Whats more, this has had progressives crawling all over it with arguments including "Just allow the slander to go on unanswered", "its someone else's definition of sexist so he's sexist", "I heard he does other evil things" and attempts to distract from the point.
At this stage vaguery without clear examples can be dismissed as nothing at best or marked as evidence of bad faith debate driven by religious compulsion at worst.
Go on... Demonstrate.
You go check the statistics so you don't accuse me of cherry picking or anything:
Go right ahead and look at all scientific studies you can find. See if men and women score exactly the same or if there are sometimes huge differences.
Assume for a minute we all agree that there are observable iq differences and observable differences in likelyhood one ventures into computer science.
Then what? You've claimed that this is due to biolgical factors not social ones. Prove it.
We're talking about biological differences in either cognitive ability or interest in engineering/CS.
The well understood answer to your question is that there was a split in gender roles at about the time agriculture was adopted, with men working outside and women doing indoor tasks. This led to a breadwinner/homemaker split across gender lines which impacted the way genders were conventionally taught.
This extended to higher education opportunities, which in the US for example only really began to be open to women in the mid to late 1800s.
Note how none of this has anything to do with any cognitive ability that women might have had. It extends from the fact that men were superior agricultural fieldworkers thousands of years ago.
A) You start out with "either cognitive ability or interest in engineering/CS", but by your last paragraph you're down to "cognitive ability" alone. Damore's thesis was, AFAICR, mainly about the "interest" bit. Does this divergence in what you are talking about vs what he was mean anything, and if so what?
B) > The well understood answer to your question is that there was a split in gender roles at about the time agriculture was adopted, with men working outside and women doing indoor tasks.
And this split... Just happened? Or was it maybe due to differences in, well, how interested people of different sexes on average were/are in different kinds of tasks? Or why else were men "superior agricultural fieldworkers thousands of years ago"?
Well, ok, fair enough, but if that's the case then the correct response was, "I can see why you think that, but have you considered..." not immediate banishment.
I don’t recall hearing about this at the time. Do you have any links to what this was about. I tried to Google, but just got results related to more recent Google removals.
It had nothing to do with anything else in the document but had to stay for some reason.
Edit: actually it looks like by the version that's public he did reword it, but I recall it being worse originally. It's still like a completely terrible understanding of intersectionality, but at least it's not as overtly antisemitic.
Throughout this entire comment tree starting from its base you have multiple long term HN users all consciously going out of their way to constructs lies in the pursuit of defaming this man.
joshuamorton is supposedly a google employee according to his profile and yet was perfectly happy to throw the antisemitism bs around.
There's several accounts down the bottom, each a number of years old and ostensibly regular otherwise; all of which have made efforts to come to this discussion and make up slander. And then of course run when pressed to provide evidence.
And they do all this despite the counter evidence being available to all.
Honestly, what is happening there? Is it some sort of collective insanity? Is it something they all agree needs to be done for some greater good? And if that's the case do they agree to it subconsciously/consciously? Is it all just people who are incredibly susceptible to group pressure and who will go along with any absurdity so long as it's ordered from the right authority.
How do you go about justifying deliberately attempting to hurt a person like this?
Just the sight of it astounds me.
Hopefully, if this is the case, these individuals realise the bubble they exist in, and give such topics more scrutiny in future.
That said @textgel, I find bringing up individual user's details a bit unsavoury; By all means, distinguish between long-term vs short-term users, but I don't think you should bring up employer, even if it's public info.
Despite HN being explicitly not a venue for politics, enough of the userbase has de-facto decided it should be. This of course invites all the sort of internet antics that come with politics which HN users in the past have decried and claimed that the lack of here makes it a more pleasant place in general.
That's when you find these otherwise normal accounts, acting up, accounts that exist solely for flamebating, drive by throwaways attempting to derail threads, etc. And since HN is primarily user-moderated (ironically despite what a subset of the previously described types often insinuate), these sort of behavior can become encouraged if enough people agree the the text or subtext of such comments.
The goal was to find how to make the job more attractive to female developers. If the difference exists, then in this context the distinction does not matter.
But why should that be a goal? Is there any inherent value in having all jobs be equally attractive to everybody? If so, where are all the efforts to make jobs like garbage collection less male-dominated?
I think the main issue with his memo is the implication that diversity efforts were, at the time, problematic. The truth is, with such low diversity numbers even with the diversity programs, it's likely that any subpar candidates admitted probably equaled the subpar candidates admitted into Google at large. The numbers for gender diversity are even more skewed when viewed through the lens of the engineering department (which is the one relevant to the memo), which is unfortunately not available from the google diversity site like it used to be.
You can see the diversity breakdown for yourself here: https://diversity.google/annual-report/representation/
You can also see a longer analysis Damore's liberal assumptions here: https://www.wired.com/story/the-pernicious-science-of-james-...