Billion dollar companies are not persons, they should not have the same rights at all. At that size they start to mingle heavily with politicians. They want politicians to enact the right policies, and in return those politicians wants the company to censor the right people or fund their campaigns. Just because there is no formal agreement here doesn't mean that the companies aren't just the extended arm of the government and vice versa.
Twitter is different: It is close to a common carrier, and you can't just shut down one side of the political discussion. If you do, you'll have the appearance of free discussion, when in reality you are exercising totalitarian control.
That is more harmful for democracy than occasional idiots dressing up in Viking costumes and entering the capitol (of course, riots of the opposing spectrum can be safely promoted on Twitter anyway).
It isn’t at all. Twitter’s business model is getting people to join and engage with the network, and to that end they broadcast, moderate, curate, promote, remove, suggest messages based on the content of the messages. If we pass some law that forces it to be a simple message or feed delivery platform, twitter as a business is done.
> totalitarian control
Twitter running its business the way it wants is normal western freedom. Forcing twitter to broadcast the messages of the leader of the government would be totalitarian control.
It goes back to the conversations expressed elsewhere in this post about twitter being an utility, de-facto.
If it is given that status, then there are some expectations that come with it.
Once a company takes a political position, then it cannot appeal on 'moral' or other subjective grounds.
> How does that even work?
I don't know... maybe an entity like the Swiss? Not sure if it is a good example, being a country itself? The reason people seem to be ok with the presence of the country is that it is strictly neutral, and both sides protected it.
> Who gets to decide which topics or points of view are off-the-table for normal social-media moderation?
How about no one?
> I guess you’re saying government figures and major political parties could decide unilaterally. We’ll have to repeal the first amendment, anyway.
The 1st amendment is for the US exclusively. This version of the Freedom of speech is a distinctively American concept, and for that reason, twitter actually finds some tepid support from conservatives.
Each country is sovereign in the laws that govern their land, unless they breach some major crimes, and thats when the UN steps in. Nothing new here.
Parties within a nation are all subject to the same laws with established responsibilities and rights with established procedures for settling differences.
The fact that some platforms choose to exclude a minority of players from using said platforms to spread ideas that the majority finds evil and harmful is a feature not a bug. There are established laws that protect actual rights and privileges. Just none that would privilege you to stand on others property and shout hateful offensive things.
Get your own bullhorn and stop trying to make laws demanding your neighbor lend you his.
What is being discussed here is Twitter, an American company in relation to countries like India, etc.
> to spread ideas that the majority finds evil and harmful
Who is the majority? And how did twitter find it? If twitter lets a ranking system similar to HN/reddit, and content below a particular ratio is hidden, that might be fine I guess. it would be a mob, I would'nt like it, but atleast, its uniform.
> Get your own bullhorn and stop trying to make laws demanding your neighbor lend you his.
What does that even mean? Is twitter my neighbour? Do I, a ordinary citizen have similar clout?
In a way, I see twitter as a bully (a loud bullhorn) who was terrorizing the neighborhood one after the other. He walks into this one, where there is a stronger bully (with laws that have teeth) and slaps him silly.
This bully now cries, and yeah, not getting much sympathy from the folks he bullied.
it is also coinciding with a period of extreme distrust of the media, wherein, if some thing is spreading outside of the media, the position being taken is that it must be true, whereas one would expect the opposite to happen.
The media and the government must introspect their roles in leading to this situation.
Many lump twitter as being part of the media itself, because of its proactive actions.
Because the media is presenting reality in a fashion vastly closer to objective truth the liars are obliged to explain why their positions and the medias differ and the most trivial response is to continue lying and call the media liars. The liars audience has chosen their own alternative facts over objective reality and there is absolutely nothing the media could have done to prevent it.
and the other half comes out smelling like roses?
Let me ask you this, as atleast you know there are 2 universes (which many do not ):
- Do you sample both of the universes and make up your mind?
- Do you know which direction the media thats most accessible (otherwise called as mainstream) leans politically?
- Do you lean that same direction yourself?
- if so, it is that side that needs to seek out the alternate universe and figure if there is any truth to it. ( theoretically, there can be right?)
--
The people on the right are generally exposed to the mainstream media, and therefore, and also consume alternate media from the right, and at least, get to hear both sides.
The people on the left, on average, simply do not do this
I HAVE sampled both sides mostly because I had an interest in watching the crazy. The far side of the fence from the "liberal media" is sadly stunted men swimming in a cloud of misinformation so thick that escape appears difficult. Explaining one wrong thing nearly always involves dealing with not only present issues but prior preconceptions.
Although these men may possess in some areas of their life judgement, character, values but they are guided by not only fake information, but fake resources who will not only at need feed them more misinformation but has poisoned them against sources apt to contradict their line of bullshit.
Militarily, invading Switzerland would have been far more work than it was worth.
Well, it could work similar to the existing and uncontroversial laws, that are already widespread on certain communication companies.
Specifically, we could take common carrier laws, which already apply to certain communication companies, and extend them.
Those laws are uncontroversial, and established. So it is silly to claim that such a thing is unconventional.
> We’ll have to repeal the first amendment
No we won't. Common carrier laws already exist, and we didn't have to repeal the 1st amendment to have them.
The rest of your question I consider invalid. Companies do not have civil rights [1]. Hell, it's in the definition of the word:
"relating to ordinary citizens and their concerns, as distinct from military or ecclesiastical matters"
But clearly the existing common carrier regulations don't infringe on the "civil rights" of the companies they apply to, so even accepting your false premise, this is very straightforward.
[1] or at least, they didn't until extremely recently https://www.inquirer.com/business/hobby-lobby-citizens-unite...
Emphasis on the word "ought".
And you responded to someone bringing up other laws by saying this "to suppose that existing laws already cover the situation ".
Which nobody said.
Instead, the other person was directly answering your question, of which specific laws "ought" be applied to social media companies. The implication being, that they do not currently apply now, but should, by changing the law such that they do.
> at least one contrary law would need to be repealed
You used the word ought. That was your premise. And someone answered your question of what ought happen. So, the implication, is that other contrary law, also ought be changed.
I am not sure why this always happens in these types of conversations. People say X is bad, and then someone else comes in and says "Well actually, X is totally legal!".
Nobody here said anything about it being illegal. Instead we said that X is bad. And the implication being that we want something to change, such that the bad thing stops.
Saying X is legal, is just an end run around, to ignore the original point that was brought up, by talking about the legality, when nobody brought up was is legal in the first place.
Yeah, we knows the bad thing is legal. Thats why it is happening. Thats why we are complaining about it. Because it is legal, and happening, and we don't want it to happen, and we want to figure out a way to make it not happen.
That why, in my original comment I said that we should "extend" common carrier laws. "Extend" means change. It means that I already know that common carriers laws don't apply, and I want them to apply. By changing those laws.
Like, my god. This always happens, and the conversations are so stupid.
How does that even work? Who gets to decide which topics or points of view are off-the-table for normal social-media moderation? I guess you’re saying government figures and major political parties could decide unilaterally. We’ll have to repeal the first amendment, anyway.