News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#27844089)
But it isn't "our tribe" - it's specifically the "blue church" pushing a very intentional narrative against an easy target.

That's to say: This isn't just the chaotic whisperings of twitter, but many complicit media outlets repeating this.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:36AM (#27844482)
Lol, yes. I agree. It's not "our tribe" that has bias. It's "their tribe". "Our tribe" is noble, generous and infallible. "Their tribe" is misinformed at best, but probably crazy if not outright evil.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @10:29AM (#27845164)
Well not completely but yes more or less. Look at this comment collection surrounding Damore. The one thing that unifies the group defending the firing is that they are all willing to lie to do so and are doing it in pursuit of socially destroying someone who is by rational, innocent. After all if he wasn't the group wouldn't have to lie.

At that stage if you can't reflect on your behaviour and that of those on your side, well there either is no hope for you or you're just further lying along with your fellow ideologues.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:30AM (#27845877)
Well, I agree with respect to Damore. He is innocent of these accusations. That was awful.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by textgel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:40AM (#27846007)
Don't get me wrong, you're absolutely right about the tribalism that affects all sides in this situation we're in.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:30PM (#27846594)
I didn't say anything about "our tribe" being right/biased.

I said "our tribe" isn't saying this, where "our tribe" is a quote of the original comment.

This is consistent with any of these statements:

- our tribe say the opposite

- our tribe say something different entirely

- our tribe have no consensus on the issue / there is no "our tribe"

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Sunday July 18, 2021 @03:49AM (#27871411)
Ok. But still, Damore's situation as part of a general human trend, from which the pro-Damore faction is not immune. There are no doubt pro-Damore people who are pro-Damore just because their tribe* is pro-Damore, and not because of the actual content of the memo. This is the identical error as the antis.

It's difficult not to make such errors because those of our tribal ancestors who did not immediately and unconditionally support the tribe died. Those who did, lived.

If you want to help, pointing out which faction is making the error is not as helpful as insisting on the principled truth no matter which faction is correct. It's a dangerous road, because humans are scary, genocidal apes.

* > - our tribe have no consensus on the issue / there is no "our tribe"

Agreed. If one can lift one's perceptions out of partisanship, there is only a unified group of people who all (with a few psychopathic exceptions) want the best for themselves, their families, and society as a whole, whose only disagreement is as to method of getting there. And nevertheless, these small disagreements can easily magnify and become physically violent, because humans are scary apes who will elevate tribal affiliation even above literal perception. So, for some people, they absolutely have a tribe, and if you disagree with it, you are them.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @03:21PM (#27875767)
> If you want to help, pointing out which faction is making the error is not as helpful as insisting on the principled truth no matter which faction is correct

Which also doesn't work, precisely because of the "tribal error" being made, that removes all nuance of principle.

> whose only disagreement is as to method of getting there

This isn't really true. as a group of people, our circumstances are different, and hence we are motivated towards different, non-unified goals. It's hard to fight zero-sum instincts.

Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by rendall on Sunday July 18, 2021 @06:40PM (#27877322)
Well, there have always been those of us who do hold principles above partisan affiliation. Doing so brought the world Enlightenment, Democracy, Emancipation, Suffrage. Give it a go.
Re:Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on... by Chris2048 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @08:51PM (#27878128)
Affiliation and principle aren't always different. Hitler was defeated by murdering his associates. Taking credit for the fruits of civilization is to whitewash the history of the world.