News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by midnightclubbed on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:38PM (#27269422)
More importantly that bar ends is the comment "Today, you have a higher chance of seeing a bell on a modern mountain bike than a set of bar ends"... If there is one thing every MTB rider should have on their bike it is a bell. With trail usage way up having a bell is not just a curtesy to other bikers/hikers but an important safety feature. Big fan of the Timber bell, but anything that lets other trail user know you are approaching works just fine.

And anyone who is out on the trails with headphones... you still won't hear a bike bell, but then you won't hear a rattle-snake either.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by yarcob on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:01PM (#27269648)
I definitely prefer a bicycle bell to getting yelled at from behind.

But you know what would be even nicer? If bikers had the curtesy to slow down a bit when the trail / path is crowded.

I also love riding fast. I understand that crowded paths are annoying. But when I see that the path is full of people, I don't start ringing my bell, or hollering "on your left" or "attention" at the people in front of me, I just slow down. There is no curteous way to pass someone with delta V of 15km/h on a narrow path.

If I want to ride fast, I pick a time when the paths aren't crowded. I don't understand why everyone wants to race their bikes on multi use paths on a sunny afternoon at 3PM when everyone else is outside too.

Try riding eg. Saturday at 7AM and you'll have the world to yourself and you can go as fast as you like.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by dahart on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:36PM (#27270011)
Most people seem to be curteous already where I ride. There are always a few people giving us all a bad name, but I'm seeing growing awareness of good behavior, and of better signage, at the same time that crowds are increasing. Good to keep in mind that crowds are growing and MTB popularity is growing, because it means that good behavior may be on the rise faster than it seems unless you pay attention to and notice how many people aren't being pushy.

That said, I have an always-on bell that rings as I ride over bumps. I like it for multiple reasons - for one bikers hear me coming for a long time, and know that I'm not going agro right behind them. For two, hikers and dog-walkers appreciate hearing it from far away, and often thank me for it.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by midnightclubbed on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:59PM (#27270180)
The bell I recommended isn't one you ring - it's like a cowbell that rings constantly (while you are moving) and lets people know you are coming before they can see you. Basic trail etiquette.

I have nothing against hikers (would be hypocritical as someone who trail-runs) and blasting past people on a crowded path (or at all) is an idiot move. But on a single track trail people can come up on you really quick, 10km/h is a brisk jog so a 15km/h (4m/s) delta V isn't exactly fast.

My local trails are way quieter at 3pm (most people are in work and temperatures are still hot) than at 7am (pre-work dog walkers and exercisers). Saturday 7AM is literally the worse time in SoCal - big groups of riders and local running clubs all hit the trails Saturday morning. Guess it is varies by region but no matter the time I'd want to give other trail users the maximum oppertunity to know I was there so we can all be safe.

For the record I don't want to ride my bike fast on multi-use paths at any time of the day, not sure why you thought I did. If I ride fast it is on bike focussed routes (accessed via the multi-use trails).

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by tester89 on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:00PM (#27270196)
> it's like a cowbell that rings constantly (while you are moving)

This is horrific, so much unnecessary noise pollution.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by realbarack on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:11PM (#27270301)
It's really not. These bells aren't that loud, you really only hear them once the cyclist is maybe 50 yards away. It's an incredibly important safety feature on low-visibility singletracks.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by haspok on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:19AM (#27274686)
I have a loud rear hub instead... mostly works just as fine. But if not, I'm also very patient in passing hikers, once I spent like 10 minutes behind two hikers on a singletrack before they realised I was behind them, because they were discussing something very intensively... but this is fine, in the meantime I can rest a bit, adjust my gear, eat and drink something etc. I always try to smile and thank people for letting me pass by.

The only - very few - occasions when this tactic did not work were usually hikers coming in the opposite direction and being actively hostile. There was an angry lady once who refused to move even an inch to the right, so I had to move to her left, which was a large field of nettle... To this day I don't know what her problem was, but this happens sometimes.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by dahart on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:08AM (#27276936)
Maybe she’d had a run in with a pushy bike, or just got really scared? So what happened, did you step into the nettle, or did you stop and wait, or have a conversation with her and point out the nettle, or turn around and walk back a bit?

Or maybe the question is: in retrospect do you have any wishes or regrets about how you handled it? Did you think of anything you should have done differently to defuse the situation? Do you have any strategies for avoiding or resolving the rare but possible next hostile confrontation?

Multiple times in the past I have goofed and reacted to someone’s aggression with return fire, and I don’t think it’s ever made anything better, usually it’s worse. I would like to have some prepared strategies in my mind for handling it smoothly.

Hikers and animals (dogs and horses) have right of way over bikes at all times on the trails I ride, is that true for you too? I’ve bumped into an angry hiker or two also, but on the whole they’re almost always super friendly and contentious. For me it’s more common than not that hikers are apologizing and getting off the trail before I even have a chance to yield, sometimes so much so that I feel bad about it. Anyway, I think we should take stock of all the nice hikers and lucky interactions, because it’s perfectly okay and reasonable for a hiker on a shared trail to not expect to yield. It’s definitely unkind if they refuse to make any room to pass, you do sound very patient, and the angry hiker experience totally sucks - triply if you got nettle all over. But at the same time, if we as bikers aren’t yielding first as much as we can, it’ll only get less fun for everyone and we can lose trails, right?

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by midnightclubbed on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:12PM (#27270302)
It's not that bad at all, and stops when you are not moving. I'd say it has maybe a 20m range so it's not like people can hear you from the other side of the mountain.

I do agree it adds noise to (potentially) tranquil trails but imho its a good safety trade-off. Way better than people who insist on blasting music from their phone speakers or conference call while walking.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by tyrust on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:53PM (#27272429)
Thanks for using a bell, I really appreciate it as a hiker!

I feel like any naysayer hasn't actually been out on the trails much or haven't run into a bike while doing so.

>music from phone speakers

Now those are unjustifiable noise.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by Alupis on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:36PM (#27270980)
It doesn't just let the two-legged critters know you're coming down the trail.

A bell that clangs as you walk is also common for back-country hikers to keep bears and others away too.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by ar_turnbull on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:44AM (#27273121)
Bear bells are not effective in any way and in fact may attract curious bears. Bears do not know that the sound of a bell means humans. In fact, in Canada where grizzlies are a concern Parks officers recommend against bells. The best deterrent is your voice.

https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/parks-canada-officials-endorse-th...

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by Alupis on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:33PM (#27278972)
The point of the bell is to prevent you from startling an unsuspecting bear or mountain lion, which often will put them on the (aggressive) defensive. Not good if you come around a bend and find yourself 10 feet from a bear that was previously minding it's own business.

> The flaw with bear bells is their sound means little to a bear. “They just don’t make enough noise and they don’t make a bear aware that you’re human. A little tinkling noise doesn’t necessarily tell a bear that there’s a person nearby.”

> To prevent a negative encounter with a bear, Stuart-Smith recommends:

> Making noise when travelling on a trail

This advice contradicts itself. Bells make noise, and are louder and carry further than a human voice at normal conversation levels. I've never heard a serious hiker/backpacker warn against a bell... and the bear spray this guy recommends using only works when the bear is within 10-15 feet of you, and hopefully not startled into an attack. Bears can run a lot faster than you, and can climb a lot better than you. It's really best to avoid that situation entirely.

The advice of singing loudly, or yelling your name is unrealistic. Nobody that's hiking in backcountry will be able to sustain that for long, it's exhausting, particularly on all-day or multi-day hikes.

I do agree, the small bear bells often sold at REI are not the best though, the cowbell type OP mentioned is far superior.

Rarely do bears and other wild animals go out of their way to interact with humans... the bell just lets them know something is coming so they aren't startled by your sudden presence.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lovemenot on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:01AM (#27273261)
This advice may be good for some bear species / locations, but certainly not for all.

In Japan, hikers are advised to use bells and many do. People here have been using these trails for hundreds of years. They know what they are doing.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:43PM (#27271461)
Until they learn to think 'The Ice/Meatman cometh!'
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by LargoLasskhyfv on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:20AM (#27277987)
I INSIST on my interpretation of signaling "Meals on wheels" to them.

Because 'Life finds a way.'

BASTA!

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by callalex on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:21AM (#27272572)
This is such a non-existent concern compared to a startled animal lashing out. People have been in the wilderness for a reeeeeeaaaaaaaaallly long time. Take their advice.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by PascLeRasc on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:50PM (#27270608)
Agreed, just use a loud hub. It’ll let people know when you’re flying down DH trails and be silent for climbs when you can see people and slow down in time. I can’t even think about what the cowbell must sound like when it’s up on your roof rack.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by dahart on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:31PM (#27270956)
> I can’t even think about what the cowbell must sound like when it’s up on your roof rack.

Hahaha. These comments are funny. It's not a cowbell, that was just an analogy. It's a bike bell with an off switch.

https://www.google.com/search?q=timber+bell

It's not "noise pollution" in any meaningful sense, except to the rider while it's on. :) But it is a good safety measure and is kind to other people on the trail.

A loud hub isn't a particularly good replacement for me since I'm running into other riders and hikers just as often while pedaling as while free-wheeling or downhilling. Maybe even less often downhilling since we're getting more and more one-way trails these days. I even watched my friend who has a loud hub have a slow mostly harmless head-on with a climber coming around a blind corner last season. Climber got angry but hadn't made any attempt to be noticed whatsoever, it would have been completely avoided had he made any noise, like, you know, had a bell...

My positive experience with it is very similar to what this guy describes, multiple people on the trail thanking me for using a bell. I've never once had a complaint about the noise, but occasionally I want it quieter for me. And I also found his 'secret' trick for keeping it slightly quieter, in addition to aiming it downward. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tD63c5pgHcU

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by osigurdson on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:44AM (#27273129)
I've often wondered how a loud hub would compare to bear bells in terms of alerting wildlife of your presence. I definitely prefer the sound of SRAM or Chris King hubs to bear bells.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by mig39 on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:45PM (#27272387)
For some of us in Northern Canada, this is how we alert bears that we're approaching. Even when not biking, we use "bear bells" that make constant noise.

You don't want to sneak up on a bear.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by ar_turnbull on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:44AM (#27273133)
Please do not use bells, they are not an effective deterrent to bears and they annoy the hikers around you. https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/parks-canada-officials-endorse-th...
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lovemenot on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:07AM (#27273306)
Please don't be so emphatic. You seem to have only part of the whole picture wrt to bears.

And many hikers use them too. The ones I encounter are no louder than a dog-collar.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by dahart on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:03PM (#27295394)
That article is specific to bears (and not dogs or people), it doesn't say anything about bells being annoying, and it seems to contradict you by recommending that people should be "Making noise when travelling on a trail".
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by GuB-42 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:24PM (#27271314)
Cowbells in a mountain don't seem out of place. As a matter of fact, we need more of them.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by kybernetyk on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:54PM (#27272436)
In my experience the tires of my bike rolling on the ground tend to be louder than those cow bell things.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by callalex on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:25AM (#27272584)
Distant rustling, while noticeable by human hearing, is not instantly prioritized with the speed required to dodge bikes on a single-track compared to a ringing bell that engages human brains as soon as the sound is perceivable.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by sethammons on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:52PM (#27272420)
I use it to ward off predators - noise pollution is a feature :)
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by pa7ch on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:07AM (#27272776)
Agreed, all riders should be able to stop before their event horizon. So if you can't whip blind corners on crowded paths if you would hit someone who is a the worst spot on the turn.

I ride a lot of bike paths. I don't like hollering or ringing. I just slow down and let people hear my hub if need be. They can take their time.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by comprev on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:25AM (#27273444)
A Hope Tech, Industry Nine or Chris King hub is plenty loud enough!
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by datavirtue on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:20AM (#27276431)
Well said. I don't use a bell but I have developed a deep, unalarming: "on your left" that travels well ahead of me. I also try to slow to just about pedestrian speed and create maximum distance when passing.

A lot of my fellow cyclists (all of them kitted to the nines) thread the needle at 20mph. It's bullshit.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by kybernetyk on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:50PM (#27272408)
> If bikers had the curtesy to slow down a bit when the trail / path is crowded.

Where I live we have a wonderful bike/pedestrian path which is heavily frequented whenever there's good weather. The worst offenders are racing bike drivers. Well at least those who like to LARP as such. (50yo, wearing cloth like they would be competing in the Tour de France).

They don't have bells on their bikes because "aerodynamics" (my guess) and they drive like absolute madmen down the path (they compete on Strava).

I myself got yelled at several times which I usually shrug off or tell them to f** off. But what gets my blood boiling is when those people go out on a Sunday when there's sunny weather and start their BS on a crowded path.

The path is frequented by families on weekends and I have seen multiple times how those 40yo/50yo "gentlemen" yell at little children because the kids have the audacity to have fun with their little bikies and thus ruin the racer's Strava times.

Our local mountain biking (we're not really mountain terrain yet we still have some single trails) community is completely different. They're nice, they always make room when you meet them in the woods. No problems there.

/rant

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by brippalcharrid on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:14AM (#27273822)
This is why it's important that Road Cycling takes place on roads; shared-use paths are designed for everything from small children frolicking about in the sunlight to large slow-moving bicycles and big groups of hikers, whereas road bikes are designed for cruising at >20mph and large turn radii. They are vehicles, and are designed for use on roads in the presence of other vehicles.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by akadruid1 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:21AM (#27273401)
There's something about that hobby. I suspect having "all the gear and no idea" is expensive and somehow they feel entitled. We have a steep winding road near us which is full of blind spots. On a sunny weekend you're guaranteed to encounter a line of cars unable to overtake a 50yo man on foot slowly pushing a expensive carbon frame bicycle up the hill. I live in a very car-central part of the world, I suspect if we had actual cycle infrastructure the hobbyists would be diluted by people actually going somewhere on bikes.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by pharmakom on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:38AM (#27273564)
This 1000x. The types of rider you get are a reflection of the infrastructure you have. Mostly busy roads? Aggressive ,fast male riders. Quiet, physically separated bike lanes? Families, children going to school, cargo bikes...
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by pjmlp on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:09AM (#27273323)
No need for mountain bikes for that, you see that behaviour everywhere here in Germany.

It is like some bikers forget they have breaks on their devices, instead just yell and curse the other people on the sidewalk that happen to be on the bycicle lane for whatever reason, after all it is just a different colour on the sidewalk.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by sva_ on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:44PM (#27270069)
Yeah, the comment about bells struck out to me as well. I didn't have one on my MTB in the beginning, but it just felt so stupid to yell 'sorry' at people. I don't see what's the reason, saving a few grams of weight? While riding recreationally? Makes no sense. First I got one of those minimalist designs that blend in with the handlebar, but it didn't work too well. So I just got a huge one, in black color like the handlebar, which is very loud. Sometimes people get scared for a moment but it's much better than them jumping as you ride by them silently. And I don't think it looks bad at all.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by pedalpete on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:00PM (#27270681)
Why yell "sorry" instead of "hi there", or something as you come up to them.

I'm Canadian, and as the saying goes "we say sorry 50 times a day, and we're sorry we can't say it more", but still...I don't understand why you're apologizing rather than giving warning, and is ringing a bell really any better in this instance?

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by kybernetyk on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:57PM (#27272451)
>Why yell "sorry" instead of "hi there"

The local racing biker etiquette here seems to be yelling "AUS DEM WEG" (make way) in a very rude tone. "Hi there" or even "sorry" would be a definitive improvement over what we have now. ;)

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by notatoad on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:27PM (#27270910)
Instead of yelling "sorry" at people, I try to stick with "on your left", "on your right", or most importantly "can I pass you when the trail widens out". All of which are safer and friendlier than the vauge "move-outta-my-way" signal a bell sends.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by chrisseaton on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:48PM (#27271489)
> "on your left", "on your right"

I wouldn’t know what these were supposed to mean!

Are you telling me that you’re going to pass on my left or are you telling me to move onto my left? How do you expect people to know?

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by djitz on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:17PM (#27271665)
If you hike any sort of trail where you will come across bikes, you’ll quickly get that it means they will pass on the side they mention.

They should say it when you have a bit of time to take a look and assess, but there are some who say it a couple of feet behind you

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by butwhywhyoh on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:30PM (#27271724)
Maybe you aren't a native english speaker, but have you ever heard someone ask you to move over by saying a phrase even remotely like "on your left" ?

If something is "on your left" <side>, I'd hope it should be easy to realize that you should either move to the right, or be aware of someone passing "on your left".

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by chrisseaton on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:35AM (#27275176)
> Maybe you aren't a native English speaker

Lol I'm English.

> If something is "on your left" <side>, I'd hope it should be easy to realize that you should either move to the right

But it could just as likely mean 'please step off the path on your left so I can pass by your right side'.

People make up these conventions and then assume everyone else knows them!

Ideally I'd say don't cycle where people are walking in the first place!

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by iamacyborg on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:19AM (#27273386)
I’m a native speaker and I still get confused if folks shout it at me without giving me more than a second to think about it.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by stephencanon on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:42AM (#27275628)
Those are the idiomatic phrases for cross-country skiing, biking, trail running, and pretty much every other sport where a slower competitor is required to yield the trail in North America. It’s a pretty reasonable expectation that trail users would be familiar with them.

(The main alternative used in competition is “track track track!” which is distinctly less helpful.)

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by chrisseaton on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:43AM (#27275640)
Many 'trail users' are just normal people out for a walk, not part of any competitive sport. You can't assume people know your lingo.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by stephencanon on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:54PM (#27279257)
It’s not about assuming other people know your lingo, it’s about it being the most widely understood phrase with the desired meaning; there isn’t something else you would say that’s more clear to more people.

You should not assume that the other person will understand it and act immediately, but it’s absolutely the correct thing to say in this scenario. You just also need to slow down to be able to respond if they don’t.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by chrisseaton on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:14PM (#27279512)
> there isn’t something else you would say that’s more clear to more people

How about 'I'm passing you on your left'?

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by sva_ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:02AM (#27273764)
I had people express appreciation about having a loud and clear bell, over some unclear yelling from behind. Maybe it's a cultural thing.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by midnightclubbed on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:05PM (#27270236)
I think there may be a thought a bell isn't cool enough for mtb bro's? Or maybe it's just that they aren't fitted to mountain bikes as standard (they should be) and so people don't think to pick one up.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by puchatek on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:28AM (#27272973)
Obviously not cool enough! Same thing with racing bikes. All that gorgeous gear and Lycra and then you're supposed to announce yourself to the slow masses with that ridiculous sound!? No way!
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by Humphrey on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:10AM (#27272511)
Perhaps there is a place for a bell on shared use trails... but I don't see the need for them on dedicated MTB trails. Riding a bike is loud, so you usually hear somebody smashing down a track faster than you are going. I'll usually say something like "there you go" when the trail straightens/widens to indicate they should pass me.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by ajuc on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:22AM (#27273405)
Wait, can you drive a bike without a bell at public roads in your countries? It's illegal here (and for a good reason) so you won't find a bike without a bell (or lights for that matter).
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by Ichthypresbyter on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:18AM (#27275933)
In the UK bikes are required to be sold with a bell, but there is no requirement to have one when riding. So bikes are often sold with the cheapest bell the manufacturer can find, which the rider will remove when it inevitably breaks if not before.

Oddly, here in the Netherlands the reverse seems to be true- it is illegal to ride a bike without a bell on public roads, but bikes are often sold without them...

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by sundvor on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:22AM (#27273880)
Spurcycle bells on both my MTBs. They are great, sound nice and clear -and certainly not too offensive, and are just easy to use whilst looking awesome.

So sad to see their design being ripped off by copycats.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:45AM (#27272676)
A bell is pointless unless you have some difficulty speaking. People pay much more attention to a verbal hello or warning than a bell.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by MarkusWandel on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:46AM (#27277492)
As someone who uses both verbal alerts e.g. "passing on your left!" and bell dings, I've found that the human brain is quicker to process the "ding" than the verbal cue. At the relative speed of pedestrian vs. cyclist this matters. I think it's simply that "ding ding" is a standard alert with a preprogrammed response, whereas spoken stuff needs to be interpreted first.

My personal optimization is also to not make noise at all, if I can clearly and safely pass without warning i.e. the pedestrian is not moving erratically and there are no small children. On rare occasion this elicits anger from (usually elderly) pedestrians though.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:42AM (#27286812)
> As someone who uses both verbal alerts e.g. "passing on your left!" and bell dings, I've found that the human brain is quicker to process the "ding" than the verbal cue. At the relative speed of pedestrian vs. cyclist this matters. I think it's simply that "ding ding" is a standard alert with a preprogrammed response, whereas spoken stuff needs to be interpreted first.

For some humans, sure. The trouble is that maybe 1/3 of people simply won't process the "ding" at all, which makes it so unreliable as to be useless in practice, IME. (You can ring repeatedly and people eventually notice, but overall that's less effective than saying something).

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by MarkusWandel on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:07PM (#27293179)
It's the headphones. 100% of the time if I call out or ring the bell and get no reaction, it's because they've got earbuds in. That's OK if at least they're behaving themselves. People who walk onto a busy bike path without looking and with earplugs in are the real menace.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:20PM (#27298256)
Not my experience. A decent chunk of non-headphone people ignore a bell too.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by CogitoCogito on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:46AM (#27274474)
It's pretty obviously not pointless. This helps with blind turns for example. It also can be heard earlier than a biker's speech (assuming the biker doesn't continually give verbal warnings for 15 seconds as is true for basically all bikers on earth).
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:45AM (#27286822)
> This helps with blind turns for example.

How so? You can say something in the same scenario where you'd ring the bell.

> It also can be heard earlier than a biker's speech (assuming the biker doesn't continually give verbal warnings for 15 seconds as is true for basically all bikers on earth).

I don't quite understand the point you're making here - most bikers don't continually ring a bell for 15 seconds except if a pedestrian is obviously not paying attention, and speech is more effective in that case. Maybe a bell is louder than typical speech, but since it's not acted on reliably by pedestrians, that doesn't help much - you always have to be prepared for the worst case.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by swader999 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:52PM (#27271509)
I prefer the Air Zound. It's like a train horn. Cars notice it.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by scottlamb on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:40PM (#27272367)
What a strange non sequitur. I've never said "I don't need a bell because I have an Air Zound" or vice versa. There's no overlap in when I'd use them.

The Air Zound isn't a polite way of telling a pedestrian or cyclist you're passing them. It's more like yelling "move over, jackass!" I can count on one hand the number of times I've used mine on a trail—only when folks were (perhaps deliberately) unaware of more subtle attempts at communication and blocking me from passing and/or doing something reckless. In the few cases I did use it on a trail, people involuntarily jumped in response.

On the other hand, the Air Zound is a way of telling cars "I'm here" / "be careful" / "don't do the stupid thing I see in your eyes". I use it in that way almost daily. (Maybe as much a commentary on the drivers around here as anything else.) A bell just wouldn't work for that at all. They really wouldn't physically hear it.

(I'm a road cyclist and the trails I ride are paved urban creek trails rather than mountain bike tracks, but I think the etiquette is similar.)