News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:05PM (#27836200)
> The vast majority of the world will be better off with a twitter/fb etc cut down to size, and the current massive power of social media networks being reduced.

There is no "cutting down to size", these sites are popular as the function of individual choices, short of authoritarianism you can't dictate which sites people decide to use.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:19PM (#27840119)
Parler users would like to disagree. So do users of other platforms who can not use mainstream payment systems to pay for their services, and can not install the apps using Google or Apple app stores.

I think by now one has to be extremely naive and uninformed to claim that only individual user choices are the factor in whether or not a social network can prosper.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:11AM (#27841290)
> Parler users would like to disagree. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/parler/id1402727988

People bring up Parler as if the political context of the very recent (at the time) attack on the U.S. capitol had no bearing on how things transpired.

> I think by now one has to be extremely naive and uninformed to claim that only individual user choices are the factor in whether or not a social network can prosper.

I'll have to replay that "naive and uninformed" label back at you if you seriously believe that sites like Parler are unpopular because of big tech collusion rather than the type of content cultivated by such sites.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:42AM (#27842311)
Yes, I seriously believe that Parler was shut down because of of big tech collusion and not because the users voluntarily abandoned it, disgusted by the content cultivated there. I can tell you why I believe it - because Parler was shut down by the collusion of big tech companies, while many many users (millions) were willing to go there and tolerate the type of content that you obviously don't like. It's something that is called "fact". After Parler was able to overcome the hostile actions of the big tech, they still have millions of users. You may not be one of them, and that's ok - you are free to use whatever networks you like, and if the content on Parler disgusts you, you're free to avoid it and join the network you like. What you're not entitled to do is to invent your own facts.

BTW, another fact - most of the planning for US Capitol protest that is known about actually happened on Facebook, and livestreaming the even also happened on Facebook and Youtube. Of course, nobody shut them down for that.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:01PM (#27846937)
> I seriously believe that Parler was shut down because of of big tech collusion and not because the users voluntarily abandoned it.

Try reading my post again because I never made any such claim.

> most of the planning for US Capitol protest that is known about actually happened on Facebook

I never stated otherwise (besides calling it an attack, not a "protest"). It seems to me you have fixated on a certain perspective and are projecting that on to my comment.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by smsm42 on Friday July 16, 2021 @02:00AM (#27853411)
You said:

These sites are popular as the function of individual choices, short of authoritarianism you can't dictate which sites people decide to use.

In fact, however, Big Tech oligopolists very much can dictate that people won't be able to use sites they want to use (despite the fact you personally don't like the content there). If I decide to use Parler but Parler is shut down by Amazon, then it's very much not a product of my individual choice.

> I never stated otherwise

And again, you said:

People bring up Parler as if the political context of the very recent (at the time) attack on the U.S. capitol had no bearing on how things transpired.

What transpired is that some people involved in Capitol protest on Jan 6 were using Parler, and many more were using Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Instagram, etc. Parler was shut down - very much not a product of individual choice of anyone but Jeff Bezos maybe - and neither of other platforms, who played bigger role in the same event, didn't even bat an eye. So your mentioning the events at the US Capitol only goes to illustrate my point, not yours - the idea that we somehow have a free market here where people are free to choose whatever platform they like according to their individual choice is very much delusional. Some platforms have more freedoms than others, and some are subjected to strictest scrutiny - and sometimes shut down - despite the preferences of their users. That's my perspective, which aligns with known facts.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by nxmnxm99 on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:26AM (#27843943)
You have next to no understanding of the opposite side of the political spectrum if you think Parler shut down because of people running away from their content. Who created that content in the first place?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:00PM (#27846934)
> if you think Parler shut down because of people running away from their content.

Try reading my post again because I never made any such claim.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by buran77 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:43PM (#27837508)
> you can't dictate which sites people decide to use

You can invest in education and empower people to make informed choices about the source or value of the information. This is an investment governments go out of their way to avoid because it just so happens the same lack of education that gets people hooked up on low quality content is what makes them easily manipulated by the political class.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:19PM (#27837904)
I don't see a problem with educational outreach, but what kind of education do you think the public needs?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by DoubleDerper on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:33PM (#27839297)
From an early age more public investment in STEM, financial literacy, empathic education.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by chacha2 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:26PM (#27840161)
Pre-school STEM is your plan to get people off twitter?
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by orhmeh09 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:06PM (#27837767)
*Are* these sites popular as functions of individual choices? It’s been pretty well established that governments and regulators in the U.S. overlooked the actions of or actively supported these companies from the start.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:16PM (#27837878)
Sure they are. The popularity of one website does not diminish the availability of another website. The popularity of YouTube didn't prevent tiktok from also becoming popular. Using one website does not make it more difficult to use another website which is why literally everybody on the internet uses multiple websites. Not everyone uses FB, twitter, or reddit, others use some combination of them, some use all of them, others none of them, this is entirely the result of free choices made by individuals.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by ManBlanket on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:37PM (#27838750)
Right. Plenty of people are free to use MySpace these days, what with its thriving community full of friends and family, everyone using the shared platform to communicate with each other.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#27838789)
Right... MySpace was once the most popular social network on the internet and that fact meant absolutely nothing with respect to its longevity because individuals made their own choices about which sites they wanted to use and MySpace wasn't one of them.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:00PM (#27838376)
tiktok and youtube are not synonymous in functionality...

It is extremely hard to have a 2nd youtube, reddit or facebook... because of the network effects

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:38PM (#27838762)
> tiktok and youtube are not synonymous in functionality

This is a subjective distinction, but setting aside subjectivity for the sake of argument, it's a user-driven video sharing website, it's pretty similar to YouTube in many ways, but the fact that it is not synonymous is exactly my point - TikTok created something that differentiated itself from YouTube and so people flocked to it, and the fact that YouTube was already popular didn't diminish TikTok's accessibility nor did TikTok's explosion in popularity come at the cost of YouTube's popularity. TikTok created something attractive and people made individual choices to use it.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by foolinaround on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:45PM (#27840270)
I agree on the distinction, but the main point is that tiktok and youtube cannot be compared for the core functionality.

a better comparison is the conservative leaning 'rumble' - without google's massive support, it stands no chance of winning against youtube.

--

parler was the alternative to twitter and fb, and see how it was cut down for no real reason, though at the time, the entire media made it seem as if it was the most logical thing to do.

later one finds that there is more extremist stuff in fb and twitter..

also, it was interesting how all the biggies - Amazon, Google, Apple, Visa all joined hands to squelch Parler an opponent of their enemy (for ad dollars) Twitter...

speaking loosely, this is quite an example of a cartel.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:54PM (#27841225)
> but the main point is that tiktok and youtube cannot be compared for the core functionality.

tiktok and youtube have essentially the same core functionality: sharing user generated video content. YouTube even has a "Shorts" section that is entirely composed of tiktok style videos wherein most of the videos are actually ripped from tiktok.

> parler was the alternative to twitter and fb, and see how it was cut down for no real reason

Parler is an alternative to twitter and fb, it exists today, it was not "cut down" https://apps.apple.com/us/app/parler/id1402727988.

The furor over Parler was manufactured outrage, Parler was suspended from the app stores because they didn't do what the app stores asked, a very common occurrence, we could all be so lucky as to have that much publicity surrounding the suspension of our apps from the notoriously capricious app stores.

> also, it was interesting how all the biggies - Amazon, Google, Apple, Visa all joined hands to squelch Parler an opponent of their enemy (for ad dollars) Twitter...

It's not that interesting, it was an obvious reaction to Parler openly courting extremism after there had just been an attack on the U.S. capitol. Parler made themselves toxic and nobody wanted to do business with them because they were extremely unpopular. Anyway, I suspect we probably won't agree on the details of Parler, but there's no disputing that Parler's temporary shutdown was under extremely unusual circumstances.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by visualradio on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:10PM (#27837094)
Eh, governments could probably take a supply-side approach and throw money at new ARPAnet protocols for developing federated content publishing networks to grow competing networked application ecosystems without resorting to heavy handed authoritarianism.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by root_axis on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:24PM (#27837269)
Another layer of federated content publishing doesn't solve any problems. The web is already federated, websites are the "nodes", these big websites are just very popular nodes, if fediverse style apps take off the problem would just move to the most popular nodes on that network.
Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by visualradio on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:44PM (#27837523)
> Another layer of federated content publishing doesn't solve any problems.

HTTP is a request-response rather than content broadcast or publish-subscribe protocol. Presumably you could develop a publish-subscribe protocol with low-latency encryption support embedded in protocol layer similar to QUIC.

> if fediverse style apps take off the problem would just move to the most popular nodes on that network.

So suppose the Department of Energy provides a public cloud which people can get a network address to hold files for them similar to how they can get a Post Office box number at the post office. Except when you put a file in your own PO box the PO will make free copies of the file for others on your behalf which are subscribed to your PO box without destroying the original copy.

This would really just create a lower-level protocol or new number system for publish-subscribe content. It would compete with the other ARPAnet protocols such as TCP.

Re:Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of re... by blooalien on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:30PM (#27840182)
https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/an-introduction-to-solid-t...

Tim Berners-Lee might get it right this next time around?