News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zabzonk on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:09AM (#27728805)
Is it just me, or did all these "hackers" that apparently bought Macs back then not really produce all that much hacker software (or non-hacker software, come to that)? It seems to me that Windows and Linux both had much greater funds of developer software than did the Mac ecosystem.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by m12k on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:53AM (#27728991)
As someone that uses both Mac and Windows regularly, I find the quality of the software I use on Mac to be generally higher. Cyberduck (FTP), Transmission (bittorrent), Charles Proxy (packet sniffing), Sourcetree (git gui), Pixelmator (image editing), Sketch (vector graphics), Things (todo), 1Password (password management) are all solid applications with polished user interfaces, where I struggle to find anything quite as nice on Windows (several of these have been or are being ported to Windows, with varying levels of polish carrying over).
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by kitsunesoba on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:08AM (#27730211)
This is a problem on Linux too. The lack of a Sketch equivalent for Linux bit me just the other day. Akira is the closest thing, but it’s so early in its dev cycle that it won’t be useable for several more years. A lot of people will point to Inkscape, but it’s much more of an Illustrator alternative and as such feels more geared for print.

I might’ve been able to fudge Figma to do what I needed, but even that wouldn’t have been ideal, with how it’s designed for collaborative prototyping more than a generic digital vector graphics editor. Aside from that, I don’t like using Figma simply because they don’t publish specs for their file format and try to lock you in (as opposed to Sketch, which uses a publicly documented file format that has plenty of converters).

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zabzonk on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:15AM (#27729082)
As you say, several of these are also available on Windows - I can't think why anyone developing such software would not make them available on multiple platforms.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zepto on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:35AM (#27729905)
> I can't think why anyone developing such software would not make them available on multiple platforms.

Because it’s a lot more work, and because it’s next to impossible to create a great cross platform app with a native feeling UI.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by ficklepoet on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:54PM (#27731009)
> it’s next to impossible to create a great cross platform app with a native feeling UI

And who do we have to thank for that? Perhaps there's some business out there that made a chocolate-themed UI toolkit that was notoriously proprietary and unworkable, so much so that it drove the industry into a software drought that only let up when x86 was fully standardized?

Maybe I'm just spitballing here.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zepto on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:38PM (#27741602)
This comment makes no sense at all. You’ll need to explain it. What ‘software drought’ are you talking about?
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by herbst on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:37AM (#27729193)
Sometimes because APIs? Back when I had a Mac forced on me I was surprised how fast you can discover files and software, something windows back then simply has not managed to offer via their API. The 'finder' or whatever that tool was called simply felt wrong on windows, nothing like the original.

One different example may is the gnome shell desktop. Many of us who use it have basically overcome the win95 approach of desktop design. There is as far as I know no equivalent on windows or Mac. And a port would not be possible as you can't replace their window managers.

Then there is the whole Linux standard toolset, that yes works on windows these days, but obviously feels very foreign and doesn't integrate well to the system.

It's not only a matter of porting software when some things are so fundamentally different

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by GnarfGnarf on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:16AM (#27730281)
CyberDuck (macOS) is inferior to Ipswitch WS_FTP (Windows). The CyberDuck interface is awkward, it's confusing to tell where your uploads and downloads will wind up.

Cornerstone (macOS Subversion client) is atrocious, God help you if you created a sandbox in the wrong place, deleting it could wipe out your repository. Tortoise (Windows) is so much better.

As a Windows developer recently porting my code to macOS, I am underwhelmed. I expected to be blown away.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pilsetnieks on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:01PM (#27730633)
Cyberduck is an odd choice for a file transmission app showcase, Panic's Transmit (https://panic.com/transmit/) is much better.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by mkl95 on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:12AM (#27729074)
What are your issues with Transmission on Windows? I have been using it for years and it works like a charm.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by vincentmarle on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:33PM (#27730865)
These are all apps that did not exist in 2005. In 2005, XP was king.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by m12k on Sunday July 04, 2021 @02:55PM (#27731792)
Right, that was my point. The comment I was replying to said that all those hackers that supposedly switched to Mac in 2005 didn't seem to have produced any notable software, so I listed a whole bunch of nice software that they had produced.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by aidos on Sunday July 04, 2021 @03:40PM (#27732067)
Nitpick: I might be misremembering but I feel like I had CyberDuck in 2004 (OSX Panther?)
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by criddell on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:53PM (#27730998)
There seems to be a lot more interesting software on the Mac than Windows or Linux and I've never really understood that.

Think about how many Mac enthusiast podcasts, websites, and blogs there are. Windows should have many more of these, but they don't. And Linux enthusiast sites are very technical and low level. There's no writing about being a Linux user that isn't also about being a developer.

Where are there no companies like the Omni Goup, Cultured Code, and Panic turning out great applications for Windows? In theory, the market is an order of magnitude bigger yet the reality seems to be that there are fewer Windows users willing to pay for great software. Is it because Windows users are not on that platform by choice?

Desktop Linux users are definitely there by choice, yet they too seem to be unwilling to pay for software.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by handrous on Sunday July 04, 2021 @02:44PM (#27731718)
> Where are there no companies like the Omni Goup, Cultured Code, and Panic turning out great applications for Windows? In theory, the market is an order of magnitude bigger yet the reality seems to be that there are fewer Windows users willing to pay for great software. Is it because Windows users are not on that platform by choice?

There are such companies! For video games. Video games and B2B/business-productivity software is where the money is on Windows. Your buyers are PC gamers or businesses.

There are also lots of unsophisticated low-needs users who are on Windows at home because it's what was cheap at the big box store, and/or they learned in the earlier PC days to shop based on spec numbers back when those mattered much for basic home users, and the Apple section of the store doesn't look very interesting if you shop that way.

AFAI can tell (from watching relatives fitting this profile, which is... all of my relatives, plus many relatives of friends) the only way to make money off them, since the death of actual boxed software in stores (which they did used to sometimes buy!), is to be Microsoft and use Win10 to spam them until they buy (maybe not even realizing what's happening or, once they've paid, what they bought or what it's for or how to ever use it—yes, really) or be a straight-up malware scammer type. The problem with those users, if you want to sell them software, is they basically just want/need a browser, MS Office, and perhaps something to play the unorganized folder of pirated MP3s of 50s-90s music the unsophisticated-user side of the family has been passing around for 20 years. They may want something to organize photos and such, but they'll never figure out how to use it right even if you show them how, unless it's high-lock-in, very automatic ("AI" tagging and such), and probably cloud-based (so, likely some Web crap, not desktop software, oh and because advertising and hoovering up user data to train AI is an endless money spigot if and only if you already have massive scale you'll likely be competing on price with "free", so, have fun with that).

> Desktop Linux users are definitely there by choice, yet they too seem to be unwilling to pay for software.

Developing for Linux means receiving support load for all its desktop brokenness (driver problems [mostly video drivers]; issues with any basic hardware+software systems your software relies on to work well for all but the most basic operation, like audio for example; xorg/wayland/DE instability) and every crazy configuration out there.

Sure you can say "fuck off, we support exactly and only [a couple major desktop distros] with the default config that you get if you keep clicking OK on the OS installer and then not changing anything, and only on [list of hardware], report on any other set-up and you will be ignored" but you're already on such a tiny platform that you can hardly afford to annoy/turn-off/generate-vocal-anti-fans-among users. So instead... you develop for literally anything else, or maybe toss out some electron garbage to Linux as an afterthought.

Linux is expensive per-user and doesn't bring you that many users to begin with. Plus, yeah, there may be less willingness to pay for software.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by criddell on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:36PM (#27733182)
I'm glad you pointed out video games because that's a great counterpoint.

It just seems strange that with a billion desktops, there aren't a few million who would buy software like OmniFocus or Things if it existed on Windows.

And yeah, desktop Linux is messy.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by dijit on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:23AM (#27728859)
A lot of what works on Mac bleeds into Linux.

Linux userland tools in the last 10 years are incredible; it’s not easy to draw a direct line between that and the Mac, but I’m relatively certain there is correlation.

I’m talking about castnow, youtube-dl and a whole slew of other software which integrates proprietary things. In the 00s things like those were almost all running exclusive to windows.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zabzonk on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:27AM (#27728872)
> A lot of what works on Mac bleeds into Linux

I'd say it was the other way around, and it also bleeds into Windows. For example (of course): git.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by herbst on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:39AM (#27729201)
Or literally the whole Linux ecosystem with WSL
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by csomar on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:00AM (#27730134)
> Linux userland tools in the last 10 years are incredible

Yet, still waiting for a Git GUI for Linux.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by ficklepoet on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:52AM (#27730569)
Pretty much everyone I know has used GitG since... 2006?
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by ptomato on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:21AM (#27730318)
Sublime Merge?
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by aenis on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:03PM (#27730661)
From my purely anecdotal experiences of attending/organizing a few 500-person-plus hackstons and dozens of smaller ones, at least half of the people I meet there use macs. Its definitely in fashion still.

I switched to a m1 mac last year after nearly 4 decades of low level x86 work, incl. drivers, rootkits, and the like. These days I code in higher level languages such as rust or, ehm, python, and the mac offers a fine experience. Ironically, what pushed me over the fence was the pandemics; most of the video conferencing stuff causes windows laptops to sound like vacuum cleaners.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by aidos on Sunday July 04, 2021 @03:42PM (#27732075)
It did the same to the Macs (even recent models) to be honest. The M1 is the only laptop that seems to not die under zoom strain.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by makeitdouble on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:52AM (#27728986)
The mac’s main advantage to devs/hackers is Darwin, and we mostly use it for linux compatible software. Heck, I’ve switched from FreeBSD to osx just to get better laptop hardware and peripheral support.

Most stuff we produce are *nix compatible. I’m no great hacker but everything I wrote to make my life easier is shell based.

I think Windows with ASL will have the same impact, with more and more *nix compatible software being produced.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by speedgoose on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:21AM (#27728849)
I believe that objective-c and the Apple documentation didn't encourage people to create on Mac for a long time.

Now it's a bit better with Swift or web applications using Electron.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:57AM (#27730602)
On the contrary, OS X had first support to Java via the Java Bridge and Apple's own JVM implementation, because they weren't sure if the developer community educated in Object Pascal and C++ would be willing to touch Objective-C, so they decided to play safe with having Java for the ride, doubling down on Java uptake.

Objective-C was embraced by the developer community in such a way that they quickly deprecated Java Bridge and eventually got rid of Java development costs altogether.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by speedgoose on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:32PM (#27731252)
I remember running Java applications on a powerpc g4. It was incredibly slow and ugly, no wonder why developers still preferred objective-c over Java on Mac.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:39PM (#27731301)
That was certainly not Apple's Java, as it had good JIT compiler with code cache, and the same L&F than Objective-C applications, that wasn't definitely it.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by speedgoose on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:59PM (#27731434)
I remember the Java IDE like Eclipse or NetBeans being incredibly slow, and ugly, compared to the same software on similar priced computers running windows or GNU/Linux, or compared to more native software like Xcode or TextMate. But perhaps the powerpc g4 was simply a bad CPU for a JVM and Java developers were not very good at designing UIs for Mac.

I also remember having to wait a long time whenever the JVM was starting. It was annoying when a website did contain a Java applet because my web browser would be stuck until the JVM was ready.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday July 04, 2021 @03:15PM (#27731915)
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by WanderPanda on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:30AM (#27729878)
What the M1 giveth, Electron taketh away
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by tomxor on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#27730324)
vi inspired the concept of the GUI.

Then Electron sent many of us back to vi in search of lost CPU cycles.

-- A JavaScript Dev

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:29AM (#27730393)
Just the plain idea that vi had anything to do with GUI is hilarious.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by tomxor on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:38PM (#27730894)
It is. It's modality was an anti-inspiration, as in... how the hell can we not have modes (a GUI)... sort of... then everyone started burring crap under menus though feature accretion... hence we go full circle, because people get fed up of bloat, leading to both UX fatigue and performance fatigue, which eventually gives you a kind of appreciation for simple modal interfaces.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:19PM (#27731162)
These are GUIs,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_Vision

https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/800225.806843

vi might have visual on the name, but only for those in the Bell Labs silo

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by zepto on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:33AM (#27729900)
The hackers that bought the Macs built startups.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by deregulateMed on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:24AM (#27728861)
People really don't want to believe that we are chemical reactions and that Apple used psychology tricks on us through marketing campaigns.

It's a lot easier to justify buying an Apple product with an excuse than to realize that relentless advertising is what caused people to give Apple money.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by onethought on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:40AM (#27728937)
I don't buy this. There was something special in that time of having a Unix system with a well considered cohesive UI. Windows was not an option, and 1 click install set-and-forget linux distros weren't (aren't? :P ) really common.

There was a clear gap in the market for a unix system that was up and running with minimal fuss, apple capitalised (accidentally happened upon) this.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by fundad on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:02AM (#27729033)
Exactly! Psychology tricks would include supporting Linux commercially which is a wildly successful business (even before counting the likes of AWS which supports an OS as part of hosting).

They by definition market their product and win sales. Sales funded Linux and a lot of OSS beyond what hobbyists could possibly have done, an inconvenient truth.

People who want to support their own installation of Linux or FreeBSD do so without considering a commercial OS and a few of them constantly shitpost about how anyone could possibly not make the same choice as they do.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by throw2871 on Sunday July 04, 2021 @09:47PM (#27734041)
I'm not sure about this. Dev's are by far not the mass market of the PC industry - definitely not enough to achieve large adoption. Office users, casual users, students, etc may not even know what a "Unix system" is. For them marketing, being in the "cool crowd", aesthetics, and broad easy compatibility IMO are the things that make them more comfortable making a purchase. Herd behavior is real, and the lines in front of stores, that everyone they know is talking about them, etc just enforce more purchases. It makes users more secure, and inclusive in their purchase of your device.

More just an anecdotal opinion but to me the iPad and iPhone (the ecosystem effect) and Apple's marketing are really what gave them the leg up on the personal computing level. I still remember those "I'm a PC, I'm a Mac" ads pitching the PC as the uncool choice. That's a powerful message to people and they must of thought it would work otherwise they wouldn't of run that ad - if not to dev's the general public. Individuals were buying them locally as home machines way before companies really allowed them for work because of this marketing and the easy integration to their other consumer devices - at least that's what I saw locally here (not US).

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by onethought on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:57AM (#27734744)
I was specifically responding to the Developer angle of Mac buying. If you want to talk mainstream it was clearly the iMac then the iPod then the iPhone then the iPad that captured society.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by throw2871 on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:50PM (#27743501)
I would argue they aren't that separated. If the Mac hadn't got popular with the consumer market it could be said that Linux distro's could of been the popular choice for that market, as it's free and the Apple laptop ecosystem could of languished. The success on the consumer side fuels the viability of the laptop from the dev side as well.

If it never got popular on the consumer end and I couldn't manage my office docs and such on it, while I may use it at home, many workplaces and therefore the mainstream dev may of never adopted the Mac. What I use at "home", is what I want to use when I come into the workplace. There needs to be a critical mass before most workplaces (where many dev's work) to adopt it and therefore develop an ecosystem around it (e.g. your favourite IDE's, tool chains, etc)

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by onethought on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:21PM (#27743940)
I think their laptops were not particularly popular outside dev world… perhaps the iBooks… not sure. I see what you are saying though.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pjmlp on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:49AM (#27735247)
Actually you could buy Sun and Toshiba laptops running Solaris before that accident happenend.

This accident also allows for what-ifs, had Apple been successful with Copland or bought BeOS instead, none of which UNIX friendly.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by shkkmo on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:41AM (#27729959)
Dell makes hardware that easily rivals Apple and sells it with Linux pre-installed and officially covered by their support services.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by mthoms on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:32PM (#27730860)
The parent was referring to 2005 (when PG posted this). Did Dell have that option way back then? Colour me impressed if so.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by slacktide on Sunday July 04, 2021 @02:03PM (#27731471)
Pretty close. They started offering Ubuntu preinstalls on 24 May 2007.

https://www.delltechnologies.com/en-us/blog/15994-2/

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by onethought on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:59AM (#27734754)
So that period of Unix based Mac started around 2002ish (maybe earlier), and was as you say unchallenged until 2007 by dell. Then Ubuntu back then would still have problems with printers/external screens etc (Printers back then were more important than they are now too).
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by deregulateMed on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:33AM (#27730427)
The same people that want a Unix based operating system can't manage to install Linux?

I was 14 years old in 2005 and knew nothing about programming, but was able to get Linux installed in a few minutes.

There is a real reason, but the part of the brain that makes the decision is different than the speech part of the brain.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by linguae on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:04PM (#27730667)
Sometimes users have problems installing Linux, not because of lack of ability, but because of lack of driver support. This is especially true for laptops. I remember installing Linux on my desktop in 2004 as an 11th grader, and I remember having to purchase a $50 serial port modem at Fry's (yes, my parents were still on dial-up at the time) because the modem that shipped with my PC was a "Winmodem," one that had many of its core functionality implemented in software that was only available for Windows.

After my freshman year of college ended, in the summer of 2006 I replaced my desktop (which was dual-booting Windows XP and FreeBSD) with a Core Duo MacBook, which was just released two months before. It felt great using a Unix machine where I didn't have to worry about driver support, and where I can run Unix applications and various proprietary software packages such as Microsoft Office without dual-booting, emulation, or virtualization.

I've stayed a Mac user since, though lately I'm in the slow transition of switching away; I just replaced my 2013 MacBook Air with a Microsoft Surface Pro 7 running Windows 10 (I love WSL!), and I plan to replace my 2013 Mac Pro with a Ryzen 7 or 9 build sometime in 2022 or 2023, which will most likely run FreeBSD. In the interim I've installed many Linux and FreeBSD systems for work and for play.

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by spiderice on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:00PM (#27730630)
I have also installed and managed many Linux systems. Doesn’t mean I want to on my main driver. I also don’t want a cheap plastic computer with a terrible trackpad (regardless of how great the intervals are) and until recently, that was pretty much all you could find in the non-Mac laptop world.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by deregulateMed on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:43PM (#27731326)
"cheap plastic"

The marketing company won.

This is a Major red flag.

Speaking of cheap plastic. "Cheap keyboard" ring a bell?

Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by onethought on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:01AM (#27734764)
Yes I'm sure a good majority of us were mucking with Linux when we were 14... that didn't change the slickness of OSX as a Unix driver. It took Linux UI 10+ years after to get competitive, and still because of lack of corporate software (Microsoft, et al) it's still lacking.
Re:Return of the Mac (2005) by pram on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:56PM (#27731418)
Nah dude, I installed Slackware 7 in 1999 when I was 13, and used Linux up until 2003. Then I bought a G4 PowerBook and never looked back. People who chose OSX for its UNIX foundation weren't too dumb and stupid to use Linux, contrary to what you believe.