News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by throwawayboise on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:10PM (#26835697)
Seems more like an issue for parents to manage.

It's hard to control what teenagers do, but young children simply don't have the resources and opportunity to do things their parents don't permit them to do.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by tartoran on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:10PM (#26836532)
Ok, but for the parents who are unable or who mismanage this, we all end up paying for this collectively as a society. No, things that harm people need to be kept a very close eye onto. Gambling is regulated to some extend and it still attracts the weak willed people but at least children are not allowed in. Instagram for kids is a similar thing, it captures all the attention of children for profit, it primes these kids to be superficial and instills a consumerist behavior creates only problems down the line, we can't ignore these things or we will live in a sicker society. It is never perfect but we should strive to at least head in that direction. This is my opinion at least.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by staticassertion on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:21PM (#26835847)
That doesn't seem true. What if this were drugs? "Just leave that to the parents, don't force people to stop selling to kids"?

These days many kids have cell phones. For better or worse, that's what parents are doing. I don't know why, I'm not a parent and I don't know any children, but I know that as a young kid a cell phone allowed me to walk home alone or with another kid at an early age, so I can imagine justifications.

Anyway, I don't see why this should be on parents to manage, or how that would be effective.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by logifail on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:39PM (#26837505)
> These days many kids have cell phones. For better or worse, that's what parents are doing. I don't know why, I'm not a parent and I don't know any children, but I know that as a young kid a cell phone allowed me to walk home alone or with another kid at an early age, so I can imagine justifications.

Our 11-year old travels to school on the train. Last week he set off to school on a day that (thanks to Covid19) he was supposed to be doing "home schooling" (there's a rather crazy timetable, he's got two [different!] days each week in school, three days at week home-schooling). So, we called him on his cell phone : "get off the train as soon as you can, we'll come and pick you up, you need to get back home ASAP"

In the good old days he'd have been blissfully unaware of his(our) mistake until arriving at school, at which point he'd have asked an adult for help, and would (probably) come home by himself.

I'm not convinced that kids carrying cellphones around is a net benefit, but here we are...

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by montecarl on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:25PM (#26835893)
Seems much easier to control, influence, and parent your children than to make other people stop selling drugs. The USA has been losing a war on drugs for decades.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by staticassertion on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:35PM (#26836028)
But we're not talking about making something illegal, this is a plea to not create a service specifically for children.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by celticninja on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:34PM (#26836014)
Which means the people on drugs are winning.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by guerrilla on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:36PM (#26836035)
You seriously think parents aren't trying to stop their kids from doing drugs too? No, they do both. What planet are you from?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by azinman2 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:56PM (#26836329)
Or poison, cigarettes, alcohol, porn, fast food…

There are a host of things parents have the responsibility of shielding their kids from. Trying to cancel out harms in the world is futile.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by quietbritishjim on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:29PM (#26836734)
Those are mostly examples of things that are _not_ the exclusive responsibility of parents. For example, selling alcohol to children (at least here in the UK) is a criminal offence, not something you can just say "well it's the parents' fault for not stopping them coming into my shop to buy". Pre-internet, that was even true of porn. They seem to support the opposite point than you make in your second paragraph.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by nemo44x on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:15PM (#26837300)
A lot of people keep alcohol, poisons, guns, knives, etc in the house. It is the parents job to ensure their kids don’t have access to these things. You’re a bad parent if you don’t prevent your kids from harming themselves.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by hnbad on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:36PM (#26836853)
If poison, cigarettes, alcohol and porn were explicitly marketed towards children, you'd have a point there.

Note that cigarettes and alcohol were both implicitly and explicitly marketed towards children in the past until governments stepped in and there have been steps to attempt to crack down on fast food.

> Trying to cancel out harms in the world is futile.

You missed the word "all" there but I don't see how that statement is relevant when discussing one specific new harm which we can literally cancel out before it sees the light of day.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by foepys on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:27PM (#26836705)
Cigarettes, alcohol, and porn is actually regulated. In the US alcohol is even so tightly regulated that they bind infrastructure budgets to the legal drinking age of 21.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by kube-system on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:12PM (#26837259)
It's so highly regulated in some parts of the US that certain types of alcohol are sold exclusively by the government.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by the-smug-one on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:58PM (#26836364)
Are you going to be launching cigarettes for kids tomorrow?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by azinman2 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:22PM (#26836646)
I didn’t realize this was a totally separate product. I’m mixed in that probably many kids are already using Instagram as is… I guess I go back to parent responsibility (although we probably all lose through the tragedy of the commons).
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by LegitShady on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:36PM (#26837476)
So that's a yes?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by citruscomputing on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:45PM (#26837571)
You mean like Juul?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by grawprog on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:30PM (#26835956)
>Seems more like an issue for parents to manage.

No, it seems like zuckerberg should justify why this needs to exist. There doesn't need to be an Instagram for children. What benefit to children get by having an Instagram. Why should this now be an issue for parents because zuck figured he could monetize children?

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by bko on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:56PM (#26836331)
In a free society, you don't need to justify why something needs to exist.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by mettamage on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:01PM (#26836409)
There are so many things that need justification for safety reasons. All the 18+ stuff comes to mind, most notably slot machines.

Even in a free society.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by prichino on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:47PM (#26893853)
Yeah and horses trampled over kids all the time. Justification enough is that the kids should've known better
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by vletal on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:12PM (#26836542)
"free" like in the "regulations are harmful" way?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by AlexTWithBeard on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:14PM (#26836566)
"free" like not guilty until proven otherwise
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by vletal on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:32PM (#26836782)
More of a "free" like in "you are free to behave immorally"
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by imbnwa on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:29PM (#26836745)
That principle exists in a domain where you've already been alleged of wrongdoing established by a given set of laws, it just means the allegation isn't also the warrant for guilt, as in a witch trial. It wasn't meant to hand-waive away any kind of collective speculative concern
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by hnbad on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:31PM (#26836774)
The open letter cites plenty of sources explaining why the product would be harmful to children. Convictions are made on less evidence than this.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by aaomidi on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:40PM (#26836101)
Eating disorders at even a younger age! Coming to a child near you.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by hk1337 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:58PM (#26836357)
That could go along the same line as "an issue for parents to manage". Facebook shouldn't be creating an "Instagram for children", it's up to the parents to manage and monitor their children's internet usage.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by logifail on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:43PM (#26837559)
> it's up to the parents to manage and monitor their children's internet usage

I'm happy to block/ban internet usage for my kids, can we presume you happy for those in power to legislate that no school can set kids any homework that requires the internet/youtube to complete?

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by hk1337 on Friday April 16, 2021 @09:05PM (#26840749)
Yeah, if their schoolwork requires Internet/YouTube then the school should be providing access to it.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by yeetman21 on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:00PM (#26837141)
>justify why this needs to exist wtf justify why you need to exist. if people want something, others will provide it. if kids don't like it then they wont have it
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by aeternum on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:10PM (#26836524)
Even he did add an age restriction, why wouldn't kids just put in a fake birthday?
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by smithza on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:38PM (#26837496)
We should compare and contrast to other engagement mediums designed for children; i.e. Cartoon Network, Nickelodeon, PBS Kids, Amazon Fire Kid's edition, etc.

For these, excepting PBS I think, monetary motivation is the same. More engagement equals more opportunity to show 'Baby Bottle Pop commercials'.

One major difference is gov't regulation over open airwaves (in America at least). There is no regulation in the app/product domain. Amazon Fire and Instagram are bound to whatever company moderation policies are in place at Amazon and FB (and App store moderation at Apple/Google).

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by aftergibson on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:04PM (#26836443)
Great, yet another communication channel kids need to be "parented" away from at the potential cost of social isolation. It must be wearying for parents.

Kids are resilient, but I imagine many parents don't like the thought of their kid missing out on context/social interaction because the lazy-parents kids let them do whatever they want.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by logifail on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:47PM (#26837593)
> the lazy-parents kids let them do whatever they want

One of the kids in our 11-year-old's class lost it in the class WhatsApp group last week, hurled any and all terms of abuse you can think of. So our 11-year-old left the group as did many of his friends, and that got reported to the school.

Who thinks an 11 year old can understand that saying stuff online could potentially destroy your career several decades hence if someone made a screenshot?

I'd happily enforce a minimum age 18 for use of social media.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by throwaway3699 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:31PM (#26836759)
> Kids are resilient, but I imagine many parents don't like the thought of their kid missing out on context/social interaction because the lazy-parents kids let them do whatever they want.

(I mentioned what this was like for me growing up.)

Would encourage people to share some alternative paths to not being excluded socially. There's always a way around these platforms, but as a shy kid I never would've found them without a bit of guidance.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by simonswords82 on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:40PM (#26838241)
You are making the bold assumption that all parents are knowledgeable enough or give a shit enough to keep their kids off of social media.

The kids are ultimately the ones who suffer so why not just prevent the problem at the root cause by disallowing Instagram for kids.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by agentdrtran on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:56PM (#26836325)
parents cannot fight multibillion dollar tech companies trying their damndest to get to their kids alone. it's a one-sided fight.
Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by LegitShady on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:35PM (#26837468)
> Seems more like an issue for parents to manage.

No, if something is harmful and addictive it should be regulated, parents or not.

Instagram should not be free to get away with addicting children to social media because some parents are not as attentive as they should be. Children should be legally protected from this predatory behaviour by tech ogilarchs looking to embed themselves into the behaviour of young children.

Why not a kid's gambling site? I mean, it seems like an issue for parents to manage. Children don't have the resources so it shouldn't be regulated, right?

It's predatory, and should be regulated, and heavily punished.

Re:Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Inst... by sharkjacobs on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:21PM (#26838006)
And cigarette companies should be allowed to advertise to children.

Free capitalism is sacred and parents are the only ones who should care about the wellbeing of their children. Society doesn't exist and no one is responsible for the wellbeing of anyone else beyond their own nuclear family.