing ride, and would probably double my commute time even with an e-bike.

As I mentioned there are people doing that anyway, but even the hardcore cyclist types are doing it only a few days in a month.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by skinkestek on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @10:09AM (#27972652)
I lived there too and I can vaguely remember getting from Fyllingsdalen to Sotra at night by bus while bringing my mopping gear :-\
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by mft_ on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:53AM (#27957542)
Same for Germany and the UK, in my experience. Within or very close to major cities, it’s feasible albeit often slow and frustrating.

A bit further out, cars are close to vital, unless you specifically optimise for public transport when choosing your home and work locations, and accept major restrictions around social and hobby activities.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thefr0g on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:42AM (#27959245)
I live in germany and even in "structually weak" eastern regions you can get by ok without a car unless you live in a very tiny village or are physically impaired. Public transport could be way cheaper though.

Imo many people in germany have still to realize that it's not feasible to make big bucks in the city while hiding from the fruits of their labour in the countryside.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by kewrkewm53 on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:12AM (#27958044)
At least here in Finland public transportation absolutely does not work in most of the countryside. Maybe you count us as Eastern Europe, but I can tell that the situation is no different in Sweden for example.

The truth is that replacing private car ownership for people living in countryside in many countries would require large government spending to operate lines that are not commercially viable.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bookofsand on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:32PM (#27962351)
In practice, 'bus lines that are not commercially viable' actually means empty behemoths running at times where nobody needs them, wasting way more fossil fuels compared to just letting people own their own comparatively tiny cars.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by paulddraper on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:55AM (#27956476)
> there is no viable alternative to cars

Well, there I agree. Mopeds, motorcycles, electric bikes...alternatives, but not viable for most people.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Karrot_Kream on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:44AM (#27956420)
> But they are.

They are. Except for building highways. Gas subsidies. Gas stockpiling for security purposes. Road Maintenance. Signage. And then there's the opportunity cost of the space lost to parking.

Those above choices? Well they're collective and everyone has to pay for them, because without raising taxes they are much too expensive to fund privately. So even if you ride a bicycle to the train to work everyday, you still get to pay for the construction and maintenance of the highway that driving commuters drive their cars on that you can't ride your bicycle, or any smaller motorcycle, on.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by masklinn on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:34AM (#27956707)
> Except for building highways. Gas subsidies. Gas stockpiling for security purposes. Road Maintenance. Signage.

No need to even go that far. Just building so many roads (which are inimical to anything but cars by definition), stroads and parking space requirements: when 60% if a commercial lot has to be parking you reduce commercial density by 2/3rds, and increase the difficulty of alternate modes if transport because it becomes significantly more difficult to make rounds without a car.

And that’s if you can even reach the place to start with. The latest “not just bikes” video has a demo of a short walk through a houston suburb (where the author originally needed to go 800m to buy replacement luggage), and it’s terrifying.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by shadofx on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:16PM (#27966171)
I doubt Houston suburbs will ever replicate a European walkable city. Europe had a heatwave recently and thousands died. Houston deals with that sort of temperature every summer. Then there's the humidity.

Meanwhile business offices in Houston continue to be aggressively air-conditioned, filled with people wearing full suits and ties, in blind imitation of European culture.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by masklinn on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @11:14AM (#27973420)
That's rather missing the point.

People die in european heatwaves because they're not used to the heat and don't have the right habits, and the homes are not set up to handle them: AC is relatively rare (especially whole-house AC), homes are not set up for airflow, and almost none have ceiling fans. Unshaded southern / south-western windows are also rather common, as usually the goal has been to get the sun and heat in, not keep them out (in fact in the last few decades the building codes have drastically increased the required window surface).

Which of course doesn't mean you should follow a central or northern european set up for a city like Houston, you should rather look at southern-europe, or SEA. But overall it's probably going to look like favouring shade, greenery, and airflow.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by adrianN on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:57AM (#27957208)
Cars are the choice dictated by infrastructure and land use patterns optimized for cars. Strictly separate residential areas and commercial areas, connect the two with wide roads and offer free parking at each end and, surprise, people really like cars. Build neighborhoods where daily necessities are in walking distance and connect them using trains and, surprise, people really like walking and taking the train.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by okokwhatever on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:41AM (#27957128)
I adore how your moral position is more important than the opinion of those who believe the contraire.