It's fine for many people, but some like this writer, still can't shake the idea the world must have omniscient oracles.
I think however the intersection and pop culture and science is what makes us queasy about scientific confusion. Often, while we don't know somethings completely, we know them quite well enough (anthropogenic global warming from carbon emissions, lung cancer from cigarette smoking etc).
However, if there is scientific uncertainty it often becomes an invitation for quacks and charlatans - which is why scientists are sometimes so hesitant to speculate in public.
Scientists may propose a novel model. Then they check whether the model predicts reality better than the old model within some boundaries. Rinse and repeat.
Although a model will probably seem to be "explaining" reality, this is mostly misleading and by all means unnecessary. Pop-sci will explain anything to anyone anyway, they can even explain Hawking radiation without showing even one equation.
I mean, I can think of a few brain-related questions with no good answers:
- What is consciousness and how does a brain become conscious?
- How and why is one specific consciousness attached to one specific brain (& body)? Why am I controlling my body and not yours?
haha :D
To take it a bit further, I am not sure if the first question makes a lot of sense either.
I would also note that the second question can make sense, but only if you believe consciousness is not strictly tied to the brain and body.
Why assume consciousness is necessarily linked and/or only a property of isolated individuals (vs a community, possibly multi-species)?
Do we define consciousness as awareness of 1 the general environment, 2 of the self as a distinct part of that environment, 3 of the (Freudian) ego as the self?
note that 2 & 3 especially make some pretty strong assumptions-- is it possible to separate something from environment (consider the impact of your microbiome), & for #3, is a person who has temporarily suspended ego (meditation, high-flow state, psychedelic drugs) conscious?
Former brain scientist speaking.
So, it seems I'm a brain mostly (or a nervous system?), or at least it seems it's my brain that is talking to you. The question is: are my feet conscious too?
What if it looks like I'm a brain because only the brain can talk?
Regarding the consciousness of multi-organisms: we are like a colony of many cells already! So it's possible that a group of humans may share consciousness somehow (but this seems different than my own, personal consciousness).
Likewise, we use our environment as an extension of our minds, or at least, spiders do[0]. Perhaps that's what the rest of our bodies is for our brain: just part of the environment.
I took a couple of neuroscience classes.
[0] https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg24532680-900-spiders-...
There are core parts of our understanding that would take a lot of counter evidence to really change. For example, evolution. It's as close to a fact as you can possibly get.
On the flip side, there is always fringe parts of science that we are actively generating new models and theories around.
The problem is distinguishing between the two. Yes, you are an idiot if you think the earth is flat. No, you aren't an idiot if you think that we don't have a full understanding of how the brain works.
Scientific "blasphemy" is making a claim with little evidence that runs counter to the current accepted and working models which have mountains of evidence behind them.
It's the "Let's rewrite the whole system" mentality whenever you encounter a small bug in the software. Scientific understanding is generally a bunch of small fixes and tweaks vs rewriting things ever few years.
So, yes evolution by several forms of selection is pretty well established but by no means do we fully understand how the natural world came to be as it is today. Which is nice if you ask me.
As you say, we are tweaking this theory.
I think some people confuse scientists with science teachers or science students. Scientists aren’t people who spend their time learning about what we already know, they are people trying to discover things we don’t know.
He won the Nobel prize, but was tremendously unhappy. For, with no more questions to answer, what was the purpose of living?
Fry then asked a question in his savant way: why is the unified theory what it is, instead of something else?
The professor then realized there was another question to ask, one that would take decades to answer, thousands of postgrads, and flaming dump trucks of grant money. He was happy again.
“And, now that I've found all the answers, I realise that what I was living for were the questions!”
(Futurama, Reincarnation, 2nd part)
Religions are specifically claiming that they know a fundamental truth about existence. Their core tenants are one of knowing a truth that doesn't have supporting evidence and cannot be falsified.
This has nothing to do with religious institutes and everything to do with a fundamental claim of the religious.
Reading your post here, I take it you believe the bible is from god or a higher authority. Do you ever question that belief?
Why are my personal beliefs relevant?
Buddhism, for one, would not only accept that someone but would say it loud and clear on its own.
When someone says "I don't believe in karma, rebirth, or the teachings of Buddha" are you talking about a Buddhist? What makes a Buddhist if not at least some belief in some of the Buddhist teachings and beliefs. (Granted, the notion of the "sacred" doesn't really exist in Buddhism like it does in abrahamic religions).
What? I'm a scientist, I often don’t know what’s going on! I see it more as my duty to help others understand that that is ok, and often even a good thing because that is when the fun starts. Science is a method, not a “state”. States are for religions, they “know” what’s going on because "it has been written!". Us scientists are always writing.