News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by cm2187 on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:05PM (#27427753)
That's not the price of batteries in general, that's the price of Li-Ion batteries. Were Li-Ion batteries mass produced in 1991?
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by UncleOxidant on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:30PM (#27428713)
We used a Lithium D cell in a prototype wireless product at a startup I worked at in 1989. The cells were pre-production samples. I forget the name of the company that was producing them now (I think it was a Japanese company - there were no logos on these batteries), but we were warned not to let them short out as they would go off like a 1/4 stick of dynamite. We were pretty careful with them, but we did have a unit come back from the field that had pretty much burned up, nothing but a charred circuit board left and most of the plastic enclosure melted away.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by catblast01 on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:42PM (#27430076)
Were these disposable lithium metal batteries or rechargeable lithium ion? They’re pretty different technologies. Both are prone to rapid discharge overheating problems though.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by hypnoscripto on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:02PM (#27429828)
How much better than the competition were they then? Did you understand why you were using such a dangerous alternative?
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:03PM (#27436949)
We needed long battery life - 3 years for a small 8051-based board with a data radio (kind of like wifi in 1989) that turned on every second or so. We created a power control ASIC that kept the 8051 off most of the time - it would wake up when data was available for processing. This was a proof of concept project for the military not a consumer item.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by nine_k on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:45PM (#27430096)
Weight, I suppose. And silver+zinc was likely still more expensive.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by neltnerb on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:19AM (#27430896)
I was never rich enough to own a laptop in that era, but I remember weight being the commonly espoused difference, or at least how it was marketed.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by azernik on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:44AM (#27431000)
This illustrates a big problem in econometrics, specifically inflation measurement ("price indexes"): when comparing the prices of equivalent (baskets of) goods and services, "equivalent" gets harder and harder to define over longer time and space intervals.

The classic example is light bulbs [1]. If you use naive comparisons of like goods across years, with weighting by percentage of expenditures, to measure consumer/producer price changes from e.g. 1890-1930, you'll see:

1. decreasing weight in the basket and increasing price of whale-oil lamps over time 2. increasing weight in the basket and decreasing cost of light bulbs over time

But what you won't capture is that these two goods are both providing lighting, and that the switch from one to another provides a sharp drop in the price of light that is not captured by the change in prices of either in isolation.

Here it's the opposite effect, in that looking at Li-Ion battery prices in isolation overestimates the deflationary effect on energy storage prices.

This problem has also popped up in the context of measuring US manufacturing output over time. Specifically, the correction factors used to deal with this are called "price deflators", and their inability to deal with the pricing and business model of computer hardware may have produced an incorrect impression that US manufacturing output is holding steady or increasing, when it's actually decreasing [2]

[1] "Classic" as in used to draw the attention of the field in this important 1998 paper: https://lucept.files.wordpress.com/2014/11/william-nordhaus-...

[2] https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&htt...

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by RobinL on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:51AM (#27431049)
'Overestimates' because at the start of the time series people were using cheaper alternatives to the very-expensive li-ion batteries.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by oblio on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:33AM (#27431926)
> But what you won't capture is that these two goods are both providing lighting, and that the switch from one to another provides a sharp drop in the price of light that is not captured by the change in prices of either in isolation.

I wonder if there was any way to compute light emitted per source. Then you could calculate a price per unit of light and whale-oil lamps would be obliterated by incandescent light builds which would in turn be obliterated by LED light bulbs.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by azernik on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:12AM (#27433550)
There is! That paper I linked does exactly that. It uses light to illustrate the point because it's particularly easy to calculate the comparative amount of utility per unit of cost regardless of technology, and show how it diverges from what naive price indices would show.

It's harder for something like batteries, where there are multiple relevant performance parameters to reduce to one utility heuristic. And good luck when the utility is subjective (clothes), still under study (food and nutrition), or ill-defined (media).

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by cbhl on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:44AM (#27431973)
Planet Money had an episode where they used the metric "minutes of light per day's wages". Here's the transcript: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/503769949

But there are qualitative changes that aren't captured by this -- street lights are brighter and whiter now than they were in the 1990s for example, and those were brighter than oil lamps before them.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by azernik on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:14AM (#27433562)
Note: that's a more accessible podcast/write-up of the paper I linked in my comment as [1]. If people want the denser in (in both good ways and bad) version, look up there.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by KorematsuFred on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:07PM (#27438716)
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by azernik on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:21PM (#27439610)
Yup! That's a condensed version of a BBC write-up of that first paper I linked. Super influential in the field, but only percolated into popular media in the last decade.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by HarryHirsch on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:57PM (#27428381)
They were not. In 1998, the second edition of Greenwood/Earnshaw's chemistry textbook came out, a magisterial survey of inorganic chemistry. They state that the major use for lithium is in lithium grease, but "looking to the future, Li/FeSx battery systems are emerging as a potentially viable energy storage system ... and a ... source of power for electric cars". The 1991 edition did not talk about batteries at all.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by sgerenser on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:42PM (#27430429)
I still remember the PowerBook 5300 series that was released around 1996 and had to be recalled due to reports of fires with their then cutting edge lithium batteries. Apple had to rerelease the product with NiMH batteries IIRC.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by elihu on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:29PM (#27428084)
The other commenter says that they were first introduced as a commercial product in 1991.

According to Wikipedia, they were preceded by two years by the first commercially-available nickel-metal hydride cells in 1989, so that would be an interesting point of comparison. Also nickel-cadmium and lead-acid have been around for a very long time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel%E2%80%93metal_hydride_b...

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by stormbrew on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:52PM (#27428327)
I remember a lot of stuff having NiMH for a long time throughout the 90s, seemed like it took LiIon a lot longer to catch on.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by taf2 on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:37PM (#27429678)
We raced electric RC cars in the 90s (really my dad and brother - I mostly just liked the smells and ideas). But I know my brother said to win they always had to have fresh as new batteries and as I recall they were NiMH
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by paulmd on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:10AM (#27436212)
Yes, performance of a battery declined over time, just as "battery health" declines on your phone today, for the same reasons. Mostly due to surface oxidation of the electrodes iirc.

Lithium-ion was never a good idea due to the fire hazard (in a crash they would just straight up explode, not even just cause a raging uncontrollable fire like LiPo, just boom) and Lithium-polymer could not support the necessary discharge rates (which I believe was also true of li-ion at the time too...). Early LiPo packs were only rated to like 0.5C or 1C peak discharge - this means, for a 2 amp-hour pack, 1C would be a discharge rate of 2 amps. Even then the packs did not really do well at their rated discharge rates - NiMH packs were far more tolerant of abuse in terms of discharge rates, in some cases you could push well beyond the rated spec and they would take it for a year or two's worth of sessions.

I was an "early adopter" on electric R/C airplanes back in the day (this would have been like 2000-2004) and the early stuff I used was mostly repurposed stuff from electric cars. The changeover to 4/5 or 2/3rds sub-C cells was a big deal at the time, the first "good" packs I owned were something called "HeCells" around 1800mAH or 2000 mAH, I also used KAN 1100mah cells. What I finally settled on at the time were these Sanyo "1950FAUP" cells which were extraordinary performers - we could push those cells to 70-80 amps peak discharge and they would take it. So in terms of the way LiPos are rated today[0], that is 40C discharge. This would only be doable for short periods, but it is necessary for launch and climbout (when the motor is running flat-out and the wing is basically stalled). Without the ability to sustain those currents it becomes very difficult to launch. Even still we did not "taxi" them like a normal airplane (or a normal model airplane), just wasn't enough power to get off the ground without a paved strip.

We typically expected about 10-15 minutes of flight time if you were flying normally, maybe 8-10 if you were really hotdogging it. So that means we averaged about 6C over the course of a flight (higher during climbout, less during cruising).

Another unsung miracle is how much motor technology has improved over the same period. My early motors were, again, repurposed brushed motors from Graupner's electric car lineup. We later moved onto some brushed Kyosho "magnetic mayhem" car motors that could push even higher levels of current. There was a Czech company called "Mega" who was an early mover on small neodymium brushless motors and that was a big deal at the time, they were far more powerful and far more efficient. Nowadays you don't even think about it, they're just a commodity, but at the time even a small brushless motor would run you about $130 or so!

[0] (tangent but it's kinda weird that NiCd and NiMH cells have traditionally been specced in amps but LiPo cells are specced in terms of "C discharge", obviously it's trivial to move between the two if you know the capacity of the pack but there's a definite difference in "style" of how the discharge rates are represented here...)

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by pixelpoet on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:16AM (#27430881)
Likewise, and I was quite perplexed as a kid why The Secret of Nimh had no mention of batteries.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by reportingsjr on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:12PM (#27427857)
The first commercial/mass produced lithium ion batteries came out in exactly 1991 as a matter of fact! They were used in a Sony camera.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by xkjkls on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:40PM (#27428200)
There's a graph there on market size, which shows the market size has grown 50,000x since 91.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by colechristensen on Monday June 07, 2021 @06:45PM (#27428246)
This is a sort of meaningless metric, you can adjust your time frame to make the market size arbitrarily small because it was 0 before 1991.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by gerdesj on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:44PM (#27429327)
Your parent specifically stated 1991 not "before 1991".

I think I understand what you mean but there was also a unfulfilled requirement before 1991. Back then (I'm 50.5 years old) cells didn't explode but then they also didn't set the world alight in terms of longevity either.

We had Walkmans and crappy clones that drained the shitty rechargeable cells we had at the time in a few hours. OK those things drove mechanical beasties - cassettes but cells/batteries were not particularly good before Li-Ion turned up.

Do you have any idea how something as simple as an iPod becomes exciting because no mechanical spinny things means power draw is much, much lower? It also helps if the thing isn't beige or grey. Apple are no more exciting to me than any other mob: design-wise, but they did get a few things right early on: "don't look shit". As it turns out, that simple mantra means that you get to >$1T t/o.

Now I own a phone that runs for around two days before charging. That doesn't sound too grand until you recall that just the GPS thing in it would have required 2U+ in a comms rack back in the day. The camera? If I kept an equivalent camera from the 1990s in my pocket then I'd be making silly jokes about it. The phone: I can stand on the top of Hay Torr and make a call.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by eric-hu on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:59PM (#27429807)
Initial iPods used spinning disks. Solid state was not a factor in early iPod success.

https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/iPod+Classic+Hard+Drive+Replace...

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by leucineleprec0n on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:11PM (#27429874)
It didn't really take off until flash and the colored assortment anyways tho
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by Marazan on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:04AM (#27431767)
They started taking off when you could load them from a windows machine.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by leucineleprec0n on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:47PM (#27498100)
Ah yeah, correct. Weren't the first ones using Firewire IO? Just classic levels of insular on Jobs' part

edit: maybe not, plausibly just charging

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by nickik on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:31PM (#27438232)
IPod with a 40G disk was the only Apple product I ever liked.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by colechristensen on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:55PM (#27430154)
Most of that seems true but orthogonal to my point, which is when comparing states of something with a power law growth, it is really easy to come up with big numbers that don’t contain any real information.

That 50,000x or whatever didn’t really give any information about the growth of a product over thirty years, it only really gives information about the growth during the first year which if it had been marginally different would give you a wildly different value for your “market growth today” number.

We should all be careful not to publish large numbers with dubious sources.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by Dylan16807 on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:33PM (#27430376)
> We had Walkmans and crappy clones that drained the shitty rechargeable cells we had at the time in a few hours. OK those things drove mechanical beasties - cassettes but cells/batteries were not particularly good before Li-Ion turned up.

NiMH came out around the same time and it's fine. A good one has similar energy to a good alkaline. Not very far behind a small-cell lithium ion either.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by dang on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:44AM (#27431665)
Ok, we've add lithium ions to the title now. Thanks!
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by bluedino on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:00PM (#27428411)
Yea, AA batteries have definitely not gotten cheaper
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by chrisseaton on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:38PM (#27428780)
AA is a form-factor, not a chemical technology. You can get lithium AA batteries. You probably mean alkaline cells have not gotten cheaper.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by NikolaNovak on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:48PM (#27428847)
I will second the notion that indeed AA batteries, whether Alkaline, Lithium, or Zinc Carbon, for purchase by consumer at a super-market checkout, have not gone cheaper recently.

I will even venture that consumer lithium-ion batteries, such as for camera or laptop replacements, do not appear to have gone cheaper over last, say, decade. I can only assume healthy profit margin by brands (Nikon/Sony/Canon/etc, Lenovo/Sony/Dell/etc). Third party cheaper batteries are available, of dubious quality, so I suppose that may be a sign of cheaper manufacturing...

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by simcop2387 on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:25PM (#27430330)
I'm not quite so sure about that. The prices have remained relatively stable, but the capacities have gone up. I think on a per Wh basis they may have actually gotten cheaper still. That means that you've gotten more battery life and/or more useful power in the devices that are using the batteries.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by mkr-hn on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:02PM (#27429442)
Ni-Mh still seems to be the go-to for rechargeable AAs. I rotate four Ni-Mh Eneloops out in my wireless mouse.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by sgerenser on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:47PM (#27430455)
NiMH has the advantage of having very similar voltage to alkaline. Lithium ion AA batteries wouldn’t work as direct replacements in a product designed to be powered by alkaline batteries.
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by usrusr on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:36PM (#27429243)
And it's an excellent example. Technology gets better until efficiencies are maxed out and battery cell production can't be an exception. The only big outlier has been computer chips, where slowly shrinking cost per square mm (if it even sank?) was an insignificant footnote compared to the ever increasing ability to pack in more per unit of surface area. Lithium batteries have far more in common with alkaline batteries than with transistors for logical operations.

Power transistors for example I would also consider closer to alkaline cells than to logic, there has surely been a lot of progress in that field which eventually brought us the miracles of HVDC, but on a far more conventional scale.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by jandrese on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:00PM (#27437763)
Most technology follows an S curve. It starts out slow with initial experimentation until most of the dead ends and pitfalls are eliminated, then there is a period of rapid growth as the tech matures and gains mass market acceptance, then it levels off with all of the easy gains mined out and you see only incremental improvements moving forward.

The middle part of the S curve is when you see the dumbest articles about the technology, with people extrapolating the growth linearly and talking about how it will rule the world in a few years.

Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by ajsnigrutin on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:29PM (#27429629)
Yep, mobile phone batteries haven't either (just the battery, without the expensive replacement fee, because manufacturers are too greedy to make user replacable batteries).
Re:The price of lithium-ion batteries has declined by 97% in... by sschueller on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:58AM (#27431737)
Why are they so expensive? In particular Energizer and Duracell? Is there a recycling fee included in there or is Energizer and Duracell just gauging the public and not doing anything regarding recycling?