News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:45AM (#27272676)
A bell is pointless unless you have some difficulty speaking. People pay much more attention to a verbal hello or warning than a bell.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by MarkusWandel on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:46AM (#27277492)
As someone who uses both verbal alerts e.g. "passing on your left!" and bell dings, I've found that the human brain is quicker to process the "ding" than the verbal cue. At the relative speed of pedestrian vs. cyclist this matters. I think it's simply that "ding ding" is a standard alert with a preprogrammed response, whereas spoken stuff needs to be interpreted first.

My personal optimization is also to not make noise at all, if I can clearly and safely pass without warning i.e. the pedestrian is not moving erratically and there are no small children. On rare occasion this elicits anger from (usually elderly) pedestrians though.

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:42AM (#27286812)
> As someone who uses both verbal alerts e.g. "passing on your left!" and bell dings, I've found that the human brain is quicker to process the "ding" than the verbal cue. At the relative speed of pedestrian vs. cyclist this matters. I think it's simply that "ding ding" is a standard alert with a preprogrammed response, whereas spoken stuff needs to be interpreted first.

For some humans, sure. The trouble is that maybe 1/3 of people simply won't process the "ding" at all, which makes it so unreliable as to be useless in practice, IME. (You can ring repeatedly and people eventually notice, but overall that's less effective than saying something).

Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by MarkusWandel on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:07PM (#27293179)
It's the headphones. 100% of the time if I call out or ring the bell and get no reaction, it's because they've got earbuds in. That's OK if at least they're behaving themselves. People who walk onto a busy bike path without looking and with earplugs in are the real menace.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:20PM (#27298256)
Not my experience. A decent chunk of non-headphone people ignore a bell too.
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by CogitoCogito on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:46AM (#27274474)
It's pretty obviously not pointless. This helps with blind turns for example. It also can be heard earlier than a biker's speech (assuming the biker doesn't continually give verbal warnings for 15 seconds as is true for basically all bikers on earth).
Re:Why did bar ends go away from mountain bikes? by lmm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:45AM (#27286822)
> This helps with blind turns for example.

How so? You can say something in the same scenario where you'd ring the bell.

> It also can be heard earlier than a biker's speech (assuming the biker doesn't continually give verbal warnings for 15 seconds as is true for basically all bikers on earth).

I don't quite understand the point you're making here - most bikers don't continually ring a bell for 15 seconds except if a pedestrian is obviously not paying attention, and speech is more effective in that case. Maybe a bell is louder than typical speech, but since it's not acted on reliably by pedestrians, that doesn't help much - you always have to be prepared for the worst case.