News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:29AM (#27834193)
When one government/party (implicitly or explicitly) gets twitter to put content favorable to it to the detriment of its opponents, right there, twitter lost the script, and the moral standing.

the talk of legality is nonsense, because there are jurisdictions where anything can be made legal.

The vast majority of the world will be better off with a twitter/fb etc cut down to size, and the current massive power of social media networks being reduced.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:00PM (#27836960)
> The vast majority of the world will be better off with a twitter/fb etc cut down to size, and the current massive power of social media networks being reduced.

That's exactly what state sponsored media, dictatorships and big media conglomerates want to promote. Having layman question if social media is really good or not is great for these people.

People forget so fast [0]

[0] https://www.npr.org/2021/05/04/993605477/as-arab-spring-unfo...

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:11PM (#27837102)
People keep bringing up the Arab spring as an argument for Twitter being socially beneficial.

However, I am not sure the Arab Spring was a net positive. Tunisia turned out ok, but Libya is still a disaster. Egypt went from Dictator to Islamist Party to Military Dictatorship. Syria has seen massive death and destruction and Assad is still clinging to power. Yemen is involved in a nasty civil war.

I think many in the West take a too rosy view of the Arab Spring. For the average Middle Easterner in those countries, the Arab Spring has been a disaster.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:17PM (#27837175)
It takes courage for a nation to take matters into it's own hands and march toward democracy. And it's not an easy road either.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by nxmnxm99 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:24AM (#27843922)
That doesn't mean it was a good thing. Democracy isn't the only "right" way to maximize outcomes for a society, as much as western moralism might want it to be.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by 908B64B197 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:40PM (#27848421)
And yet what are the alternatives?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by sbmthakur on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:45PM (#27838197)
Those outcomes are often referred to as Arab Winter that followed the Arab Spring.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @09:42PM (#27840618)
yes, people want change, but sometimes the rate of change is too overwhelming...

and once the change is set in motion, no one is able to predict what the next actions would be.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by orhmeh09 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:03PM (#27837747)
The line you’re promoting is exactly what the state sponsored media that the U.S. employs wants you to believe. Remember that the U.S. set up a fake Twitter clone to sow division and misinformation in Cuba? 2014: https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/03/us-cuban-twitt...
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:10PM (#27837819)
Apparently they didn't need it: Cubans spreading real information is enough to cause massive riots and for the regime to shut down internet access. [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27812670

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:05PM (#27836200)
> The vast majority of the world will be better off with a twitter/fb etc cut down to size, and the current massive power of social media networks being reduced.

There is no "cutting down to size", these sites are popular as the function of individual choices, short of authoritarianism you can't dictate which sites people decide to use.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:19PM (#27840119)
Parler users would like to disagree. So do users of other platforms who can not use mainstream payment systems to pay for their services, and can not install the apps using Google or Apple app stores.

I think by now one has to be extremely naive and uninformed to claim that only individual user choices are the factor in whether or not a social network can prosper.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:11AM (#27841290)
> Parler users would like to disagree. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/parler/id1402727988

People bring up Parler as if the political context of the very recent (at the time) attack on the U.S. capitol had no bearing on how things transpired.

> I think by now one has to be extremely naive and uninformed to claim that only individual user choices are the factor in whether or not a social network can prosper.

I'll have to replay that "naive and uninformed" label back at you if you seriously believe that sites like Parler are unpopular because of big tech collusion rather than the type of content cultivated by such sites.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:42AM (#27842311)
Yes, I seriously believe that Parler was shut down because of of big tech collusion and not because the users voluntarily abandoned it, disgusted by the content cultivated there. I can tell you why I believe it - because Parler was shut down by the collusion of big tech companies, while many many users (millions) were willing to go there and tolerate the type of content that you obviously don't like. It's something that is called "fact". After Parler was able to overcome the hostile actions of the big tech, they still have millions of users. You may not be one of them, and that's ok - you are free to use whatever networks you like, and if the content on Parler disgusts you, you're free to avoid it and join the network you like. What you're not entitled to do is to invent your own facts.

BTW, another fact - most of the planning for US Capitol protest that is known about actually happened on Facebook, and livestreaming the even also happened on Facebook and Youtube. Of course, nobody shut them down for that.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:01PM (#27846937)
> I seriously believe that Parler was shut down because of of big tech collusion and not because the users voluntarily abandoned it.

Try reading my post again because I never made any such claim.

> most of the planning for US Capitol protest that is known about actually happened on Facebook

I never stated otherwise (besides calling it an attack, not a "protest"). It seems to me you have fixated on a certain perspective and are projecting that on to my comment.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Friday July 16, 2021 @02:00AM (#27853411)
You said:

These sites are popular as the function of individual choices, short of authoritarianism you can't dictate which sites people decide to use.

In fact, however, Big Tech oligopolists very much can dictate that people won't be able to use sites they want to use (despite the fact you personally don't like the content there). If I decide to use Parler but Parler is shut down by Amazon, then it's very much not a product of my individual choice.

> I never stated otherwise

And again, you said:

People bring up Parler as if the political context of the very recent (at the time) attack on the U.S. capitol had no bearing on how things transpired.

What transpired is that some people involved in Capitol protest on Jan 6 were using Parler, and many more were using Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Instagram, etc. Parler was shut down - very much not a product of individual choice of anyone but Jeff Bezos maybe - and neither of other platforms, who played bigger role in the same event, didn't even bat an eye. So your mentioning the events at the US Capitol only goes to illustrate my point, not yours - the idea that we somehow have a free market here where people are free to choose whatever platform they like according to their individual choice is very much delusional. Some platforms have more freedoms than others, and some are subjected to strictest scrutiny - and sometimes shut down - despite the preferences of their users. That's my perspective, which aligns with known facts.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by nxmnxm99 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:26AM (#27843943)
You have next to no understanding of the opposite side of the political spectrum if you think Parler shut down because of people running away from their content. Who created that content in the first place?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:00PM (#27846934)
> if you think Parler shut down because of people running away from their content.

Try reading my post again because I never made any such claim.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by buran77 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:43PM (#27837508)
> you can't dictate which sites people decide to use

You can invest in education and empower people to make informed choices about the source or value of the information. This is an investment governments go out of their way to avoid because it just so happens the same lack of education that gets people hooked up on low quality content is what makes them easily manipulated by the political class.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:19PM (#27837904)
I don't see a problem with educational outreach, but what kind of education do you think the public needs?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by DoubleDerper on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:33PM (#27839297)
From an early age more public investment in STEM, financial literacy, empathic education.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by chacha2 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:26PM (#27840161)
Pre-school STEM is your plan to get people off twitter?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by orhmeh09 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:06PM (#27837767)
*Are* these sites popular as functions of individual choices? It’s been pretty well established that governments and regulators in the U.S. overlooked the actions of or actively supported these companies from the start.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:16PM (#27837878)
Sure they are. The popularity of one website does not diminish the availability of another website. The popularity of YouTube didn't prevent tiktok from also becoming popular. Using one website does not make it more difficult to use another website which is why literally everybody on the internet uses multiple websites. Not everyone uses FB, twitter, or reddit, others use some combination of them, some use all of them, others none of them, this is entirely the result of free choices made by individuals.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by ManBlanket on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:37PM (#27838750)
Right. Plenty of people are free to use MySpace these days, what with its thriving community full of friends and family, everyone using the shared platform to communicate with each other.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#27838789)
Right... MySpace was once the most popular social network on the internet and that fact meant absolutely nothing with respect to its longevity because individuals made their own choices about which sites they wanted to use and MySpace wasn't one of them.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:00PM (#27838376)
tiktok and youtube are not synonymous in functionality...

It is extremely hard to have a 2nd youtube, reddit or facebook... because of the network effects

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:38PM (#27838762)
> tiktok and youtube are not synonymous in functionality

This is a subjective distinction, but setting aside subjectivity for the sake of argument, it's a user-driven video sharing website, it's pretty similar to YouTube in many ways, but the fact that it is not synonymous is exactly my point - TikTok created something that differentiated itself from YouTube and so people flocked to it, and the fact that YouTube was already popular didn't diminish TikTok's accessibility nor did TikTok's explosion in popularity come at the cost of YouTube's popularity. TikTok created something attractive and people made individual choices to use it.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:45PM (#27840270)
I agree on the distinction, but the main point is that tiktok and youtube cannot be compared for the core functionality.

a better comparison is the conservative leaning 'rumble' - without google's massive support, it stands no chance of winning against youtube.

--

parler was the alternative to twitter and fb, and see how it was cut down for no real reason, though at the time, the entire media made it seem as if it was the most logical thing to do.

later one finds that there is more extremist stuff in fb and twitter..

also, it was interesting how all the biggies - Amazon, Google, Apple, Visa all joined hands to squelch Parler an opponent of their enemy (for ad dollars) Twitter...

speaking loosely, this is quite an example of a cartel.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:54PM (#27841225)
> but the main point is that tiktok and youtube cannot be compared for the core functionality.

tiktok and youtube have essentially the same core functionality: sharing user generated video content. YouTube even has a "Shorts" section that is entirely composed of tiktok style videos wherein most of the videos are actually ripped from tiktok.

> parler was the alternative to twitter and fb, and see how it was cut down for no real reason

Parler is an alternative to twitter and fb, it exists today, it was not "cut down" https://apps.apple.com/us/app/parler/id1402727988.

The furor over Parler was manufactured outrage, Parler was suspended from the app stores because they didn't do what the app stores asked, a very common occurrence, we could all be so lucky as to have that much publicity surrounding the suspension of our apps from the notoriously capricious app stores.

> also, it was interesting how all the biggies - Amazon, Google, Apple, Visa all joined hands to squelch Parler an opponent of their enemy (for ad dollars) Twitter...

It's not that interesting, it was an obvious reaction to Parler openly courting extremism after there had just been an attack on the U.S. capitol. Parler made themselves toxic and nobody wanted to do business with them because they were extremely unpopular. Anyway, I suspect we probably won't agree on the details of Parler, but there's no disputing that Parler's temporary shutdown was under extremely unusual circumstances.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by visualradio on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:10PM (#27837094)
Eh, governments could probably take a supply-side approach and throw money at new ARPAnet protocols for developing federated content publishing networks to grow competing networked application ecosystems without resorting to heavy handed authoritarianism.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:24PM (#27837269)
Another layer of federated content publishing doesn't solve any problems. The web is already federated, websites are the "nodes", these big websites are just very popular nodes, if fediverse style apps take off the problem would just move to the most popular nodes on that network.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by visualradio on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:44PM (#27837523)
> Another layer of federated content publishing doesn't solve any problems.

HTTP is a request-response rather than content broadcast or publish-subscribe protocol. Presumably you could develop a publish-subscribe protocol with low-latency encryption support embedded in protocol layer similar to QUIC.

> if fediverse style apps take off the problem would just move to the most popular nodes on that network.

So suppose the Department of Energy provides a public cloud which people can get a network address to hold files for them similar to how they can get a Post Office box number at the post office. Except when you put a file in your own PO box the PO will make free copies of the file for others on your behalf which are subscribed to your PO box without destroying the original copy.

This would really just create a lower-level protocol or new number system for publish-subscribe content. It would compete with the other ARPAnet protocols such as TCP.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by blooalien on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:30PM (#27840182)
https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/an-introduction-to-solid-t...

Tim Berners-Lee might get it right this next time around?

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by jmull on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:23PM (#27835631)
The idea that Twitter — or any other company or person — should not be able to choose or express it’s own side in any matter of political contention because one side or the other wouldn’t like it is insane to me.

How does that even work? Who gets to decide which topics or points of view are off-the-table for normal social-media moderation? I guess you’re saying government figures and major political parties could decide unilaterally. We’ll have to repeal the first amendment, anyway.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by username90 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:55PM (#27836065)
> company or person

Billion dollar companies are not persons, they should not have the same rights at all. At that size they start to mingle heavily with politicians. They want politicians to enact the right policies, and in return those politicians wants the company to censor the right people or fund their campaigns. Just because there is no formal agreement here doesn't mean that the companies aren't just the extended arm of the government and vice versa.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:09PM (#27837813)
Billion dollar companies are composed of people individually acting within their rights and although they should be provided no special privileges neither should they lose their individual rights. Having companies have too close a relationship with donors is a defect not a reasonable basis for regulating businesses as if they were in fact part of the government.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by grb100 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:53PM (#27839487)
Newspapers and persons obviously should choose to express their own opinions.

Twitter is different: It is close to a common carrier, and you can't just shut down one side of the political discussion. If you do, you'll have the appearance of free discussion, when in reality you are exercising totalitarian control.

That is more harmful for democracy than occasional idiots dressing up in Viking costumes and entering the capitol (of course, riots of the opposing spectrum can be safely promoted on Twitter anyway).

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by jmull on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:15AM (#27841612)
> It is close to a common carrier…

It isn’t at all. Twitter’s business model is getting people to join and engage with the network, and to that end they broadcast, moderate, curate, promote, remove, suggest messages based on the content of the messages. If we pass some law that forces it to be a simple message or feed delivery platform, twitter as a business is done.

> totalitarian control

Twitter running its business the way it wants is normal western freedom. Forcing twitter to broadcast the messages of the leader of the government would be totalitarian control.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:49PM (#27835966)
> should not be able to choose or express it’s own side in any matter of political contention

It goes back to the conversations expressed elsewhere in this post about twitter being an utility, de-facto.

If it is given that status, then there are some expectations that come with it.

Once a company takes a political position, then it cannot appeal on 'moral' or other subjective grounds.

> How does that even work?

I don't know... maybe an entity like the Swiss? Not sure if it is a good example, being a country itself? The reason people seem to be ok with the presence of the country is that it is strictly neutral, and both sides protected it.

> Who gets to decide which topics or points of view are off-the-table for normal social-media moderation?

How about no one?

> I guess you’re saying government figures and major political parties could decide unilaterally. We’ll have to repeal the first amendment, anyway.

The 1st amendment is for the US exclusively. This version of the Freedom of speech is a distinctively American concept, and for that reason, twitter actually finds some tepid support from conservatives.

Each country is sovereign in the laws that govern their land, unless they breach some major crimes, and thats when the UN steps in. Nothing new here.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:28PM (#27838017)
The way nations relate to one another is fundamentally different from the way parties relate to one another within a nation. The UN is a debating society that serves to provide a venue for potentially belligerent actors subject to different laws who ultimately can only truly enforce their will with bombs and bullets if debate fails.

Parties within a nation are all subject to the same laws with established responsibilities and rights with established procedures for settling differences.

The fact that some platforms choose to exclude a minority of players from using said platforms to spread ideas that the majority finds evil and harmful is a feature not a bug. There are established laws that protect actual rights and privileges. Just none that would privilege you to stand on others property and shout hateful offensive things.

Get your own bullhorn and stop trying to make laws demanding your neighbor lend you his.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#27838787)
The UN also theoretically can step in if a nation does bad things to its own citizens ( like genocide etc).

What is being discussed here is Twitter, an American company in relation to countries like India, etc.

> to spread ideas that the majority finds evil and harmful

Who is the majority? And how did twitter find it? If twitter lets a ranking system similar to HN/reddit, and content below a particular ratio is hidden, that might be fine I guess. it would be a mob, I would'nt like it, but atleast, its uniform.

> Get your own bullhorn and stop trying to make laws demanding your neighbor lend you his.

What does that even mean? Is twitter my neighbour? Do I, a ordinary citizen have similar clout?

In a way, I see twitter as a bully (a loud bullhorn) who was terrorizing the neighborhood one after the other. He walks into this one, where there is a stronger bully (with laws that have teeth) and slaps him silly.

This bully now cries, and yeah, not getting much sympathy from the folks he bullied.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by yibg on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:53PM (#27836020)
Problem here is "favorable" and "political position" are pretty subjective. Who's to decide what is favorable to whom and what constitutes political position? Is saying wear a mask a political position? These days it seems to be. So someone still has to decide what is political and what is not right? So seems like we're back to square 1.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:16PM (#27836375)
the deeper point about the mask is that AFAICT, the people are not really opposing the mask, but the government that is directing those mandates, and the real root cause is the lack of trust in the government.

it is also coinciding with a period of extreme distrust of the media, wherein, if some thing is spreading outside of the media, the position being taken is that it must be true, whereas one would expect the opposite to happen.

The media and the government must introspect their roles in leading to this situation.

Many lump twitter as being part of the media itself, because of its proactive actions.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:33PM (#27838083)
People distrust the media because one half of our political spectrum is busy as a beaver spreading lies so blatant that they can't be credibly presented as another side of the issue or an alternative perspective.

Because the media is presenting reality in a fashion vastly closer to objective truth the liars are obliged to explain why their positions and the medias differ and the most trivial response is to continue lying and call the media liars. The liars audience has chosen their own alternative facts over objective reality and there is absolutely nothing the media could have done to prevent it.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:26PM (#27838643)
> because one half of our political spectrum

and the other half comes out smelling like roses?

Let me ask you this, as atleast you know there are 2 universes (which many do not ):

- Do you sample both of the universes and make up your mind?

- Do you know which direction the media thats most accessible (otherwise called as mainstream) leans politically?

- Do you lean that same direction yourself?

- if so, it is that side that needs to seek out the alternate universe and figure if there is any truth to it. ( theoretically, there can be right?)

--

The people on the right are generally exposed to the mainstream media, and therefore, and also consume alternate media from the right, and at least, get to hear both sides.

The people on the left, on average, simply do not do this

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:14PM (#27848072)
There aren't 2 universes there are n universes where n is the number of people. In most respects my politics are more progressive than the medias but I take a nuanced view and I think for myself.

I HAVE sampled both sides mostly because I had an interest in watching the crazy. The far side of the fence from the "liberal media" is sadly stunted men swimming in a cloud of misinformation so thick that escape appears difficult. Explaining one wrong thing nearly always involves dealing with not only present issues but prior preconceptions.

Although these men may possess in some areas of their life judgement, character, values but they are guided by not only fake information, but fake resources who will not only at need feed them more misinformation but has poisoned them against sources apt to contradict their line of bullshit.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:01PM (#27836143)
Swiss neutrality was noticeable more in the breach than the observance: https://www.warhistoryonline.com/instant-articles/switzerlan...

Militarily, invading Switzerland would have been far more work than it was worth.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by stale2002 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:07PM (#27836244)
> How does that even work?

Well, it could work similar to the existing and uncontroversial laws, that are already widespread on certain communication companies.

Specifically, we could take common carrier laws, which already apply to certain communication companies, and extend them.

Those laws are uncontroversial, and established. So it is silly to claim that such a thing is unconventional.

> We’ll have to repeal the first amendment

No we won't. Common carrier laws already exist, and we didn't have to repeal the 1st amendment to have them.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:14PM (#27837866)
Please cite the exact laws that we ought to apply to social media companies and do touch on how the application of said laws will avoid infringing on these companies civil rights.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by baumy on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:27PM (#27838003)
Exact laws: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/chapter-5/subchap...

The rest of your question I consider invalid. Companies do not have civil rights [1]. Hell, it's in the definition of the word:

"relating to ordinary citizens and their concerns, as distinct from military or ecclesiastical matters"

But clearly the existing common carrier regulations don't infringe on the "civil rights" of the companies they apply to, so even accepting your false premise, this is very straightforward.

[1] or at least, they didn't until extremely recently https://www.inquirer.com/business/hobby-lobby-citizens-unite...

[dead]
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by stale2002 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:26PM (#27838642)
You just said this "Please cite the exact laws that we ought to apply "

Emphasis on the word "ought".

And you responded to someone bringing up other laws by saying this "to suppose that existing laws already cover the situation ".

Which nobody said.

Instead, the other person was directly answering your question, of which specific laws "ought" be applied to social media companies. The implication being, that they do not currently apply now, but should, by changing the law such that they do.

> at least one contrary law would need to be repealed

You used the word ought. That was your premise. And someone answered your question of what ought happen. So, the implication, is that other contrary law, also ought be changed.

I am not sure why this always happens in these types of conversations. People say X is bad, and then someone else comes in and says "Well actually, X is totally legal!".

Nobody here said anything about it being illegal. Instead we said that X is bad. And the implication being that we want something to change, such that the bad thing stops.

Saying X is legal, is just an end run around, to ignore the original point that was brought up, by talking about the legality, when nobody brought up was is legal in the first place.

Yeah, we knows the bad thing is legal. Thats why it is happening. Thats why we are complaining about it. Because it is legal, and happening, and we don't want it to happen, and we want to figure out a way to make it not happen.

That why, in my original comment I said that we should "extend" common carrier laws. "Extend" means change. It means that I already know that common carriers laws don't apply, and I want them to apply. By changing those laws.

Like, my god. This always happens, and the conversations are so stupid.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by Dma54rhs on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:29PM (#27838041)
Rest of the world doesn't care about your laws or rights, when youtube is doing business in a country they have every legal right/opportunity to write laws to demand whatever they want from the company.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:13PM (#27838503)
In some cases it would make sense to comply in others it would make more sense to refuse especially if compliance with one nations laws would interfere with the companies core product. For example if smallistan decided that material critical of its monarch must be expunged from all of youtube not just the content served inside smallistan then it would be in everyone else's interest if Google ignored them.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by LatteLazy on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:13PM (#27835520)
Making them smaller will make them more likely to resist government censorship how exactly?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:37PM (#27838122)
They don't want them smaller they want their autonomy not their sized reduced. Specifically they cling to the idea that social media ought to be a common carrier as obliged to carry their views as that of their detractors. If you look at the actual speech that is being disincentivized this looks objectively terrible in our present context.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:33PM (#27838724)
i dont know who you are speaking for, but agreed that the need for reduced autonomy for any agency of that size.

In general, conservatives believe in markets, and if they happen to grow to a particular size with these constraints, so be it.

--

> If you look at the actual speech that is being disincentivized this looks objectively terrible in our present context.

I'll give one example to see what the reaction ought to be.

A private citizen makes an otherwise legal speech at a political meeting - and youtube and all media wipe it out of the internet last week.

Regardless of the private citizen being Trump and the party being Republicans, a liberal ( as the word used to mean before) should have been up against such censorship.

'Moderation' does not come into play in this example, but there is nothing specific to moderate really in what is essentially a semi-private meeting of free people.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:18PM (#27840113)
A semi private meeting would be held on hardware that you control which is entirely feasible.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by username90 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:31PM (#27835725)
Being large just makes you a large target, smaller things like HN wont get targeted since governments lack the capacity to handle that many things. And being large doesn't offer much protection to resist once targeted either, no matter how large they are they wont sacrifice significant revenue for moral reasons.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:51PM (#27836002)
twitter is attacked exactly because they are the only voice out there.

As an example, There are several newspapers in India, which still continue to post opinions critical of the government. There is a system of courts still, sort of working, and would step in if things got too bad.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by munk-a on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:01PM (#27836144)
A single shut down of a platform can be written off as "for the children" or some other character assassination BS. When you start repeatedly attacking platforms that's when you get the moderates of your country to start taking umbridge.

I think a good parallel might be TikTok in the US, Trump was exploring banning the platform toward the end of his term without a particularly large pushback from the general populace (though a whole bunch of pushback from tech literate folks). You can use excuses like that a time or two without raising too many eyebrows, but once it becomes a pattern people get angry.

Having more smaller platforms makes it harder to effectively accomplish any censorship since your few shutdown freebies won't significantly impact the ability for political opponents to communicate with the public.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by burnished on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:12PM (#27835497)
Can you point to some specific examples, instead of leaving it vague? I ask because I'm curious whether there are more pertinent framings than of a disagreement purely between political parties.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by ManBlanket on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:35PM (#27838731)
Funny how a surge in requests of this nature coincided with proliferation of tools for managing, "misinformation". Who gets to decide what or what constitutes misinformation, anyway. Is it the Abundant Nigeria Renewal Party or African Democratic Congress? I guess for the time being rich white Californian tech executives and product managers decide what information or news stories are or are not real.