News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by motohagiography on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:01AM (#26942571)
Given where ML and CV are today, I'd bet on open source models trained on weeds within 3-5 years. This company can scale, but their unit price is going to plummet. Also, it sounds like they're using cameras, where it's concievable that other future sensors could be more efficient. An iteration of this with higher resolution cameras and small flying drones seems like an intuitive next step.

This is a super interesting problem because the confusion matrix (fp/fn/tp/tn) rate that makes this economical is going to be variable across both crops, and market demand.

If there suddenly there was a demand jump for peas, you could afford to use a model with less accuracy, because you are optimizing betwee a sunk labor cost and margin on your yield. You could literally tune your detection parameters based on futures price data, since if if prices were high, you could optimize compute on your model. Anyway, spoken as a total outsider, but what a cool and interesting set of problems.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by piyh on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:19AM (#26942754)
Drones do not seem like a logical step for me. I'm not a laser expert, but seems like the energy storage needed to kill hundreds to thousands of something with light is heavier than flying would realistically allow. Wheels and tracks are what farming is built around, no need to literally reinvent the wheel here.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by eloff on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:28PM (#26944445)
Drones also have poor flight time to recharging time ratio. Which means you need more of them to get the job done.

Farms are designed to be serviced by farm vehicles. A vehicle makes a lot of sense.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by cwkoss on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:32PM (#26945321)
If they were able to make drones work, it could open up more variable farm designs: rows are mostly necessary so that farms can be serviced by vehicles.

Polyculture farming could become much more economically feasible if drones could weed out all non-whitelisted species.

Would also be a great boon to forestry: would be awesome to make a bunch of drones to fly through forests and zap any non-native invasive species it sees.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Arnavion on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:42PM (#26945460)
>If they were able to make drones work, it could open up more variable farm designs: rows are mostly necessary so that farms can be serviced by vehicles.

Sure, but the weedkiller isn't the only vehicle that needs to work on the farm. I don't think flying drones are going to be ploughing any time soon.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by visarga on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:09AM (#26954012)
> If they were able to make drones work

Yes, let's put powerful lasers on drones flown by AI. What could happen? I just hope the human recognition model doesn't shoot more of one race than another.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by red75prime on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:41PM (#26949743)
> zap any non-native invasive species it sees

Given the climate change it could be the other way around. Zap some native saplings, which can no longer thrive.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by shostack on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:05AM (#26951889)
I'll bet there's creative solutions that could take advantage of a hub and spoke model. Picture a solar recharging base station that drones can dock with to charge while others rotate in.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by bri3d on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:42PM (#26945466)
Drones don't need to be battery operated - but, I agree that there is no reason to use them in fields which are already designed for vehicle access with semi-standardized dimensions.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by eloff on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:55PM (#26945638)
If they're fuel powered drones, they need to refuel. Plus that's potentially expensive to operate depending how many you need and how heavy they are.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by GauntletWizard on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:04PM (#26948857)
There's probably something to be said for hard-wired drones here. The weight of the cable is something you have to contend with, but with a physical wire you can run a larger drone longer.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by eloff on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:50PM (#26949311)
How is that better than a wheeled drone dragging a giant orange extension cord behind it?

I'm not sure that's a great idea either, but flying brings more problems than it solves in this problem space.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by GauntletWizard on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:31PM (#26950706)
Given that the plants are on the ground, I imagine not sweeping over them with an extension cable would be an obvious advantage. Still, you could work with suspended powerlines as easily for the big-box drone as with tractors, which brings me to another (probably dumb) question: Why has nobody built a landline electric tractor?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ravel-bar-foo on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:31PM (#26951673)
Farmers sweep things along the field all the time. The standard farming sprinkler is supplied by pipes / hoses which are bridged above crop height between wheeled towers. As the spinkler works its way in a circle on the field around the water supply, the towers roll over a negligible amount of crop.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by drdaeman on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:32PM (#26951675)
> landline electric tractor

Well, there are some robots that travel on aerial lines, typically used for cable inspection. Here's a quick search result: https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/industrial-robo...

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Gustomaximus on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:00PM (#26949910)
For vehicles, crops yes, animal husbandry often roads get you to parts of a property but are far from covering a property.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by mycall on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:09PM (#26951052)
Helium assisted drones could provide longer air time.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by CRConrad on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:06AM (#26966936)
Hydrogen. Even lighter, much cheaper, and would save on a (very!) finite natural resource.

And, hey, with unmanned drones over rural fields you won't get any Hindenburg disasters.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by arrosenberg on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#26946429)
Maybe very small drones with mirrors and cameras and a ground-based robotic tank with a laser cannon.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by m463 on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:57PM (#26948025)
Or it could just fly upside down. maybe add wheels to set cutting height :)
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by dylan604 on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:39PM (#26948540)
The scene from Spies Like Us always comes to mind when bouncing lasers around. Or the Real Genius as well. So you better be careful using this around corn fields, or we know what can happen.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by jadbox on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:06PM (#26947382)
I love the image of this in my head, but I can imagine in practice that many farms are not on flat terrain where there's direct line of sight [fire] for a central station to flash a lazer pulse. Perhaps if you had many smaller stations with these laser cannons spread about the field and each cannon would coordinate with the drone in the closest line of sight.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by a1369209993 on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:41PM (#26951323)
Pretty sure they're explicitly suggesting indirect fire, actually. Base station fires at mirror, and drone uses mirror to reflect laser to target. There might be stability problems, angle-at-which-it-hits-the-weed problems, and more-laser-scattering-due-to-longer-beam-path problems, but line of sight itself should be fine since the drone is up in the air.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by extropy on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:53PM (#26948713)
Heat-ray welding Tripods.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ping_pong on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:44PM (#26947099)
This is an incredibly great idea.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by hawski on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:08PM (#26947406)
Indeed a good idea, but I would only hope it would have a reliable fail-safe, becaue it would be a little reverse GoldenEye.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by pragmaticpandy on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:50PM (#26950345)
Spoken like a true software engineer.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by esrh on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:25AM (#26942828)
To me that message implied weed recognition and marking with drones followed by destruction with the cube.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Igelau on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:06PM (#26944994)
Ah, the classic "Death Cube and Tracker Drone" design pattern. DCTD for short.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by hu3 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:06PM (#26944128)
That's my understanding too but what about precision?

Both the drone and the ground robot would need milimiter precision geolocation to coordinate otherwise the laser can miss the weed.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by birdman3131 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:43PM (#26944664)
No they don't. They need fairly coarse tracking (A few feet or so.) for geolocation as that is only to make sure you end up covering the whole field.

Now for individual weeds you need precise aiming but that's only from a few feet away at max.

The overall geo location boils down to being able to track a row as you go down it and then go to the next row at the other end. The lasers don't care about the geo location at all.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by sgtnoodle on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:58PM (#26948035)
Unless you have a precise map of all the weed locations, precise location in absolute world coordinates doesn't seem too important. You'd need fairly precise and accurate relative positioning from tank to drone and drone to weed, though. Drone to weed could be done via camera (you need to detect the weed anyway), but tank to drone would likely be a difficult engineering problem.

A flying drone seems like the wrong way to solve the problem, though. For a drone close enough to the ground to reliably detect weeds, you'd likely need a multi-rotor, a slow flying fixed wing aircraft, or a blimp. A multirotor has a huge energy penalty, and a fixed wing aircraft or blimp loses the practical gains vs. just using a tractor of some sort.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by abakker on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:09PM (#26945039)
RTK GPS has +/- 3cm Lat/long precision. That gets you very close, and then with a confirming camera, you could aim and fire.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by samatman on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:43PM (#26949250)
Completely agree about flying: but I wonder about the wheel.

A spider-carriage walking robot which could step around the valuable plants, climb steeper hills, and wouldn't dictate a row-and-plow approach to agriculture, that could be pretty compelling. Less soil compaction, more flexibility, could work inside forested regions as well. It has potential.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:00PM (#26949911)
IMO; I think setting up lightweight aluminum rails, and run a framework of multi-purpose bots along that. Since the technology is getting lighter and lighter, it seems you could even do this and use LESS material than these gargantuan tractor/harvester/combine units. It may not even be necessary to plough fields anymore, when a smaller automated unit could just operate on the least amount of soil necessary for the plant to thrive.

Also: no more chemical weed killers.

Do this with bugs, and get rid of insecticides as well.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by piyh on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:20PM (#26963848)
It's not just the robot though, it's the millions or tens of millions of dollars of wheeled or tracked equipment he already has.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by mparlane on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:21PM (#26949589)
Still easier to harvest if you have the rows though.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by pkdpic_y9k on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:41AM (#26942988)
Good point, but you havent thought of the *millions of tiny mirrors* they'd obviously be using :)
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by amelius on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:46PM (#26944695)
One mirror mounted on the drone would be enough. And a strong enough laser device at a stationary position. Of course, the challenge would be to hit the mirror and not the drone ...
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by SamBam on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:01AM (#26943213)
They'd probably just use rare-earth magnets.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by justicezyx on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:57PM (#26945671)
DJI has some demonstration of target pesticide spreading drone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mfdWYztSqUI It's not as targeted as laser, and it has residual problem, and requires the crop to have resistance, or the pesticide/weedkiller to be specifically targeted.

But I think it might be possible to focus sunlight to generate energy to kill weeds, not through battery or generated electricity.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by kickout on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:12PM (#26945907)
Drones will be a big player in next 2-10 years (search for Rantizo). The more they can operate autonomously the better. The small payload size on drones aren't a huge problem if you can have 'refilling stations'
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by slt2021 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:22PM (#26944356)
agricultural drones run on gasoline and have plenty of energy
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:02PM (#26949934)
gasoline? I'm thinking ethanol derived from fermentation of the parts of the plant that were not shipped to market.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by slt2021 on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:22PM (#26951155)
yeah could be that as well, definitely some conventional ICE engines, not batteries
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by stubish on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:33PM (#26951258)
When they can scale this down for home use, I think the market will want legs. A miniature Imperial Walker ambling around your garden zapping weeds would sell.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by nemo44x on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:54AM (#26943138)
What about putting them on an electrified wire? String a grid of them over the fields for motion and for power. Power the grid with solar.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ogre_codes on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:03PM (#26944066)
Any kind of wired setup would interfere with other tractors they use in the field. Fertilization, and eventually harvesting.

I’m not sure why people are inventing more complicated solutions when this robot seems to handle the job quite well without them. It covers 20 acres in a day, you can likely keep 100+ acres weed free continuously without any other special gimmicks.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by stubish on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:38PM (#26951297)
I think most people here don't run large farms, and actually want something for their garden.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by riskable on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:57AM (#26943171)
It stands to reason that if you're going to be running wires over the entire field you wouldn't need flying drones so much as you would need cameras on wheels (like they have at football stadiums).

If the camera sees the correct spectra for a known weed it can drop down and get a closer inspection then mark the spot or just burn the weeds with an attached laser.

I assume the crawler is necessary because--in order for the laser to work--the weeds need to be identified very early as they emerge from the ground. You might not be able to spot them at such an early stage from above without expensive optics.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by smiley1437 on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:07PM (#26945005)
Yes totally agree on the benefits of early detection — easier to identify eg. once the desired crop is larger than, say 10mm, then just fire the laser on anything green that is less than 2mm, adjust those parameters as required as the crop matures, also getting them early means less laser energy required to kill it, longer battery life, larger acreage covered
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by bluGill on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:00AM (#26943196)
Wire is too expensive for that. You need thick wire to hold itself up without posts every few meters, which in turn means it is more expensive than the normal house wires. Not that it couldn't be done, but it is too expensive.

Now there is opportunity to have one long wire that the tractor reels in/out as it makes passes. This isn't a flying drone, but that isn't really needed for anything other than cool.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by baybal2 on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:59PM (#26948797)
No, wire gantry would be very much ok for this solution.

You don't need wires to be that rigid for that.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Arrath on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:40AM (#26943728)
I would see the drones being used to help map weed concentration and optimize the route/efficiency of the weed killing robot, not using drones to kill the weeds.

There are already solutions that use drone photogrammetry to map crop health, ground coverage and so on. It feels like a logical next step to use a drone to assist mapping the best route/find problem areas to target for the weed-roomba.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by delfinom on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:53AM (#26943904)
>I would see the drones being used to help map weed concentration and optimize the route/efficiency of the weed killing robot, not using drones to kill the weeds.

That's a ridiculous solution to a non-existent problem. The robot literally has no rush to go to the weeds. It can crawl along the field by itself 24/7. Throw in a solar panel charging station and you literally have free energy for it to piss away.

Instead you want to add complexity to the setup, increase maintenance costs and potentially shorten the lifespan of the system.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by jcims on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:47PM (#26948628)
It’s not ridiculous at all, hours count. I haven’t looked at the article, but I’m assuming it’s the same machine, it’s a 10,000 pound unit with tiny little tires and a 75 hp diesel engine. It’s going to compact the soil, get stuck, and waste fuel driving around looking for weeds.

If sending a 20 pound gas drone with a 2 TB solid-state drive and 60 FPS 4K camera on it up and down the field for one 100th of the fuel consumption once a week saves 500 hours a year off that beast, it’d probably be worth it.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Melting_Harps on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:43PM (#26951741)
> It’s going to compact the soil, get stuck, and waste fuel driving around looking for weeds.

This true of any modern farming equipment, which is why planting strategy is so critical--I kept messing up in my first year as I was going way too fast instead of taking my time and my planted rows were never straight, it was in a green house and we had an old diesel tractor so my lungs were hurting after the first hour and I just compromised on that aspect.

But then when I had to go back and weed, maintain and eventually harvest the oddly planted fields of salads and potatoes I made sure to follow the natural ebb and flow of the soil compaction, which was there even after it was tilled.

What I'm saying is that the compacted soil can help you in later seasons to maintain the direction of growth so it's not entirely a bad thing to have. And unless you farmed the same fields for several seasons/years you would overlook this as a net benefit. Eventually seasoned farm hands can do it while drinking and smoking and just listening to how the engine is struggling without even touching the steering wheel, they can even get out of the tractor and walk ahead of it as it's crawling forward to check if everything is fine. Where as for apprentices like myself who had no real experience in Ag it was a remarkable discovery that one shouldn't overlook.

Also, drones are already widely in use; they monitor temperature and moisture in real time and a offer other services right now [0]. Their is a company that I found that posted here on YC a few years ago that offers this as a service [1].

I was actually going to get my commercial drone's license a couple month's before I retired as a farm manager in Hawaii due to extensive injuries, but my fintech startup required saving and scraping all my pennies to afford getting it off the ground. I might consider getting it again as things start to be more widely deployed and the costs keep coming down and I still would like to be involved in some capacity in Ag.

0:https://uavcoach.com/agricultural-drones/

1:https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/terravion

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by IanCal on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:28PM (#26948398)
That does depend on how much area it can cover per day.

If it covers all your land in under a day, sure. If not, then route planning may mean you can have one rather than two or more of these very expensive machines.

It's not a drasticly complex addition, and mapping weeds with drones appears to be a use of them already.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by flukus on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:24PM (#26950109)
> That does depend on how much area it can cover per day.

This assumes weeding is a time sensitive task, which I find very doubtful. Realistically covering your land area in a week is probably enough, but maybe that's much higher.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by kickout on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:14PM (#26945928)
Ok thank you. Common sense on non-programming topics on HN is more rare than I would like. You clearly understand the problem better than most
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by silasb on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:28PM (#26946889)
Tethered drones might work.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MayeulC on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:41AM (#26942997)
I don't think you really need AI/CV if you have multispectral or full-spectrum imaging. Different species will have different absorption/emission at multiple wavelength. This makes it easy to identify crops, and seems to be commonly used for aerial imaging[1-3].

That kind of sensor is expensive though, and while you could probably do it for cheap with something like a DLP wheel (edit: or an array of different light emitters) plus a B/W camera, ML might be more price-effective, though probably more error-prone, so it isn't a given if you want a high match rate.

Also, isn't this a fire hazard?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperspectral_imaging#Agricult...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multispectral_image

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full-spectrum_photography

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by riskable on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:54AM (#26943142)
> This makes it easy to identify crops

...until they evolve to emit the same spectrum of light as the crops being harvested! Cuz you know that's going to happen.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MayeulC on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:08AM (#26943300)
Well, that's right, and I didn't think of it. But besides what the sibling comments pointed out, that's an issue with any kind of weeding, including manual.

The answer is to select according to a wide range of criteria, and not rely on a single one. That way, weeds cannot progressively acquire resistance, and need to check all the boxes at once, which makes it highly unlikely that they will pass on their "slightly better" genes.

And of course, the larger the scale you employ a single weeding system at, the more risky it gets. It would be great for supplementing herbicide (while lowering doses) at first, for instance.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ticklemyelmo on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:59PM (#26947270)
This is the part where Monsanto starts engineering crops to fluoresce in a particular frequency of light, so you can target weeds inversely.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:07PM (#26949971)
That makes me think that this also makes crop-rotation obsolete. You can plant 20 different crops in the same field, in repeating sequence. The bot will take care of them as-needed, and next season, move everything down one slot.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by OldManAndTheCpp on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:56PM (#26947229)
This is a known process already https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vavilovian_mimicry

Examples of this are Rye and Oats.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Retric on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:03AM (#26943245)
That’s a slow process, further you can always rotate between crops with different spectra.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by delfinom on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:56AM (#26943961)
It sounds like a slow process but plant life cycles are yearly compared to 20+ years for human generations to spawn, it will happen faster than you think. There are already round up resistant weeds and it's only been 50 years.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Retric on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:26PM (#26946862)
Even 30 years after first implementation would be several generations of better hardware and software. Spectra is just one way to get v1 out the door, there are many ways you can improve things.

Crops are planted in a specific pattern, at a specific time, grow at a specific rate, and have a unique shape. So you have a lot of information to work with.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by _nalply on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:02AM (#26943240)
Bacteria and viruses do that, but weeds first don't reproduce as fast and second humans can see them and find out something like treating crop seeds with fluorescent color.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by atat7024 on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:32AM (#26943625)
Eventually, the only organisms that remain will be mutualistic ones, if we do it right.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by kps on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:48PM (#26947913)
We just need the weedbots to test plants for flavour and nutritional value; cf. xkcd.com/810
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by sjburt on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:32PM (#26947699)
I think the AI solution is actually pretty well proven. I use PlantNet to identify weeds in my yard and it's plenty accurate and doesn't require any sort of advanced sensor.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MayeulC on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:39PM (#26947807)
Could be, but having more discriminating data as an input can only improve speed and accuracy. I don't know what technology they picked for the first iteration, but can only imagine they'll end up using every trick in the book going forward.

A slightly more advanced sensor or lighting apparatus wouldn't cost much more, proportionately to the cost of the whole system.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by sjburt on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:03PM (#26951003)
The cost would be acquiring a training data set that includes data from the more advanced sensor, versus existing catalogs with many millions of images and tens of thousands of species.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by throwaway09223 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:04AM (#26956873)
> Also, isn't this a fire hazard?

Unlikely. Heating a plant to kill it is considerably lower power than heating a plant to combust it and turn it to ash. It would also be trivial to add a water sprayer as part of the process.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by goodpoint on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:07AM (#26943296)
> you have multispectral or full-spectrum imaging

...that's exactly what CV needs to handle.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MayeulC on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:11AM (#26943342)
Well, right, but it doesn't need particularly impressive algotithms to achieve something with that data. Those algorithms were here 20 years ago, with less processing power and camera resolution.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by goodpoint on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:11PM (#26945889)
A lot of modern ML is not that impressive either.

I can imagine discriminating species of a hundred leaves in a very high resolution images to be very challenging.

The leaves are 3-dimensional objects can be twisted, tangled, curled up, broken, half rotten, sunburnt...

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by exabrial on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:16PM (#26947500)
Actually, the next most logical version is an implement that runs off the PTO drive of a tractor, not drones. One needs to piggyback off existing infrastructure, not replace it.

My high school summer job actually was helping with wheat harvest. You can only work when it's hot as you get better prices on the harvest.

There were certain kinds of weeds that really clog the combine (usually ragweed, not a huge problem in the early summer, but weird things happen) or cause damage to the cutting head (invasive brush/tree species). We walked the field and pulled anything really bad out.

Talk about a way to earn $25/day. You only finished when the equipment was put up for the night.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by le-mark on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:35AM (#26942929)
It doesn’t need to recognize every possible weed species, just “crop of interest / not crop of interest”. A much simpler but still valuable task.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by jmchuster on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:07PM (#26948149)
That's what made sense for my company; we just identify the crop, and then churn up all the areas of dirt that are "not crop". Also, hey, free cultivation. Do it often enough, and your weeds never even get that large, which also greatly increases your identification accuracy.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by capitainenemo on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:43AM (#26943010)
A real world useful variant of Not Hotdog. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14636228
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by CoastalCoder on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:00AM (#26943203)
That was my first thought as well.

My second thought was, "Please nobody invent a drone that shoots lasers at 'not hotdog'".

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by SubiculumCode on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:57PM (#26944867)
I wonder why it can't it be done via location? Where we planted, vs where we did not plant.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by shepting on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:35PM (#26945362)
This is the comment I came here for.

I had a professor in college who was building self-driving tractors and would come in every other week complaining about John Deere this, or Case that, trying to steal his business with more expensive solutions. It turns out you can use GPS for a rough location and a fancy $200 gyroscope for millimeter precision. Then just plant the seeds on an exact grid and you know that anything not on the grid is a weed.

And actually, his suggestion was to use high-pressure water jets to cut the weeds instead of lasers. It would/could be less energy-intensive.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by thruflo22 on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:45PM (#26946358)
RTK GPS is used as a second factor to vision in these machines. It’s just not good enough to target with as a sole / primary factor in the real world though. Bit of drift and whoops, $30,000 of crop gone.

Lasers are not used because they’re expensive and dangerous. And Co2 lasers (as per the machine in the article) are powerful but super fragile.

Water shooting around at high pressure is in no way efficient or easy to handle.

Compressed light is the technology that’s actually going to be used for precision weeding. It has the speed, power and simplicity of lasers, without the cost and danger: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/activity:67899797724715...

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by SubiculumCode on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:18PM (#26948282)
Its like cabling or rails have never been used before to guide a machine along its intended path. Alternatively, markers could be placed at planting.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by NortySpock on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:08PM (#26948159)
Thanks for posting this, very interesting. The linkedin profile pointed to a youtube video (unlisted) that was pretty interesting and covered how they could calculate eye safely using simple math that indicated the safe distance was 2 meters away. They appeared to be using blue LEDs at high intensity to char-or-inactivate weed photosynthesis.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnL3zYhBlVs

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:12PM (#26950006)
it'll probably end up being something like a gamma ray source; as probably the cheapest and most durable solution.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by gbasin on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:33AM (#26943639)
Hot dog, no hot dog?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by cogman10 on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:11PM (#26949504)
My prediction, this thing will be built into pivots.

Most farms irrigate with a giant automated system that sweeps around the field in regular intervals. These weed death lasers could be integrated to the base of the system and ran from the same power that moves the pivot.

Since these things don't move all that fast, you could have a central track and move the killer box up and down the line.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by filoeleven on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:19PM (#26950603)
It wouldn’t even have to burn all the weeds on the first pass. It’s like the herbicidal equivalent of mark-and-sweep garbage collection.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:09PM (#26949986)
yes, this seems like a natural progression.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Balgair on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:43AM (#26943019)
> Also, it sounds like they're using cameras, where it's concievable that other future sensors could be more efficient.

Bit of a pedantic note:

What other sensor could you use?

I'm grasping at straws (pun not intended) to figure out any other modality that could work as well in a giant field of psuedo-randomly mixed plants with the wind blowing chemical signatures all about.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MengerSponge on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:09AM (#26943311)
I assume they mean "visible spectrum" when they say cameras, because that's what most off-the-shelf systems are tuned to.

A spectrometer is a single pixel camera, I guess, but it isn't being used with imaging optics, and it isn't being used to stitch together a photograph.

In a general case you could embed some version of GFP instead of glyphosate resistance. Then you can set the system loose (within the field, lol) to actively interrogate plants, zapping intruders that fail their scans.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by kickout on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:17PM (#26945958)
Don't think there will be a need to bio-tag weed versus no weed. Current tech and sensors can probably get to 2-3 9s worth of accuracy (bonus, you don't care about accidently hitting/killing a false positive or two, there are many plants if this is a commodity crop)
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by dylan604 on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:47PM (#26948647)
I wonder if Monsanto seeds will start producing a signature that could be recognized. This will help in 2 ways. First, more easily identify those pesky farmers using their seeds without proper licensing. Second, help the machines know what plants to keep, and the ones to remove.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by kickout on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:36AM (#26957376)
Monsanto.....doesn't exist anymore....Laughable people hate on Monsanto/Bayer for protecting their IP, but when big tech does it it's just good business
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by MengerSponge on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:07PM (#26950493)
But if you add a bio-tag, you can make your system look like ED-209 and recreate this scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYUnp-x0SDE
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by SamBam on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:03AM (#26943248)
I think the question was just visible light cameras vs other wavelengths.

With visible light, all you have to go on is small differences in shades of green and shape of the leaves. With other spectra you'd have more cues.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by chasd00 on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:44AM (#26943775)
i'm sure i'm oversimplifying but if you can reliably identify your crop then everything else is a weed. Maybe put some kind of GMO marker that makes what you want to keep stick out like a sore thumb then you just nuke everything else.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Frenchgeek on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:52AM (#26943893)
If you know where your crops are, everything else is a weed.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by cameron_b on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:31PM (#26946145)
This is the traditional approach and it really blows my mind that so many hammer-syndrome AI/ML/flavor-of-the-month VC spenders haven't simply gone to see for themselves what works on farms. It probably doesn't even register to the casual observer, but planting a careful row of tomatoes with the root ball in a particular direction is a fit for the cultivator tool to come by and turn the soil up on the stem of the young, but now established plant.

That's actually the "weed control at scale" developed in conjunction with the tractor.

I'm not a fan of modern conventional agriculture. The abuse done to topsoil is terrible, and we need better systems. But new systems need to keep their eye on the ball and the ball is a John Deere pulling a 40-foot cultivator across a field while the "operator" reads twitter ( or <verb>s Clubhouse ) only looking up to mind the turns.

Everything starts somewhere, but just because your tech has ML and Laserbeams doesn't mean it passes the tool/toy test.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by metaobject on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:04AM (#26943261)
Perhaps he just meant IR sensors? Also, I wonder whether UV sensors would be helpful.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by marcus_holmes on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:53AM (#26943119)
I wonder at what point it becomes economically feasible to breed crops that are more distinguishable from weeds?

After all, this is what we did with chemical weedkillers.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by hackeraccount on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:31AM (#26943601)
I wondered about the corollary - at what point does selective pressure create a weed that's indistinguishable from a crop?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by intergalplan on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:14PM (#26945109)
I doubt weeds will be able to maintain advantages that let them compete well to begin with, while also evolving to evade all of a series of detection techniques that will be added as they evolve their way around the first few. To stick around they need to survive well outside of fields, too, and I'd expect detection-resistant varieties to become increasingly inefficient at surviving in areas where they're not being lasered to death.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by marcus_holmes on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:50PM (#26962156)
well, same, do we have weeds that have evolved resistance to roundup?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by swiley on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:11AM (#26942670)
Commodity drown with high powered laser for killing things based on image recognition sounds like sci-fi dystopia.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by DennisP on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:09AM (#26943314)
True, but it seems less dystopian than soaking vast fields with millions of pounds of neurotoxins, like we do today.
[dead]
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by burnished on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:50PM (#26944755)
Hey, I get it, needles are scary. You don't need to make stuff up to justify a completely rational fear of getting jabbed with a needle.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by linuxftw on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:19PM (#26945165)
I'm not concerned about the needle, only what's coming through it, approved by an entirely captured regulatory body.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#26950036)
can't be any worse than what's potentially in your hamburger.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by sushid on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:15PM (#26948245)
Then you drink a cup of glyphosate. Even folks on payroll spewing that nonsense would never entertain the thought of actually going through with it.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by bigbizisverywyz on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:40AM (#26955667)
There is a video on youtube of a Monsanto lobbyist being challenged to do exactly that, quite funny.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovKw6YjqSfM

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by dkarl on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:21AM (#26942784)
Yeah, I imagine massive overuse on "pest" species. Mosquito eradication will be a high priority for such technology, but there will be people who modify it to eradicate everything that flies or crawls. Everything smaller than a cat, if they could.

I think lasers for killing large animals (including us) will be prohibitively expensive for a long time to come, fingers crossed.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by dash2 on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:30AM (#26942873)
Don't worry. The robots can use machine guns like the rest of us.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by shantara on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:44AM (#26943025)
Unfortunately, you don't need that much power to permanently blind a human.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by Pokepokalypse on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:15PM (#26950045)
for that matter; microwaves cook us from the inside out at 100+ meters, and don't require very good aim.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by stevespang on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:33AM (#26942903)
Bill Gates was already involved in a startup to radar identify and kill mosquitos with lasers . . . guess it did not go well.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by joshuaissac on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:48AM (#26943066)
It resulted in a prototype that apparently cost $50 per unit, but no retail product yet.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito_laser

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by atat7024 on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:03PM (#26946591)
Are there massive amounts of retail products in, say, Africa?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by joshuaissac on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:56PM (#26950393)
Yes, Africa's retail market was worth US$1.4tn in 2015.[1]

1. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/africas...

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by protomyth on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:43AM (#26943767)
I know a lot of farmers that would respond very well to having "laser weed killer" as a product. I get the feeling the video feed would be amazing. Throw in pest killing and you own the market.

Although I keep thinking the movie Runaway (1984) is going to be a much truer representation of reality than I would like.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by martin_a on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:22AM (#26942789)
Just don't step on the field and you won't be mistaken for a rat and be zapped.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ourmandave on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:20AM (#26942777)
All roads lead to Skynet, some less obvious than others.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by ajarmst on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:36PM (#26948496)
I'm not sure that "killer robots with lasers that can be field-trained to identify specific targets" would be quite the blessing that everyone seems to think.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by dylan604 on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:41PM (#26948559)
Why do your weeds have 2 eyes, a nose, and a mouth in all of the training libraries?
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by anonuser123456 on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:39AM (#26942968)
>An iteration of this with higher resolution cameras and small flying drones seems like an intuitive next step.

The gimbal alone on your flying drone will cost more than the entire river.

Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by capitainenemo on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:22PM (#26944360)
Non-engineer speculation. Seems like drones might have the potential to make it cheaper? What if the laser was tower mounted and the drones just were there as a camera and reflector and to verify clear line of sight? I guess that would only really work well when the plants are small...
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by RHSeeger on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:21PM (#26946803)
My first thought was that ML-guided flying drones with laser weapons seems like it could be catastrophic is hacked. Imagine someone changed the drones to recognize humans (or, assuming the lasers can't hurt a human normally, the eyes of automobile drivers) as valid targets.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by hourislate on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#26946252)
Open Source models don't need to be trained on weeds. They need to be trained on whatever product is being grown. Everything else can be zapped regardless of what kind of weed it is.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by propertymagnate on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:21AM (#26954456)
Sounds a lot safer to whitelist what can be zapped rather then blacklist what can't, no? I mean, this is a moving autonomous laser platform we're talking about.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by loonster on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:47PM (#26959857)
Microwave powered drones. Have a mothership or tower track and send energy to the drones.
Re:Farming robot kills 100k weeds per hour with lasers by WalterBright on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:13PM (#26948939)
I'd like a lawnmower sized one for my yard!