News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:07PM (#27723077)
You mean “What did ancient European languages sound like” perhaps? I would submit that Samskruta (NOT the anclicised Sanskrit) sounds exactly like how it did in ancient times. How come there is no discussion of that at all?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by imbnwa on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:21PM (#27723196)
A discussion of that would have to also include a discussion of why Lithuanian has also not changed much since the vocabulary is filled with Samskruta cognates that Lithuanian does NOT share with Slavic languages like Russian or Polish, some examples from Wikipedia:

- S: sunus, L: sunus (son)

- S: avis, L: avis (sheep)

- S: padas, L: padas (foot)

- S: viras, L: vyras (man, also compare Latin vir [pronounced weer])

- S: dhumas, L: dumas (smoke)

- S: antaras, L: antras (other, second)

- S: vṛkas, L: vilkas (wolf)

- S: yuñje, L: jungiu (I join)

- S: jántis, L: gentys (tribes, also compare Latin gentes [a/the people])

- S: dantas, L: dantis (also compare Latin dentes)

- S: naktis, L: naktis (also compare Latin noctes)

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by vkazanov on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:43PM (#27724219)
Knowing Russian, Lithuanian and bits of Polish I would also add that it's amazing how lithuanian is very similar to slavic languages in grammar structure but radically different phonetically.

I.e. a direct translation, word to word, works (with some style issues), but it's hard to recognize the sentence when pronounced.

This makes me wonder how sanscrit sounds...

Also, the language is quite complex, probably more complex than polish or russian, which is typical for archaic languages, afaik.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by imbnwa on Sunday July 04, 2021 @11:32AM (#27730417)
I find the rhythm/meter is very Romance-like but without identifying with any one specific Romance-speaking region, the phonetics vaguely remind me of Brazilian Portuguese.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by vkazanov on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:34PM (#27741165)
Heh... Brazilian Portuguese is my favourite language I'll never learn :-)
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by KhoomeiK on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:59PM (#27723501)
Lithuanian in general is considered one of the most conservative IE languages. There isn't really any clear reason that historical linguistics has produced for whether languages change quickly or slowly afaik.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by imbnwa on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:02PM (#27723515)
My understanding was that the isolation of the Baltic speakers was a big contributor, though off the top of my head I wouldn't know the geographical obstacles, hence also why they were the last to Christianity in Europe
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:52PM (#27724305)
No Sanskrit absolutely doesn't sound like it did in ancient the ancient times. Modern (north Indian) Sanskrit pronunciation uses Hindi/Urdu style of pronouncing vowels which was significantly influenced by Arabic and Persian.

Ancient Sanskrit pronunciation was essentially similar to what we call the Prakrit language, which was a more colloquial version and spoken by most people. Bengali, Marathi and Gujarati are a bit closer to that pronunciation, but of course they have changed a fair bit too.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by FlyingSnake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:15PM (#27724536)
> Modern (north Indian) Sanskrit pronunciation uses Hindi/Urdu style of pronouncing vowels which was significantly influenced by Arabic and Persian.

This has to be the most far-fetched and absurd claim I’ve heard so far. Sanskrit has been orally transmitted since several millennia and there’s no change in its pronunciation and grammar since days of Panini. That robust oral tradition is well researched and proven to be fool proof.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:45PM (#27724763)
I mean, you could listen to samveda chants from different parts of India and see the pronunciations are very audibly different...

Your kind of hot take about Sanskrit is somewhat common.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by schoen on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:09PM (#27724946)
I once went to a wedding involving academic linguists and Hindu prayers. A Hindu priest chanted a prayer in Sanskrit and then an academic linguist followed up by chanting the same prayer with his view of what it would have anciently sounded like. Notwithstanding the priest's own view of his Sanskrit as an ancient language, his pronunciation didn't match up with the academic linguist's view of the historical pronunciation.

Relatedly, I went to a spoken Latin event where I (an American) spoke Latin with an Italian man. His pronunciation and mine were wildly different, although we could understand each other. Neither was all that similar to the academic linguists' view of what our conversation would have sounded like thousands of years ago, though I guess his vowels were generally closer and my consonants were generally closer.

People retaining ancient languages for liturgical and scholarly uses are generally not that great at preventing the pronunciation from shifting, and I think that's true across the board. ("Atque memento, nulli adsunt Romanorum qui locutionem tuam corrigant." -- Henry Beard.)

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:27AM (#27749077)
I don't understand why an academic linguist is more qualified than a traditionally educated scholar in India, who has deep knowledge of the classics. I don't deny that there were likely some influences, but the care and precision with I was taught recitation is something I have not encountered in any other discipline. I am an engineer, but if I start from the Ashtadhyayi, I don't see how things could have changed much.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by schoen on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:57PM (#27756873)
My understanding is that it's not clear to what extent Panini understood or attempted to explicitly treat articulatory phonetics. Addressing articulatory phonetics well in writing alone is still hard, and understanding it in detail was immensely hard before the creation of audio recording, spectrograms, and x-rays.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shiva_Sutras#Arrangement

So while a present-day understanding of classical Sanskrit grammar could be derived fairly directly from his work, that's still not any guarantee that you would pronounce Sanskrit just as Panini would have.

A moderately imperfect analogy is that while Jews have been carefully learning to read, recite, and copy the Torah for thousands of years -- including reading commentaries, which, while nowhere near as systematic or thorough as Panini, elucidate lots of grammatical issues -- there still emerged huge, systematic regional differences in the pronunciation of particular Hebrew letters, even in liturgical use.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Hebrew

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sephardi_Hebrew

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mizrahi_Hebrew

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiberian_Hebrew

among several others. The people using each pronunciation were often incredibly sophisticated in their religious scholarship and incredibly familiar with the underlying material, but they definitely didn't (and don't) pronounce it the same way.

Modern linguistics has been able to find evidence for comparing these pronunciation variants and also understanding their histories, and I believe something similar is true for Sanskrit pronunciation.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:09PM (#27733022)
"There are no more Romans to correct your speech"?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by schoen on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:21PM (#27734159)
"And remember, there are no Romans around to correct your pronunciation."
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by YeGoblynQueenne on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:24AM (#27736013)
Cheers. Yeah, I let the "remember" bit drop :)
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by AbrahamParangi on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:33PM (#27724659)
That would make it the only language in the world to be passed down unmodified, which seems... unlikely.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by FlyingSnake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:37PM (#27724698)
I understand it comes across as jingoistic, but truly Sanskrit grammar and pronunciation hasn’t changed since Pānini. The word Sanskrit itself means “constructed” and there was a rigorous effort to prevent ambiguity.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by hawk_ on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:17PM (#27725002)
there are no recordings from panini's times and panini's texts pertain to grammar. they don't prescribe pronunciation - like precise position of tongue lips etc...
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by ummonk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @11:34PM (#27727040)
What are you talking about? Panini did detail the pronunciation of each character. And the actual pronunciation (i.e. accounting for things like assimilation) is then encoded in the writing via Sandhi.

Likewise, we have older information on pronunciation as well in the Pratishakhyas.

Ancient Indians cared a lot about accurate pronunciation, especially for mantras where the thinking was that without correct pronunciation, the mantra would not work. Picture the Harry Potter "wingardium leviosa" scene.

Modern don’t actually hew to the prescribed pronunciation for certain letters, but it’s certainly specified by Panini.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by prox on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:08AM (#27728261)
That’s actually the first thing you learn and it’s quite rigorous where to vocalize and how.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:17AM (#27781211)
Yeah, and it differs based on where you're from!
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:58PM (#27724865)
Grammar hasn't. Pronunciation has, a lot.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:27PM (#27762905)
You are almost completely wrong. How do you account for the precision of Panini as the previous commenter pointed out? How do you know to postulate that? There is NO other formalized grammar akin to Panini, so don’t judge Samskruta by other so called Indo European standards!
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:28AM (#27749102)
It is NOT Sanskrit, which was foisted on the world by the british. Please be respectful and call it by it real name, given by Panini which literally codified and formalized it.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:10AM (#27781186)
Maybe if more people learnt the language instead of crusading on about it's supposed heritage, it would have been the official language of India.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by KhoomeiK on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:57PM (#27723478)
I agree with the sentiment but ironically your transliteration of the name of that language reveals that it certainly has undergone at least some sound changes. Why do people in the north pronounce the vocalic "r" as "ri" while in the south they use "ru"? Why do people in the north drop word final schwa but in the south they add a nasal bilabial?

While it's very easy to pronounce Samskrta in a way similar to what was likely used in classical times, there have definitely been sound changes to an extent.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:53PM (#27723863)
In classical recitation, with ghanapatha and other techniques, I would expect that pronunciation is strict, meters are accounted for, and things have remained relatively unchanged in the way the Vedas and Upanishads are recited. Unfortunately, there is little exposure of the rigorous training in the Western world.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by KhoomeiK on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:53PM (#27724322)
I've listened to rgveda samhita patha of what I believe is the shakala shakha which is predominant in north india but even they seem to mispronounce the vocalic "r" as "ri".
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:16AM (#27781206)
It's more of a Pali/Prakrit influence than a mispronunciation.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:48PM (#27726394)
Exactly. This transliteration, in eastern India would be 'Shongskrito'. Which is no more right or wrong compared to saying 'Sanskrit'.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:28PM (#27762925)
Songuahkrito is not Samskruta but Bengali. So what’s your point?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by fooker on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:15AM (#27781202)
Sure, and that's exactly why pronunciation has changed over the last few thousand years.

People are always going to speak how they want and eventually the 'correct' version isn't the majority. None of the many thousand people who have learnt Sanskrit in the eastern part of India would pronunce the name as 'Samskruta'. You could argue all day about how they are all wrong, that doesn't really change the fact.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by Ar-Curunir on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:03PM (#27724902)
While it’s very true that we have a much better idea of how Sanskrit was pronounced millennia ago than we do for most languages, we can’t make absolute claims like yours.

No, that’s not true. there’s a bunch of varieties of Sanskrit, including Vedic Sanskrit, Classical Sanskrit, and various local dialects. Not all of these have been preserved in oral traditions.

Second, even within the preserved oral traditions, pronunciations vary across schools. For example, the “kru” part in your Samskruta is pronounced differently in different parts of India; some people do say “kri”

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by ummonk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @11:28PM (#27727012)
Which ancient times? It was only frozen after Panini’s time, but there had been changes from original rigvedic pronunciation by then.

And your quibbling is indicative that there have been also been changes today as well - e.g. southern speakers tend to pronounce vowel r as “ru” while others say “ri” and at some point in time the pronunciation was likely more like American English r.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:40PM (#27763075)
This has been an incredible discussion, thank you all for contributing. I hope my original point was made, which was that there is often bias when the western world talks about “ancient”, and I place the blame squarely on the imperialistic british for that. The other issue I want to point out is that there is a certain arrogance that the linguistic academia has as it relates to traditional scholars by regularly discounting their knowledge and assuming their own superiority. Not trying to change anyone’s beliefs, just an opinion I am expressing. I am going to drop out not for want of willingness to engage, but because this discussion is devolving into familiar patterns of debate. All I can say as a practitioner is that when I was taught, I was actually taught the “correct way” and the differences so I was always aware. There is an academic rigor in traditional teaching that Western academia seems to be unaware of.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by throwawaysea on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:37PM (#27725125)
> How come there is no discussion of that at all?

Leaving aside the linguistic debate in the comments here, there’s often no fair or truthful or representative discussion of the ancient East’s legacy (or others) for reasons relating to imperialism, colonialism, and supremacist thinking. I don’t mean that in the explicit “we’re taking over your country way” but in the more subtle or implicit ways. Western world views and Eurocentric histories are everywhere, from academia to Wikipedia, and due credit or consideration isn’t given elsewhere.

The problem persists even in the very countries we are talking about, like India, since their earlier “original” Hindu culture was changed by invasions (whether from the Islamic Middle East or Christian Europe). My understanding is that when the British finally left India, their academic culture still persisted in the form of Western education that replaced earlier forms of education, textbooks sourced from Western publishers, taxpayer funding into this system, and the adoption of languages like Hindi and English as the official languages (rather than say Sanskrit or Tamil).

So to answer your question in the broader sense beyond this article and discussion, there is no discussion of these things in part because of the power of Western spheres and in part because Eastern spheres themselves haven’t retained their own knowledge or promoted themselves adequately either domestically or internationally.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by prox on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:27AM (#27728343)
Afaik the original culture (take India) has been massively influenced by the English occupation and Mogul occupation.

Lots of the original way people thought, lived their culture and worshipped in their religion has changed.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by stan_rogers on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:40PM (#27723759)
While there is an element of truth to that, it's largely because the language was deliberately fossilized for religious reasons, while the "real" language that people actually used day to day continued to evolve around it.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:57PM (#27723884)
How fossilized? While it is not used as an everyday language, there is a yet growing library of literature, and vigorous philosophical debate that happens in Samskruta. BTW, an unrelated rant, the other thing that grinds on me is that the Ganga river is ALWAYS referred as Ganges (another anglicization)! Ganga is easier to pronounce, so why did that get anglicized, I wonder?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by stan_rogers on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:32PM (#27724129)
Certainly vocabulary has been added to, but the whole point of the work of Pāṇini and others was to prevent the Vedas from drifting over time. That freezing of the core of the language was deliberate and artificial. (The same thing applies to the Arabic of the 7th century. It exists nearly unchanged at its core for religious reasons, and a version with various additions functions as a lingua franca and language of academic discourse - rather as Latin or Greek did in other cultures - in the Islamic sphere.)
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by Ar-Curunir on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:06PM (#27724915)
And Paninian/Classical Sanskrit is not even Vedic Sanskrit!
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by prox on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:12AM (#27728282)
Not only that, but in Vedic ceremonies you have a priest who is just there so no mistakes are made.

>The brahman was the reciter of hymns from the atharvaveda who was largely silent and observes the procedures and uses Atharvaveda mantras to 'heal' it when mistakes have been made.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:32AM (#27749153)
It seems to me that you are proving my point.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by hassancf on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:12PM (#27723983)
I think it is really hard for speakers of European languages to believe that a language could have the same pronunciation that it had centuries ago.

Obvious example:

Arabic from at least the 7th century AD:

As an Arabic speaker, I can totally read a text the way it was pronounced 14 centuries ago and also perfectly understand it.

You cannot say the same thing for European languages.

Probably the same for sanskrit.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by yorwba on Saturday July 03, 2021 @06:43PM (#27725589)
> As an Arabic speaker, I can totally read a text the way it was pronounced 14 centuries ago

You probably cannot. Every region with a tradition of reciting the Qur'an has their own way of pronouncing it. It would be a strange coincidence if your tradition in particular happened to keep the pronunciation unchanged while all the others didn't.

E.g. do you pronounce ﺽ as a pharyngealized voiced alveolar lateral fricative? That's the most likely reconstruction of the sound: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E1%B8%8C%C4%81d

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by ssr2020 on Sunday July 04, 2021 @03:12AM (#27727847)
Because it is necessary to read the Qur'an properly, and in order for it not to change or deteriorate over time, old scientists wrote in books how to read each letter and its rules. It is written in detail where each letter will come out of the mouth and what features(like the sibilants, the stressed letters, the soft letters, the labiolinguals, and tremolo etc. ) it will have. For us in Turkey it is different ve more difficult but we learn it to read the Qur'an properly. You can listen a surah from the Quran from a Turkish or Arabic reciter there is no big difference.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by yorwba on Sunday July 04, 2021 @04:31AM (#27728130)
> old scientists wrote in books how to read each letter and its rules. It is written in detail where each letter will come out of the mouth and what features(like the sibilants, the stressed letters, the soft letters, the labiolinguals, and tremolo etc. ) it will have

Indeed, that is why modern scientists believe that ﺽ must have represented some kind of lateral sound, like a lateral fricative (or maybe a lateral affricate or a stop with lateral release – the descriptions aren't detailed enough to distinguish between these options.) But most modern speakers nonetheless pronounce it as a plain stop or dental fricative instead of lateral.

Having a description of the pronunciation doesn't mean that someone reading the description will be able to follow it perfectly. Otherwise everyone learning a foreign language would be able to develop a native-like accent just by reading about the correct pronunciation.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by hassancf on Saturday July 03, 2021 @11:17PM (#27726976)
>> You probably cannot.

Exactly my point.

You’re under the impression I cannot because of your limited knowledge of this topic: even if 1 letter was slightly different (which it is not), how does that discard the prononciation of 99% of the rest?

>> Every region with a tradition of reciting the Qur'an has their own way of pronouncing it

Plain wrong.

If you knew the topic, you would know that the various way to read the Holy Quran are so close that you could just say they are identical.

In my original post, I’m not even necessarily talking about the holy Quran.

What about the vast poetry written in Arabic in pre-Islamic times that anyone today can read the same way?

I will not get into the subject of whether I would understand it or not since you are still debating whether I would pronounce it the same way.

BTW, this is very different from : how does one pronounce Latin etc.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by yorwba on Sunday July 04, 2021 @04:34AM (#27728141)
It seems our disagreement is mostly about the semantics of what it means to pronounce something the same way.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by anthk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#27724019)
> As an Arabic speaker, I can totally read a text the way it was pronounced 14 centuries ago and also perfectly understand it.

I may be able to do something similar in Spanish. I've read Emilianensian /Glosas/ in Navarrese-Aragonese and understand near the 95% of it. That being a close Romance to Castillian Spanish.

Scroll down and compare, you don't need to understand Spanish:

https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glosas_Emilianenses

Also, I can perfectly read Don Quixote. My main issues would be the old Medieval slang with things that do not exist anymore or they changed a lot. But without the footer annotations, I had no issues at all to understand the 80% of it.

But, spelling it? Heck, it didn't change at all, our Spanish standards (Nebrija's grammar) date back to that era.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by jltsiren on Saturday July 03, 2021 @06:25PM (#27725452)
That's how foreign names work. People hear the name used in another language, and then they adapt the pronunciation and/or spelling to their own language.

As a Finnish speaker, "Ganges" has the familiar form of a name borrowed from Greek or Latin, and it does not need further adaptation. "Ganga", on the other hand, sounds awkward in Finnish. Had ancient Finns been in contact with India, we would probably know the river as Kanka or Kankajoki ("Kanka river"). The latter in particular sounds like a proper Finnish river name.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gerdesj on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:03PM (#27726072)
That's if we can even all agree on how to pronounce "Ganges"! Should it rhyme with cheese or oranges; are the g's hard or soft? In en_GB the first g is hard and the second one soft and the word rhymes with cheese. Oh, and the a is short.

Place names are notoriously tricky. The town I live in is now called Yeovil. It has well over sixty documented spellings since around 500CE. It started off as Gifle - bend in the river. G -> Y is a common Old English/Saxon to modern English thing (-gard and -yard, -burg and -bury, dag or tag and day.) If you squint really hard you can get the rest of the word OK. It was Ival, Givelle, Evil and all sorts of spellings on the way to today. There was also a vowel shift en-route and a generally open approach to spelling.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by Causality1 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:03PM (#27723920)
Ganges is what the Hellenic Greeks called it. Most English words for Indian things come from Greek.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by naveens on Sunday July 04, 2021 @01:33AM (#27727463)
it's tamil-ized as Kangai. Proper nouns are always absorbed according to the target language's own rules. Why quibble?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by codesnik on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:37PM (#27726314)
if that'd peace your mind, we call it "Gang" in Russia. But I wouldn't be surprised that it came from greek too, most greek words lost their endings when loaned to Russian
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:25PM (#27733125)
Can you give some examples please? I'm Greek and I don't know any Russian.

In Greek we have adopted many Turkish words and we always stick an "-i" at the end. For example, "passoumi" (a kind of footwear, "passoum" in Turkish), "briki" (for making coffee, "brik" in Turkish), "ati" (horse, "at" in Turkish) etc. I think we've also taken some Slavic words and treated them this way, for example "boureki" (borek, dumpling), kokoretsi ("kokorec") and probably others I can't think of now.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by prosody on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:46PM (#27723812)
It's been a long time since I've done anything with Sanskrit so please forgive any misunderstandings, but didn't Vedic ळ become Classical ड, as in नीळ and नीड ?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by FlyingSnake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:17PM (#27724017)
> Vedic ळ

There is strong evidence that the ळ came from Substratum languages (Dravidian or Munda) and many Indo-Aryan languages still retain it e.g. Marathi, Gujarati.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by KhoomeiK on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:55PM (#27724350)
Yes but it's still present in Vedic, literally in the second word of rgveda 1.1.1.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by chakkepolja on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:41AM (#27738471)
Vedas were not passed unmodified since they were originally written. Neither were the purānas.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by chakkepolja on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:38AM (#27738440)
Vedic Samskrutham was pretty much different I guess.

And regular people didn't speak sanskrit in classical age. They spoke regional languages like Prakrit and Pali.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:31AM (#27749130)
Vedic Samskrutam was a different language than Paninis classical Samskrutam. We need to recognize size that.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by FlyingSnake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:16PM (#27724002)
The reason there's no discussion about Samskruta is that all the scholars of संस्कृतम are in India and most of the University departments lack the cultural and linguistic nuances that are needed to learn संस्कृतम. Unless Indians come and share their research with the world, there won't be any discussion on it.

I also think this is so because the prevalent narrative is post colonial in nature and the (English) Internet is came out of Anglosphere. This is not a criticism of the prevalent order, it's just the way things have evolved naturally post WW2.

Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by ta___1254 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:26PM (#27724081)
It's संस्कृतम् not संस्कृतम
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by FlyingSnake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:46PM (#27724249)
Another casualty of transliteration keyboards.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by chakkepolja on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:19AM (#27738842)
Lot of Sanskrit scholars are priests and their bias is shown a lot as well. They cry whenever something becomes slightly better offensive to 2000 year ago people.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by hallarempt on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#27723197)
No, it doesn't. End of discussion.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by gpraghu on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:50PM (#27723832)
Could you elaborate please? How do you establish that?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by poisonarena on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:14PM (#27723126)
The article is about Indo-European languages, that includes 'indic, iranian, and slavic'. You can write a blog about Samskruta.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by imbnwa on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:16PM (#27723143)
Samskruta is an Indo-European language.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by poisonarena on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:11PM (#27723586)
I didn't say it wasn't...
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by tweaktastic on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:26PM (#27723239)
Are you saying Samskruta is not an Indic language?
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by poisonarena on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:12PM (#27723592)
No, I didn't say that.
Re:What did ancient languages sound like? by tweaktastic on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:26PM (#27723232)
Are you saying Samskruta is not an Indic language?