Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by pratio on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:28AM
(#27641276)
This article gives no information about how these microscopes work, what advantage do they have over electron microscopy. An HN comment below actually provided more context.
Who developed this tech and how long have we been working no it. I don't understand how it reached the top posts.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by doctoboggan on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:13PM
(#27646883)
I don’t think that is the same technology, it seems to be an electron microscope not a light microscope.
The article references “squeezed light” which is a trick for adding more certainty to a photons position (at the expense of less certainty in its momentum - heisenburg always wins)
To learn more about squeezed light check out this video from PBS Spacetime[0]. The video doesn’t cover this light microscope, but does explain squeezed light.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by wolverine876 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:58AM
(#27648981)
> This article gives no information about how these microscopes work
Are we reading different articles? From the article:
They used a type of microscope with two laser light sources, but sent one of the beams through a specially designed crystal that “squeezes” the light. It does so by introducing quantum correlations in the photons – the particles of light in the laser beam.
The photons were coupled into correlated pairs, and any of them that had energies unlike the others were discarded instead of being paired off. That process lowered the intensity of the beam while decreasing its noise, which allowed for more precise imaging.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by wolverine876 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:01AM
(#27648993)
Why trust a random person on HN over a random person at the New Scientist (who is probably an experienced journalist in the field, and has editors double-checking what they write), who researched the story and spoke to the people who made the microscope?
Imagine if someone here said, 'I spoke to the scientists who made the microscope and they said...'. We'd think that was awesome? That's in the New Scientist article.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by bryan0 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:30PM
(#27643280)
Oh you didn’t find the image captioned “An artist’s impression of a quantum microscope” of what appears to be an alien tractor beam sucking up small creatures helpful??
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by ur-whale on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:34AM
(#27641313)
I agree with you 100%, and I find this happens very often on the net: an article describing something essentially visual that can't bother adding a couple of pics or videos.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by perl4ever on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:02PM
(#27646335)
No, I have come to expect that any article like this, about microscopes or telescopes or any imaging technology, is guaranteed not to have any example of what they are talking about.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by TheRealPomax on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:08PM
(#27643048)
Would be nice if the article, you know, explained the part that of the title. The only thing it mentions is:
>They used a type of microscope with two laser light sources, but sent one of the beams through a specially designed crystal that “squeezes” the light. It does so by introducing quantum correlations in the photons – the particles of light in the laser beam. The photons were coupled into correlated pairs, and any of them that had energies unlike the others were discarded instead of being paired off.
Which tells us nothing, and as someone who took both physics and quantum computing in university, infuriating. They used magic? Got it. Details, or you just made shit up. You're newscientist, do better.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by akiselev on Saturday June 26, 2021 @03:22PM
(#27644962)
I'm curious what the dark blobs are in the photos of the live yeast cells in the paper [1]. They look like what I'd expect organelles to look like but yeast are eukaryotes so I'm guessing coagulation of some sort?
I would have thought that bacteria would look much more homogeneous internally, at least at this scale.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by quenix on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:31AM
(#27642734)
Sound waves have a much larger wavelength (in the tens or hundreds of meters). That can never map out the details of a cell.
Light, on the other hand, has a wavelength in the order of nanometers. If my math is correct, the wavelength of light is smaller than that of sound by a factor of around 1000000000000 on average.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by failwhaleshark on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:40PM
(#27646151)
IIRC, most configuration of electron microscopes tend to lyse cells because of the environmental conditions of hard vacuum and high charge.
Then some instruments came along that took advantage of lysing cells for analysis: flow cytometry.
If you can look at cells without going full-power Death Star on them, that sounds damn useful.
---
I anticipate Applied Science will build one in his garage over the weekend and apologize for not making it 2 orders-of-magnitude more sensitive than UQ's. :bow before the might of this over-achiever who ships, a hacker as salty as my HP 48G/X:
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by Gatsky on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:08AM
(#27641176)
This isn’t bullshit. Directly observing the behaviour of live cells in context is a powerful technique. This work means such techniques will be even more powerful, by increasing the feature resolution and reducing light induced damage to the cells.
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by cstross on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:08AM
(#27641178)
Electron microscopy has drawbacks when it comes to studying biological samples. The sample has to be prepared for examination in a vacuum chamber using ionizing radiation and using fixating processes and reagents that kill the cells and may damage/distort lipid membranes. Brief intro here:
Re:Quantum microscope can examine cells in unprecedented detail
by cstross on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:25AM
(#27641603)
The structures in biological samples are often very delicate, their structures ruined by all of those treatments: think soap bubbles rather than bones.
It doesn't matter how small the structures you can observe are if you can't be sure they haven't been warped and distorted by dehydration, doping with heavy metals like osmium, exposure to vacuum, and being blasted with radiation until it's heated to 150 degrees celsius.
Don't get me wrong: electron microscopy is great for mineral samples, and can be used for biological samples subject to some constraints. But you can't examine specimens with it while they're alive.
Here's a more info from Technion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtcVL7KnfCI
The article references “squeezed light” which is a trick for adding more certainty to a photons position (at the expense of less certainty in its momentum - heisenburg always wins)
To learn more about squeezed light check out this video from PBS Spacetime[0]. The video doesn’t cover this light microscope, but does explain squeezed light.
[0]: https://youtu.be/uZDhCW-PTRM
Are we reading different articles? From the article:
They used a type of microscope with two laser light sources, but sent one of the beams through a specially designed crystal that “squeezes” the light. It does so by introducing quantum correlations in the photons – the particles of light in the laser beam.
The photons were coupled into correlated pairs, and any of them that had energies unlike the others were discarded instead of being paired off. That process lowered the intensity of the beam while decreasing its noise, which allowed for more precise imaging.
Imagine if someone here said, 'I spoke to the scientists who made the microscope and they said...'. We'd think that was awesome? That's in the New Scientist article.
Frustrating.
I'm guessing New Scientist had not got permission to use the stuff yet?
-The Court "
For those who don't have access to Nature it includes an example image.
>They used a type of microscope with two laser light sources, but sent one of the beams through a specially designed crystal that “squeezes” the light. It does so by introducing quantum correlations in the photons – the particles of light in the laser beam. The photons were coupled into correlated pairs, and any of them that had energies unlike the others were discarded instead of being paired off.
Which tells us nothing, and as someone who took both physics and quantum computing in university, infuriating. They used magic? Got it. Details, or you just made shit up. You're newscientist, do better.
I would have thought that bacteria would look much more homogeneous internally, at least at this scale.
[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03528-w.epdf?shar...
Light, on the other hand, has a wavelength in the order of nanometers. If my math is correct, the wavelength of light is smaller than that of sound by a factor of around 1000000000000 on average.
Then some instruments came along that took advantage of lysing cells for analysis: flow cytometry.
If you can look at cells without going full-power Death Star on them, that sounds damn useful.
---
I anticipate Applied Science will build one in his garage over the weekend and apologize for not making it 2 orders-of-magnitude more sensitive than UQ's. :bow before the might of this over-achiever who ships, a hacker as salty as my HP 48G/X:
https://www.sciencelearn.org.nz/resources/500-preparing-samp...
A low energy optical microscope can examine living samples (in aqueous environments).
It doesn't matter how small the structures you can observe are if you can't be sure they haven't been warped and distorted by dehydration, doping with heavy metals like osmium, exposure to vacuum, and being blasted with radiation until it's heated to 150 degrees celsius.
Don't get me wrong: electron microscopy is great for mineral samples, and can be used for biological samples subject to some constraints. But you can't examine specimens with it while they're alive.