News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by cauliflower99 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @05:43AM (#27842951)
'After Google employee James Damore circulated his memo that included many sexist statements about the "natural abilities" of female vs. male engineers...'

Really? Do people (who actually read the study) really think it was sexist? It stated the obvious - that there are differences in interests in men compared to women by aggregate.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by fareesh on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:57AM (#27844131)
Came here and CTRL+F Damore, glad I wasn't the only one disappointed with that framing.

We are now living in an age where it is simply not possible to discuss some topics without someone twisting the discussion into one of the various deadly sins, and everyone who engages becomes guilty of it by association.

For example, in the USA if you are in favor of less immigration, the assumption is that you are operating from a place of xenophobia and racism, because there is no other possible explanation in the universe from having those views. If you state your views coherently, demonstrated that the concerns are rooted in other factors entirely - then the bogeymen of subconscious and unconscious biases and inability to confront deeply rooted bigotry and revealed as the causes, much like the spirits of evil who possessed you when you said things to criticize orthodoxy in the past.

Likewise if one wants to discuss topics like representation across groups, one is inevitably branded a heretic for a heterodox view, regardless of the reasoning.

It's really terrible that this kind of attitude is so widespread in the west.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by derangedHorse on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:02AM (#27843753)
Yeah but he was pretty liberal with his conclusions he claimed were derived from data. It's pretty easy to see flaws in his arguments like how he inflated the behavioral differences between genders, and his inability to thoroughly consider differences being caused by societal factors (nature vs. nurture).

I think the main issue with his memo is the implication that diversity efforts were, at the time, problematic. The truth is, with such low diversity numbers even with the diversity programs, it's likely that any subpar candidates admitted probably equaled the subpar candidates admitted into Google at large. The numbers for gender diversity are even more skewed when viewed through the lens of the engineering department (which is the one relevant to the memo), which is unfortunately not available from the google diversity site like it used to be.

You can see the diversity breakdown for yourself here: https://diversity.google/annual-report/representation/

You can also see a longer analysis Damore's liberal assumptions here: https://www.wired.com/story/the-pernicious-science-of-james-...

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:26AM (#27843949)
Looks like the wired analysis and your own views can be summarised as "we don't understand everything about psychology", and that "biological differences barely matter, it largely comes down to nurture instead of nature." One is worthless noise, the other demonstrably false.

Whats more, this has had progressives crawling all over it with arguments including "Just allow the slander to go on unanswered", "its someone else's definition of sexist so he's sexist", "I heard he does other evil things" and attempts to distract from the point.

At this stage vaguery without clear examples can be dismissed as nothing at best or marked as evidence of bad faith debate driven by religious compulsion at worst.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by CleaveIt2Beaver on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:07AM (#27844208)
> "the other demonstrably false"

Go on... Demonstrate.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by sanity31415 on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:41AM (#27856126)
The data[1] shows that as countries get more egalitarian, the personality differences between the sexes increases rather than decreases, which is the opposite of what would be predicted if these differences were 100% due to socialization.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30206941/

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by skinkestek on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:39AM (#27845984)
I'll take the bait.

You go check the statistics so you don't accuse me of cherry picking or anything:

Go right ahead and look at all scientific studies you can find. See if men and women score exactly the same or if there are sometimes huge differences.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by joshuamorton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:52AM (#27846160)
That doesn't address the nature vs. nurture question.

Assume for a minute we all agree that there are observable iq differences and observable differences in likelyhood one ventures into computer science.

Then what? You've claimed that this is due to biolgical factors not social ones. Prove it.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by elzbardico on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:19PM (#27846453)
Why in hell would societies start by nurturing the sexes differently if they weren’t different to start. I know that lots of girls are mechanically inclined, but in average they aren’t. 14 years and thousands of dollars of robots, mindstorms and all kind of stuff that my daughter is not into technical stuff, no matter how much I tried to avoid the barbies and make up stuff. And she is like most, but not all the friends her age. We need to make sure that girls that want to do stuff that usually is more associated with boys are free to pursue their interests in equal conditions. But extrapolating this to “we need to have parity in all those predominantly masculine professions(of course, only the well paid).
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by joshuamorton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:11PM (#27848807)
> Why in hell would societies start by nurturing the sexes differently if they weren’t different to start.

We're talking about biological differences in either cognitive ability or interest in engineering/CS.

The well understood answer to your question is that there was a split in gender roles at about the time agriculture was adopted, with men working outside and women doing indoor tasks. This led to a breadwinner/homemaker split across gender lines which impacted the way genders were conventionally taught.

This extended to higher education opportunities, which in the US for example only really began to be open to women in the mid to late 1800s.

Note how none of this has anything to do with any cognitive ability that women might have had. It extends from the fact that men were superior agricultural fieldworkers thousands of years ago.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by CRConrad on Saturday July 24, 2021 @05:37PM (#27944687)
Note how

A) You start out with "either cognitive ability or interest in engineering/CS", but by your last paragraph you're down to "cognitive ability" alone. Damore's thesis was, AFAICR, mainly about the "interest" bit. Does this divergence in what you are talking about vs what he was mean anything, and if so what?

B) > The well understood answer to your question is that there was a split in gender roles at about the time agriculture was adopted, with men working outside and women doing indoor tasks.

And this split... Just happened? Or was it maybe due to differences in, well, how interested people of different sexes on average were/are in different kinds of tasks? Or why else were men "superior agricultural fieldworkers thousands of years ago"?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by commandlinefan on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:09AM (#27844896)
> he was pretty liberal with his conclusions he claimed were derived from data

Well, ok, fair enough, but if that's the case then the correct response was, "I can see why you think that, but have you considered..." not immediate banishment.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by joshuamorton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:54AM (#27846183)
Don't worry, there was quite a bit of that. He was asked to tone down the document and remove some of the most ridiculous parts (including for example the antisemitic conspiracy bit) and refused.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by the_only_law on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:57AM (#27846210)
> including for example the antisemitic conspiracy bit

I don’t recall hearing about this at the time. Do you have any links to what this was about. I tried to Google, but just got results related to more recent Google removals.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by joshuamorton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:03PM (#27846272)
"postmodern neo Marxists" in a foot note. It may have been unintentional, but it's essentially the cultural Marxism conspiracy, repackaged by Jordan Peterson.

It had nothing to do with anything else in the document but had to stay for some reason.

Edit: actually it looks like by the version that's public he did reword it, but I recall it being worse originally. It's still like a completely terrible understanding of intersectionality, but at least it's not as overtly antisemitic.

[dead]
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:17PM (#27847144)
It's honestly getting creepy at this point.

Throughout this entire comment tree starting from its base you have multiple long term HN users all consciously going out of their way to constructs lies in the pursuit of defaming this man.

joshuamorton is supposedly a google employee according to his profile and yet was perfectly happy to throw the antisemitism bs around.

There's several accounts down the bottom, each a number of years old and ostensibly regular otherwise; all of which have made efforts to come to this discussion and make up slander. And then of course run when pressed to provide evidence.

And they do all this despite the counter evidence being available to all.

Honestly, what is happening there? Is it some sort of collective insanity? Is it something they all agree needs to be done for some greater good? And if that's the case do they agree to it subconsciously/consciously? Is it all just people who are incredibly susceptible to group pressure and who will go along with any absurdity so long as it's ordered from the right authority.

How do you go about justifying deliberately attempting to hurt a person like this?

Just the sight of it astounds me.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:11PM (#27848028)
It's possible that each of the individuals, rather than act with bad intentions, simply exist in bubbles in which they heard these allegations, and repeated them here without checking them first.

Hopefully, if this is the case, these individuals realise the bubble they exist in, and give such topics more scrutiny in future.

That said @textgel, I find bringing up individual user's details a bit unsavoury; By all means, distinguish between long-term vs short-term users, but I don't think you should bring up employer, even if it's public info.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:33PM (#27849066)
That's fair; apologies. I'm too late to edit it now but if some passing mods see it and is able to alter please do so.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by the_only_law on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:55PM (#27849338)
> Honestly, what is happening there?

Despite HN being explicitly not a venue for politics, enough of the userbase has de-facto decided it should be. This of course invites all the sort of internet antics that come with politics which HN users in the past have decried and claimed that the lack of here makes it a more pleasant place in general.

That's when you find these otherwise normal accounts, acting up, accounts that exist solely for flamebating, drive by throwaways attempting to derail threads, etc. And since HN is primarily user-moderated (ironically despite what a subset of the previously described types often insinuate), these sort of behavior can become encouraged if enough people agree the the text or subtext of such comments.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by commandlinefan on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:41PM (#27847521)
The comment you replied to is actually flagged dead now.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:45PM (#27847594)
"showdead" is a must for HN
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by elzbardico on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:22PM (#27846485)
I was a Marxist for a long time. A well read one, and I can tell you that definitely there’s something that we could call “cultural Marxism” .
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by the_only_law on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:29PM (#27846575)
As someone faintly familiar with various Marxist ideologies (admittedly, not particularly well read though) how would you define the latter. I assume you are contrasting it with textual Marxism or Marxist theory.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Izkata on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:47AM (#27856183)
> and his inability to thoroughly consider differences being caused by societal factors (nature vs. nurture).

The goal was to find how to make the job more attractive to female developers. If the difference exists, then in this context the distinction does not matter.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by CRConrad on Saturday July 24, 2021 @05:44PM (#27944722)
> The goal was to find how to make the job more attractive to female developers.

But why should that be a goal? Is there any inherent value in having all jobs be equally attractive to everybody? If so, where are all the efforts to make jobs like garbage collection less male-dominated?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by sanity31415 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:00AM (#27843050)
I read his study at the time and it said no such thing, he was vilifed for questioning an orthodoxy that said any difference in representation must necessarily be caused by discrimination. Respected psychologists like Steven Pinker agreed with Damore.

This guy either didn't read it or he's easily influenced by cancel mobs.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by mStreamTeam on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:39AM (#27843603)
He left Google to go to Twitter, the HQ of cancel mobs
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by thinkingemote on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:43AM (#27843311)
It's important to read the stated reason from the company for his firing. He was fired for spreading "unhelpful stereotypes". These differences might be obvious and natural to most of the world but they are unhelpful and not welcome in that company. The company wanted to fight against the stereotypes as they considered those a barrier. It's important to realise that the company in that episode never fought to properly and logically argue against the stereotypes and why they were factually false versus others arguing why they were true because that would have been much more troublesome. Much discussions on HN seem to get stuck around the logic and truth nature of the issue - where the actual stated reasons is all about what's "helpful" or not.

In other words, if enough people feel something is sexist then it's in a company's best interest to agree with them.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by flavius29663 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:06AM (#27843780)
That was the whole point of the debacle, though. IIRC Google noticed that what they were currently doing was not bringing more women onboard, so they asked some of their employees for opinions. Damore wrote his, which circulated internally for a while with no issues. Then it was leaked and the cancel mob got to him. Only then Google fired him. It wasn't like he was trying to promote these opinions like a googler Alex Jones, at least not from what I know.

I think firing Damore for an opinion shows what cowards they are and everything that is wrong with the current woke movement: don't talk about new ideas or possible solutions, don't open up uncomfortable discussions, only bow to mob led slogans otherwise you're burned at the stake.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:09AM (#27843438)
That...changes nothing?

It just demonstrates a collective insanity at the organisation in question.

They're welcome to put their heads in the sand and claim whatever irrational bs they desire is "unhelpful" and "sexist" but that doesn't make it so.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:19PM (#27848155)
My old accountant maintained that $1+$1=$2, which was very harmful to my finances. I fired them immediately for such unhelpful stereotypes.

My new accountant agrees that $1+$1=$3, creating a much less hostile work environment. S/He even practises intersectionality wrt profit vs debt - me and my employees have never been happier!

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:45AM (#27844057)
I have come to the conclusion that we humans have a very difficult time perceiving reality once our tribe has decided something. I'm sure it saved our ancestors from ostracism and exile. I have no doubt that some people read that memo thoroughly and are sincerely convinced it is sexist while being unable to point to anything sexist in the memo. Scary. Humans are scary apes.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#27844089)
But it isn't "our tribe" - it's specifically the "blue church" pushing a very intentional narrative against an easy target.

That's to say: This isn't just the chaotic whisperings of twitter, but many complicit media outlets repeating this.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:36AM (#27844482)
Lol, yes. I agree. It's not "our tribe" that has bias. It's "their tribe". "Our tribe" is noble, generous and infallible. "Their tribe" is misinformed at best, but probably crazy if not outright evil.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:29AM (#27845164)
Well not completely but yes more or less. Look at this comment collection surrounding Damore. The one thing that unifies the group defending the firing is that they are all willing to lie to do so and are doing it in pursuit of socially destroying someone who is by rational, innocent. After all if he wasn't the group wouldn't have to lie.

At that stage if you can't reflect on your behaviour and that of those on your side, well there either is no hope for you or you're just further lying along with your fellow ideologues.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:30AM (#27845877)
Well, I agree with respect to Damore. He is innocent of these accusations. That was awful.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:40AM (#27846007)
Don't get me wrong, you're absolutely right about the tribalism that affects all sides in this situation we're in.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:30PM (#27846594)
I didn't say anything about "our tribe" being right/biased.

I said "our tribe" isn't saying this, where "our tribe" is a quote of the original comment.

This is consistent with any of these statements:

- our tribe say the opposite

- our tribe say something different entirely

- our tribe have no consensus on the issue / there is no "our tribe"

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Sunday July 18, 2021 @03:49AM (#27871411)
Ok. But still, Damore's situation as part of a general human trend, from which the pro-Damore faction is not immune. There are no doubt pro-Damore people who are pro-Damore just because their tribe* is pro-Damore, and not because of the actual content of the memo. This is the identical error as the antis.

It's difficult not to make such errors because those of our tribal ancestors who did not immediately and unconditionally support the tribe died. Those who did, lived.

If you want to help, pointing out which faction is making the error is not as helpful as insisting on the principled truth no matter which faction is correct. It's a dangerous road, because humans are scary, genocidal apes.

* > - our tribe have no consensus on the issue / there is no "our tribe"

Agreed. If one can lift one's perceptions out of partisanship, there is only a unified group of people who all (with a few psychopathic exceptions) want the best for themselves, their families, and society as a whole, whose only disagreement is as to method of getting there. And nevertheless, these small disagreements can easily magnify and become physically violent, because humans are scary apes who will elevate tribal affiliation even above literal perception. So, for some people, they absolutely have a tribe, and if you disagree with it, you are them.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @03:21PM (#27875767)
> If you want to help, pointing out which faction is making the error is not as helpful as insisting on the principled truth no matter which faction is correct

Which also doesn't work, precisely because of the "tribal error" being made, that removes all nuance of principle.

> whose only disagreement is as to method of getting there

This isn't really true. as a group of people, our circumstances are different, and hence we are motivated towards different, non-unified goals. It's hard to fight zero-sum instincts.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Sunday July 18, 2021 @06:40PM (#27877322)
Well, there have always been those of us who do hold principles above partisan affiliation. Doing so brought the world Enlightenment, Democracy, Emancipation, Suffrage. Give it a go.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @08:51PM (#27878128)
Affiliation and principle aren't always different. Hitler was defeated by murdering his associates. Taking credit for the fruits of civilization is to whitewash the history of the world.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by UncleMeat on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:18AM (#27843480)
Now we use the word “study” for it? The text preemptively claims that people will reject it because they are too politically correct. It was never presented as a neutral scientific analysis. From the beginning it was a slanted criticism of Google’s hiring practices.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:32AM (#27843559)
I don't really get what you're arguing? This seems to be just semantics on a 3rd party comment on a forum.

> The text preemptively claims that people will reject it because they are too politically correct.

The text was right.

> From the beginning it was a slanted criticism of Google’s hiring practices.

Yes, how does this relate to the original point?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by UncleMeat on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:21AM (#27843893)
> The text was right.

Weird how a lot of academics don't agree.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:31AM (#27843976)
Quite probably. They're welcome to disagree about the reality we are literally discussing right now, just as there were no doubt members that disagreed with the realities outlined in the letter, and in taking part helped cause the situation (that according to you they are denying) in the first place.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by commandlinefan on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:16AM (#27844982)
But just as many academics do.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:59AM (#27844144)
A lot more journalist don't agree too, which is perhaps why those academics got so much airtime.

Even in the legal system "expert testimony" can be a dubious process - in the court of press-media there is no bar to cherry-picking.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by CRConrad on Saturday July 24, 2021 @05:50PM (#27944753)
> The text preemptively claims that people will reject it because they are too politically correct.

Yeah, so? You say that as if the fact that a lot of people did exactly that for exactly that reason somehow shows some flaw with the text.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by ggggtez on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:53AM (#27844717)
"study"

It wasn't a study, it was basically a MGTOW chain letter. Anyone who has experience in science knows that the arguments it purported to show were cherry picked nonsense. A conclusion looking for evidence.

And yes, obviously people read it that way. He was fired because he wouldn't stop arguing about it, remember?

People acting like sharing a "study" that [minorities] are intellectually inferior is just normal behavior for an engineer. Who the hell does that?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:13AM (#27844945)
> And yes, obviously people read it that way. He was fired because he wouldn't stop arguing about it, remember?

Various people keep claiming that but there doesn't appear to be any proof of it.

> People acting like sharing a "study" that [minorities] are intellectually inferior is just normal behavior for an engineer.

Quote the part where he says this.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by ggggtez on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:44AM (#27845354)
> quote

I don't need to read it for you. If you walked away from that and didn't notice that the entire thesis is that [minorities] are worse engineers than [majority] then you just didn't read it

And beyond that, it's a moot point, because even if you don't see it, plenty of other people read it that way. Enough people read it that way that he was fired for it. It doesn't matter which citation I make. It's been dissected by hundreds of people in excruciating detail. Go read one of those ready analyses for the gory details and citations. It will be more intellectually fulfilling than rehashing it here again

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:05AM (#27845599)
Oh isn't that convenient. The definitely racist memo full of racism has so much in it that it is somehow completely impossible to quote any section at all that contains it.

> And beyond that, it's a moot point, because even if you don't see it, plenty of other people read it that way. Enough people read it that way that he was fired for it.

Well you personally are absolutely certain that a document definitely contains racist statements despite being completely incapable of quoting even one. Seems this is an affliction that can affect quite a few people. Well seeing as that's the "logic" you can muster perhaps we should put some sort of protections in place to the shipping industry. After all quite a few people are adamant the world is flat and we don't want to see cruise liners falling off the edge of the world now do we.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by browningstreet on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:30PM (#27846592)
> Enough people read it that way that he was fired for it.

Cause there are never culture-wide delusions?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:29PM (#27848269)
Then, assuming they all agree with you, can you link to one of those people/analyses who quote the racist parts of the memo?

If this is being "rehash[ed] here again" it should be easy enough to find a quote from the previous it was "hashed", no?

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by ausbah on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:43AM (#27843630)
I personally viewed the statement as verging-on-sexism because the I think the extent to which gender disparities are explained by "biological differences" is still much smaller than plain old discrimination

I don't think he's evil or sexist for writing what he did, but I strongly disagree with what he wrote and even more disappointed he went on to become a poster child for Fox News

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by cauliflower99 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:18AM (#27844306)
EDIT: Someone rightfully pointed out that it was a memo, not a study.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by elzbardico on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:12PM (#27846380)
We are not supposed to discuss this. Please just accept it as a taboo topic, not only here on HN but elsewhere too. Probably even Damore would like to be forgotten
[dead]
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:04AM (#27844847)
When does a HN thread ever have a fruitful end? Most threads I read here on the topic end the same way: One side is convincing, the other is not. This topic in particular is important because it concerns an specific document, and the facts therein, rather than a more subjective interpretation of events. Whenever these claims are made, references (from the memo) are requested, and never/rarely supplied.

I agree this is repetitive, but so is the repeated lie of sexism. Since "a lie oft repeated becomes truth" - the boring repetition is simply a means to prevent this.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by ashtonkem on Friday July 16, 2021 @01:38AM (#27853315)
I find it really fascinating that your response to my frustration on the subject is to attempt to engage me on the subject I visibly and clearly am sick of. You seem to be under the impression that I am interested in this matter; you are wrong.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by CRConrad on Saturday July 24, 2021 @05:56PM (#27944791)
You utterly misunderstood the comment you replied to. Re-read it, and maybe you'll understand. If not, maybe my re-formulation of it will help:

It is not about convincing you. It's about not letting your wrong-headed viewpoint stand unopposed, sine otherwise the preponderance of such unopposed viewpoints might give uninformed bystanders the impression that they're actually true.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by jeffbee on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:39AM (#27844536)
Forever, because HN constantly argues the content of his stupid document while ignoring the fact that he wasn't fired for writing it, he was fired for going all around the company harassing people and waving it in their faces, for months.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:45AM (#27844607)
Any proof of this claim?
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by bcrosby95 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:24AM (#27845096)
I highly doubt it, considering the CEO's memo on the subject:

https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/diversity/note-empl...

If he were literally harassing people I'm pretty sure that would have been mentioned.

What usually happens in these cases is people that object to the material wave it in everyone's face.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by jeffbee on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:41AM (#27845310)
There is no usual pattern of these things. Damore had been shopping his thing around for a long time. I first saw it on the libertarians mailing list, where the members of that group told him in no vague terms to fuck right off with that noise. Then he crashed the "women in engineering" conference to whine about its existence. Finally they got rid of him.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:33PM (#27848333)
None of this is mentioned in any publication I can find, do you have inside information?
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by eloisant on Thursday July 15, 2021 @05:56AM (#27843018)
please don't start this again
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by sanity31415 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:01AM (#27843057)
False narratives should be challenged.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:58AM (#27843396)
No, we aren't going to just politely allow you to enable slander.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by strangecyan on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:07AM (#27843090)
Yes, both the tone and the words on paper were sexist. I would give it another look and try and read it in the most empathic light you can, you might reflect on it.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by sanity31415 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:32AM (#27843247)
I assume you don't mean empathy for its author. Can you quote the sexist part? Please be specific.

Here is the original memo for your convenience: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-I...

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by UncleMeat on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:19AM (#27843486)
Believe it or not, that isn’t the “original” in the sense of the first thing Damore did on the subject. The external world just got to see this one event.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:24AM (#27843512)
A claim you have both proof of and a link to the "original" that you will surely provide.