News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by exdsq on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @10:53AM (#27833714)
> Amazon aims to have a 3,236-satellite constellation in orbit by 2029

Assuming Starlink is similar, are there any risks of "imprisonment" on Earth having ~8k low-orbit satellites flying around? In that they gravely affect efforts to fly Humans to the Moon/Mars?

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#27833992)
On most days there are up to 20,000 airplanes (which are 100-1000x larger than satellites) in the sky. And the satellites, being at 100x higher altitude, are 100x more spread out than the airplanes.

So just from a "unusable space" point of view, it's on the order of 10000x less of a problem than airplanes. The caveats here are the satellites are moving much, much faster than airplanes, and they stay in the sky much, much longer.

But it's not really a huge problem unless stuff goes wrong and you get Kessler Syndrome. This is more of a risk with the higher constellations like Amazon's and OneWeb's than it is with SpaceX Starlink (which is in a low enough orbit to de-orbit all debris within a few years, rather than centuries).

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by jsnell on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:26AM (#27834163)
> And the satellites, being at 100x higher altitude, are 100x more spread out than the airplanes.

This doesn't feel right. Shouldn't the right frame of reference be the distance to the center of the earth, not the sea level? Then it is not a 100x difference, but more like a 10% one.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by montenegrohugo on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:37AM (#27834312)
Here's the actual correct math:

---

Area of sphere: 4πr^2

Airplane cruising height: ~10km

Satellite orbit height: ~550km

Radius of earth: 6371km

thus, relative increase: (6371+550)/(6371+10) = 1.084 = 8.4% increase

Squared (because of first formula) that corresponds with a 1.084^2 = 1.175 = 17.5% increase in area.

---

Still, a few caveats:

1. Earth is huge. 510.1 million km² is a lot of space (+20% at 550km altitude). We could have a million sats with each having more than 1km^2 to themselves.

2. Satellites orbit at different heights. Amazon's and SpaceX's satellites will not be on the same orbit.

3. Starlink satellites are at a sufficiently low altitude that Kessler Syndrom is not a problem; even if they all simultaneously turned into millions of pieces of dead debris at the same time, the atmospheric drag would make them lower their orbits and burn up in just a few months.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by karatekidd32v on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:30AM (#27834214)
Agreed rough math there doesn't seem right. Also, I wonder if there's an added benefit from the inverse square law here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverse-square_law
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:42AM (#27834370)
If we were also launching from the center of the earth I would agree, but as we are launching from sea level, I think the general idea still holds.

Thought experiment:

You are standing in a field.

There is a 10x10 meter plate hovering 10 meters above you. There is a 1 square meter target on it. You fire a gun upwards at a random location on the plate. There is a 1 in 100 probability you hit the target.

Now imagine there is a 20x20 meter plate hovering 20 meters above you. It is perfectly occluded by the original 10x10 meter plate. It also has a 1 square meter target on it. When you fire at a random location on the original plate, the bullet passes through it and continues on to the higher plate. What is the probability you hit the target on the higher plate? I believe it is 1 in 400.

From this thought experiment it seems that altitude from launch point is what counts.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by tgb on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:00PM (#27836121)
If your original claim were true, then you'd also be saying that there is twice as much area at 2m above sea level as there is 1m above sea level, and infinitely more than at sea level. If you truly believe this, then I will be willing to make you a trade where I give you one tenth floor condo in exchange for 10 first floor condos.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by jsnell on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:11PM (#27834713)
Now expand your thought experiment to 4 people, standing in a 10 meter square from each other. They each have their own 10x10 and 20x20 plates, and their own targets.

Clearly the 10x10 plates are lining up (modulo curvature). But the 20x20 plates are not, they're overlapping. So when I shoot through a random location of my own 10x10 plate, there's a chance that I'll hit a target from somebody else's 20x20 plate. Sum up those additional chances, and they'll cancel out the 4x difference you found.

This feels like it would make a nice puzzle, your phrasing makes for a great misdirect / sleight of hand.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:38PM (#27835802)
I totally agree with you and the other commenters that the total area of the spherical shell is only increasing by a few %, but I still think for the purposes of "escaping earth" as the top level comment was talking about, all that matters is how spread out things are directly above you.

When talking about the area of the spherical shells, it conflates what is above me as equally relevant to things that are on the other side of the planet from me.

That is, satellite X and Y may be over me at 500km and 1000km distance, respectively. Later, they may be directly through the earth from me at distance 13200km and 13700km distance.

In the first case, if I shine a laser straight up, my probability of hitting X is 4 times higher than my probability of hitting Y.

In the second case, (if I could somehow shine a laser straight through the earth), the probabilities are nearly equal.

But my intuition is that for the purpose of escaping earth, this second case does not matter, because we are just dealing with what is above us, not the entire spherical shell.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by shkkmo on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:52AM (#27834481)
Except you can't generalize a square plate to a spherical shell...
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:59AM (#27834563)
Can you explain why?

If I am launching a rocket, and there is a 1x1 meter satellite orbiting 1000km above me. What is the probability that my rocket hits that satellite compared to an identical satellite at 2000km above me? The area of the angular sector of the sky that the 2000km altitude satellite is 1/4 of the 1000km altitude satellite.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by shkkmo on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:13PM (#27834731)
The orbital launch will follow a curved path through succesive spherical shells. The percentage of the spherical shell occupied by the 1000km satellite is not 4x larger than the percentage of the spherical shell occupied by the 2000km satellite.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by only_as_i_fall on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:31PM (#27837352)
This is the wrong mental model entirely unless your rocket launch is directly vertical and instantaneous.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by froh on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:53AM (#27834498)
(10x10):(20x20) sounds like 1:4 to me, instead of 1:400, no?
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:56AM (#27834537)
It's not 1:400 -- it's 100:400 which is equal to the 1:4 you mention.

That is, you 2x the height of the target which results in the probability of hitting being 4x less.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by tgb on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:22AM (#27834109)
They're at 100x higher altitude relative to the sea level but nearly the same altitude relative to the Earth's center which is what matters here.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by kmonsen on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:46AM (#27834410)
But we know where all the planes are, and actively monitor and move them around to avoid collisions. If there are a sufficient large number of satellites would there not be some risk of accidental collision with spacecraft taking off?
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gvb on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:56AM (#27834528)
We know where all the satellites are and they are actively tracked by both governments and private citizens.

Every satellite is in a very deterministic orbit which requires energy to change (enormous amounts of energy for a significant change) so they don't change their orbit significantly nor often.

Ref: https://sos.noaa.gov/catalog/datasets/space-trash-and-satell...

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by dehrmann on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:53PM (#27835241)
> But we know where all the planes are

We really don't. We mostly know for commercial flights, but not so much for general aviation. What aviation does is have zones around airports with restricted airspace that is well-controlled.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by haliskerbas on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:00PM (#27834580)
This is a fun site for tracking stuff in space:

http://stuffin.space/

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by popz41 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:59AM (#27834569)
NASA & the ESA actively monitors all satellites and actually maintains a database of every little piece of space debris they find (payload fairings, failed satellites, etc). They determine the orbit and track it until it falls back to earth.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by shkkmo on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:53AM (#27834507)
> But we know where all the planes are, and actively monitor and move them around to avoid collisions.

This is also true for satellites.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by chrisseaton on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:59AM (#27834560)
> But we know where all the planes are, and actively monitor and move them around to avoid collisions.

Do you think they don't know where their satellites are?

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by EveYoung on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#27834524)
A similar monitoring applies to satellites as well. We're not launching spacecrafts and just hope that everything goes well.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by staticassertion on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:39AM (#27834334)
But we can ground airplanes in a matter of hours. It doesn't really feel comparable.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by Voloskaya on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:14PM (#27835521)
* Altitude is essentially the same 6300km vs 6700km, so satellites aren't signficantly more spread out.

* Those 20k planes don't all fly at the same time.

* Retired / Broken planes don't fly, satellites may still be on orbit for decades.

* There are no debris flying in the sky at 11000 km/h

* Planes can adjust their path at will instantly for avoidance.

* Planes can be grounded instantly if we need to.

Orbital space is a limited resource that gets depleted very fast and recovers very slowly. We are talking about launching in the next ten years 5x the total number of satellites that were ever launched so far. I am sure humans in 50 years would still be able to launch a thing or two in space as well.

This is an actual problem, and unlike for planes, once the problem is apparent, you can't just take some of them out of the sky while you figure out a solution.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gamegoblin on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:18PM (#27835580)
> Those 20k planes don't all fly at the same time.

They absolutely do. Check out https://www.flightradar24.com, there are currently 15,673 planes in the air worldwide at the moment I am typing this comment.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by Voloskaya on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:21PM (#27835611)
Fair point, but does that really change the conclusion?
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by agilob on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:43PM (#27836750)
Broken planes fall down, while satellites create space debris.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by dogorman on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:47PM (#27838835)
Dead sats in LEO fall.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by ncallaway on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:05AM (#27833862)
I haven't looked at the Amazon plans, but the risks of something like Kessler syndrome "trapping" us on earth from Starlink are low.

The main reason is that the Starlink satellites fly in a very low altitude, such that even if they lose all control, they will deorbit in a few years. Which means, if something went horrifically wrong, the Starlink system debris would clear itself within a short period of time.

It looks like the Amazon Project Kuiper satellites will be slightly higher up, but still have a natural orbital decay time of between 5-7 years. https://spacenews.com/amazon-lays-out-constellation-service-...

So, the long term risks from these kinds of low-orbit mega constellations is fairly low. If anything goes catastrophically wrong we wait a decade and it's gone.

I think personally, the longer term risks we should be wary of are medium altitude and geostationary orbits that won't naturally clear themselves for decades or centuries if something goes wrong.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by runnerup on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:11AM (#27833955)
Probably not. Even 500,000 sattelites would still leave more than enough space between them for whatever you want. The risk would be if many of them blew up or something, creating billions of tiny pieces of debris. In that scenario, we might just wait 5 years and then most of the debris will have burned up in the atmosphere.

SpaceX satellites are around 550km attitude. If someone puts satellites higher than that, collision debris will last longer, the satellites' fuel will last longer so the satellites won't have to be replaced as often, but network latencies will be higher. Seems like 500-600km is the optimal zone for the primary constellations of internet satellites.

Video showing decay of debris vs. its altitude. The "X" shape is because each debris is plotted twice, once at it's perigee and again at its apogee (describing the ellipse of the orbit as they generally are not perfectly circular)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mQT5aMa_7iI

Higher altitude satellites would be a bigger concern but these aren't a big deal.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gpm on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:19AM (#27834058)
What you're asking about is basically https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome

In general the question of collision risk and debris is something evaluated for every launch/constellation. Starlink, for example, mostly avoids it being an issue by flying so low that debris quickly falls to earth and burns up in the atmosphere (they also design their satellites to fully burn up in the atmosphere). On the flip sides Starlink is planning on an order of magnitude more satellites than this.

Even the worst case though doesn't really impact humans ability to fly to the moon/mars. You can make low earth orbit relatively unusable because there is a high collision risk if you hang out there for a year, but you should basically always be able to fly through low earth orbit to a higher orbit with negligible collision risk.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by T-A on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:06AM (#27833882)
Suppose there were only 8000 cars in the world, evenly spread all over it (I'm being generous here, since 2/3 of Earth is covered by water). How likely would you be to ever see one?
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by kamkazemoose on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#27833986)
The starlink satellites are traveling a little bit faster than your average car though. They complete an orbit about every 100 minutes. So your 8000 satalites are covering much more ground than the same 8000 cars.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by robbedpeter on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:40AM (#27834345)
At any given moment the distribution is similar, and we track and regulate the orbits, leaving swathes of space open. Everything about the satellites is engineered, including their orbits. Other countries have less stringent standards, resulting in more or less random de-orbits that can drop space junk anywhere in their path, but the US has a lot of forethought put into orbital standards.

Space junk is an issue, but it's not anywhere near crisis level yet.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by Rebelgecko on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:09AM (#27833933)
The planned Starlink constellation is actually quite a bit bigger, but even if there's 20k satellites whizzing around it's not a huge problem.

I think it's sometimes hard to reason about the vastness of space, but imagine if the planet Earth had exactly 20,000 cars on it's surface. Even if you crossed the street without looking, your odds of getting hit by a car would be incredibly low. And ofc in reality low earth orbit is bigger than the surface of the earth AND we know where every obstacle is located. If humanity ever gets to the point where we decide it's too crowded, most of these constellations are low enough that they'd naturally deorbit in less than a decade.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by robbedpeter on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:43AM (#27834374)
Space is big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the drug store, but that's just peanuts to space. - Douglas Adams
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by kiba on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:32AM (#27834247)
You quoted that Amazon planned to have 3,236 satellites.

Yet, SpaceX already launched 1730 satellites, 1630 of which are active, with a planned constellation of 12,000 satellites.[1]

Amazon's Kuiper Systems hadn't even launched yet, and they're going with ULA for their first launch, which AFAIK, is much more expensive than SpaceX, with only 9 satellites as opposed to 60 satellites at a time.[2]

[1] See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink

[2] See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuiper_Systems

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by SEJeff on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:27PM (#27834909)
And if/when SpaceX finishes Starship plus Superheavy, SpaceX will be launching up to 400 satellites per launch.

Also, they've submitted authorization for up to 42,000 total starlink satellites: https://spacenews.com/spacex-submits-paperwork-for-30000-mor...

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by tigershark on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:57AM (#27834540)
And they applied for permission to launch additional 30k satellites, bringing the total to 42k. Amazon Kuiper is a toy by comparison..
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by SEJeff on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:23PM (#27834851)
No. This wouldn't happen as space is much bigger and there are far more airplanes today in the sky than satellites with a higher more distant apart orbit.

These low earth orbit constellations will naturally experience orbital decay and at the end of their useful life will simply burn up on re-entry. They're explicitly designed to prevent Kessler Syndrome:

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by johannes1234321 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:15AM (#27834008)
There are two probable problems:

a) debris damaging other satellites or space stations. There currently is no proper liability currently and different monitoring systems are still in development

b) astronomy from earth will see problems.

As long as they are on their orbits there is enough space (haha) and if they don't cause conflict with radio frequencies they also don't cause issues

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by bagels on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:34PM (#27834995)
There are already approximately 250,000 objects in low earth orbit 2cm and up. The risk from these constellations isn't from the satellites themselves directly, but from Kessler syndrome if they start getting smashed by untracked debris.
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by gorgoiler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:31PM (#27835717)
Atmospheric drag brings down anything below 800km:

https://www.esa.int/Safety_Security/Space_Debris/About_space...

Starlink operates at 550km altitude:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Launches

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by bagels on Thursday July 15, 2021 @12:09AM (#27841280)
At 800km it can take a long time (decades)
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by HideousKojima on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#27833990)
Starlink is at low enough orbits that even if the entire constellation spontaneously exploded all the debris would deorbit within ~5 years
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by bjacobt on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:00PM (#27834579)
pardon the dumb question - how do rockets from spacex, etc avoid crashing into a satellite on its way up? Is there a way to keep track of all the satellites and debris in space and time the launch so there is a clear path?
Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by sgtnoodle on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:38PM (#27835809)
Yes, there is a database and radar tracking stations, and they'll avoid launching if there's an increased chance of a collision. The density of satellites and debris in orbit is so low in absolute terms, though, that the probability of any given rocket colliding is negligible even if launching totally blindly.

Most launches are timed for minimizing fuel to achieve the desired orbit, and there's only a few seconds of wiggle room for a launch window. So, a particular launch window may be preferred over another depending on the relative probability of a collision. Nobody is explicitly timing their launches or ascent profile with regard to other satellites other than for space stations and other explicit destinations. Most launches the rocket just gets the satellites up into roughly the right orbit, and then the satellites use their own propulsion systems to maneuver into precise orbits over several months.

Re:Amazon has acquired Facebook's satellite internet team by bagels on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:38PM (#27835801)
Short answer: yes.

They do this thing called "COLA", Collision On Launch Assessment, an analysis of launch trajectory to ensure they it won't hit known objects.